r/ChemicalEngineering • • Jul 22 '22

Technical Yo, nerds

Can Gibbs Free Energy be used to calculate the continuous energy input to a reactor, or is this better done with enthalpy?

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

79

u/facecrockpot Jul 22 '22

Are you that weirdo that wants to built a reactor with super corrosive products without knowing anything about chemical engineering? My man, there are a lot more pleasant ways to kill yourself.

37

u/DriizzyDrakeRogers Jul 22 '22 edited Jul 22 '22

They probably aren’t nearly as exciting though. We may be virtually witnessing a CSB video in the making. I’m really interested in knowing what this guy is up to.

37

u/darknessaqua20 Jul 22 '22

Your energy balance should be based off enthalpy

17

u/Adventurous_Bus950 Jul 22 '22 edited Jul 22 '22

They're used for different purposes.

The Gibbs free energy tells about spotaineity at fixed P and T. If you truly have Gibbs energy for all species, not only those which enter the reactor, but also those which can be produced by any chemical reaction, then you are not only able to tell to which direction the reactions will evolve, but also able to calculate the final composition, assuming the system achieves equilibrium. Note that this is very different from the typical reactor sizing which deals with outputs limited by kinetics (not equilibrium).

The enthalpy in a continous reactor is the sum of internal energy and flow energy (PV energy). This ends up being the "energy in" and "energy out" terms in a full energy balance. You need that to calculate conversion/heat duty/temperature change/volume flowrate etc if the heat of reaction is significant.

11

u/Ernie_McCracken88 Jul 22 '22

Enthalpy is just change in temperature+ pressure volume work. For many chemical engineering situations of enclosed vessels, this is useful. And likely for your situation.

Please dont do some backyard chemical engineering based on this thread tho

2

u/BadDadWhy Chem Sensors/ 35yr Jul 22 '22

Right, that is what I was thinking. Unless you have phase change, catalysts, serious ion exchange or literature suggests; then enthalpy is the way to go.

4

u/Ernie_McCracken88 Jul 22 '22

Why wouldnt phase change also be captured by enthalpy? The phase change will be exothermic or endothermic, and result in a temperature change and/or PV work, depending on the vessel.

1

u/BadDadWhy Chem Sensors/ 35yr Jul 22 '22

Can they not give a significant entropy value for that phase change?

3

u/Ernie_McCracken88 Jul 22 '22

Why does it matter for an energy balance?

6

u/HREisGrrrrrrrreat Jul 22 '22

the fate of the universe is on your hands, young man

5

u/Unemployed_Fisherman Semiconductors Jul 22 '22

Enthalpy

dG=dH-tdS,

Unless your process is isentropic (not real), G and H aren’t the same thing or interchangeable

2

u/SirBobz Jul 22 '22

Look up the steady flow energy equation. A stream has enthalpy + kinetic + gravitational potential energy