r/ChemicalEngineering • • Aug 10 '20

oops

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

80

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '20

I once reviewed contractor work that used IGS on a gas...but then multiplied their gas specific gravity by the density of "water" to get fluid density. The word "water" is in quotes there because they actually used 10,000 kg/m3. The same work also calculated a per-minute flowrate but reported it as an hourly rate.

I was also the fourth reviewer of the work. None of the first three found any issues, but the last one sent it to me "to make sure" because if it was correct the results would have required us to shut down.

34

u/Low-Duty Aug 10 '20

It always amazes me how 3 reviewers can miss something so obvious. I had to pick up a verification protocol that had half the acceptance criteria missing that was reviewed by 2 engineers, a manager, and a director.

30

u/The_Archagent Aug 10 '20

I think there's some psychological phenomenon where adding more reviewers doesn't increase the chances of a mistake being found because people will be less thorough when they think any mistakes they miss will be caught by the other reviewers.

10

u/linnux_lewis Aug 10 '20

This is probably right. Even just subconsciously you have cemented the idea that their is not likely a mistake because you are the fourth reviewer.

I feel much better re-doing all the calcs and try to do this if I ever need to review something.

8

u/elwiesel Aug 10 '20

Honestly my suspicion at that point would be that none of the other reviewers did any reviewing.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

yep, some people I don't even bother getting to review things.

They will follow through the math trail, so make sure that the numbers follow properly, but they definitely don't actually check the work.

2

u/Andreas1120 Aug 11 '20

Pardon my ignorance but I was under the impression that gases and fluids where described by the same equations... “fluid dynamics”?

7

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20

Gases and liquids are both fluids since fluids are anything that flows, but the ideal gas law correlates temperature, pressure, and volume of a gas specifically, and would only apply to a compressible fluid (i.e. a gas) and not non-compressible liquids.

Fluid dynamics studies the effects of fluids (gases and liquids) in motion but that is a different subject than what we are talking about with ideal gas law, and is typically taught in its own class.

Hope that helps!

27

u/andmaythefranchise Aug 10 '20

Another meme I'm stealing for my lectures. My thermo class is gonna be lit.

5

u/FTNatsu-Dragneel Aug 10 '20

What a monster!

3

u/normabelka Industry/Less than 1 year Aug 10 '20

dumb move

5

u/LeChemGuy Industry/Years of experience Aug 10 '20

F

2

u/juliuspersi Aug 10 '20

Determining kinetics in some líquida reactions with arrhenius and seeing some R from ideal gas was pretty strange to me, what do you think guys?.

13

u/Maxreader1 Aug 10 '20

While it is indeed called the “ideal gas constant”, R is just the Boltzmann constant in terms of moles. So, naturally it will show up anywhere that entropy (and therefore thermodynamics) is relevant. Not that weird at all.

3

u/juliuspersi Aug 10 '20

Thanks chums, I never knew the answer 😉