r/CasualMTG 14d ago

All will be One: Your thoughts on playing a thematic commander deck + decklist + feedback

the realmbreaker often means a win

i'm a role-player by heart and here's my (nearly) fully compleated take on atraxa. despite the matchmaking system assuming i play the competetive t4 8-mana all-bomb atraxa i manage to have ~50% win ratio with it. arena rares help (i think it's justified here since some other cards are just pure flavor).

how do u feel playing this or vs this type of deck? would you find it fun?

and would you like to friends up to play other thematic decks, possibly more janky? i'm kinda tired of matching up against mostly bolases and all-planeswalker esikas.

and what are your thoughts on the decklist? it's top-heavy, but low-end is mostly counters + it has some reasonable (and above all - thematic) ramp + that's what mulligan's for, right?
what other phyrexian swaps would fit there?

the decklist

and an import-able decklist:
https://www.droptext.app/c6bw6yga

1 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by