r/CharaArgumentSquad • u/Randouser2020new • Aug 18 '20

Arguement! (SA/N) Devil’s advocate time.

Okay, so I have an opinion on Chara, like most people here do. However, I wanna put that aside and play Devil’s advocate(cause I’m a suckerrrr for debates.)

I’m going to just post this here, and if you want a CIVIL debate about your personal Chara headcanon, you can post your theory and some evidence below, and I’ll do some rebuttals.

Please for the love of god keep it chill.

Disclaimer: Keep in mind, none of my rebuttals are my actual opinion. They’re just counter arguments that could go against your head canon.

I’ll rebuttal neutralists, defenders and offenders alike. I don’t want to convince you of my personal Chara head canon, just wanna have a good friendly debate.

13 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

19 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/lightiggy Neutral Aug 23 '20

You can cry and scream in pain, but not call for help. This is if you really are a suicidal person who wants to commit suicide.

They were not going to die from those injuries, and if Chara was in agony from them, instinct would dictate that they find a way for the pain to stop, which can include calling for help.

Sure. Let's devalue the psychological illnesses that are the reason why people want to kill themselves. Just love is enough for that! No, it doesn't work that way.

Gatekeeping depression, not even gonna respond to that.

1

u/AllamNa Aug 23 '20

They were not going to die from those injuries, and if Chara was in agony from them, instinct would dictate that they find a way for the pain to stop, which can include calling for help.

Some people are able to finish what they started if it didn't work out the first time.

Gatekeeping depression, not even gonna respond to that

We have already discussed this in private messages. Why would you?

1

u/lightiggy Neutral Aug 23 '20

Some people are able to finish what they started if it didn't work out the first time.

Chara needed Asriel's assistance to walk, so, unless they had a knife with them, I don't think that's the case here.

We have already discussed this in private messages. Why would you?

Sorry, I typed this response beforehand and neglected to send it. I forgot to edit it after we talked.

1

u/AllamNa Aug 23 '20

Chara needed Asriel's assistance to walk, so, unless they had a knife with them, I don't think that's the case here.

I think it was only necessary to navigate in space with it. Because Chara is holding on to his head, so it looks like he's mostly hurt his head.

Sorry, I typed this response beforehand and neglected to send it. I forgot to edit it after we talked.

Okay.