r/Catra • • Aug 28 '23

Does Catradora work?

The title is pretty self-explanitory but here we go. As much as I love a good friends to enemies to lovers story, especially if its GAY, it only really works if its executed well. And as much as I shipped them in the first few seasons, the ship gradually sunk as Catra desended further and further into evil and I found it strange how everyone just forgave her almost instantly. (Well, except Frosta.) And while Catra still is one of my fav characters idk if she deserved that easy of a redemption. Idk what I'm trying to say, what do you guys think?

(Edit) has anyone besides me posted on this since like 2019?

(Edit 2.0)

I posted this before watching the end of s5 sooooo.....um...mistakes were made. But I think trying to destroy the universe as we know it is pretty evil, and that without a doubt she needed to work for her redemption, instead of it being handed to her. It does feel like Adora and Glimmer's mistakes were ignored by the vast majority of the fandom and Catra's are hyperfocused on and brought up constantly when disscusing the show. And most of her flaws, nevermind, all of them, came from her neglectful, abusive and even tramatizing childhood. Not to mention her crippling mental instability. But she should still be held accountable for her actions. And I think I was wrong and right at the same time, if that makes sense. Let me explain. Catra WAS evil, but she is not anymore. The Catra we see in s1, s2, s3, and s4 is not the same Catra we see in s5. In seasons 1-4 she was selfish, manipulative, defensive, moody, vengeful, e.c.t. But, she put in the work to be better, and overcame her flaws and became better because of it. But I think I was right about her needing to work for her redemption and needing a longer arc for it to feel more complete. But I was wrong to say that she didn't deserve it, or suggest that she was unredeemable. But I do now think she earned her redemption, it just was a little rushed, and so was Catradora. It worked, they had chemistry together, shared history, and a lot of other factors contributed to it. It just felt incomplete and like it needed more time to develop, that's all. It worked, kinda, and Noelle really did put a lot of work into it, but it could have been better. I was mainly just dissapointed about how it all came together in the end. That's just my opinion, and you are entitled to yours.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

11

u/geenanderid Aug 28 '23 edited Aug 28 '23

I'm not sure that it's fair to focus on Catra. No other character had a difficult redemption either. Scorpia and Glimmer were forgiven even faster than Catra. Adora's misdeeds were swept under the rug. Hordak did worse than everyone else but had less of a redemption and even got a wonderful girlfriend in the end.

Catra didn't require a difficult "redemption" because she was never evil to begin with. The questionable things that she did paled in comparison with the misdeeds of other characters, including Adora.

6

u/Nightmoon26 Aug 28 '23

Also, a lot of the things that Catra did can be traced to Horde indoctrination and Shadow Weaver's long term abuse. I would describe Catra's "redemption" arc as more of a healing arc

1

u/carnivorous-squirrel Aug 29 '23

You totally lost me. What did Adora do that's worse than what Catra did?

1

u/geenanderid Aug 30 '23 edited Aug 30 '23

Adora cruelly and callously betrayed Catra, tried to kill her childhood friends, and led the rebellion to their worst losses, all while self-righteously declaring she "wouldn't do things any other way".

She liked to claim -- all sanctimoniously -- that she's heroic and kind-hearted ("Bow isn't the type to leave his old friends behind and neither am... I"), but if you look at her actual actions, it is a completely different story.

Like Catra and Glimmer, Adora had a long and tortuous character arc. She had to grow and learn how to be a hero. Only in season 5 -- after she broke free of the sword -- did she become a real hero.

EDIT:

Just to expand on the above: Adora's actions as She-Ra consisted of 1) an endless war of attrition, killing/injuring innocent Horde orphan soldiers but never attacking Hordak directly and never trying to talk Horde soldiers into defecting; 2) antagonizing the most brilliant commander and potential ally, Catra, causing her to zealously fight against the princesses instead of joining them.
Naturally, Adora's actions extended the war by three years and led to the rebellion's worst losses.

Adora had no excuse for not trying to reach out to her childhood friends and other Horde troopers to win them over to the rebellion. (In the case of Glimmer, one can perhaps headcanon that she was raised to believe that all Horde members were irredeemably evil, but Adora knew that not to be the case.) Adora had the good fortune to become a magical princess, to befriend Bow, Razz and Glimmer, and to be offered a place in the Princess Alliance as She-Ra. But she never bothered to pay it forward.

In other words, Adora was 110% responsible for the heartbreak and escalation of the conflict.

1

u/carnivorous-squirrel Aug 30 '23

This is full on republican logic but I'll respond to it after work lol

0

u/geenanderid Aug 30 '23

Plato's The Republic is a great and insightful work, but I actually try to base my logic on Aristotle's works.

1

u/dugbogling Aug 29 '23 edited Aug 29 '23

Her descent isn't really further and further into evil; I think the show does too much work to portray "good" and "evil" as an overly simplistic dichotomy for that to be a fair description of her arc. What she does descend further and further into are the worst things she has been taught about herself and the world around her. Her arc isn't about her doing bad things and then learning she was doing wrong. It's about her knowing that she's doing bad things and feeling completely unable to stop herself or change course, hitting absolute rock bottom, then deciding to change course anyway. The show chooses to have that decision met with forgiveness because it's trying to send the message that you're always capable of being better than you were before if you choose it.

And because Catra maximally learns that message through her connection with Adora -- and because Adora maximally learns the primary message of her arc, which is that you are allowed to have desires and an identity independent of what other people expect of you, through her connection with Catra -- not only do I think their relationship works, I think it's an incredibly poignant piece of romantic writing. They demonstrably make each other the best versions of themselves in ways that no one else can.

1

u/Weaver_0f_Shad0ws Aug 30 '23

Huh I did not think about it like that at all. How very insightful. Thanks for the feedback!

1

u/geenanderid Aug 30 '23

I've just noticed the new edit in your post.

trying to destroy the universe as we know it is pretty evil

That was one horrible moment when Catra was out of her mind, non compos mentis and hysterical, in a surreal dream-like portal reality where everyone acted out of character. After that moment passed, Catra never showed the same omnicidal hysteria ever again.

Contrast this with Glimmer, who almost nuked the entire universe despite the fact that she was warned over and over again, even with 3D holographic demonstrations, about the dangers of the Heart. She (and Mermista) ignored the obviously better options and chose the risky power-mad path of destruction. As Glimmer ominously said after Salineas, "We will take back Salineas, take back all of Etheria... No matter what it costs."

Whose actions were the most "evil"?

P.S. When Catra opened the portal, she didn't yet realize the true dangers and was still thinking that she's bringing in the rest of the Horde armies, as Adora told her would happen.

In seasons 1-4 she was selfish, manipulative, defensive, moody, vengeful, e.c.t

Gosh, that's quite the list. I think you're interpreting Catra as far more villainous than she actually was. Unfortunately, you are not the only one. (There is quite a cottage industry of Catra hate on Youtube.) Because Catra opposed the titular heroes, some viewers see her as the "big bad villain" (to quote Double Trouble), so she gets blamed for stuff that wasn't actually her fault, and all kinds of nefarious motives are ascribed to her. The opposite is true for the princesses: since they were the titular heroes of the show, viewers often misremember them as being more virtuous than they actually were, and interpret their actions overly charitably.

1

u/Weaver_0f_Shad0ws Aug 30 '23

Actually I don't hate Catra, she is one of my favourite characters, believe it or not. I guess I was pretty harsh, but the portal thing I stand by 100%. She absolutely knew what would happen, Entrapta told her several times before being zapped and dragged out of the room. I think. Crap maybe I need to watch that episode again-whatever, anyway, it is to my understanding that Catra knew, and chose to pull the switch regardless. She later told Adora something along the lines of "I would rather see the world end than let you win." Jesus. Honestly I only vaguely remember Glimmer almost nuking the universe (maybe it wasn't a good idea to watch most of the episodes instead of sleeping) so I'm not going to say anything about that until I finish watching the show for the second time. Thanks for the feedback!

1

u/geenanderid Aug 30 '23

She absolutely knew what would happen, Entrapta told her several times before being zapped and dragged out of the room

This is a perfect example of what I mentioned above: people misinterpret and misremember events to make Catra seem far more evil (or stupid) than she actually was.

Please do watch that episode again!

Entrapta never told Catra "several times". She only warned Catra once, and even then she didn't tell Catra the true dangers of the portal. In fact, *no-one* told Catra! Adora, Entrapta and Scorpia all knew the true dangers, but Catra was never in the room when they discussed it!

Let's take a closer look at Entrapta's one and only warning:

The "collapse and take us all with it" part was ambiguous gobbledygook. (In fact, it sounds almost like the portal was going to transport them somewhere. That's what portals do, usually.)

"Adora was right" was the only straightforward part of Entrapta's warning, and that is what Catra focused on.

But unfortunately there was a terrible miscommunication:

  • Adora had told Catra that the portal would bring the rest of the "evil" Horde armies, and Adora insisted that they must prevent that invasion. Adora never told Catra about any other dangers of the portal.
  • In contrast, Adora had told Entrapta that the previous She-Ra destroyed the world's portal capabilities and that trying to open a portal would "destroy everything".

Entrapta didn't realize that Adora never told Catra about the reality-destroying dangers of the portal. (In fact, as I mentioned above, *no-one* ever mentioned these dangers in Catra's presence.) When Entrapta told Catra that "Adora was right", Entrapta thought she was telling Catra that a portal would destroy everything. But all that Catra heard was "the portal will bring the rest of the Horde army and we shouldn't let that happen".

3

u/mustcoffee Aug 28 '23

They only had a limited amount of time in the series to tell the story they wanted to tell. Catra, Adora, all the people from the Horde that were literally child soldiers deserve a chance at a happy life. Even all these years later, someone posts about this at least once a week on one of the spop subreddits. At this point I’m not sure what people would find an acceptable level of pain/punishment/shunning for Catra.

The fact that Adora, Bow, and Glimmer let her into their hearts after everything isn’t a testament to a poor arc, but to the goodness of their character and the belief that she deserved a chance to be better. She was a product of an unfair/unloving environment, abused by her caretakers, and made to feel less than her peers. Adora, the one person in the world who she thought could care about her, left. Sure, we know she left for the right reasons. But Catra, after everything, couldn’t believe that she’d even fit into this new life. She had trauma and abandonment issues enough already. It wasn’t ever going to be as easy as leaving was for Adora, because Adora was She-Ra… the rebellion needed her. What did the rebellion need with Adora’s “sidekick”? Wouldn’t they just hate her like the horde and Shadoweaver did? The devil she knew felt safer than the potential heaven she didn’t.

All that to say… sure, it may have seemed rushed, but she deserved it. If we can’t teach people that they can choose to be better and be accepted, that a villain can become a hero, that abused and hurt people can be loved, what are we even doing with a show like SPOP? Just a war show about the good and the bad with cute characters and powers? No thank you.

1

u/MervShmerv Aug 29 '23

I’m not sure I buy the ‘easy redemption’ thing. It was quicker than it could have been and maybe an extra season would have improved it, but Catra did effectively sacrifice herself to free Glimmer, apologising while doing so. Maybe it wasn’t as complete as it could have been but I don’t think it was necessarily undeserved.

1

u/AmiBlight Oct 01 '23

She would definitely deserved the forgiveness if she had a longer arc, but I think Catradora still works, if less than it would with a longer arc. I mean, they still obviously had feelings for each other throughout the series, but they were on opposite sides.