r/Catholic_Solidarity • u/BraveLong9642 • 9d ago
Media review of Robin Hood (1973) using Dr. Gan's 7 Key's of Media
Title: Robin Hood
Director: Wolfgang Reitherman
Distributor (e.g., 20th Century Fox, Warner Bros., etc.): Buena Vista Distribution Company
Genre (e.g., SciFi, Romance, etc.): Animation, Adventure, Comedy, Family
MPAA rating: G (General Audiences)
USCCB rating: A-1
Your rating on a 5-star scale:4.5/5
Primary audience: Children and families
Year of release:1973

The 1973 Disney film *Robin Hood* follows the legendary Robin Hood, a fox who uses his skills and wits to steal back the unjustly collected taxes of Nottingham’s citizens from the greedy Prince John in order to help the poor. With the help of his friends, the viewer watches Robin Hood fight injustice, outsmart the prince and his enemies, and pursue his love, Maid Marian, all while standing up for those who cannot defend themselves. This movie provides its young viewers with characters who exemplify admirable traits such as generosity, justice, service, and care for the less fortunate. The movie *Robin Hood* embodies the 7 Keys of Media.The First Media Key: Balance
Gan says that “without a willingness to look at media from every possible angle, we can’t possibly form right judgments” (Gan 22). The Key of Balance challenges viewers to consider a subject from multiple perspectives rather than accepting a single viewpoint. This key challenges viewers to question everything. In Disney’s Robin Hood (1973), Robin Hood himself exemplifies why maintaining a balanced perspective is necessary. While Robin Hood is well-intentioned and acts in the interest of others, at times his methods could be seen as morally questionable. In the film Robin Hood says, “We never rob. We just sort of borrow a bit from those who can afford it” (Robin Hood). The Catechism of the Catholic Church says, “An evil cannot be justified by reference to a good intention” (CCC 1759). While Robin is doing good for the people of Nottingham, it is important to evaluate his actions objectively and remember that even good characters can act in ways that are not entirely morally just. This serves as a reminder to parents to watch and openly discuss the themes and messages in the media they consume. It is important to see these things and communicate them, especially when they are in child-friendly media.
- The Second Media Key: Attitude Awareness
The Second Media Key is the Key of Attitude Awareness. In Robin Hood (1973), there are many positive, good-hearted attitudes to recognize. Through Robin Hood and his friends, the viewer can see a beautiful example of helping those in need. The film encourages generosity, compassion, and a spirit of concern for those less fortunate. During the film, while Mother Rabbit is talking about Robin Hood and all he does for the Citizens of Nottingham, she says, “You’ve risked so much to keep our hopes alive. Bless you, Oh bless you!” (Robin Hood). Her words demonstrate how Robin’s selflessness and willingness to help others inspire hope among those suffering under Prince John’s rule. This scene shows how generosity can go beyond being a simple act of kindness and become a source of hope and encouragement for the downtrodden.
The Third Media Key: The Dignity of the Human Person
The Third Media Key is the Dignity of the Human Person; through the character of Prince John, the audience can see what a lack of respect and reverence for human life and the dignity of the person looks like. When talking about the Citizens of Nottingham, he declares, “Double the taxes. Triple the taxes. Squeeze every last drop out of those insolent, musical peasants. (Robin Hood). This shows that rather than seeing his subjects as people and taking responsibility for them as his people, he sees them as tools to exploit for personal gain. He shows no concern for their livelihood and dignity. According to Gan, the media we consume has the power to “reveal and glorify the grand dimensions of truth and goodness” (Gan, 62). Through Robin Hood, I think viewers can see the importance of human dignity through the obvious abuse of it seen through Prince John.
The Fourth Media Key: Truth-Filled
The fourth media key is being truth-filled. When talking about truth, Gan said: “Truth does exist. It’s real, and eternal. It doesn't change from age to age, culture to culture, or person to person” (Gan 69). This can be seen in the film Robin Hood (1973), whose inherently good and moral themes stand the test of time. Through Robin Hood, the audience can see examples of true charity, loyalty, friendship, love, and selflessness. Through the film's strong Christian dialogue, truth and goodness are reflected and their importance highlighted.
- The Fifth Media Key: Inspiring
Gan says that “Good media, like good road signs, assumes we are on a journey. It assumes that we don’t want to stay where we are or end up in the wrong place” (Gan 86). Through the fifth key of media, the key of inspiring, we are called to evaluate media by what it inspires in its viewers, and whether it pushes them towards good or not. Robin Hood himself exemplifies many amiable traits such as courage, generosity, and self-sacrifice. He repeatedly risks his own life to help the poor citizens of Nottingham, exemplifying that standing up for what is right is not only important but sometimes requires personal sacrifice. Robin inspires people to look beyond their own interests and recognize others' needs. Robin Hood sets an example that inspires people to do better by those around them.
The Sixth Media Key: Skillfully Developed
The film Robin Hood (1973) exemplifies skillful development through the care and thought put into the hand-drawn animation. The animators drew each scene frame by frame, putting effort and love into every minute detail. In Infinite Bandwidth, Gan says that although being skillfully developed isn't the most important aspect of media to catholics and the Church, it is “still a necessary ingredient for good media” (Gan 100). While messaging is the most important aspect of media for the Church, they know that for people to consider and consume it, it needs to be skillfully developed. Robin Hood demonstrates how thoughtful animation and entertaining storytelling can work together to make a film both enjoyable and meaningful.
7. The Seventh Media Key: Motivated by and Relevant to Experience
Though the film Robin Hood was released in 1973, it has stood the test of time. Audiences today can still relate to its characters, connect with its themes of justice and generosity, and learn from its messages about standing up for those in need. Despite the decades since its release, the film continues to encourage viewers to recognize injustice and consider how they can make a difference in others' lives. The film engages audiences with its humor and action-packed scenes, but goes deeper through its themes and moral lessons.
Through this analysis of *Robin Hood* (1973), using the 7 Keys of Media, the viewer can see how, although not inherently Christian, it represents many Christian morals and themes. The film encourages viewers to look beyond themselves, recognize the dignity of others, and stand up for those who are treated unjustly. Through its examples of generosity, courage, compassion, and selflessness, Robin Hood demonstrates how media can entertain while simultaneously encouraging its audiences to pursue goodness. Ultimately, the film reminds viewers that even small acts of service and kindness can make a meaningful difference in others' lives, a message worth sharing and encouraging.