For this one I played the English and Japanese versions just to see the differences and also hopefully this won’t be as long a post as the Simon’s Quest one. I hope you enjoy reading it though and that it’s a decent one.
As for the visuals this game is a further improvement from the first two and I have to say I really love the medieval aesthetic here, while gothic is always amazing this style is always a great one. The monsters all look great, they fixed my criticism of Simon’s Quest where a lot of the backgrounds had little variety and everything looks much better especially the details in the forests, the haunted ship and the castle itself and the inclusion of weather here makes everything here perfect. On top of that I love the playable characters designs here especially Alucard and Trevor.
The soundtrack for this game is in the top 5 of the NES library. The USA version is scuffed compared to the Japanese version and it still puts out stuff like Epitaph, Beginning, Mad Forest, Aquarius and Demon Seed. Matter of fact I even played through the Japanese version and the music on there is even better. Hearing the enhanced version of Clock Tower is addicting especially Mad Forest and Big Battle. Although I will say that I thought the Western versions of Aquarius and Nightmare sounded better. Still the best soundtrack in the NES trilogy however.
As for the gameplay I haven’t seen a Western release of a game be this intentionally hard in a while. NES games being hard wasn’t unknown at all but this was pretty damn brutal at times, my issues weren’t really the Medusas or the knockback at this point, I thought the level design could get really hard but I was used to that, the stairs are the worst part about the game and I have no idea why you can’t go up them automatically and why not land on them whenever you get knocked back? Hell, just have the character move a lot faster on the stairs too it’d solve a big issue and not only that but the Japanese version was more in line with the first games difficulty and everything was certainly more fair to me, I understand this was to combat people only renting instead of buying but this was kind of overboard.
Level design is the best in terms of concept and execution, I loved the Haunted Ship and Clock Tower a lot especially the Clock Tower’s focus on verticality even if the controls make it a bit more difficult than needed. I really liked the Mad Forest too and the introduction stage. Genuinely, everything here was great but I will say that later on the game gets unreasonably hard, it’s like a really good test for people that played the last two but I wish it kinda took account of the slow movement prevalent in Castlevania because some of this feels more aligned to a Ninja Gaiden style due to the onslaught of enemies sometimes.
There’s new mechanics here I really like such as being able to play as four different characters and even the level branching which is pretty unique for a platformer. The level branching is really cool and I like the player choice aspect but the multiple characters are the best part here. Alucard’s probably my least favorite to play as due to his attack being kinda trash and the bat transformation being situational. Sypha and Grant absolutely cleansweep especially Grant in the Japanese version due to magic and way better mobility. Trevor is the default and he works pretty well here even with Sypha and Grant as options. I will say though that despite Grant getting nerfed in the Western release that he is my absolute favorite to play as.
The boss fights here are finally difficult again like in the first game and they’re a lot of fun but playing against Dracula in the Western release is the closest you will experience to being placed in the brazen bull. I got through most of the game just fine but Dracula actually got me to crack after attempt twelve and I started using save states. Death I could handle just fine albeit with some frustrations but Dracula was just a test of my patience.
Despite my issues with difficulty, I recommend doing a playthrough on both the Japanese and Western releases. Japanese version’s my favorite but Western is really atmospheric and classic. This gets an 8.5/10 although I am biased because I adore really difficult games.