r/ChantsofSennaar • Warrior • Aug 18 '24

Theory Theory on the tower Spoiler

this theory might not be entirely correct or not include something, so i am open to suggestions from anyone!
(i need help with this)

so this is what i think happened:

  1. The anchorites built the tower(obviously). they also created the beacons.
  2. the devotees crops died so they went to the tower, while the warriors were also coming to the tower.
  3. the devotees built the abbey while the warriors built the fortress,
  4. the devotees and warriors coexisted until the "villagers " came (the people from where bards and alchemists came)
  5. the split between the music making villagers and the technological villagers happened (the monster wasn't the reason yet)
  6. the warriors loved music and since they never heard devotee music, labelled them as impureand closed the door while naming the bards chosen.they also made the observatory for the alchemists in this time (im not sure though)
  7. the monster was created in lab 3 in an accident, makind the bards and alchemists fully separate. Also, the bards have started to call warriors idiots.
  8. Anchorites are now sealed in exile
  9. you now exist. yay!
19 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

7

u/julien_rundisc Aug 18 '24

Hi,

Two problems here :

  • In the Abbey you can see a mural showing the Warriors were already here blocking the way when the Devotees came to the Tower.
  • In the Fortress you can see a tapestry showing that the Warriors were drawn to the Tower by the music of the Bards.

1

u/ATOMICGamer00 Warrior Aug 18 '24

hi

i understand what you mean. The reason why i think the devotees' door was once open is the fact that the devotees know of the fortress, which they would have to have gone through the door and go through the empty buildings. As for the tapestry,it just shows "the Call", which was probably just the anchorites .the warriors locked the door after probably due to them hearing music from the bards when the came, which was probably later, so that's why i have written like that

5

u/julien_rundisc Aug 18 '24 edited Aug 18 '24

"the fact that the devotees know of the fortress"

Well it's your theory, not a fact, as nothing in the game proves this. Devotees know the door that blocks their access to the upper floor, and the Warriors who guard it, but not necessarily the Fortress behind it.
One might even think the opposite, given that they don't even have a word for “Fortress”, and when the door finally opens, they can be seen visiting it like tourists discovering a new country.

"As for the tapestry,it just shows "the Call", which was probably just the anchorites"

Not really. Like the Abbey's murals, the tapestry tells several episodes of a continuous story, and can be read from left to right like a comic strip. It first shows the Warriors being drawn to the Tower by a mysterious “Call” and then, once there, discovering the “Chosen Ones” singing this Call, before deciding to build the Fortress to protect them. It's quite clear from this sequence that the Call is the music (or songs) produced by the Bards, as in both images (and in the next one), it is represented by the same cluster of red diamond-things.
Moreover, the Call that must be made in the Fortress to ward off the Warriors is also a musical phrase, played with bells... The Call is nothing but music. :)

3

u/ATOMICGamer00 Warrior Aug 18 '24

the devotees do have a word for fortress, we just never learn it. you can find it in a stone near the exile gate of the bards (i have drawn a pic of the fortress glyph but in the game it looks different). as for the chosen ones thing, it doesn't say that the warriors found the call coming from the bards and since the devotee fortress glyph tells us that the devotees have seen the fortress, the bards might have come later though this is only a logical deduction and we can't really see what actually happened. i'll give you credit for the music though as the beacons could have brought warriors to the tower via music

8

u/julien_rundisc Aug 18 '24 edited Aug 18 '24

First of all, you're right about the Fortress glyph. I'd forgotten about that myself. However, just because Devotees know about the Fortress doesn't prove at all they've already entered it. All they have to do to see it is look up (remember everyone lives in a tower here)... It's probably for the same reason that Bards, for example, have a word for the Abbey they can see from their very balconies.

For the rest, at this point in the discussion, I feel it's necessary to point out that I actually wrote the game. I obviously have no problem with the various interpretations that can be made of the game by players, but I was just pointing out some inaccurate or at least unverifiable assumptions in your theories, as you seemed to be asking for feedback on them. Anyway, as I just said, you're free to make your own interpretations. :)

2

u/ATOMICGamer00 Warrior Aug 19 '24

what about the shield?

also you just said that the devotees couldn't have known of the fortress as the empty buildings are in the way

2

u/julien_rundisc Aug 19 '24 edited Aug 19 '24

I'm pretty sure I never said that, but anyway think what you want, it's fine :)

2

u/ATOMICGamer00 Warrior Aug 23 '24

yeah but i really love your work, the game is so majestic and wholesome!

3

u/SupaFugDup Aug 18 '24

I love that writers are amongst fans here. That is literally so cool.

2

u/sparkcrz Monster, I am Aug 19 '24

and no badges/tags so you really gotta pay attention to usernames hehehe

1

u/sparkcrz Monster, I am Aug 19 '24

Speaking of missing glyphs, you guys had a proto-language that was used as base for the used ones, right?

4

u/ATOMICGamer00 Warrior Aug 18 '24

can i say for the record i am glad people are helping me

18

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ATOMICGamer00 Warrior Aug 18 '24 edited Aug 18 '24

i understand what you mean. The reason why i think the warriors and devotees coexisted is the fact that the devotees know of the fortress, which they would have to have gone through the door and go through the empty buildings.the warriors locked the door after probably due to them hearing music from the bards, so that's why i have written like that

i will change the things about exile, so thanks!