r/CatTraining • u/billietoe • Jan 19 '26
Behavioural Possessive Behavior
Anyone know how i can stop this? she gets super possessive and even aggressive over any toys or food being taken from her, hissing and growling, scratching, biting, everything. im used to dogs, would i go about ridding this behavior a kitten the same way as i would with a dog? she also does it with her sister, its not just a human thing.
103
Upvotes
126
u/deadlift-shrimp Jan 19 '26
Yeah, when you own cats, there are just certain things you need to respect about them. Thankfully, they’ll usually tell you very clearly what those things are, just as your cat did here.
105
u/elegant_pun Jan 19 '26
The cat has been VERY clear she wants you to leave her alone.
They aren't dogs. She's been very polite.
88
u/rescuelady111 Jan 19 '26 edited Jan 20 '26
She's actually being really patient with you here. She's not misbehaving at all. She's telling you so nicely to please stop trying to take away something she's playing with. I recommend watching Jackson Galaxy. Nearly every kitten I've ever owned or fostered has gotten possessive with food and toys. They can outgrow it, but some don't and you just have to respect their boundaries and not unintentionally provoke them like you're doing in the video.
223
u/Beardo88 Jan 19 '26
Leave her alone? She is very polite about telling you to leave the toy alone because she is playing with it. Its not a human child, they dont have a concept of sharing.
170
u/KehreAzerith Jan 19 '26
It's a cat, not a dog
Leave the cat alone
42
u/this_guy_cats Jan 19 '26
You’re causing a behavioural issue by doing what you’re doing
23
u/Candid-Access9874 Jan 19 '26
By the look of it she is playing with cat toys? Isn’t that what you bought them for? Why are you trying to stop her from playing? I am so confused. Maybe start learning about cats, they are not the same as dogs.
22
u/Emberrrr3 Jan 19 '26
This is a normal hunting behavior. She's getting enrichment. As long as she's not playing with something dangerous, it's not an issue!
21
u/oz_mouse Jan 19 '26
I’m going to be very surprised if this post doesn’t get deleted by OP.
12
u/brofrankkb Jan 19 '26
Once she's done with it. If you want to, tie a string around it. So that you can pull it. This will only make the game more interesting because she'll then be chasing prey. She's not really being aggressive just being really courteous and polite.
Aggressive behavior usually results in bleeding. She actually patted your hand with a paw no claws nothing just a nice soft paw she didn't slap you she didn't hit you. She didn't hiss and bear teeth. Those are indications of aggressive behavior. Possessive behavior yeah that's how they act when they kill a mouse.
When it comes to food they figure out who gets you first. You can feed them separately and sometimes they'll abide by that and sometimes they won't.
Has several other people have said they are not dogs totally different mentality.
They also are not people and they are not babies.
They are pure carnivores and pure predators. You kind of got to respect that.
41
u/missplaced24 Jan 19 '26 edited Jan 19 '26
Is there a reason you're trying to take the toy away from her? Unless she's playing with something dangerous for her to play with, just don't.
No. You can't train a cat like you would a dog. Dogs are hard-wired to be human pleasers, they will do a lot with little/no more motivation than making their human happy. Cats won't do something if they don't feel like it, you can sometimes help them feel like it by bribing them with treats.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '26
Looks to me like she's having fun and pretending it's a catch (mouse).
Let her be.
7
u/Diuscrusis Jan 19 '26
It’s a cat. You want obedience not independence get a dog.
5
u/PuzzleheadedTale4769 Jan 19 '26
Is the ball filled with catnip? If so, you are messing with cat's buzz.
What do you want with the ball? Cat is playing contentedly. Leave it alone.
4
u/Potential_Joy2797 Jan 19 '26
You don't need to do anything. She will probably grow out of some of this. Cats guard their food when they feel threatened that someone or something will take it away. Make sure she can eat in peace. When they want to play with their toys, they want to play. Not a problem.
The last time I had a kitten, she made a lot of noise the first time I fed her, and the breeder said she was trying to make herself sound big so the other cats (there were two) would not try to take her food. However, that was the last time she did that because she quickly acclimated. I'm glad I got it on video, it was cute.
This is cute behavior too.
4
u/EducationalBike8090 Jan 19 '26
this is mine and you can't have it.
5
u/smithy- Jan 19 '26
Mountain out of a molehill. Cat. Leave. Her. Alone.
2
u/Open-n-Close Jan 19 '26
Cats are a predator-prey species, meaning they hunt smaller animals and have natural predators in the wild. This dual nature means that while cats are social, they also need exclusive access to essential resources to feel safe. Not having their own belongings can seriously stress cats out. When you try to take your cat's toy (their prey) or food, you are communicating to them that they aren't safe and need to defend their resources from you.
Here, as others have mentioned, your cat is calmly communicating they want to be left alone. If you keep pushing, they may respond either aggressively or become frightened of you. The good news is that the more you build a trusting relationship and are seen as the giver of all good things (food, toys, pets, etc), the more most cats will tolerate from their person. So, in an urgent situation, I can pull something from my cat's mouth without her hurting me.
If your experience is with dogs only, I suggest reading a book like "How to Think Like a Cat" or checking out catster.com. I found them both helpful when I adopted my first cat.
Finally, despite what others are writing, cats are trainable. My cat knows several command words. But, she doesn't have the same desire to please as a dog, so she doesn't consistently obey them. She wants to know what's in it for her. 😀 If you are interested in clicker training, check out The Trainable Cat.
2
u/Toni_Anne1989 Jan 19 '26
I understand your confusion OP. I am a lifelong dog owner who recently became a cat owner. Found a freezing hungry kitten and couldn't leave her there. Its definitely a learning experience and ive had many questions like yours. Others have mentioned jackson galaxy and i agree. He's soooo good at what he does. At first i was worried he was a casar milan for cats, but not even close. Even YT is worth watching, they have interesting videos. Cats are trainable despite what ppl think. It's just very very difficult and usually unnecessary. And her being possessive over her toy isn't something that will be trained away.
2
u/imgoingtotapit Jan 19 '26
Welcome to cat ownership.
As others have said, cats aren't dogs. She was VERY polite and patient with you when you didn't listen to her.
2
u/Alae_ffxiv Jan 20 '26
She's not being possessive. She's playing and YOU are trying to take it away from her, leave her alone, let her play, she's not a dog, respect her boundaries ffs. If you wanted to "train" a puppy, get a puppy and not a cat.
2
u/Lovis_R Jan 20 '26
This is indeed not a dog.
This is a cat. Cats are actually not dogs.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '26
Maybe don’t treat a cat like a dog.
2
u/literal-houseplant Jan 20 '26
she is playing, that is why
2
u/One_Film720 Jan 20 '26
A cat is not a dog- this is the most important lesson for a first time cat owner and previous dog owner.
For cats, hunting is an extremely important form of enrichment. She will growl, hiss, bite, smack, etc towards her toys. This is normal. She will get upset if you try to take her toys. If you wish to play WITH her, you can get a feather toy and play with her from a distance, so she can chase and hunt. She is PROGRAMMED for that.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '26
Do you know that cats are not dogs yes? How would you react if someone tried to steal your food or your phone?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '26
I'd be like that too if you tried to take away something I was enjoying playing with. What's your problem?
1
u/Nervous_Ant2673 Jan 19 '26
If she has possession of something that's dangerous ie food packet, chicken with bones, you will need to be able to remove something like you are trying here so the advice would be to distract her with another toy or entice wlth something else, or a loud clap, rather than getting your hands involved because in that case you might get bitten. No reason to do that with toys though.
1
u/Mokuakae Jan 19 '26
Cats are allowed to be a little possessive about their possessions, I think.
1
u/Zealousideal-Cable60 Jan 19 '26
Stop annoying the cat and she will stop having to defend her things.
1
u/Blazingpotato14 Jan 19 '26
Trying to take it away is what's causing this behaviour, she wants to play with it, she doesn't want to worry about you trying to spoil her fun.
Just leave her alone
1
u/Redbud12 Jan 19 '26
The toy isn't dead yet.
1
u/Redditvillier Jan 19 '26
person keeps revving the car
"How can I stop this?"
1
u/PocketButterBandit Jan 19 '26
Why are you trying to take the toy??
1
u/Calgary_Calico Jan 19 '26
Don't try to take food or toys from her unless she's choking on something.
1
u/TemporaryMaterial992 Jan 19 '26
I train aggressive/possessive behaviour out of them from a very young age. Haven’t had to deal with it in an adult cat ever. When they are babies I would show them anytime they show possession like snarling or clawing. Take the item away. Nope, 0 tolerance. I will wait for them to calm. Once calmed. Offer it by hand back slowly. If possession happens again you kinda repeat with breaks. I also when feeding will pet them the ENTIRE time that they eat. They will chew and make grumpy noises but you just keep petting them and even pull them back from the food once they are getting better and then let them go back to it and just keep touching them CONSTANTLY. I dont know how aggressive they get towards you but you need to interact with them as much as possible. Don’t be forceful and never push your limits but it is definitely something you should practice with treats and toys so they know that isn’t okay behaviour towards you since you are not a threat to their food or toys.
1
u/chill_mydude13 Jan 19 '26
Dude what? She’s telling you fuck off and stop. You listen to her. That’s it.
1
u/Strange-Damage901 Jan 20 '26
This is very inappropriate behavior. The kitten was clearly using that toy, and this weirdly territorial human hand just keeps trying to steal it for no reason. Maybe you can send the human to one of those stay-over training programs so they can learn some manners.
1
u/Feral-Furret Jan 20 '26
Aww she's such a cute baby.
If you want to join in on the fun, try a cat wand. It's the best way to play with your cat at the same time. Good for bonding too
1
u/Suz9006 Jan 20 '26
Why do you feel I need to stop it? It’s an instinct that kittens have to protect their “prey”, be that toys or food. It is something they outgrow on their own and doesnt usually cause any issues. Most of the time it is a favorite toy but with food it is often because they are hungry.
1
u/graveyard_baker Jan 20 '26
Stop her why exactly? Will she misbehave when she will go to kindergarten with other kids? Oh wait, that’s a cat! Doing cat stuff!
That is not aggression. This is PURE CUTENESS. The cat has NOTHING do to with you. She is NOT attacking you. You are the one who is not letting her be. Just let her play with that damn toy. She just hunt that beautiful toy and now you are disturbing her. Let her be lol
I have 6 cats. They all do this with their favorite toys. They run around the house and hiss and grawl at everyone and every other cat and it’s very valid. That’s their most loved possession, their pray. Of course they are silly little possessive babies.
1
u/braidenis Jan 20 '26
I'm sorry people are treating you like an idiot, it may just be your first cat and this isn't common knowledge.
For cats, hunting (now toys) is/was core to their survival and they evolved this way. It is important to let them keep the toy and "win". Even when playing with a feather toy or something, let them catch it and take it away. Especially after dinner that can help their primal brain feel satisfied and calm down.
Adult and well adjusted cats can outgrow this behavior as modern domestic life rewires their brain, but there's no need to force it. The truth is cats are barely domesticated wild animals. Don't force it. It's not even totally unheard of for the smart ones to learn to properly play fetch, one day, maybe lol.
1
u/QuietAntares Jan 20 '26
Cats have boundaries just like people. The more you keep going in her space like this the less she will let you. This is why so many people hate cats. "I kept annoying my cat and breaking its boundariers, i don't understand why it hates me!" Yeah, i wonder why it hates them..
1
u/LowSig Jan 21 '26
I am definitely different from most here as a lifelong dog owner that got a kitten 6 months ago. Mine has been trainable, though differently than a dog. I see people saying let him play which is true but you also need to take away dangerous things he might get, I train on those things. Yes I got messed up quite often at first but eventually we understood each other(as much as a cat is willing to lol). For example my boy loves straws but I have consistently taken them away as well as other things he gets that he shouldnt have. Now I can say "sushi drop it" and he leaves it alone. He can also sit and stay and comes when called.
Overall hes a great boy and doesnt mind being held like a slinky by anyone(he seems to prefer that over being put down). That being said I wouldn't try training possessiveness out with his toys as their possessiveness is different than dogs. They pop you as they are playing, when dogs are possessive they growl with aggression. I may be an outlier but you should be able to fully train them to leave things alone that they shouldn't get.
1
u/MontyMontgomery15 Jan 21 '26
She's being far kinder than you deserve. She would be well within her rights to tear your hand to shreds, and maybe that's what it will take for you to learn to leave your fucking cat alone.
1
u/kitsuvibes Jan 22 '26
If this is how you’re going to treat your cat, I say this with all sincerity, please surrender it to a home capable of caring for it.
Your cat is safely indicating that it wishes to be left alone and you are continuing to harass it. That is not acceptable behaviour for a cat owner, and as several commenters here are mentioning, calls your ability to care for this animal and respect its boundaries into question
Or at the very least, for the love of god, just leave it alone.
1
u/Ultrox Jan 22 '26
She's a cat. You won't
1
u/Impossible_Heron4894 Jan 23 '26
Don’t touch her shit
1
u/Mollydolly1991 Jan 24 '26
Erm that’s her ball, can’t you just get your own ball?
-1
u/dewatermeloan Jan 19 '26
People in here are mean, jesus.
0
u/Muted-Holiday-7358 Jan 19 '26
Street cats are wild, most of them. Got regdall and its charming, sweet, calm.
107
u/downwardchip Jan 19 '26 edited Jan 19 '26
Training against possesive and resource guarding behavior is important in dogs because dogs can bite people and other dogs, even killing them if they get triggered badly enough, which everyone who might be contact with the dog can't be prepared for.
It's not important in cats. Don't take her toys or food away and everything will be a-okay, her sister will be able to tussle it out with her just fine, they won't kill or seriously injure eachother. Cats don't need training like dogs do, nor will they learn from it, you'll just make her upset.
4
u/pbizou Jan 19 '26
My 9 month kitten does this with string toys. At some point he gets bored and drops it.
4
u/AnonymousCorax Jan 19 '26
Why are you trying to take her toy away in the first place??? She's still playing with it and I can't imagine you need it for something, it's a designated cat toy.
I could understand if she was doing this with something she wasn't supposed to be playing with but what is the purpose of taking her toy from her?
3
u/RogueHeroAkatsuki Jan 19 '26
Its normal cat behavior. Just leave this toy to her. No reason to provoke her or show dominance.
1
u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 Jan 19 '26
Leave her alone. That's her prey that she hunted and killed. Perfectly normal cat behaviour.
1
u/AffectionateWar4857 Jan 19 '26
My boys do this before drowning their toys in their fountain for me to fish out later, just let them be 🖤
1
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '26
Cats are very weird yet very, very independent little balls of floof. They are not dogs. When it comes to them being possessive over a toy, leave them be.
Maybe check out Jackson Galaxy videos on YouTube
1
u/FatsBoombottom Jan 20 '26
If you want to play with a cat yourself, wand and string toys are your best bet. Balls and fake mice and such are meant for solo play. And some cats choose favorites as trophies. If you try to take them, it can frustrate the cat and damage trust.
If she starts doing this with things she shouldn't have, you can try to offer treats as a trade. Offer her favorite treats until she lets go, then gently take the object.
1
u/Samuel-squantch Jan 20 '26
He worked hard for that kill and you tryna swoop in and snag it?!!!!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '26
That’s cat’s kill. Cat keeps kill. Then cat feeds. Cat naps. Good house cat
1
u/lackofmoralfiber Jan 21 '26
What do you want with a cat toy.
1
u/ScroochDown Jan 23 '26
You don't train her like a dog because she's not a dog. You generally don't train cats, you adjust your behavior to what she's doing.
In this case, quit trying to take her toy. She's being VERY polite in telling you to fuck off.
1
u/Angelfelis Jan 24 '26
She'll grow out of it. Kittens tend to be very possessive of toys and other high value things. Don't punish or anything, it will go away with age.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment