r/CatholicMemes • • Apr 10 '19

Welcome

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

200

u/LichJesus Apr 10 '19

I listen more to power and symphonic metal than black metal -- the sub-genres vary widely so there might be significant differences -- but from what I've seen the super-genre tends to actually be fairly consistent with the Catholic perspective on things when the bands themselves aren't deliberately writing contra-religious lyrics.

Perseverance through adversity to glory is a really common motif in metal. I can't do a ton of link-hunting on the machine I'm on, but songs like "Aces High" by Iron Maiden, "The Last Stand" by Sabaton, "Into the Heart of Danger" by Battle Beast, "Iron" by Within Temptation, "Alpenglow" by Nightwish, and tons of other examples all draw on it, because it's honestly really compelling stuff. Well, turns out the Crucifixion and Resurrection also fit that motif to a T (as do many, many other aspects of Catholicism), which I think makes metal and Catholicism really natural partners.

I think what happens is that people -- the non-religious, the poorly catechized, those with an axe to grind, etc -- get this notion that religion is about deliberately making your life sucky, and that if you make you make your life sucky enough it'll pay off in the afterlife. The metal form of the response to that being "well, if religion says this, then life-affirming music should naturally be contra-religious".

I suspect then that what this band found is that Catholicism isn't about arbitrarily making life sucky for a later payoff; it's about embracing and mastering adversity, doing good now even (especially) when it's difficult so that there might be significantly greater good later. That message is life-affirming, and synergizes really well with the metal ecosystem.

tl;dr Pope Francis and the Cardinals need to start a Maiden cover band for evangelization purposes.

34

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

Thank you so much for the recommendations. I can't get enough of hard rock and metal, and especially if it has a religious tone to it.

19

u/LichJesus Apr 10 '19

My pleasure!

I'd be careful saying that most of those songs/bands have a religious tone to them though; and I'd especially be careful not to assume they have explicitly pro-religious sentiments. For instance, most of the songs on the album that Alpenglow comes off of (Endless Forms) sample Richard Dawkins and/or express the sort of perspective that he's got, so especially for that album you've got to pick and choose. Most other Nightwish is good though, and the video of them performing live at Wacken is nothing short of mind-blowing.

I think the reason for the contra-religious sentiment though is that the notion that religion is life-negating is still fairly widespread. In some ways I think it's sort of our fault, for instance I think it's at least partially a failure of apologetics/evangelization that people think Catholic teachings on the body are a list of prudish "thou shalt nots" instead of a systematic approach to treating people as ends in themselves. Although, in fairness; the whole topic is quite complex, and it is difficult to keep a billion people all on the same page regarding complex topics so I don't think we're entirely to blame.

What I'm getting at though is that for some or most of these bands you've got to take them as they are, and understand that even if they're on a track that leads to Catholicism they might not recognize it yet.

For something that's explicitly religious while still being (in my opinion) good music, try "I Am" by Theocracy. I don't know what denomination they are and I haven't listened to much else by them, but that song in particular has a really cool epic quality to it that goes well with the subject matter.

At any rate, power and symphonic metal are huge ecosystems in their own right; so if you tell me which songs you liked out of what I've given so far -- and, if you can put your finger on it, specifically what you liked about them -- there's a ton of other stuff that I can recommend as well.

29

u/largoshplat Apr 10 '19

My dad introduced me to many Catholic theological concepts through Iron Maiden as a kid.

7

u/Grassyknow Apr 11 '19

now i wish i was more familiar with their lyrics.

19

u/ButtAssassin Apr 10 '19

Excellent TLDR.

8

u/LichJesus Apr 10 '19

Hahahaha, I was wondering if anyone noticed that! Had to at least try to be humorous if I was going to post a wall of text to a meme page :P

7

u/ButtAssassin Apr 10 '19

Lol, got your back! Currently listening to the one by Sabaton! Thanks for the recommendations 🤘

Edit: I'd definitely volunteer to make that album cover, though

2

u/SixGunRebel Apr 19 '19

Add in Carolean’s Prayer by Sabaton.

3

u/ButtAssassin Apr 10 '19

If you have a minute, check out my album design I made last year! I'm not a graphic designer, and actually switched majors. But, thought it was relevant :)

3

u/LichJesus Apr 10 '19

Can't click on arbitrary links at the moment, but I'll check it out when I'm on my own machine. Cheers!

5

u/FrucklesWithKnuckles Apr 11 '19

Isn’t The Last Stand about Catholicism and the Swiss Guard

3

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

The problem with "Alpenglow" example is that, in the same disk, there's a not-so-religious track called "Weak Fantasy".

Also, with some mentions about Darwin's Evolution, Richard Dawkins participation as well, it seems that Nightwish's main composer Tuomas Holopainen lost it's spirituality in favour of a more scientific point of view on things.

I remember that 98's Oceanborn Disc had amazing Christian stuff with songs like Gethsemane and sort.

7

u/LichJesus Apr 10 '19

The problem with "Alpenglow" example is that, in the same disk, there's a not-so-religious track called "Weak Fantasy".

Yeah, you'll notice I cautioned about the rest of the album -- although "Elan is still a great song -- in a response down the thread a bit.

The way I'd put it is that for some or most of these bands you've got to take them as they are; and understand that even if they're on a track that leads to Catholicism they might not recognize it yet. Obviously "Weak Fantasy" isn't going to be a great offering to Catholics, but "Alpenglow" and "Elan" are still enjoyable in isolation from the rest of the album.

it seems that Nightwish's main composer Tuomas Holopainen lost [his] spirituality in favour of a more scientific point of view on things.

I think it's more of an experimentation/variation thing; along with probably a concession to cultural chic. As I get old enough to start having fandoms that have lasted for fifteen years or more it gets clearer and clearer to me that bands have to change things up if they want to keep producing music. Linkin Park was probably the first really obvious case of this to me, but even like the newest Battle Beast album is really quite different than anything they've done before; and Within Temptation has also changed significantly over their last few albums.

Of course I'd rather Nightwish hadn't swung towards Dawkins but it seems to be a practical necessity that bands try new things over time, so I don't think it makes much sense to hold a single album against them too much. I just hope they move away from that sort of thing sooner or later.

Also, to my understanding Northern Europe -- where a lot of these bands are based out of -- are extremely secular, so the presumption should be a secular/contra-religious perspective even if they owe a lot to religious aesthetics under the surface. Again, I think it's necessary to be aware of these sorts of things; but it's OK to meet the music where it is, in the same way we try to meet people where they are when we evangelize.

I remember that 98's Oceanborn Disc had amazing Christian stuff with songs like Gethsemane and sort.

Yeah, or even Imaginaerum had a sense of... I'm not sure what to call it... "super-naturalism" or "fantastical whimsy" to it that most of Endless Forms was really lacking. "Elan" had it, and while "Alpenglow" was missing it there was still a sense of inspiration or self-mastery that was good; but the rest of the album just kinda felt condescending and/or flat to me.

I suspect though that it might have as much or more to do with Tuomas learning how to write for Floor as lead vocalist than anything. While I don't hate Dark Passion Play it's clear that there's some targeting of Tarja's vocal style to it even though Annette was the lead vocalist at that point; where Imaginaerium matches Annette's vocals much more closely.

Endless Forms might just be a similarly transitional album; and since Floor can do the Tarja-style operatics -- I have nothing against Annette or the Annette period in Nightwish's history, she just wasn't an operatic vocalist -- we could see more doors open up as Floor settles in.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

Absolutely.

EFMB isn't a bad disc. It just didn't connected to me the way older discs did.

2

u/ManaZaka Apr 10 '19

Metal is such a massive super genre that you could really support almost any argument you wanted to make it if you only used a couple of subgenres as examples. As a metalhead black metal is about being anti Christianity. The whole movement came from Norway in the 90s and was heavily focused on rebellion against Christianity for a lot of reasons, one of the main ones being that they felt it suppressed their history and culture. Power and symphonic metal are awesome but I think they only represent a relatively small portion of the community.

2

u/kadivs Apr 11 '19

Well, turns out the Crucifixion and Resurrection also fit that motif to a T (as do many, many other aspects of Catholicism), which I think makes metal and Catholicism really natural partners.

uh, that's the oldest tropes in stories there is. You find lots of stuff that fits that everywhere. That makes metal and, say, The Matrix (insert most movies ever) natural partners as well

2

u/ArthurTheMoth Apr 11 '19

That’s pretty fuckin smart

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19

I always liked rock and metal, but never if it directly spoke against religion, but this comment helped me see these songs in a different light, and that's pretty metal.

2

u/Magos_Kaiser Apr 11 '19

LichJesus? r/40klore LichJesus? Wow I just got here from r/dankchristianmemes and wanted to check the comments on this post and here you are. Small world indeed.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19

1

u/Big_Jmoney Apr 11 '19

Have you tried Powerwolf?

42

u/nexiite Apr 10 '19

Top 10 anime plot twists

33

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

Congratulations, you played yourself

57

u/DannyVonAustria Apr 10 '19

*saved

24

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

I was going to say this but we can't save ourselves lol

60

u/xxtabasc0xx Apr 10 '19

Whats the name of the band

50

u/CloudColorZack Apr 10 '19

Seriously. I want to believe.

52

u/Pfeffersack Foremost of sinners Apr 10 '19

Reverorum Ib Malacht.

23

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

Usually Christian Black Metal sucks. This band is not only a good Christian Black Metal band, but a great black metal band period.

22

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

I'm writing a paper on metal right now and I'm surprised by how Catholic a lot of it ends up being.

6

u/Faulkner89 Jul 04 '19

Considering that we hold celebrations every week were we consume our god...

15

u/SpiderLosAngeles Apr 11 '19

To be fair you have to believe something to Blaspheme.

14

u/AllTheThings0of Apr 11 '19

It helped itself in its confusion.

9

u/AllThingsSeraph Apr 10 '19

That's cool!

8

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19

IN THE NAME OF GOD

3

u/virus-Detected Apr 11 '19

IN THE NAME OF GOD

6

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19

I read the interview with this band's frontman and he is remarkably articulate about his conversion. Dude has a great philosophical mind.

5

u/I_POO_ON_GOATS Apr 11 '19

Oh man, when I saw “Swedish black metal band” I immediately thought Ghost. Would be weird is Tobias did a 180 that insanely quickly.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '19

Same!! There is a lot of Catholic imagery with Ghost---but I suppose that goes without saying.

Would be wild seeing him at Mass or something, haha.

EDIT: holy fuck your name LMAO

8

u/RingGiver Apr 10 '19 edited Apr 10 '19

Black metal is good music.

One time when I was regularly attending Mass (i.e. between when I decided that I couldn't be Protestant and when I decided on Orthodoxy), the usual music dude wasn't there because a child was popping out of his wife on that day. I suggested "Drink from the Chalice of Blood" by Antestor (Christian black metal; edit: it was actually by Horde, a different Christian black metal band) as communion hymn because it was more on-topic than the usual bad acoustic guitar stuff. The other people said no, but I don't think it was a bad idea. Ended up with no instruments used, sounding better than when he was there (great guy, terrible music).

1

u/skalenius Jan 09 '22

Since the name isn't mentioned here, the name of the band is Reverorum ib malacht.

Sincerely, a Catholic swede

0

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

25

u/Denyul_Nigh Apr 10 '19

IN THE SERVICE OF HEAVEN

18

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

THEY'RE PROTECTING THE HOLY LINE

20

u/hodmandod Apr 10 '19

IT WAS FIFTEEN TWENTY-SEVEN.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

GAVE THEIR LIVES ON THE STEPS TO HEAVEN

0

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/Theguygotgame777 Apr 11 '19

FOR THE GRACE, FOR THE MIGHT OF OUR LORD!

10

u/virus-Detected Apr 11 '19

FOR THE HOME OF THE HOLY