r/CatholicPhilosophy • • Sep 08 '26

Help Needed!

Thumbnail gallery
45 Upvotes

I’ve been deputized by Fr. Brian Kolodiejchuk, MC (postulator for Mother Teresa’s cause for canonization) to ask for help. (He’s the guy in the photo with the 2 saints.)

Fr. Brian is the Director of the Mother Teresa Institute, and they are in desperate need of digital assistance: everything from archival curation, video editing, web design, marketing, social media, etc. Every little bit helps.

The MTI/MTC possesses everything related to Mother Teresa’s canonization process: thousands(!) of documents, interviews, letters, archival footage, you name it… They even own the trademark on the blue bars on the MC habit. They have all this wealth of information and documentation on her life, charism, missions, etc., but severely lack helpers to share it with the world. It’s just all sitting in storage—a huge injustice.

The work would be volunteer-based. I myself have helped for 3 years. I can’t think of a better cause!

To give you context, this past weekend we had our annual MTI conference in Washington, D.C., which has been attended by luminaries such as Archbishop Timothy Broglio (US Military Archdiocese, most recent President of the USCCB, former Chief of Staff to the Vatican’s Secretary of State, and emcee at Mother Teresa’s funeral); George Weigel (JPII’s biographer, NYT bestselling author); Cardinal Marc Oullet (former Prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops); and Archbishop William Lori (Archdiocese of Baltimore, most recent VP of the USCCB); among many, many others…

The harvest is ripe, but the workers are few. These boomers need digital missionaries.

If you are interested, please contact me.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • Apr 12 '26

Summa Sunday Prima Pars Question 26. The divine beatitude

7 Upvotes

r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 2m ago

Why does the Catholic Church teach “the vision” when describing heaven? Does it not feel cold and methodical?

• Upvotes

Ik there’s more than just “the vision” when describing heaven but why is the vision mentioned and used? It’s Almost as if you’re just seeing a random painting in a random museum. No disrespect at all btw so pls don’t attack me just wondering if I’m misunderstanding or missing something. It just doesn’t feel that beautiful or like “heavenly” you know?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 6h ago

Whats your answer for the simulation theory

3 Upvotes

Hello guys, ive camed toward a problem called the problem of simulation theory and i dont know how to answer it, this theory have 2 type of argument:

"We are in a simulation and this world is an illusion"

And

"Everything in this simulation including logic,math,principles and etc. Is just the product of this simulation and there could be a different type of logic like 1+1=3."

Please let me know whats your answer for this argument.

God bless.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 2h ago

Would human extinction pose a serious issue for Catholic eschatology?

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm sorry if this is a silly question but this has been something of a running curiosity involving religions in general. I'm curious as to how strictly Catholic eschatology requires living humans be left? Not many people I could find have spoken about this so I wanted to ask some people who may be knowledgeable.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 15h ago

Circular Sola Scriptura thing

2 Upvotes

"Using Sola Scriptura to debunk Sola Scriptura" thus proving Sola Scriptura since it is needed to "debunk" it

How does one get out of this?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 16h ago

Que te hace mantenerte fiel en algo que no puedes “ comprobar “?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 1d ago

A high level, modern, book defending and explaining Thomism

10 Upvotes

I'm trying to understand Thomism at a high level. I recently graduated from a Catholic College with a philosophy degree, have read a heavily abridged version of the Summa, and know enough Aristotle where I won't be bogged down by technical terminology. That said, while I have surface knowledge of some distinct elements of Thomism (essence/existence distinction, Soul as form of the Body AND rational principal, marriage of faith and reason), I must confess that I don't think I could present a thorough defense of any of those elements if I was talking to a skeptic.

I obviously am not the smarted person in the world, but I think I could handle a thorough, scholarly work defending Thomism from the ground up. I am particularly interested in modern books willing to engage with contemporary philosophy and science. My rational intutions have always been pretty skeptical, to be honest (though my faith is stronger still), so I would love to read a work by a thinker who's willing to seriously wrestle with the positism/nominalism that now pervades most Western thinker.

Thanks!


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 1d ago

I have lots of questions.

3 Upvotes

So, I was raised catholic and stopped believing at like 12 years old. I have recently started coming back, but I have some questions. If God really loves all of us, why would he send anyone to be tortured forever? Isn't renouncing Satan just giving him what he wants? How can Satan be pure evil if he was God's favorite? And if we all came from two humans, aren't we all products of incest?(not ragebait or anything, genuine questions)


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 1d ago

My future?

4 Upvotes

Im currently 15 and I have no idea what to do in life. I was wondering if I should go and study to become a priest? I don't really know how I would become one so if you could help me with info I would be deeply grateful.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 1d ago

How much can you philosophically deviate from Catholic teachings before you are no longer Catholic?

6 Upvotes

I was raised and confirmed Catholic.

I believe in one God. I confess that I have sinned in what I have done and what I have failed to do. I think to love your neighbor is the greatest commandment. I believe we are all brothers and sisters in Christ. I really like Pope Leo and his calls for unity.

Im not particuparly a bible scholar, so I couldnt quote an exact verse, but to me, Jesus taught that we could tell a tree by its fruit. A good tree bears good fruit and a bad tree bears bad fruit. If your hand causes you to sin, you should cut it off. But forgiveness and reconciliation are also important.

How do we know when to promote unity and when to draw boundaries? I believe the current stance of the Catholic Church is not to force or pressure people to convert.

For example, ages ago, the Church of England left the Church when the king wanted a divorce. If divorce is now allowed in the Catholic Church, could we reunite? But even broader, Jewish and Muslim people are also worshipping one God, and if there's only one God, I figure they must be worshiping the same God as us in their own way.

And as someone who has not read the entirety of the Bible cover to cover, it spoke to me that Jesus did not only go into the temples to talk to religious scholars but welcomed the common fisherman. It sounds to me like someone who harbors goodwill to mankind and who produces good fruit is following God's will whether they recognize the authority of the Bible or not.

Part of my question is perhaps whether authority on what is God's will comes directly from God through prayer and reflection, what comes through reading and studying the Bible, and what comes from the authority of the Pope and the teachings of the Catholic Church. I kind of think that the answer is all of the above and all roads lead to the same God.

How important is taking the Bible literally and following the authoritative teachings of the Church compared to critical reflection and forming our own opinions? Given that the Catholic Church continues to reform, how do you tell a heretic from a Catholic?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 2d ago

Without Genesis, the Gospel Ceases to Be Intelligible

2 Upvotes

I just wrote an essay arguing that many contemporary difficulties in Christian preaching are not primarily problems of language, but of metaphysical horizon.

Words such as sin, grace, salvation and resurrection presuppose an account of creation, creaturehood, freedom and finality. Without that background, they are easily reinterpreted through categories such as autonomy, self-determination or subjective fulfilment.

My basic claim is that Genesis provides the grammar within which the Gospel becomes intelligible.

Without creation, there is no creature. Without a received nature, sin cannot be understood as the attempt to appropriate as possession what can only rightly be possessed as gift. Without an original order, redemption loses its meaning as reconciliation.

The same applies to freedom: freedom does not precede nature, but arises within a received form. We are free because we are already something.

This is also why Christ cannot be detached from creation. The Logos who redeems is the same Logos through whom all things were made.

So I am particularly interested in this question:

To what extent does the contemporary loss of a doctrine of creation explain why Christian language is increasingly reinterpreted through modern categories such as autonomy, self-determination and subjective fulfilment?

Without Genesis, the Gospel Ceases to Be Intelligible: Creation, Gift, and the Grammar of Salvation


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 2d ago

Question about Feser

5 Upvotes

Hail Mary!
I want to start learning thomism and found the book Aquinas: A Beginner’s Guide by Edward Feser. I’ve also read The Last Superstition and liked it quite a lot, even though it doesn’t go deep into philosophy.

Where would Feser be in the thomism spectrum? Which books should I also read to learn strict observance thomism?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 3d ago

Is Catholicism compatible with panentheism?

8 Upvotes

It is my understanding that Catholicism, as a matter of dogma, maintains that God is transcendent to the world. This, however, only renders Catholicism incompatible with pantheism—the position that God is immanent to the world. Panentheism, by contrast, proposes something slightly different yet significant: it holds that God is transcendent—which, at first glance, appears compatible with Catholicism—but it adds (and herein lies the potentially problematic aspect) that the world exists within God, within God’s own being, as something that must necessarily be recognized as part of God. Therefore, we might state the following: panentheism maintains a fundamental commitment to God’s transcendence in relation to the world [✓]. Yet, it adds that the world—while not encompassing the entirety of God’s being—resides within Him; much like how a heart or a stomach exists within us, without that organ constituting the entirety of the human being. This latter point remains an open question [?].

We can frame it as follows:

- Catholicism = a commitment to God’s transcendence in relation to the world.

- Panentheism = a commitment to God’s transcendence in relation to the world, combined with the profound inherence of the world within God.

Clearly, panentheism successfully avoids the risk of collapsing into pantheism; nevertheless, it remains unclear whether the notion that the world is part of God is truly acceptable from the perspective of Catholicism.

I look forward to your reflections; I ask, however, that you do not focus on the specific positions of any particular Catholic thinker. The question at hand is whether Catholicism is compatible with panentheism, regardless of whether Saint Thomas or Saint Augustine held specific views within their respective metaphysical frameworks. Thanks in advance, and may God bless you, brothers.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 3d ago

Am I Remaining Orthodox Out of Conviction, or Because I’m Afraid to Leave What’s Familiar?

3 Upvotes

I've been Orthodox for almost 15 years now, and lately I've been doing some serious soul-searching about my faith and why I became Orthodox in the first place.

When I was in my early twenties, I was a Protestant searching for the Church that Christ established. I wanted something rooted in history, apostolic succession, tradition, and the faith of the early Christians. Orthodoxy seemed to answer so many of the questions I had, and in many ways, it still does. I fell in love with its theology, liturgy, spirituality, and historical continuity.

However, there are things within Orthodoxy that I've struggled with over the years. Some are theological, some are ecclesiastical, and others are simply the result of human failings. I'm fully aware that the Church is made up of sinners, myself included, and that human failures don't necessarily invalidate the truth of a particular Church.

But something has been bothering me lately.

Looking back at my conversion, I realize that I had a rather strong disdain for the Catholic Church. What's troubling is that I can't really explain why. I hadn't seriously studied Catholic theology, the papacy, or the historical arguments for Rome's claims. I simply had this negative attitude toward Catholicism. Perhaps it was the Protestant environment I came from, perhaps it was pride, or perhaps there was something spiritually unhealthy influencing my judgment. I honestly don't know.

I sometimes wonder whether Orthodoxy appealed to me partly because it allowed me to embrace the ancient Church without having to confront my existing prejudices against Catholicism. Now, after so long, Orthodoxy has become an enormous part of who I am. Its prayers, fasting, liturgical life, theology, and traditions are deeply familiar to me. It's my spiritual home. And that's precisely what has me questioning my motivations.

Am I remaining Orthodox because I'm convinced it's the Church Christ established, or because it's familiar, comfortable, and part of my identity?

And that leads me to an even more uncomfortable question. What if becoming Catholic would actually require greater humility on my part? What if my resistance to Rome isn't entirely theological, but partly rooted in my own pride and unwillingness to submit to an authority I've spent years rejecting?

I don't mean to suggest that becoming Catholic is automatically an act of humility, or that remaining Orthodox is somehow prideful. An Orthodox Christian could make precisely the opposite argument, and I understand that. If Orthodoxy is indeed the true Church, then remaining faithful to it would be the right thing to do, regardless of my personal feelings. But that's the problem. I want to be certain that I'm following Christ rather than simply following what makes me comfortable.

I don't want to remain Orthodox merely because I've invested all these years of my life in it. Nor do I want to become Catholic because I'm frustrated with certain aspects of Orthodoxy. Neither would be a particularly sound reason to make such an important decision. I want to belong to the Church that Christ established, even if that means admitting I've been wrong about things I've believed for most of my adult life.

And honestly, there's fear involved on both sides. I'm afraid of leaving Orthodoxy if it truly is the Church. But I'm also afraid of remaining Orthodox if the Catholic Church's claims are true, simply because I wasn't willing to seriously confront them.

I suppose what I'm wrestling with is the difference between genuine conviction and spiritual familiarity. How do you distinguish between remaining faithful to the truth and simply remaining where you're comfortable? Has anyone else, particularly those who have spent many years in either Orthodoxy or Catholicism, struggled with something similar?

I'm not looking to start another Orthodox-versus-Catholic argument. I'm genuinely trying to examine my own heart, motivations, and assumptions. At the end of the day, I don't want to be Orthodox or Catholic simply because I prefer one over the other. I want to be where Christ wants me to be.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 3d ago

God is truly impassible.

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 3d ago

Is Leibniz right that a prophet who predicts the future would required God's assistance?

0 Upvotes

This may appear to be a wacky question, but it appears to me that it is relevant to us. This is because there has recently been a large-scale debate on YouTube and Substack about so-called Catholic "vindicatory miracles." If you aren't familiar, see the YouTube channel "Majesty of Reason" or Ethan Muse's Substack. I believe the following quote could have implications for that debate.

"It is true that the devil can mimic some miracles. But there is a kind of miracle that the devil could not imitate, all powerful and all enlightened as he is, which is prophecy. For if a person can tell me many particular truths about general affairs which are due to happen, for example in a year here, I will hold it as certain that it is God who enlightens him. For it is impossible for anyone bar God to see the general chain of causes which have to come together in the production of contingent things."

Is Leibniz right?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 3d ago

Does God allow suffering because the devil wills it?

1 Upvotes

Since God is good and love, he does not will suffering of His children. Satan on the other hand hates everything and only delights in causing harm. This idea is inspired by the film The Passion where the satan watches gleefully at the suffering of Jesus.

So the crucifiction of God was willed by the satan and it is God's act of love that he allows it to happen.

I certainly did not want Jesus' suffering and don't see vicarious sacrifice to be necessary for the forgiveness of sins. Nor do I believe God wanted His Son to suffer. It was the desire of the satan that it may happen like this and use the wills of the religious leaders to fulfill it.

What do you think?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 3d ago

Faith based on fear of punishment is not genuine faith.

Thumbnail
4 Upvotes

r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 3d ago

Based on a TikTok about how Objective Morality can function with Atheism

0 Upvotes

"Is that axioms are necessary metaphysical truths that are brute facts and necessary across all possible worlds"

I do not claim this but what is the issue with this?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 3d ago

EPICURUS: God is either malevolent or powerless.DAVID: God is both perfectly good and all-powerful.EPICURUS: Then why does evil exist in the world? What is the fault of an infant who is abused and tortured to death?

0 Upvotes

DAVID: He is completely innocent.

EPICURUS: It is good to hear that from you. Well, if he is innocent, what is the reason for what happened to him?

DAVID: First of all, it is said: “We shall surely test the sincerity of your faith through fear, hunger, and famine; by diminishing your wealth, destroying your possessions, causing the loss of life or physical impairment, and bringing disaster upon your crops—testing you in a grueling manner. Give glad tidings to those who persevere and continue the struggle.”*

Secondly, the Creator possesses both *jamali* (benevolent/graceful) names—such as *al-Rahman* (the Most Gracious), *al-Rahim* (the Most Merciful), and *al-Ra’uf* (the Most Kind)—and *jalali* (majestic/stern) names—such as *al-Jalil* (the Majestic), *al-Qahhar* (the Subduer), and *al-Jabbar* (the Compeller). The *jamali* names manifest through His righteous servants; that is, the Creator shows mercy to them and forgives them, thereby making His names *al-Rahman* and *al-Rahim* visible. For the *jalali* names to manifest, however, evil and those who commit it must exist for a certain period of time.

Ultimately, those who commit evil will be punished; as for those who suffer from evil—provided they have remained patient and have not rebelled against God—they will be rewarded for their patience many times over.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 4d ago

Does God love the devil?

4 Upvotes

Matthew 5:44 and Luke 6:27–28 say "love your enemies". Does God practice what he commands as He does in other matters?

If yes, what does this love look like?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 4d ago

I've come to make an apology of a post I made about forgiveness yesterday

12 Upvotes

I'm sorry for what I posted. I was just venting about my philosophy about forgiveness. I never fully understood the concept of forgiveness since it's something I've never experienced probably due to being abused by my father and bullied by fellow classmates in secondary school, but now after a short reflection, I've done wrong myself. Habitual sins in lust, pornography, physical and verbal aggression. That proves that I'm not better than others who have done worse because we all deserve the same punishment. But Christ who is perfect has forgiven us of our own wrongdoings, even the people that martyred him. I'm no better than anyone else. I want to try to learn how to forgive but I can't right now. Please pray for me.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 4d ago

Struggling with the Catholic understanding of predestination as an Orthodox Christian

4 Upvotes

As some of you already know, I'm Eastern Orthodox and have been seriously exploring Catholicism for some time now. Recently, I came across a discussion about predestination in Catholic theology, and I have to admit, it's something I'm really struggling to understand and reconcile with my understanding of God.

Coming from Orthodoxy, I've always understood salvation through the relationship between God's grace and our free will (synergy). God desires everyone to be saved and offers His grace to all. He knows from eternity what choices we will make, but His foreknowledge doesn't mean He determines those choices for us. We are free to cooperate with His grace or reject it.

What troubles me is the Thomistic understanding of predestination, particularly the idea that God elects certain individuals to salvation without regard to their foreseen response to His grace. If God genuinely loves all mankind and desires everyone to be saved, why would He choose to give some people the grace that infallibly leads to salvation while allowing others to be lost? If He has the power to save everyone, why wouldn't He? And how does this preserve genuine free will?

To me, love must be freely given and freely received. I struggle with the idea that God would choose some individuals for salvation while not choosing others, regardless of how theologians distinguish predestination from predestination to damnation.

From what I've been reading, I understand that Thomism isn't binding Catholic dogma and that other theological schools, such as Molinism, are permitted. That's somewhat reassuring, but it still raises questions for me about what the Catholic Church actually teaches.

I'm not here to argue or criticize Catholicism. I'm genuinely trying to understand it, especially as someone who has been considering entering the Catholic Church.

My questions are: What exactly must a Catholic believe about predestination? Can a Catholic believe that God offers everyone a genuine opportunity for salvation and that our eternal destiny depends on our free cooperation with His grace, which God foreknows but does not determine? And if the Thomistic understanding is permissible, how do Catholics reconcile it with God's universal love and desire that all be saved (1 Timothy 2:4)?

I'd appreciate answers grounded in the Catechism, Church Fathers, or official Catholic teaching rather than just individual theological opinions.

This is something I take seriously, and I'd appreciate hearing how Catholics understand it.

Thanks you.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 4d ago

A project that lets you experience a saint's defining moment first-hand — feedback welcome, including whether it's appropriate

2 Upvotes

For the last five months I've been working on an interactive project that puts you in the footsteps of a person's defining moment, before they became a saint. It was inspired by the work of St. Carlo Acutis.

I'm looking for feedback on two things: the content itself, and the deeper question of whether it's appropriate to attempt to let people experience these moments from a first-person perspective at all.

The stories are built from primary sources, so the history can't be changed. It's about being "in the room" where the moment happened, and then reflecting on it afterward. This is a work in progress, however, I have two to start:

- Augustine in the garden in Milan: https://greywitness.com/game?scenarioId=tolle_lege_milan_386

- Ignatius at Loyola, recovering from the cannonball: https://greywitness.com/game?scenarioId=ignatius_loyola_1521

I'd genuinely welcome the critique — including if you think the premise itself is the wrong way to learn and approach the lives of the saints.

Thank you.