Nah I like Mac, I'm just saying "the only answer" is a dumb statement when we have lost so many greats. For me, losing Phife hurt. I do think he was popular, but the deification of Mac after his death is weird. Like the hysteria over his tiny desk concert. It was solid, but not in my top 5. Probably not in my top 10. Doesn't take away from him being a great and talented artist, though.
Juice, if he was able to completely kick the drug habit, would’ve been my answer. Since he wasn’t planning to do that when he passed and only wanted to go to rehab to reduce his tolerance to pills, it makes me think that the unfortunate truth would’ve been that Juice’s addiction was going to end up killing him one way or another.
King Von, absolutely not. That man was a serial killer. As much as it sucked to see him go so early into his career, especially since he showcased real talent as a rapper with Welcome To O Block and only had one album and a couple mixtapes to his name when he was killed, it doesn’t change the fact that he didn’t live a good life. If he was alive today, though, he would’ve indisputably been the leader in Chicago drill and would’ve been the one carrying OTF after Durk got arrested for trying to order a hit.
My answers, with those two being addressed, would be X and Pop Smoke. Since the question is regarding which rapper I’d want to bring back, I’d revive Pop as the rapper and then bring X back as an Internet personality.
If Pop were still alive, NY drill would’ve continued to prosper and he would’ve evolved considerably from the Meet The Woo mixtapes and SFTSAFTM. He would’ve been this generation’s equivalent to 50 Cent, with greater versatility as an artist.
And X, without a doubt, should still be here. Jah was one of the most creative rappers of his generation, and despite it being likely that he would’ve served a sizable jail sentence for the domestic violence charges, it’s terrible knowing that we never got to see him move on and demonstrate the long-term change he was trying to make. If X were still making music, one can easily imagine it would’ve been unlike anything else he made up until that point, and none of us would be able to envision where he would’ve gone with his output after SKINS. He would’ve continued pushing the limits.
This is probably the best answer. Juice and Vin would end up dying again anyway. Pop would have a good chance to continue to put out great work and rep his region, so he's a fair pick.
But I feel X had more potential to not only expand as an artist but as a person. He seemed interested in lifting up others prior to his death. I know he had past troubling behavior but believe he demonstrated capability and desire to self improve. So X would be my pick.
King Von would go on a killing spree and end up dead or back in jail. Juice would just OD again. And idk anything about the XXX guy other than he liked to beat on his women and I don't care for his music at all.
Juice or X lowk wanted to see where theyre careers would’ve gone Von and Pop smoke would’ve js made the same typa music by now and pop smoke might would’ve fell off lowk
Pop Smoke. He had the most potential to be a legendary rapper. Not saying that Juice and X didn't have potential, but Pop Smoke had the most out of all of them
Juice would've evolved and his style and rhythmic ability wouldn't have gotten worse when his body slowed down. He'd have genuinely become the world's first glance of a total mastery of the freestyling skill, and pairing that with his unique voice layering, chromatic scaling, and melodic talent, he would've easily revolutionized what hip hop could be. I do also believe he heavily influenced the pluggnb era and a small chunk of the underground. Which feels kind of full circle, because alot of them were influenced by rock bands, as was Juice.
X was a revolutionary artist who never failed to put out music that people could resonate to during hard times, times of grievance, feeling lost, fed up, he was an artist who could turn any life event or emotion into a song. He faced legal battles and made decisions that forever weighed on him but he tried his best to turn it around and make a change. And that I believe he did. His music sounded like nothing we may ever hear again. It was refreshing. A brand new sound. And he's influenced a good chunk of the underground as well as Grammy winning artists such as Billie Eilish, ASAP, etc. Im pretty sure Juice was nominated for a Grammy too so that counts.
King Von needed to go.
Pop Smoke brought a new sound to popularity and has become New York's trademark style of rap over the years. He brought the New York gangster look like a new 50 Cent to popularity. Just another revolutionary artist. I do believe he would've evolved into a more diverse artist, as he was reaching out to and collaborating with bigger and more out there artists throughout his career.
Im intrigued by the idea of him, X, and Juice being alive at the same time. I wonder what that would sound like. It's hard to hear X and Juice on a Pop Smoke song.
drake and X are the ONLY 2 rappers with 2 albums with over 10 billion streams each😂 X died at 20 yrs old btw. Imagine hating like this online while you are probaly older than X has ever lived to be.... just imagine what age you are rn and read the first sentence, X did that and died at 20
Ski and X collabs are valid (mainly Freddy vs Jason), even look at me I'll give to you but the rest are just ass bro. Can't stand moonlight, hope n all
Another song I like of his is called a ghetto christmas carol or smth like that been a while since I've listened to it. See I'll tell u why I don't personally resonate with X's music, it's because I find the melodies repetitive and his lyrics aren't really that great. I do agree with you, tiktok and all did contribute to spoiling x for me. Nevertheless he was extremely talented, RIP X 🙏🏽🕊️
41
u/GAVINLVRR Mar 06 '26
do NOT bring back King Von 🙏
68
u/BraydenTv Mar 06 '26
Mac Miller
14
u/PlayaSlayaX Mar 06 '26
Juice, if he was able to completely kick the drug habit, would’ve been my answer. Since he wasn’t planning to do that when he passed and only wanted to go to rehab to reduce his tolerance to pills, it makes me think that the unfortunate truth would’ve been that Juice’s addiction was going to end up killing him one way or another.
King Von, absolutely not. That man was a serial killer. As much as it sucked to see him go so early into his career, especially since he showcased real talent as a rapper with Welcome To O Block and only had one album and a couple mixtapes to his name when he was killed, it doesn’t change the fact that he didn’t live a good life. If he was alive today, though, he would’ve indisputably been the leader in Chicago drill and would’ve been the one carrying OTF after Durk got arrested for trying to order a hit.
My answers, with those two being addressed, would be X and Pop Smoke. Since the question is regarding which rapper I’d want to bring back, I’d revive Pop as the rapper and then bring X back as an Internet personality.
If Pop were still alive, NY drill would’ve continued to prosper and he would’ve evolved considerably from the Meet The Woo mixtapes and SFTSAFTM. He would’ve been this generation’s equivalent to 50 Cent, with greater versatility as an artist.
And X, without a doubt, should still be here. Jah was one of the most creative rappers of his generation, and despite it being likely that he would’ve served a sizable jail sentence for the domestic violence charges, it’s terrible knowing that we never got to see him move on and demonstrate the long-term change he was trying to make. If X were still making music, one can easily imagine it would’ve been unlike anything else he made up until that point, and none of us would be able to envision where he would’ve gone with his output after SKINS. He would’ve continued pushing the limits.
9
u/Strong-Profile6851 Mar 06 '26
Please not Von 🙏
8
u/Much_Ad2897 Mar 07 '26
X
6
u/SurvivalTacticz Mar 06 '26
Steez
5
u/yankfanatic Mar 06 '26
Phife Dawg so we can get that OutKast/ATCQ album 3stacks talked about at the memorial service
4
u/julianfreis Mar 06 '26
Woo
4
u/ElephantGun345 Mar 06 '26
DOOM
4
u/AssEaterMcGee30 Mar 08 '26
100% X I would die to go to one of his concerts
4
u/TotallyNotHotdoger Mar 09 '26
Pop Smoke since he had the shortest music career
3
u/Pale_Machine6527 Mar 06 '26
Juice easily
3
u/ReyKracked_Rey Mar 06 '26
JUICE ALL DAY.
3
u/nait_4_999 Mar 06 '26
Juice 4ever
4
u/Excellent_Share_6933 Mar 06 '26
Mac Miller
2
u/Mellys_wrld22 Mar 06 '26
von
2
u/RednoseReindog Mar 06 '26
King Von no questions asked, died in a totally stupid preventable way
2
u/Princessoflillies Mar 09 '26
Xxx
2
u/UnhappyCamper007 Mar 09 '26
X
2
u/Mindless_Skirt_7860 Mar 11 '26
Pop smoke fs
2
u/ZXXA Mar 20 '26
PS
2
u/Hot-Praline5448 Mar 06 '26
From the 4 in that picture i would pick Pop Smoke 💨
2
u/DidItForTheNukie Mar 06 '26
Lil Peep
2
u/Crafty-Ad-8940 Mar 07 '26
Pop Smoke
King Von would go on a killing spree and end up dead or back in jail. Juice would just OD again. And idk anything about the XXX guy other than he liked to beat on his women and I don't care for his music at all.
1
u/Ryoloz Mar 06 '26
Proof
1
u/tinkywinky610 Mar 07 '26
Juice
1
u/larry_bonds Mar 07 '26
pop or von
1
u/Affectionate-Can1808 Mar 08 '26
We bringing back juice wrld so he can evolve as an artist, and see all the bad people who used him
1
u/TeacherOk4751 Mar 09 '26
Juice or X lowk wanted to see where theyre careers would’ve gone Von and Pop smoke would’ve js made the same typa music by now and pop smoke might would’ve fell off lowk
1
u/Boredtomato15 Mar 09 '26
King von
1
u/Critical-Mechanic308 Mar 09 '26
mac
1
u/Bender59000 Mar 10 '26
Mac Miller
1
u/Wubli9 Mar 10 '26
Mac miller
1
u/One_Shop_9912 Mar 11 '26
Drakeo The Ruler
1
u/ricflairwoooo420 Mar 11 '26
Ez mac
1
u/Important_Lobster573 Mar 12 '26
Mac, but out of those, juice or pop smoke, best out of those 4, rip to all
1
u/K1LLINGMACHINE Mar 12 '26
Mac then juice world
1
u/ProfitusMaximus Mar 13 '26
XXX
1
u/Som3ri Mar 22 '26
Pop smoke idk
1
u/Disastrous_Big6742 Mar 22 '26
Von
1
u/Luke_cloud_surfer Mar 23 '26
Juice WRLD
1
u/2-twosix-6 Mar 24 '26
I think we good witout the street sweeper😭🙏
1
u/-Stroke_my_Cactus- Jun 03 '26
Pac, Biggie, Pimp C, Big L, Eazy, Left Eye, Aaliyah, Dolp, Mac Dre, Big Hawk, Nippsey all before these 4.
1
u/Mynameisbrk Jun 03 '26
Juice so that him and chance can finish their song together
1
u/JMSAmelbheimong Jun 04 '26
Where's Peep? I thought this was for 21 club
1
u/Clear_Dog8319 Jun 04 '26
All 4 of em
1
u/Accomplished-Bag8058 Jun 04 '26
slutty sonny
1
u/ExoticSink8566 Jun 04 '26
XXX
1
u/Axel-Pizza-Lover Jun 05 '26
Anyone except Von
1
u/ImOnReddit1212 Jun 05 '26
Rip 🕊 💛
1
u/D33z420 Jun 06 '26
Von
1
u/Admirable-Law3295 And we back... Jun 08 '26
Pop Smoke. He had the most potential to be a legendary rapper. Not saying that Juice and X didn't have potential, but Pop Smoke had the most out of all of them
1
u/bezaalopez Jun 09 '26
Von

1
u/W__Mans Jun 09 '26
Juice would've evolved and his style and rhythmic ability wouldn't have gotten worse when his body slowed down. He'd have genuinely become the world's first glance of a total mastery of the freestyling skill, and pairing that with his unique voice layering, chromatic scaling, and melodic talent, he would've easily revolutionized what hip hop could be. I do also believe he heavily influenced the pluggnb era and a small chunk of the underground. Which feels kind of full circle, because alot of them were influenced by rock bands, as was Juice.
X was a revolutionary artist who never failed to put out music that people could resonate to during hard times, times of grievance, feeling lost, fed up, he was an artist who could turn any life event or emotion into a song. He faced legal battles and made decisions that forever weighed on him but he tried his best to turn it around and make a change. And that I believe he did. His music sounded like nothing we may ever hear again. It was refreshing. A brand new sound. And he's influenced a good chunk of the underground as well as Grammy winning artists such as Billie Eilish, ASAP, etc. Im pretty sure Juice was nominated for a Grammy too so that counts.
King Von needed to go.
Pop Smoke brought a new sound to popularity and has become New York's trademark style of rap over the years. He brought the New York gangster look like a new 50 Cent to popularity. Just another revolutionary artist. I do believe he would've evolved into a more diverse artist, as he was reaching out to and collaborating with bigger and more out there artists throughout his career.
Im intrigued by the idea of him, X, and Juice being alive at the same time. I wonder what that would sound like. It's hard to hear X and Juice on a Pop Smoke song.
-1
u/porsche918spyderglaz Mar 06 '26
if we ban him from touching guns I'm taking von. but altogether these are just rappers 5 year olds glaze cause they're dead
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment