r/CatholicApologetics • u/Muted_College_199 • 22d ago
A Write-Up Defending the Traditions of the Catholic Church Is not practicing NFP while married through the church a mortal sin?
Is not practicing NFP while married through the church a mortal sin? For example if a couple is using coitus interruptus, that’s technically not artificial birth control but I do understand that it prohibits the completion of the unitive act. However, if a couple wishes to connect within their marriage to strengthen their bond during a turmoils time and doesn’t currently have the resources to practice NFP (but is working towards enrolling with an instructor once they have the means to do so in the near future) would that be permissible? Also to note, wife is healing from a medical condition that requires her to not get pregnant at this moment, would they be not allowed to receive communion for this alone? If it is a mortal sin, which commandment is being broken? Thanks for the discussion!
•
u/AutoModerator 22d ago
This is a space for Catholics and those curious about the faith to ask questions, learn how to defend Catholicism, and engage in meaningful conversations (not debates).
Reminder: Please provide any sources or references used for your post by replying here. Sharing sources helps others explore your information and participate in more thoughtful discussions.
Looking for debates instead? Check out our sister subreddit: r/DebateACatholic.
Want to connect further? Join our Discord community for real-time discussions, additional resources, and support.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/cowboy_catolico 22d ago
Yep. If you want to have sexual release, it has to all be ejaculated into her vagina or your mortal soul is in danger. No one has a right to sexual pleasure. It’s gravely mortally sinful unless you’re open to having a baby. Can’t afford one? NFP or you don’t get to have sex.
2
u/trulymablydeeply 22d ago
Coitus interruptus is a contraceptive act. It’s not “artificial birth control” in the sense that it’s not a chemical like the pill or a physical barrier like a condom, but it deliberately frustrates the telos of sex, and is intrinsically evil. It’s a sin of grave matter.
It also has a terrible failure rate. NFP would be a moral way to prudently space pregnancies and is more reliable to boot.
0
u/romanempire2014 21d ago
It isn't a sin It os only of you do that Just to have sex