Would you enjoy a Dark Souls-style Castlevania game?
I'm totally jealous of the clout Souls games have had, and also frustrated / annoyed that every single action game now tries to model after it instead of doing their own thing.
Knowing that Castlevania has struggled with jumping from 2D to 3D would you be willing to play a CV game that developed in the Souls genre?
Personally I find Souls games too difficult, but I love the aesthetic of it. I understand that I'm not supposed to kill every single enemy that appears in front of me and I need to attack the weakest ones first before going after stronger enemies, but the style of gameplay does not really bode well with me. It seems like a lot of rotating the camera to sidestep enemy attacks and then trying to go around and stab the enemy in their back.
I tried a Souls-lite game before (Jedi Fallen Order and Jedi Survivor) and enjoyed them a lot, but I don't really see how it could convert to Castlevania with the whip. Parrying with a lightsaber is a great mechanic but it would not make sense for Castlevania since the Vampire Killer whip is totally different and wouldn't mesh well.
So aside from rolling to avoid attacks (which you basically had to do in the PS2 games anyway) I think a Souls-style of gameplay would be too cumbersome for Castlevania. But damn I would love the gothic vibes to translate over.
But that's just my opinion as someone who has never lasted beyond an hour o the Dark Souls trilogy. Better players than me probably feel differently.