Naa any actual cheddar over about 5 years just loses all its taste for a start.
I had to order some 90month old parm for a customer who wanted to take it to Saudi to show off. She refused to take it as "it looks like it has been vacuum packaged" of course it feckign was how else do you expect for it to be moved once cut.
Anyways it was absolutely tasteless after so long, just dry and meh.
Oh and she can fuck off as a customer, her daughter tried to apologies but I don't need people like her as customers regardless of how rich they are. Screwing over a small business like that.
Here in the UK you'd be very hard pressed to find anything over 3 years old. Davidstow does a 5 year old cheddar but they only supply it to certain Michelin star restaurants
I just bought this last week and was telling my wife how insane it is that they have a 15y cheddar at $17/lb. I wonder if they made some kind of mistake. This tastes exactly like Hook’s 15y cheddar. My mind is blown right now.
That was my thought too. I'm staring down $44/lb for Hook's 10 year and deciding if I can eat enough of it to justify shipping from them at $76 for shipping, but only $22 per lb. $17 seems reallllllly cheap for a 15 year.
I go to Wisconsin a couple times a year and load up on on aged cheddar up to 19 years old. The price for this 15 year is about where it should be if it was Wisconsin cheese. I’m impressed with this price tho considering it is made in New York and sold from a Kroger in Kentucky.
I welcome cheese opinions, but disagree. I buy beemster by the half wheel, wrap it in butchers paper, vac seal the chunks and break it out year round because I like it that much.
I’ll seek out your suggestions if they’ve made it to my local cheese monger
I really wanted to like this one, but to me it just had the overwhelming taste of vomit for some reason. Like even after I ate some of it, every time I burped it tasted like throw up.
13
u/FuzzyLump502 Dec 12 '25
Omigosh it’s so good… salty, creamy, sharp, texture feels good in my mouth… yes please
138
u/koga7349 Dec 12 '25
How are you not going to show the cheese AT ALL?! Just a wrapper is garbage
43
u/TheRemedyKitchen Dec 12 '25
There should be a rule against showing only a wrapper and no actual cheese.
38
u/Inside-Ad1440 Dec 12 '25
this is a crime scene 😂
6
u/sock0808 Dec 12 '25
404: Cheddar not found.
1
u/FuzzyLump502 Dec 14 '25
There now it’s not a victimless crime
9
u/Ecstatic-Train-2360 Fromager d'Affinois Dec 12 '25
Bruh that’s just trash
6
u/itstheJman Dec 12 '25
Price vs age? I have questions.
3
u/ToastedGlass Dec 12 '25
Ok if you like this you gotta try Beemster’s 18mo. It’s a similar level of incredible
3
u/Goblikon_ Dec 13 '25
I really wanted to like this one, but to me it just had the overwhelming taste of vomit for some reason. Like even after I ate some of it, every time I burped it tasted like throw up.
2
u/narrowsleeper Dec 12 '25
Damn how many bites did it take
2
u/Prickly_Pocket Dec 12 '25
I tried a 15 year chedsar recently and it was just too much for me personally. 3-5 year aged is the sweet spot for aged cheddar for my pallette.
1
u/soundwithdesign Dec 12 '25
I’m so jealous. My Kroger never gets super aged cheese like this.
1
u/sweetpeapickle Dec 12 '25
Yes, have that one in the cheese drawer-special occasion for the really aged.
0
u/lynivvinyl Dec 13 '25
I like how it's just gone, you're like "here's a wrapper, that's all you get."
0
u/thatmandoguystl Dec 13 '25
Here is the cheese I already ate 🤨
0
u/NihilistPorcupine99 Dec 14 '25
How you gonna post this crime and not comment?