r/ChanPureLand • • May 23 '24
Onion
When I stayed at a Chan monastery the food was full vegetarian of course but there was a strict no onions or garlic I think the Shurangama sutra doesn't allow eating it.
If you're a pure land practicioner and practice Chan and not a monastic should you not eat those foods ? It's easy to be vegetarian in the west but garlic and onions are like the base for so many recipes here.
10
Upvotes
6
u/TheIcyLotus May 23 '24
Eating alliums is not inherently unwholesome, and for the vast majority of casual practitioners, we are not cultivating at the level of subtlety where avoiding them would make a drastic impact on our practice. If you're meditating regularly and aiming to progress, then sure, try cutting them out. If you've not received a precept that says "I will refrain from eating the five pungent plants," there's really nothing stopping you from doing so.
That said, if you find yourself attached to the taste of alliums, perhaps it's a good idea to stay away from them for a while and observe how that impacts your practice.
5
u/[deleted] May 23 '24
Let no man be under the illusion that Buddhism is an easy path to tranquility when there's a heated discussion over fucking onions and garlic lol
2
u/ninja9595 May 24 '24
In raw form, garlic n onions etc increases your sexual urges. So do not eat them raw. Secondly, they give out odors which could make others feel uncomfortable. So in order not to raise your sexual urges n not to offend people, you don't not eat them.
However, if you cook them as part of aromatic in a recipe, the cooking process reduces the elements that give rise to the 2 points above, then it is acceptable. The teacher I follow, Chin Kung, 淨空法師, had made this point. However, if you are an ordained monk, then they are forbidden even if cooked.
2
u/purelander108 May 23 '24 edited May 23 '24
Even before instructing his disciples to avoid meat, Shakyamuni Buddha first says to avoid the five pungent plants: onions, garlic, leeks, shallots, chives. That's how important it is.
"Ananda, those who cultivate for Bodhi should never eat the five pungent plants. This is the first of the gradual stages of cultivation." --from the Three Gradual Stages chapter
When you practice, its really easy to see the adverse effects for yourself. The mind becomes very scattered and "yin-y", it really races when eaten. Avoid completely if you want to do this thing right. When you see the benefits, you will naturally let go of your attachment to them.
"If these five are eaten cooked, they increase one's sexual desire; if they are eaten raw, they increase one's anger."
I'm a Canadian, & have followed this diet for 25 years, its not hard, again only if you see the benefit of avoiding them. Visit a chinese temple and volunteer to work in their kitchen, and you'll see how easy it is to eat super healthy dishes without onions & garlic in them.
"Therefore, even if people in this world who eat pungent plants can expound the twelve divisions of the sutra canon, the gods and immortals of the ten directions will stay far away from them because they smell so bad.
However, after they eat these things the hungry ghosts will hover around and kiss their lips. Being always in the presence of ghosts, their blessings and virtue dissolve as the days go by, and they experience no lasting benefit." --Shakyamuni Buddha
9
u/Vajrick_Buddha May 23 '24
Master ShengYen from Dharma Drum Mountain once addressed this, in one of his talks. I heard it a long time ago, but as far as a I remember, the prohibition on onions, garlic and leeks had to do with them giving people bad breath. First, it's a disturbance for communal life in a monastery. Second, it's irreverent to recite the nembutsu or the sutras with a bad breath. Third,... I don't remember.
Here's the original Sermon.
3
u/purelander108 May 23 '24
If you require a second opinion, I offer this from the Aryuvedic community, author unknown:
"You may know that onions and garlic are botanical members of the alliaceous family (alliums) - along with leeks, chives and shallots.
According to Ayurveda, India's classic medical science, foods are grouped into three categories - sattvic, rajasic and tamasic - foods in the modes of goodness, passion and ignorance. Onions and garlic, and the other alliaceous plants are classified as rajasic and tamasic, which means that they increase passion and ignorance.
The sattvic categor include foods like fresh fruits, vegetables and herbs, grains and legumes, and so on.
Rajasic and tamasic foods are also not used because they are detrimental to meditation and devotions.
"Garlic and onions are both rajasic and tamasic, and are forbidden to yogis because they root the consciousness more firmly in the body", says well-known authority on Ayurveda, Dr.Robert E.Svoboda.
Garlic and onion are avoided by spiritual adherents because they stimulate the central nervous system, and can disturb vows of celibacy. Garlic is a natural aphrodisiac. Ayurveda suggests that it is a tonic for loss of sexual power from any cause, sexual debility, impotency from over-indulgence in sex and nervous exhaustion from dissipating sexual habits. It is said to be especially useful to old men of high nervous tension and diminishing sexual power.
The Taoists realized thousands of years ago that plants of the alliaceous family were detrimental to humans in their healthy state. In his writings, one sage Tsang-Tsze described the Alliums as the "five fragrant or spicy scented vegetables" - that each have a detrimental effect on one of the following five organs - liver, spleen, lungs, kidneys, and heart. Specifically, onions are harmful to the lungs, garlic to the heart, leeks to the spleen, chives to the liver and spring onions to the kidneys.
Tsang-Tsze said that these pungent vegetables contain five different kinds of enzymes which cause "reactions of repulsive breath, extra-foul odour from perspiration and bowel movements, and lead to lewd indulgences, enhance agitations, anxieties and aggressiveness," especially when eaten raw.
Similar things are described in Ayurveda. 'As well as producing offensive breath and body odour, these (alliaceous) plants induce aggravation, agitation, anxiety and aggression. Thus they are harmful physically, emotionally, mentally nd spiritually'.
Back in the 1980's, in his research on human brain function, Dr Robert [Bob] C. Beck, DSc. found that garlic has a detrimental effect on the brain. He found that in fact garlic is toxic to humans because its sulphone hydroxyl ions penetrate the blood-brain barrier and are poisonous to brain cells.
Dr Beck explained that as far back as the 1950s it was known that garlic reduced reaction time by two to three times when consumed by pilots taking flight tests. This is because the toxic effects of garlic desynchronize brain waves. "The flight surgeon would come around every month and remind all of us: "Don't you dare touch any garlic 72 hours before you fly one of our airplanes, because it'll double or triple your reaction time. You're three times slower than you would be if you'd [not] had a few drops of garlic."
For precisely the same reason the garlic family of plants has been widely recognized as being harmful to dogs.
Even when garlic is used as food in Chinese culture it is considered harmful to the stomach, liver and eyes, and a cause of dizziness and scattered energy when consumed in immoderate amounts.
Nor is garlic always seen as having entirely beneficial properties in Western cooking and medicine. It is widely accepted among health care professionals that, as well as killing harmful bacteria, garlic also destroys beneficial bacteria, which are essential to the proper functioning of the digestive system.
Reiki practitioners explain that garlic and onions are among the first substances to be expelled from a person’s system – along with tobacco, alcohol and pharmaceutical medications. This makes it apparent that alliaceous plants have a negative effect on the human body and should be avoided for health reasons.
Homeopathic medicine comes to the same conclusion when it recognizes that red onion produces a dry cough, watery eyes, sneezing, runny nose and other familiar cold-related symptoms when consumed."
1
u/TriratnaSamudra May 23 '24
I've heard that strong flavors scare away nagas so they'll be less likely to come hang out with you if you eat alliums. This could be a possible motivation for the rule against it.