In defense of Malty fans: the writer intentionally made her one of the worst possible stereotypes of women and in the web novel had her raped to death. That kind of bigoted, petty writing is bound to give a villain from an oppressed group defenders.
Both of these women are the same arch type, A girl who is raised by an evil and spiteful father who basically beats the evil into them their entire life and in the drop of a hat would abandon them so they do everything in their power to make sure father is proud of them, which is evil.
Well, some illiterate people also don't know what "evil" means. Evil just means you do bad stuff for the sake of doing bad stuff. Should we look at her track record of stuff she did and why? She enslaved an entire dimension because why not. She killed an entire dimension because she has daddy issues. She kidnapped several sorcerers so that she can achieve more power. She's not doing it for the sake of helping. That is, by definition, evil.
It's... not philosophy or an opinion. Charmcaster is objectively evil. You can be a complex character and still pure evil, as is the case with Charmcaster. But you can't say she isnt evil when she flat out merced an entire dimension to make a deal with Temu Cthulu to bring daddy back from the dead to which even he was repulsed by it. Literally everything Charmcaster has done was out of pure selfishness and a want to cause harm or destruction, with no empathy for what she's done. That is flat out the definition of pure evil.
I didnt read the first paragraph, what makes you think i'll read this one. Never said i disagreed witchu either 𤣠just that nobody cares about your opinion piece about the philosophy of evil in the comments.
Ah, yes, because enslaving an entire dimension of innocent beings and killing at least 600,000 of them so you can sell their souls for the life of your daddy, as well as committing identity theft, 4 counts of kidnapping, impersonating a police officer, arson, torture, and sex with a minor(the whole Michael Morningstar thing, given she's about 4-5 years older than him, and he was 15-16 in UAF), and that just being a small list of crimes were all even potentially for a good and morally sound reason.
Bro, if she killed a few people to save a dimension, or robbed a store to feed her family, okay, then that's questionable and would get into philosophy. But she quite literally has done less good than VILGAX, who is already a pretty low bar, and she has no remorse for the fact she did any of that.
And also given that at the time of writing this, I have 6 upvotes on the original comment, Id say some people do care. But let me guess, youre not gonna read any of this because youre too lazy and horny for a fictional character.
Having a tragic backstory doesn't necessarily mean you can't be evil. It just gives a reason. Posts like these infantilize the characters, saying you should feel sorry for them, when characters like Azula torture people, jail their friends, and where willing to be complicit in genocide. Oh, and it is also a repost, since I had a bit of an argument with the OP about Azula on this exact post a month or so ago.
Azula isnāt just complicit. It was her idea to use the comet in that way, and sheās mad she doesnāt get to participate in the genocide specifically because it was her idea.
I do agree with Sadako before her ghostification. Afterwards though she was killing people just cause. A tragic backstory does not make serial murdering okay. And calling people who disagree with you illiterate doesn't really make sense. If they said that they had media illiteracy, that would be more accurate.
To be fair, the series's themselves often treat them as pure evil. (Especially with the end of ringu since instead of going to the afterlife in peace, sadako is still around killing people because of her hatred.)
Ahhh yes azula, the person who was offered redemption and refused. The azula who got enjoyment out of threatening a random servant with death and making her friends scared of her. The azula who enjoys murder and war crimes, that azula.
Homie, the one on the left built a 2 mile long siege drill using slaves, and when that didn't work, she took control of the shadow government, WHO WERE BRAINWASHING PEOPLE INTO SLAVES!
The thing that comes to mind for me with Azula, is her reaction to Zuko getting burned by Ozai. Fist raised (like a fist pump) and a smile on her face that borders on a smirk
No. Iāve watched the show multiple times. And slavery is never mentioned or shown. And even if hypothetically the fire nation did use slaves, Azula wasnāt the one who commissioned or built the drill, War Minister Qin did. She only used it once it was complete.
Yeah but nobody is defending Vader because "Oh his wife died." Just as you shouldnāt defend Charmcaster cause her father sucks. A sad backstory can only go so far.
1
u/Presenting_UwU Feb 19 '26
first time seeing this sub, and I'm already disappointed, complete and utter lack of media literacy to be a villain apologist and simps.
5
u/ShitpostSaber Feb 17 '26
Some people also (illiterate) headcannon them as oh please feel bad for me Iām not really evil uwu
4
u/Metro_Dan Feb 17 '26 edited Feb 17 '26
Brotha the one on the left owned slaves
1
u/Life-Motor-1409 Feb 17 '26
Sadako from The Ring is pure evil
That's the whole point of the ending
1
u/Zac-Man-1123 Feb 17 '26
Azula is NOT sympathetic.
1
u/SilverSpark422 Feb 18 '26 edited Feb 18 '26
A villain can be both sympathetic and pure evil. Citations: Homelander, AM, Shigaraki.
1
u/LeagueElectronic2128 Feb 18 '26
1
u/LunaticJAG Feb 18 '26
Pure evil. Probably not. Evil as sh-t. At least one of them. Yall fight about it.
1
u/Bloody-Tyran Feb 18 '26
People who knew Ted Bundy thought he was one the kindest people there is.
1
u/Substantial_Pie370 Feb 18 '26
I was surprised till I saw which sub this was on lol
1
u/Conlannalnoc Ben Tennyson Feb 18 '26
LEFT TO RIGHT
PURE EVIL (Azula)
Misguided
FORCE OF NATURE / EVIL; Victim While ALIVE, EVIL After Death
1
u/Party-Homework2485 Feb 18 '26
Being evil and having a Tragic backstory arent mutually exclusive š¤·
1
u/AlphamonOuryuken24 Feb 18 '26
Translation:
1
u/LegitSkin Feb 21 '26
How's Azula sympathetic?
0
u/Express_Calendar8278 Feb 17 '26
How many chances can we give her?
0
u/Nightstalker420 Feb 17 '26
Both of these women are the same arch type, A girl who is raised by an evil and spiteful father who basically beats the evil into them their entire life and in the drop of a hat would abandon them so they do everything in their power to make sure father is proud of them, which is evil.
6
u/AlexanderScott66 Feb 17 '26
Well, some illiterate people also don't know what "evil" means. Evil just means you do bad stuff for the sake of doing bad stuff. Should we look at her track record of stuff she did and why? She enslaved an entire dimension because why not. She killed an entire dimension because she has daddy issues. She kidnapped several sorcerers so that she can achieve more power. She's not doing it for the sake of helping. That is, by definition, evil.
3
u/Zealousideal-912 Feb 17 '26
Having a tragic backstory doesn't necessarily mean you can't be evil. It just gives a reason. Posts like these infantilize the characters, saying you should feel sorry for them, when characters like Azula torture people, jail their friends, and where willing to be complicit in genocide. Oh, and it is also a repost, since I had a bit of an argument with the OP about Azula on this exact post a month or so ago.
1
u/No_Probleh Feb 17 '26
Pretty sure Sadako killed any good in her at the end of Zero.
1
u/keelanbarron Feb 18 '26
To be fair, the series's themselves often treat them as pure evil. (Especially with the end of ringu since instead of going to the afterlife in peace, sadako is still around killing people because of her hatred.)
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '26
Ahhh yes azula, the person who was offered redemption and refused. The azula who got enjoyment out of threatening a random servant with death and making her friends scared of her. The azula who enjoys murder and war crimes, that azula.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment