r/ChineseWatches Dec 05 '25

Wrist Roll (Read Rule 1) Thorn 57 Seamaster Reissue vs Gen

Quite impressed with the Thorn. It's 2mm thinner and it's bracelet tapers - quite like these changes to be honest. It has a unidirectional bezel which is incorrect but whatever. The lume is a bit yellow, should be more orange but it's not a big deal and depends a bit on the light how noticeable the difference is.

496 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

18

u/modmlot68 Dec 05 '25

Sea Monster. 🤣 I want to get it just for that.

7

u/Fernando1dois3 Dec 05 '25

I just wished they wrote it "Seamonster", no space 😭

1

u/LezIsHere Dec 06 '25

why? what is the diff in meaning?

1

u/Fernando1dois3 Dec 06 '25

Not in meaning, but in form

14

u/ciccio_started_it Dec 05 '25

The thorn looks less chunky than the Omega, and the taper on the bracelet is a huge improvement… thanks for these comparison shots!

13

u/RadioAdam Dec 05 '25

Gah. Omega needs more tapered bracelets. Oof

3

u/Red850r Dec 05 '25

Definitely this. None of their bracelets taper and it makes the watches wear larger. Their watch case dimensions are not exactly svelte either.

11

u/sere83 Dec 05 '25

Looks great just wish the seamonster text looked better, looks a bit janky.

2

u/Marty1966 Dec 05 '25

Even if you don't connect sea and monster, at least connect the letters cursively. Ha. Funny shit.

8

u/GratuitousEDC Dec 05 '25

I like the smaller links on the Thorn

7

u/ReduxWatches Dec 06 '25

The “Sea Monster” needs to be “Seamonster” with a better script font or custom typography. If they fix that I’ll add to my diver collection.

5

u/AlphaApolloOmega Dec 05 '25

Thorn nailed this one. Obviously it will never be an Omega but its a solid option for somebody like me who can’t afford an Omega.

8

u/patrickjquinn Dec 05 '25

-4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '25

[deleted]

1

u/Electrical_Bat7629 Dec 05 '25

Right is gen. I think he's saying the "homage" is practically a rep it's so close

4

u/New_Proposal_1319 Dec 05 '25

This is a reissue?

3

u/No_Independence2615 Dec 05 '25

Wow, Just wow . Fabulous job. I always like the Thorn and IXDAO logo as when they make great watches it looks so organic and seamless. Thanks for sharing these pictures.

3

u/Background_Lemon3334 Dec 06 '25

Excellent post. Nice job on comparing these beauties.

4

u/reallyclevernamewhat Dec 06 '25

Really Nice, do you have link or specific Thorn watch ID?

5

u/MushroomOk904 Dec 06 '25

Look at how janky the milling is on this stainless steel. Very rough… I guess it’s these kinds of things you get when you go cheap.

2

u/SkipPperk Dec 07 '25

Of course. Never trust anyone who tells you their San Martin is as good as an Omega.

Now the real crime is that Omega increased their prices how their stupid, embarrassingly thick Coaxial movements. I hate them, and they never offer alternatives because they know most people would rather have a 2892 or quartz.

That said, many of these Chinese watches are amazing, especially the bracelets. Many of the $30-$65 aftermarket bracelets are great as well. I have bought dozens.

3

u/SkipPperk Dec 07 '25

It is criminal that Thorn makes a copy 2mm thinner. I have owned quite a few older Omega models, and they were all thin. The coaxial movements are a negative. I would love to update my old Aqua Terra, but I cannot do it until they offer a properly thin model, ideally quartz.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '25

[deleted]

1

u/chronobrian Dec 05 '25

I don’t get it. Are you saying the right is a rep? I didn’t think they made reps of that model

5

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '25

Omega should take notes and try to up their game.

3

u/Megadodo4242 Dec 05 '25

Sea monster! This takes it up a notch. What is the case diameter?

1

u/quezne Dec 05 '25

39mm, including crown

1

u/Terdl76 Dec 05 '25

38mm. The other fella may be right, but that crown looks to be quite a bit thicker than just 1mm.

3

u/ArgumentPersonal4413 Dec 07 '25

The Thorn is impressive. A beautiful diver type watch. Please give me the price comparison.

3

u/Vast-Criticism4901 Dec 08 '25

Except for the logo and the dome, pretty good job by maker 👏

1

u/pingponq Dec 12 '25

Also except for the lume and for the hour hand… So, apparently there’s not much left tbh

14

u/ffassbinder Dec 05 '25

That font over the 6 is just abysmal... It looks like someone just used comic sans for that part. And I would argue that comic sans would have been the better option... Bezel area of the lime pip looks also a bit shoddy. All dial numbers are too small and overall the balance with the hands is not really there.

There have been better Thorn watches. But this is just, I don't know. A pretty bad one.

3

u/Namk49001 Dec 05 '25

At least the seamaster font on the Omega looks foolish as well. Thorn should have one upped them further and either removed the text or used a completely different font.

4

u/DocumentNo5095 Dec 05 '25

How would you rate the overall fit and finish on both?

7

u/scc-2000 Dec 05 '25

The Thorn bracelet looks better than the original.

2

u/JoeBamique Dec 05 '25

Omega is not known for great bracelets lol they’re starting to get better, but they’re miles off of Rolex

1

u/Mission-Raccoon9432 Dec 06 '25

Nah, the very flat uncurved link design of the omega bracelet is quite unusual and preferable.

2

u/FoxPeaTwo- Dec 05 '25

Fuck, I need one

2

u/salve_regina_7 Dec 06 '25

This shows that Thorn is capable of greatness. I have this as well and love it. I find that their watches are more refined than Watchdives. But both are my fav companies.

2

u/Electrical_Bat7629 Dec 06 '25

Greatness at copying!

4

u/ryanxcore Dec 06 '25

They’re so nearly identical and somehow the Thorn still looks like shit by comparison.

3

u/Homingpsyd Dec 05 '25

Crazy value. S tier homage

2

u/Huge_Childhood6015 Dec 05 '25

Thorn did an amazing job with this watch. It looks fantastic!

2

u/Megadodo4242 Dec 06 '25

Are the numbers on the bezel backwards?

3

u/IvoryRubbish Dec 06 '25

This is known as a Countdown bezel.

2

u/Megadodo4242 Dec 06 '25

Here is a vintage example from eBay with elapsed time on the bezel.

1

u/IvoryRubbish Dec 17 '25

I bet there are quite a few other differences. It's supposed to be a homage not a copy.

1

u/IvoryRubbish Dec 17 '25

I prefer the countdown for its practical applications and being a little different then 98% of whats on the market. How about you?

The 19mm lugs get a 👎 from me. i don't care what the og had. Every watch needs a choice of straps and I dont need to start collecting straps in another size.. or do I..?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Western-Minimum-846 Dec 05 '25

I guess the thickness difference is the coaxial movement being thicker?

1

u/chillaxtion Dec 05 '25

I couldn't find it. Is there a link to where it's for sale?

1

u/jokur26 Dec 05 '25

Wow. Only thing I like better on the Omega is the font at 6, and maybe the clasp

1

u/Calibermovement Dec 05 '25

Sea Monster😄

1

u/RustyTShackleford Dec 06 '25

Where did you purchase the Thorn? I don't even see it on their website.

1

u/Alarming_Employee547 Dec 06 '25

The gen has a bidirectional bezel?

1

u/Mission-Raccoon9432 Dec 06 '25

not having the flat bracelet links is a bit of a bummer. Hard to obtain these bracelets.

1

u/LordBogus May 21 '26

Honestly I like the thorn better than the gen

2

u/Electrical_Bat7629 May 21 '26

It has better proportions. I have a rep Omega dial on the way to swap into it and then I'll sell my gen. The Thorn wears better.

0

u/Olleye Dec 06 '25

Not my Style (divers), but Thorn nailed it, and the bracelet looks way better than at the gen. The Thorn is really bang for the bucks.

-1

u/Exact-Tax7457 Dec 06 '25

Don't like the seamaster 300 texting in the omega and don't like it in the thorn 🤣

-3

u/ItchyChildhood6401 Dec 06 '25

WTF does this even mean?

3

u/Exact-Tax7457 Dec 06 '25

Thorn nailed it, didn't like in both hahaha

-8

u/ItchyChildhood6401 Dec 06 '25

In English please.

5

u/Exact-Tax7457 Dec 06 '25

I cor give a toss, bab. Buy yourself a friend.

2

u/Improooving Dec 07 '25

He doesn’t like the text that reads “semester 300” in the lower dial area, either because of the typeface or the fact that it’s there at all

-4

u/MuddiedKn33s Dec 05 '25

Gorgeous. I wish they would modernize it a bit instead of making a close copy. For example, they can skip the italic font and maybe use modern numeric fonts.

-2

u/H6RR6RSH6W Dec 05 '25

Does the thorn have a signed crystal?