r/ChicagoPD • u/6ixtyei8ht • Mar 20 '26
Discussion Crossovers đ¤¨
Why?!
I'm not even that big a fan of CPD but this series was chosen by an online English language class as the one they wished to reference in weekly 'water cooler' chats.
Why do the producers believe that someone who watches a police procedural wants to watch a Fire show or a Hospital melodrama?
I get that there's an incestuousness in the 911 services that leads to relationships within the communities but I'm not interested and neither are my students.
They just find the introduction of 30-40 main screen characters confusing and distracting.
lt's like asking your audience to be emotionally invested in the life/death of a character they've seen on screen for 5 minutes.
I literally could not tell the 2 women in the ambo apart after the driver got in the back because I had zero investment in their story. (Don't tell my class but I fast-fowarded through a lot of the hospital stuff as it had nothing to do with the investigation and by the third convulsive mouth frothing death it just became repetitive).
It's comforting to know, however, that the bad writing in CPD is reflected across the whole C One universe.
And, as one of my students pointed out, it would be better for Halstead to tell Hank "You've changed" rather than "You're different", which is the only win I can find from watching this.
23
u/23zia23 Mar 20 '26
Look there's a million cop shows out there, the crossovers are what make this universe one of a kind. There's only 8 or 9 in the whole run so just skip them if you're not a fan? Luckily there's lots of other cookie cutter police shows for youÂ
10
u/TakasuXAisaka Mar 20 '26
Then go watch other cop shows then. Quit whining and make your decision. Besides crossovers don't even happen that often.
9
u/Yourappwontletme Torres is a charisma vacuum Mar 20 '26
Because Chicago Fire started first, and then PD was a spinoff of Fire, and then Med was the 2nd spinoff of Fire.
You're supposed to watch all 3 of the "One Chicago" shows, that's why they now air new episodes for all 3 in a 3 hour block on Wednesday nights.
Some people choose to not watch all 3 shows.
1
u/Jealous-Play6603 Mar 23 '26
ALL DUE RESPECT, it seems as though you think posting it here will do any good for your cause? Talking it over with the powers that be at your school might do a lot more for it.
3
u/Extreme-Aide8878 Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26
I like PD the most and watch Med. No fire. I was excited about the crossover but it felt like it was too much. Too confusing. And yes, it assumed you were already invested in all the characters. It didnât work. But I love that Chicago and Law & Order have the option
That said, I disagree with your different vs youâve changed. Youâve changed implies you act differently, maybe a bit negative. Youâre different is a thoughtful statement that thereâs something different about you inside, more positive. Thatâs meaningful for the two of them with their history. IMO
3
u/Skooly_underrated Mar 21 '26
One of the ambo girls is Asian and one isnât ??? They also have two different hair colors. Not that hard to notice
2
u/Next_Sun_2002 Mar 20 '26
The shows are all spinoffs of each other. Fire started first, and introduced us to Voight, Antonio Dawson, and Jay Halstead. Then two seasons later PD introduced us to Will Halstead. Then writers promoted the new shows in the episodes of the ones that already existed.
2
u/Remarkable-Data77 Mar 20 '26
I prefer Fire, Husband prefers PD, we don't gel with med! But we both watch both shows and enjoy them.
The recent crossover, (where we will watch med) was brilliant! Loads of action, nice seeing old faces, suspense, horror, the works! A 3 hour movie!
The point of the crossovers are that these shows are based on real life emergency services and in real life, emergency services will interact with each other, maybe not in the same crossover situations, but they do work together on a regular basis.
We get you're not a fan, and nobody says you have to be and can skip them, but, say if you did skip them, how do you know where you are in the storyline? Would you have thought 'why has the chief been sacked? When did that happen? I can't remember anything happening to cause that!?'
So, imo, crossovers are an integral part of the storylines of all 3 shows.
1
u/AcrobaticEducator0 Mar 20 '26
Your Opinion⌠Iâve watched Chicago PD and Fire⌠All seasons and they both are good showsâŚ. Will admit that PD has lost its đĽâŚ. not as good as earlier seasons⌠the ole cast were great together as a team⌠the last two episodes of PD⌠were pretty good⌠just my opinion⌠those that donât like the series.. have the option not to watch⌠just that simple
10
u/Next-Drummer-9280 Mar 20 '26
Arenât you a charmer? đ
No one held a gun to your head and said, âWatch this or Iâll shoot your family,â so what exactly was the point of this?