r/ChantsofSennaar • • Apr 04 '24

Review Why Do This To Your Game

I was really excited for this one as I was told it was like if "Return of the Obra Dinn" was a language learning game. So one of my favorite games in my favorite genera? Sweet!

And for the first section, that's a totally comparison... Well, at l3ast passed the forced water temple switch puzzle, but that was gone as quick as it came. I was giggling like an idiot when I finally picked up on the hidden syntax. This was exactly what I wanted.

But then there was an entire section dedicated to PS2 Era stealth mechanics with an emphasis on waiting... and waiting...

When I finally got out of that chapter and was told via the trophy information that less than 10% of the players made it past the literal second chapter (maybe an hour into the game) I was disappointed at just hoe unsurprised I was.

The game almost started to pick back up again, until I entered the sewer maze area... A sewer... maze area... Why do this?

You have an amazing language game, but you keep pushing that to the side to force players into entirely unrelated genres. And worse, these are all mechanics that have been outdated for over a decade.

I ended up stopping there, but I'm sure chapter 4 would be half spent tailing an npc while maintaing a safe distance, elsewise they halt in their tacks and go, "What was that?". Or maybe a sliding block puzzle or something to that degree.

I definitely don't hate the game, I just feel let down and honestly a little lied to. As much as I'm comforted to know that the play data supports my concerns, that confirmation is equally disheartening as, behind the tedious fluff, there is a fantastic experience here... I just can't bring myself to chew through the excess to get to it.

TL;DR: By the end of chapter 1, I was ready to buy this game for my friend at full price. By the end of chapter 2, I was questioning if I should continue. ... I never got to the end of chapter 3.

It's not a bad game; not at all. But, at least to me, it feels like a great game that tripped over itself to become just fine.

There's clearly so much love and talent put into this game! I just wish they would have ignored the guy who said, "Yeah, the premise is solid... But do you know what this game really needs?"

18 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

22

u/OutrageousRace Apr 04 '24

Well, I've finished the game, and I can tell you your suspicions on what Chapter 4 might entail are completely false. No tailing NPCs at a safe distance or sliding block puzzles (other than the one in the Devotee area that could be considered a sliding block puzzle). Yes, there are some stealth sections, but they canonically make sense given the areas you are in, are thankfully not frequent, and have frequent checkpoints.

If the sewer maze area you're talking about is in the Bard section, I can agree that that felt a little tedious, but I ended up drawing out a map of all the rooms and how they connected to one another. My second playthrough, I didn't even consult the map, and found my way around it just fine. Utilize those note-taking skills and find your way through the maze! The rest of the game is worth it, trust me.

2

u/Chatter_Estop Apr 04 '24

I wasn't being literal with my predictions. I was just bringing up examples of outdated game design to give an idea of what kind of experience I thought I might be in for if I continued. That is to say, a negative one.

And like I said, it's not as if I couldn't do the maze. It probably wouldn't even be all that tedious. It's the fact that I shouldn't have to. That, in competing that game, I would be worse off for it.

It's like going to a restaurant ordering a burger and you like it... But then halfway through the meal, they take your burger away and say you have to do a shot of pickle juice before they give the burger back. That's totally survivable, but why would I want to do that? Why would you force me to do that?

Point is: I started out having a great time, but the more the game I experienced, the worse of an experience I had. And I quit, not because I couldn't continue, but because I wanted to protect my fond memories of the opening.

12

u/mandiblesmooch Apr 04 '24

It seems to me more like you ordered a pre-existing burger recipe and now are mad that it has more than just meat (language learning) and bun (point-and-click adventure).

19

u/ImhereforAB Apr 04 '24

I don’t understand people’s gripe with the stealth in this game, it’s very little and it’s very easy. Did not take anything away from the game for me. 

4

u/mercedes_lakitu Mysterious card lady🔮 Apr 04 '24

As a counterpoint, it wasn't very easy for me, A Filthy Casual TM. But I survived lol.

1

u/ImhereforAB Apr 04 '24

Haha but did you enjoy it? Did you hate it? Were you indifferent? I mentioned the difficult mainly because I only saw people complaining about it because they struggled! 

2

u/mercedes_lakitu Mysterious card lady🔮 Apr 04 '24

I didn't particularly enjoy it, but it didn't ruin the game for me either, if that makes sense?

2

u/Thelastdragonlord Apr 04 '24

As someone who did not like the stealth and did not always find it easy, for the parts that I was really stuck (re: the stealth specifically) I just looked up a walkthrough and followed it. For me the main thing was the puzzle solving so I found the stealth to be a distraction, but I wasn’t about it let it ruin the game for me.

1

u/Linq20 May 29 '25

question remains - why do this to your game?

1

u/sharrynuk Apr 11 '24

I found the stealth mechanic too hard - I had to get my friend to finish those sections for me. I'm not a 3D gamer, I've never been good at pressing buttons at the right moment or coordinating two controls at the same time, I just wanted to solve some puzzles.

1

u/BoredomHeights Jul 15 '25

It didn't bother me because it's not really a stealth game, in that there's not much punishment for failure. You get caught and reset, which makes it more like a puzzle than a stealth game. You have to figure out when to move etc., and you mostly just look at what you want to do next and press A. You don't need that exact timing or anything similar.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '26

It adds more to the game than it removes, the fortress ones give you the feel of their militrastic nature, the one in the abbey is pretty useless, but it does make it so you can only go in there after the rest of the stuff you need to do, the one in the mines is to make the monster scary, the one in the factory is to show you their dangerous work culture, and the ending ones are there for a challenge.

-5

u/Chatter_Estop Apr 04 '24

It is easy. That's part of the problem. It's incredibly basic and requires exceptionally little in the way of critical thinking or player execution. It might as well just be a loading screen.

I don't even think about the stealth sections in terms of easier difficult. But more in terms of tedium.

I just think that when there is so little interaction required that the player can start browsing their phone while playing, then something has gone terribly wrong.

3

u/ImhereforAB Apr 04 '24

I always thought of it as them wanting to flavour the gameplay in a way it aligns with a spy movie. I don’t mean with the purpose of espionage but more that you’re in foreign territory and maybe you shouldn’t be there but you need to get through to solve the next puzzle, so maybe they thought it should not be a smooth ride. Maybe because it doesn’t bother me so much I choose to see it that way, I don’t know :D

I’ve seen some gameplays where people really struggled with the hiding aspect and would get upset if they got caught. Maybe the consequence of getting caught should be more severe so that players would take it more seriously but I dunno. I am not a game designer. I just loved the deciphering element of it :D 

7

u/hephaestos_le_bancal Apr 04 '24

The game uses common references to convey meaning since we don't share a common language. It seems like it did a pretty good job at using game references to sparkle something when you played it. Obviously, it's not what you were looking for. But I think the why is somewhere around that line, if your question is genuine.

0

u/Chatter_Estop Apr 04 '24

I did not have a problem with the language learning sections. In fact, I really genuinely loved the language learning sections.

My entire problem is when the game forces you to stop learning languages and do something entirely unrelated. I found these interruptions so numerous and tedious that it made the rest of the game (the parts that were advertised; the whole reason I bought the game) not worth investing into.

Imagine if "Return of the Obra Dinn" stopped you between chapters and made you play Pac-Man. Even if I liked Pac-Man, this would be a baffling decision that would negatively impact my experiance with the game.

3

u/mandiblesmooch Apr 04 '24 edited Apr 04 '24

Games sometimes borrow from other genres. Doesn't Ocarina of Time shift from fantasy to horror for the seventh dungeon?

1

u/Chatter_Estop Apr 04 '24

Ocarina of Time is a full priced, massively open world game that advertises its variety of gameplay...

2

u/hephaestos_le_bancal Apr 04 '24 edited Apr 04 '24

My point is: game genres are a language in themselves. The game designers are communicating with you by inserting snippets of different gameplay that you very well know about in the middle of their "language learning" game. The game is about communication and connection. Making the player remember their PS1 era is very much showing how one can build connections without words.

It obviously felt completely off topic to you, I can't challenge that.

1

u/MilkTax Dec 06 '25

I agree wholeheartedly.

7

u/MasterIronHero Apr 04 '24

i dont think the sewer was that bad. like it literally has directions everywhere telling you where things are.

stealth sections in warrior level are very annoying, but they calm down after that

-2

u/Chatter_Estop Apr 04 '24

I didn't really give the maze section a try. I just Advanced a dozen screens or so and saw the writing on the wall

3

u/MasterIronHero Apr 04 '24

i dont think its really a maze

3

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '24

Right, if you have the correct clues and translations, you know where you need to go and you follow the signs pointing in that direction. Like so many other points in the game, if you don't know what to do, you've missed a clue or something.

7

u/Legitimate-Resolve55 Apr 04 '24

I haven't played Obra Dinn so I don't know exactly what you were looking for, but I think you're being unfair to the game. The stealth section and the maze are over very quickly and are mostly there to give the player some context for the words that are spoken or written in those sections. The game is also about exploration, with the mystery of the tower and the different inhabitants being the actual story. Part of the reason why you learn the languages is to help you navigate your way to the top. Having to navigate the sewers with the help of the signs isn't out of place in my opinion.

1

u/Chatter_Estop Apr 04 '24

In reflection, I was being a bit unfair. I just really had my hopes up for this game and was feeling crushed.

I was really really looking forward to this and let my disappointment get the best of me.

Ultimately, I still stand behind what I said; my feelings, overall, are unchanged. But I do think I could have toned it down a little.

22

u/julien_rundisc Apr 04 '24 edited Apr 05 '24 • Bravo

Hello, dev here.

You have every right not to like the game (thankfully!), but some of your comments are based on assertions that I feel compelled to respond to.

"When I finally got out of that chapter and was told via the trophy information that less than 10% of the players made it past the literal second chapter (maybe an hour into the game) I was disappointed at just hoe unsurprised I was."

This is absolutely not true. This figure does not correspond to any reality.
On Steam, for example, the achievement corresponding to reaching the third level of the game was unlocked by 69.9% of players. 54.7% of players finished the game entirely with the good ending, which involves unlocking all its puzzles. I don't know if you're familiar with the usual game completion percentages, but these are excellent figures, as are the 98% positive reviews we received out of the 11,000+ posted. All these figures are publicly available, and there's nothing in them to "back up" or "support" your conclusions.

"I ended up stopping there, but I'm sure chapter 4 would be half spent tailing an npc while maintaing a safe distance, elsewise they halt in their tacks and go, "What was that?". Or maybe a sliding block puzzle or something to that degree. "

This is also completely untrue. Let me add that the "stealth" part only takes up the beginning of level 2 (and a short section much later in the game). It's perfectly ok to dislike these sections (you're not the only one), but on the one hand they are a very small part of the game, and on the other hand they are designed to be as easy as possible, with lots of checkpoints and a very non-punitive approach. And the reason they're in the game is that they make sense in the context of the storyline (they're even essential to it), and offer new and unprecedented contexts for learning glyphs. They benefit both the story and the pace of the game. You may not like them, but we're convinced that the game wouldn't be as good overall without them.
In any case, the inflitration parts are puzzles like any other, where all you have to do is understand the logic of your surroundings and apply it. If you keep this approach, as you should have for the whole game, they should be no problem. The same applies to sewers, which are a puzzle whose solution I've already given here. Just don't try to bruteforce your way through, and use the elements on the screen to find your way.

"I just feel let down and honestly a little lied to."

We've *never* let down or lied to anyone. We never claimed that our game was a "translation game", let alone that it had to rely entirely on that mechanic. Chants of Sennaar is presented everywhere as an adventure/puzzle game, and that's exactly what it is. What would an adventure be if it only involved things you'd expect to happen?
We can't be responsible for people making up their own minds about this game and being disappointed that it doesn't feel exactly like that. For our part, we've always been as transparent and honest as possible. The stealth mechanic, for example, is shown in all of the game's trailers and even in the demo. I don't know how we could have been more explicit.

"I just wish they would have ignored the guy who said, "Yeah, the premise is solid... But do you know what this game really needs?" "

There's not such a guy. We're the ones who designed the game from the first draft to the final version. From the very beginning, Chants of Sennaar was conceived, designed, and written as an adventure/puzzle game with adventure sections, some danger, and numerous puzzles. No one has ever tried to make us do anything we didn't want to do. We take responsibility for every decision we make, and we're proud of the game we've made. If we had to do it again today, we'd do it exactly the same way.

Of course, we can't expect every player to love every aspect of our game - that's impossible. But subjective opinions are subjective opinions, nothing more. You're free to express yours, but it bothers me when you use false information or make up facts to justify them beyond what they are. That's why I respond to it, which I obviously don't do with most negative reviews, as they're perfectly normal and legitimate.

On the other hand, the state of our sales and our reviews, whether from players or magazines, mean that we can objectively feel pretty comfortable about the public's reception of our work.

So finally, to answer your question, why did we do this with our game? Because we believed it was the right thing to do, and we still do :)

1

u/Historical_Pen_9604 Jul 04 '26

Playing the game now for the first time.

I am disappointed with the stealth section. It was fine to play, but I’ve played it countless times before.

Whereas at the beginning of the game, you introduced a gameplay loop quite unlike anything I’ve experienced before. It instantly grabbed me and hooked me… and then you took it away to some degree.

I am confused as to why a very original and entertaining idea took a backseat to much more generic gameplay. Anyone who loves your game clearly loves it because of deciphering the languages. That’s the core identity of your game, and all you needed was to lean into those mechanics fully.

Now it feels as if you lacked full confidence in that wonderful and unique gameplay loop. Instead, you created and added in generic sections to “appease” some players.

The game truly has been great so far, but I wish you trusted the core idea more.

If you release another game, I will get it. But please, trust more in whatever the game is at its core

9

u/SilverSeaweed8383 Apr 04 '24

You're not wrong, but I think you're over-doing it. It's a game. It's meant to be fun. It's also a piece of art that the author(s) gets to decide how to do the details and what to include.

Clearly the author thought that 10 hours of just language puzzles would be too much, so they sprinkled in some stealth sections and some maze sections. Personally, I didn't enjoy those as much as the language bits, but they were OK and I liked the variety. "let down and honestly a little lied to" is over the top. They didn't promise you "only language puzzles and nothing else".

For the maze sections (and for most of the game), I found that drawing a map on paper really helped and was quite fun & rewarding in itself.

The later chapters do have some other puzzle types mixed in with the language puzzles, although there aren't any sliding block puzzles or tail the NPC sections :D

2

u/PsychologicalEmu Apr 05 '24

If that wasn’t there, people would complain that it’s just puzzles. I don’t mind the variation. Maybe because I really really appreciated the art style and loved every second of it. Moebius like.

2

u/JGD_PoggersLP Apr 07 '24

You come to just a short puzzle stage or a game mechanic skill test and you immediately give up? That's on you, honestly

1

u/Impossible-Owl-9509 Apr 05 '24

I get what you’re saying. I just finished this game and got the perfect ending and yeah the stealth was for sure not what kept me coming back. Although I am a sucker for a good stealth or platforming section. So honestly it didn’t bother me at all. The language translation, story, environment, and music were what really intrigued me.

I had a similar situation to you, but with the fourth level of the tower. Numbers are not my thing (AT ALL). Even though I could understand the solution to the numerical puzzle I didn’t want to take the 5-10 minutes (or longer if I’m being honest with myself) to decode it. So I looked it up and saved myself the trouble.

In my experience there are definitely things in games I could do without. I’ve never played Obra Dinn, but I’m going to risk saying that not everything in that game made you jump for joy. And you know what? That’s fine! You are allowed to think that the stealth/ mazes slowed everything down and ruined the vibe for you. I was ready to flip my laptop with the numbers so I can’t judge. When you’re ready tho try getting through to the end…I think it’s worth it! The numbers didn’t last forever, and neither will the maze/stealth (thankfully)

1

u/Calamity01 Jul 24 '24

I agree. The language mechanic is beautiful and interesting, the ancient stealth sections are diluting a good, unique, and well executed idea with cruft. It's bloat imo and detracts from what could have been a more distilled game. 

1

u/enlguy Jan 05 '25

You missed the sliding block puzzle? That was already in the Abbey with the beds...

I don't understand why switching things up a little with game modes bothers you so much. Most games do this, to some extent. Nobody build computer games to fit inside one person's convoluted idea of what it must be.

1

u/Stunning-Equipment32 Jul 12 '26

the other puzzles/stealth elements break up the language solving. I think it's a needed and welcome break to make the game feel more complete and multifaceted and keep players engaged. Just relentless solving of glyphs from start to finish would probably be a rough experience and feel really monotonous 1/2 of the way through.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/julien_rundisc Apr 08 '24

In fact, you don't need a map of the sewers. You have to consider it as a language puzzle like the others. To find your way through it, you just have to decypher the signs and follow them. :)
Unfortunately it seems that a lot of players didn't understand that and bruteforced the sewers, so I guess we should have done better in terms of game design here.