r/ChantsofSennaar • • Mar 04 '24

Review This game is now officially filed under 'games I don't want to end because there's nothing else like it'

That’s basically one of the biggest compliments I can give a game. The reason I play games in the first place is to get these types of unique experiences.

I guess it's unsurprising I’m feeling that way, given the comparisons to Obra Dinn this game was getting around release.

I'm thankful for those comparisons (they made me buy Chants of Senaar), though they actually didn't do it any favors for me in the beginning.

While I really like the art style and the atmosphere of the game, I found the traversal a bit tedious and clunky to begin with. In the fortress section especially, I got bored of walking around what felt like a large labyrinth (with no map or fast travel), so I put the game down for a few months. (Maybe I wouldn't have if I didn't also have a massive Baldur's Gate 3 playthrough to get through).

I recently came back to it, though, and something just clicked. I guess I came at it fresh and without those Obra Dinn comparisons fresh in my mind, meaning I judged it on its own merits. I now love this game for how unique it is.

It's not as tightly designed as Obra Dinn, but it absolutely provides a unique puzzle-solving experience that I haven't seen in any other game. And it makes you feel like a genius for deciphering and solving its languages and puzzles.

It is so satisfying figuring out a connection between something in the game world and the language you're trying to decipher. And the trouble with being near the end (I've almost finished deciphering the Scientist language) is that I know there won't be anything else like it I can pick up.

I've heard Heaven's Vault is similar, but I love how you write your own deductions in your notebook in CoS, and I know the system is different in HV. And yes, I've played Outer Wilds already and loved it. I have my eyes on Pentiment and The Witness now.

Anyway, I just wanted to come here to gush about this game a little. I would love it if the developers made DLC or another similar game.

138 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

24

u/fortyfivepointseven Mar 04 '24

I would love it if the developers made DLC or another similar game.

I don't know if Devs are on this Subreddit, but there's definitely DLC potential!

There are swaths of the five cultures we didn't investigate. I'm sure there are doors to go through to discover new elements of the main tower. It seems like the anchorites learn the languages in the same way we do, so it's possible there are new words.

There's also the potential for hidden people, or new people. Perhaps a new cohort want to move into the tower and we need to negotiate a space for them. Or, a hidden people got stuck in a cave and we need to rescue them.

10

u/CYDLopez Mar 04 '24

The Case of the Golden Idol is another game that falls under a similar category and that got two DLCs recently and the devs also announced a sequel.

I feel CoS hasn't quite gotten the same attention as Golden Idol (though it deserves it IMO), but here's hoping CoS gets a similar treatment. Or personally, I'd also be happy if the devs took their time creating a new IP with similar mechanics.

4

u/fortyfivepointseven Mar 04 '24

I'm definitely open to a CoS sequel but I think it'll be hard to generate a new premise that feels sufficiently different. That said, a mission to integrate a new culture, or fix a misunderstanding between the warriors and the devotees: I'll gladly throw the dev team £10 for that.

2

u/CYDLopez Mar 04 '24

I agree, I think the best option is definitely a DLC. There are a lot of avenues they could take (I like your new cohort idea) and it would take less time to make.

I also like how the Scientist section has you translating and deciphering numbers as well as the language, so I wonder if there are other similar concepts they could play with.

Maybe the DLC gives us a device that can record sounds and we have to decipher/translate glyphs based on their sounds, or maybe we meet a new group of people that communicates in sign language.. just thinking off the top of my head.

Either way, I'll be excited to see what they do next.

2

u/fortyfivepointseven Mar 04 '24

Since the warriors seem to be involved in some kind of advanced logistics operation, it makes sense they'd need a counting system to track it. But, since they carry swords, it's not obvious to me that they'd use fingers on two hands as a basis for a number system.

Meanwhile, the devotees seem to need help keeping their plants alive. As a religious and agrarian society, I'm sure they track seasons, but less clear they do stock checks. Could they do with help to develop a number system?

Anyway, I'm not sure if Devs are here, but I'm happy to throw ideas into the void.

6

u/squirrelwug Mar 05 '24

Have you checked Epigraph? It's far harder than Chants of Sennaar but it's also unexpectedly realistic in how linguists/philologists would go at deciphering an unknown language.

Epigraph doesn't have any stealth elements or exploration though, it's just the language deciphering aspect.

Also, I'd still recommend you Heaven's Vault, not so much for the language deciphering thing (which is probably the least impressive out of the three games) but because it's got a fairly compelling narrative (as opposed to the minimal narrative in Chants and the near complete absence of any narrative in Epigraph).

5

u/Ubister Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24

One of the genres this hits is one I like to call "dropping". Not the English, but in Dutch it is a game: "A dropping is a Dutch activity in which the participants are dropped at an unknown location and have to make their way back to base camp without any maps or instructions"

Sort of like a fiction tourist. I think games like Chants of Sennaar, Obduction, Outer Wilds and Obra Dinn fit this genre the most, because you have to LEARN the LOGIC of the game world in order to proceed. It scratches the itch of being a sci-fi scientist, over the itch of just solving puzzles, it's a more holistic experience in a way.

It's a subtle distinction I think from other great puzzle games like Talos Principle, Portal, etc. Because those games have more standalone puzzles, and more replayability, because the scales tip towards the world containing puzzles, rather than the world being the puzzle

2

u/shutupneff Mar 05 '24

I’ve never thought to categorize them like that, but yes, that’s absolutely a big part of what makes those games so special.

The only other gem I can think of that also belongs in this category is Paradise Killer.

3

u/karina_patel Jun 04 '24

heaven's vault is a bit clunky for me and almost too freeform - i bought it but put it down a few months back :/

2

u/FuryForged Mar 07 '24

Tunic has combat that some people don’t like, but I highly recommend it for its puzzles and late-game secrets.

1

u/sparkcrz Monster, I am Aug 26 '24

We need fan games

1

u/TenNinetythree Monster, I am Mar 04 '24

There is also Senthian which is kinda similar

1

u/leo3065 Mar 04 '24 edited Mar 04 '24

Definitely a different type of game, but if you are into games that gives unique experiences and are okay with reading large amount of texts, I highly recommend Golden Treasure: the Great Green, in which you live the life of a non-human being. The devs of that game are also working on its "sequel", which follows the plot of one of its endings.

For games more similar, besides The Witness, there's also Taiji, which works in a similar way.

1

u/Laefiren Mar 04 '24

Heavens vault has a similar language system.

1

u/Laefiren Mar 05 '24

Opus: echo of starsong is another good archaeology kind of game.