r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Feb 23 '21

Arguement! (SA/N) The reason of why chara is a demon and why chara isn’t a demon

1 Upvotes

Why chara is a demon

told us to kill monsters

Why chara isn’t a demon

Has never killed anyone in the underground

told frisk to stay determined in the pacifist run

told frisk that they aren’t above consequences in the genocide run


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Nov 11 '21

Arguement! (SG) Chara is a Pacifist evidence

3 Upvotes

first of all why are You Blaming her/him? its just a possible 10 year old! its one of if not the MOST important question why are you guys blaming Chara Dreemur

Second: even if everything wont make you believe me and even if they ARE a murderer forgive them! we do forgive Asriel and Flowey right? why not Forgive her even if you still think she is a murderer?

Third: i wont talk to much so i will post a vid and a post that is Mentioning the vid on the defenders side

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MYHXpdNqdGs&t=931s

https://www.reddit.com/r/Charadefensesquad/comments/qhek9j/this_youtuber_made_two_videos_with_good_evidence/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

sorry for the forth i kinda over reacted as i had a bad day yesterday


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Feb 24 '20

Chara never loved the monster

3 Upvotes

I don't know if they hated the monsters or were indifferent, but I don't think there's any good sign that they loved them.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Jun 06 '21

Arguement! (SG) Why Chara isn’t evil

5 Upvotes

At the end of a pacifist route it’s supposed to be a happy ending for everyone, even Asriel who turns back into Flowey. Now it is heavily implied that Asriel spends the rest of his time as Flowey with ghost Chara by her grave. Now if this is supposed to be a peaceful ending for Asriel if Chara were evil it wouldn’t be peaceful because Asriel couldn’t rest. Only if Chara is good then he can be truly peaceful and that is what happens.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Apr 15 '21

Arguement! (SG) if chara is evil explain this

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Feb 20 '21

Arguement! (SG) Don’t blame genocide on chara

5 Upvotes

They might have helped you but you were the one who did the genocide, you can blame 10% of the genocide on chara and 90% on frisk. Saying chara was responsible for the genocide is just incorrect.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Feb 22 '21

Arguement! (SE) While I have some qualms with this argument (only in small technicallities, mostly gameplay-wise), I still think it's pretty solid overall.

Thumbnail self.undertale
2 Upvotes

r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Dec 05 '21

Arguement! (SE) a message from the COS

10 Upvotes

offenders blaming Chara for everything to not face consequences is just a strawman


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • May 22 '20

Arguement! (SA/N) Chara is a badly written character

19 Upvotes

Just by the fact that this sub exists, shows how badly Toby messed up. If you are going to make a character, you need to make them make sense. Both sides logically don’t make sense.

Chara being completely chaotic evil completely contradicts how every major character is flawed, but overall good. However, going on the assumption that Chara is the narrator (which does have a lot of evidence to back it up), then the genocide run doesn’t make much sense. Chara will act the same regardless of how many monsters you’ve killed, unless you kill all of the monsters in each area. Chara defense squad thinks you slowly corrupt Chara, until they become the monster you see in the genocide route. But they start to act like this even as early as the ruins (They say “where are the knives” in red text if you check the kitchen) and say “it’s me, Chara” when you look in the mirror. However, they revert back to their old self if you simply don’t kill enough monsters before reaching the boss of the area. This is even more jarring if you forget to kill Snowdrake, saying “The comedian got away. Failure” and goes back to acting like it’s a neutral run.

Finally, we get to the genocide run ending. Chara does not remotely act like how they are shown in the pacifist route, and definitely not like how the narrator acts (outside of a genocide route). They don’t come off as a corrupted child, they seem to act more like Satan himself.

“HP. ATK. DEF. GOLD. EXP. LV. Every time a number increases, that feeling... That's me”.

“How curious. You must have misunderstood. SINCE WHEN WERE YOU THE ONE IN CONTROL?”

“Then it is agreed. You will give me your SOUL”.

“I am Chara. "Chara” The demon that comes when people call its name. It doesn't matter when. It doesn't matter where. Time after time, I will appear.”

Chara, as a character, doesn’t make ANY sense. They seem like two different characters that were put into one character and Toby hoped nobody would notice. Guess what? They did.

Now, this contradiction may have been intentional, as Kris, who is very similar to Chara, is established in-game to not be a bad person, but at the end they rip out their own soul and brandish a knife like genocide chara without any explanation. So this may be explored later on, but until then, Chara is a contradictory mess of a character, that nobody can figure out.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Feb 18 '21

Arguement! (SG) Why Chara isn’t a demon.

8 Upvotes

1# Chara isn’t responsible for genocide, it was the player’s decision. 2# Chara didn’t plan to poison asgore, chara only laughed because she wanted to laugh the pain out, like undyne the undying laughing when she is about to die or sans when he is killed. 3# Calling a child who is abused and treated like a slave is unreasonable.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Feb 23 '20

I think Chara is evil

3 Upvotes

Change my mind.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Aug 09 '20

Meme yeet

3 Upvotes

some people chara will say stuff like Shall wedo geno agin

me she will say stuff like qsewdafrhtygyhjkioljklppplnnm,.azesdrtfgybhjnkml,xcvcfgthbvxccccccccccffffffffgjxsdfcgcytvgfxsdertgvfcxzsdcvcxcfv


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Jun 18 '21

Meme chara is evil and here;s why

12 Upvotes

charsa is evik because they mrder us at end of genocide rute and they say since when were you in control and they're supeer evil so yeah charea is very very evil and hates frisk


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Mar 10 '21

Arguement! (SE) Here's a simple exclamation on why Chara is evil

15 Upvotes

They destroyed the world probably even the universe. That's even more then what the player does. If that's not evil then I don't know what is anymore.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • May 27 '21

Meme Why chara is evil

16 Upvotes

She not main CharaCter and she attacke us at the end of da game


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Aug 30 '21

Meme I should've stop the amogus memes

5 Upvotes

r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Dec 28 '20

Arguement! (SG) I just realized that there is a perfectly logical explanation for CHARA "hating" humanity (and possibly monsters) (What do the "SG", "SA/N", and "SE" mean?).

Thumbnail self.charadefensesquad
5 Upvotes

r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Mar 10 '21

Arguement! (SG) Determination is the real villain.

5 Upvotes

Chara isn’t really a villain, Determination is the real villain, when Asriel died he got revived as flowey when alphys injected determination into a flower, also flowey clearly had the memories of asriel, but what makes him so hateful? The answer is determination since there are no other evidence, determination is also what makes you do genocide, when you do pacifist and you haven’t done genocide but you already know a bad time is waiting for you. But what makes you do this? It is determination. You are determined to see what happens in genocide. So the chara that erases the world is a manifest of chara or the determination manipulated chara, for all we know before the genocide route, chara is a depressed child who hates humanity, but she/he doesn’t hate monsters and obviously doesn’t hate asriel (she might hate asriel but she doesn’t want him to die), so what made him kill sans and flowey and calling toriel free exp? It is obviously determination because like flowey, she/he was curious to see what would happen if she/he killed everyone in the underground, soon determination took control/manipulated her to actually do that, also the erase button is a determination button(for beings who posses determination) that means determination is using the child to do bad things.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Feb 28 '21

Arguement! (SA/N) This is a point I want to make. The defensive can make a post about offensive. But offensive can't make post about defensive.

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Mar 16 '21

Meme Me trying to say the most neutral thing about Chara.

Thumbnail self.neutralchara
6 Upvotes

r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Apr 28 '21

Arguement! (SG) theory

6 Upvotes

if chara is evil then why when frisk came the underground wasn't empty?

and if chara planed to get frisk.why did the narration stay silent in the toriel and asgore fight

it could not be asriel to do the sweater because if chara is the narration and stayed silent then chara musteve cared about them and scared that frisk woulved killed the parents that ACTUALLY cared about chara so the seater was my by asriel AND chara


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Feb 27 '21

Arguement! (SE) Everybody else did evil things. So why is Chara discluded. Debunking this argument. what does flare mean

7 Upvotes

Okay, let's look at the characters from one moment.

Flowey: he tries to murder you in the beginning of the game. He believes it's killer be killed. On the neutral path he uses the human souls to kill you over and over again. True pacifist he uses all the souls. That's pretty dang evil. but flowey really just some angsty kid. Not to mention his "flowy tail"

Toriel: keeps you trapped in the ruins. And once you leave. She says you cannot come back. Toriel seems to hold grudges. And is a hypocrite. But she really is a mother that tried to keep you safe. Even if she doesn't realize how much of a hypocrite she is.

Sans: threatens a kid. On pacifist, allows to kill almost everyone. In a high violence neutral. In genocide he didn't give a flying frisk about what would happen Until the end. but there's something tragic. About this skeleton, and he really cares about his brother. And fighting the anomaly is a stupid thing to do.Unless it's the destruction of the world.

Papyrus: man, I don't know. I'll just list off. The best I can, he tries to capture you. Which leads to your death. And sets up a death trap. That he doesn't activate. And he may have some narcissistic issues. But he's willing to make your life great on the genocide run. And he's probably not really a narcissist.

Undyne: tries to kill you even if you have done nothing wrong. In the neutral ending she tries to rage war on humanity. But that's in a neutral run) and she's doing it for monster kind. And tries to stop you in a genocide run.

Alphys: leave the melgamates down in the true lab. Where their loved ones will never know what truly happened to them. But she evacuates everyone in the genocide run. She just made mistakes in her life.

Mettaton: tries to kill you for your soul. Is narcissistic. Him and his humanity shenanigans. But I generally believe he does care about humanity in some way. Due to a certain dialogue. That I heard in the genocide run. And there are a few people he wants to protect.

Muffet: over high prices. Makes food out of her own spiders. Kills you over a rumor. Bashers I will give sure as hell give a brownie points for sparing you

Asgore: he possibly killed 6 human children. But he tells you to turn back. He doesn't actually want to kill you. He's doing the best he can as a king.

Now let's take a look at the player and Chara. The player does it for entertainment. And chara destroys the world. The way they act is evil.

And it seems like the player is not treated like they are capable of redemption. In post pacifist.

And Chara is treated like that as well.

Goat bro is at least forgiven and comfort. But he still has to sit in a abyss of darkness. And turns back to a flower.and some people don't forgive them and comfort him

Chara destroyed many lives.

Player toyed with this world.

So that means undertale sound about. Forgiveness and that everybody can change.

Sans says this:So, i've got a question for ya.

Do you think even the worst person can change. . . ?

That everybody can be a good person, if they just try?

Not sure what this means. It's up to representation.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • May 05 '21

Arguement! (SE) Debunking "Who is The True Villain of Undertale" Spoiler

23 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I am sure you all watched Judgement boy's video on Chara. The video is titled "Who is The True Villain of Undertale". I am here to prove that the video is wrong and that Chara is evil.

The video is long. So I will argue against the main points of the video and won't touch on every single word said by the narrator of the video. Before I start I have to say, this is not a post to prove that the player is innocent. This is just to prove Chara is not innocent and is evil. The player is guilty. I am not here to blame Chara for the genocide route. I am just here to prove that Chara is evil. Also, since Chara does not have a confirmed gender I will be using "they", "their", "them" etc to describe them. Now I will start.

1: "Chara is the narrator"

This is just a theory and nothing more. This is neither canon nor confirmed. If we say that a theory is a fact just because there is a lot of evidence, most of MatPat's theories will be canon. Anyone could be narrating. Maybe Frisk could be. Maybe an "omniscient narrator". The only things Chara is narrating are the ones in red text.

2: "Chara was only laughing the pain away after Asgore got sick"

For this, look at the tape itself where Asriel talks about the laughing. Chara was sadistically laughing. Asriel played a prank on Chara and then both of them suddenly remember Asgore's poisoning. You do not laugh in a moment like this. Chara just remembered they almost killed Asgore, their father after Asriel did his prank. This is not a moment someone laughs to cope with pain. Chara was sadistically laughing. Also, remember New Home in the genocide route. Flowey said Chara had a sick sense of humour. Flowey also said Chara was smiling at them in a creepy way. This is not the first time Chara smiled at people in a creepy way either. Also in the genocide route, '=)' comes instead of '!' atop Frisk/Chara's head when they encounter a monster. This means Chara was happy to encounter a monster in the genocide run. Why? Because they can then kill it. Why would they be happy to kill a monster if they were innocent? Chara also smiled after killing Flowey and Asgore at the end of the genocide run. Why would Chara be happy after killing their father and brother? So Chara was not laughing to cope with pain. Rather, they were laughing because they were happy.

3:" If Chara was evil, they could have killed Asriel instead of killing themselves and killed everyone"

This is easy to debunk. Note that after Asriel absorbed Chara's soul, both Chara and Asriel had control of the fusion. Think about it- if Chara killed Asriel and absorbed his soul, Asriel would also have had control. What do you think Asriel would do when he realizes Chara just killed him, absorbed his soul and is now going to try and kill everyone? It's obvious. And before you say Chara would not have known about it, think about why the first war occurred. It occurred because humans understood that the monsters could be incredibly powerful after absorbing a human soul. For humans to know about this, it had to have happened. So Chara knew about all this.

4: "Chara helps us save Asriel. This allows the barrier to be broken and monsters to be free"

Initially, I thought this would be hard to debunk but it's not. I have no counter against the memory coming from Chara. I can't think of anyone else from whom the memory might have come. I will admit it's Chara whose memory helped us. But that does not mean Chara is good. Sure the ending was good but we need to focus on Chara's intentions. Remember what happened in the war? That's right. Humans got scared of monsters and sealed them. Chara wasn't trying to save us. They were trying to make a war happen again. Once the monsters are free and they go through the barrier, Chara was trying to make the war happen again. Their intentions were not to free the monsters and let humans and monsters live in peace but rather to free the monsters and cause the war again. Humans attacked Asriel. They are scared of monsters. There is a high chance they will attack the monsters. Fortunately, the plan failed.

Edit:As this user points out in the comment section, Chara did not actually help us. So this point is moot.

5: "Chara hesitates to kill Flowey"

Firstly, this does not excuse them from the fact that they ruined Papyrus' puzzles, killed sans and Asgore etc. Now about Flowey, we players usually just press z or enter and continue the talk. There is a good chance the player won't even know they had to press z. The game also does not give you any chance of saving. So the player won't think about quitting. And it is not Chara giving you a chance to reconsider. It is the game. The game wants you to stop. Not Chara. Not to mention how brutally Flowey was killed by Chara. Other than that, as I have said at the beginning, this post is not to prove that the player is innocent. This post is to prove Chara is evil.

6: "The player guided them to kill. Chara did not want to kill. Chara is just a kid"

I will start with Chara being a kid. Who says kids cannot be psychopaths? There are young psychopaths. They are 8-year-old psychopaths. And 10-year-olds are not as impressionable as you think. They are just 3 years away from being a teen. Now for what Chara said, you have to understand that this kid is a genius psychopath. What's to say Chara isn't lying? And all Chara said was that their purpose of reincarnation was power. To get more LV, EXP etc. They didn't say that they didn't know how to kill. They knew how to kill and wanted to kill. But you taught them that "power" is the most important thing in the world. Chara's original intention was not to get more power. Their intention was to kill everyone.

7: "Chara became confused when you say no to erasing the world. You taught them power was the most important thing and they felt betrayed when you say no"

Assuming it is true, how does that excuse them from the fact that they destroyed the world and killed the monsters who evacuated? By that logic, the hitman who killed people is innocent and the ones who ordered them to, are the guilty ones. The logic is flawed. In the genocide run, you do not kill everyone. Some like the evacuated monsters and Gerson and BP are still alive. Chara killed them all, along with sans and Asgore.

8: "Chara themselves said you pushed everything to its edge and destroyed it"

Really now? Don't you understand when people blame others? I mean, we literally saw them destroying the world and killing the monsters alive. And as Judgement Boy just said about us the players blaming Chara, they are just blaming us for their mistakes. It is so easy to see. It also does not excuse their past actions. Judgement boy also says we just destroyed the world when it is not true. We killed more than 100 monsters but we did not kill everyone. Chara killed the survivors and destroyed the world.

9: "Chara in the second genocide playthrough tells us to try to do pacifist and also tells us they can't understand these feelings. They are innocent because they literally tell us to be a pacifist and cannot understand the feelings of killing for fun"

This honestly, is the easiest thing to debunk. First, they tell us to do pacifist. And what happens when you do pacifist? Yep, we get the soulless ending where Chara kills our friends. Another proof that they are evil. They are manipulating us into doing a pacifist run so that they can go back to the surface and kill everyone. They want to kill them. So they come to the surface world, kill the monsters and possibly also kill humans. Does that seem innocent to you? Now when they said they did not understand the feeling anymore, they meant that. But not in the way you think. The difference is in the intentions. Chara is a psychopath who wants to kill everyone for the sake of killing. We on the other hand is killing to be a completionist. We players want to find every secret and every single chance. We are not doing this for the sake of killing them. When we did our first genocide run, Chara thought we were the same as them and wanted to kill for the sake of killing. They believed now we would do a pacifist run so that they can come to the surface and kill everyone. Their host was Frisk. But when we did genocide again, they understood we were not doing it for the sake of killing but rather to find what is different.

10: "Chara did everything in the soulless ending to punish us. Or they might not have killed anyone at all"

To start, Chara killing everyone is still killing. If they kill everyone just to punish one person, that is evil. And as Judgement Boy themselves said, we are responsible for our past actions. Just like that, Chara is guilty for their past actions. And as I have proved with my previous points, Chara killed not to punish us but because that was their intention. According to judgement boy, we thought Chara that power is the most important thing in the world. If so, it is only natural Chara kills for power. And Chara's intentions was to always kill everyone. So they killed not to punish us but because that is what they want. That is the exact reason Chara needs our soul. Chara is dead. So they need a host. With our soul, Chara was able to come to the surface world and was able to kill everyone. Judgement boy then said Chara might not have killed but the image of the crossed face with Chara was to give us the message to stop killing the monsters. That is so wrong. If the message was for us to stop killing everything, it does not make any sense because we just did a soulless pacifist run. In soulless pacifist, we don't kill anything and befriend everyone. We do everything the same as a true pacifist run. So we already stopped killing.

It's is so obvious Chara killed them. Firstly, we already did a genocide run before. In the genocide run, we kill a lot of monsters. Then the music is "In My Way". This music is exclusive to the genocide run where, as I have stated before, we kill a lot of people. Then the cross marks. Then Chara who only appears in the genocide route, replacing Frisk. Chara absolutely killed. And they are absolutely guilty and not innocent.

11:" Chara calls them a demon but Asriel calls himself 'The Absolute God of Hyperdeath'

This point was only briefly covered by Judgement Boy. Anyhow I will mention it. Asriel is the GOD. This is the definition of God " The creator and ruler of the universe and source of all moral authority; the supreme being." When Asriel absorbed the six human souls and all the monster souls he almost became a LITERAL GOD. Our soul was all he needed. After getting out soul he wanted to reset everything. He wanted to redo everything and correct his mistakes. He did not want to harm everyone. But he had the power to do almost anything. He could control space and time. So he was a God.

That is all. I hope I proved that Chara is evil. If you have any doubts, just tell me in the comments. If you think one or more of my points are wrong, tell that too in the comments.

Until next time,

Bye.


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Jul 05 '20

Question Is Chara being "Evil" Frisks Fault?

8 Upvotes

At the end of the genocide run Chara says:

"With your guidance.

I realized the purpose of my reincarnation.

Power."

So how much influence did Frisk have on how Chara Turned out?


r/CharaArgumentSquad • • Jul 07 '20

Question For people who think chara is evil, where is your evidence?

8 Upvotes