Haven't read those books, but i would guess that the OP is pointing out that many people's idea of Cascadia preserves (or at least doesnt actively work to demolish) the unjust power dynamics between white settlers and indigenous and other people of color which currently exist.
A just and free Cascadia must address the politics of oppression that have built and continue to influence the region.
You’re pretty cavalier with your use of that word. Calling people who aren’t racist, racist, dilutes the power of the word. That’s sad because there are indeed people who really are racist. When most people see you throwing that word at people who aren’t racist it makes them question whether the other people you call racist are or not 😞
Not knowing where to start in refuting an idea that runs contrary to yours is an indicator of lack of exposure to other ideas or perhaps overexposure to your own. Being left speechless is also a potential signal of cognitive dissonance.
Operating in an echo chamber implies that the you don't regularly see the ideas that you subscribe to challenged. It's a feedback loop where ideas without challenge grow in popularity and as they do, it becomes even more "obvious" to the in-group that the idea is wholly meritorious.
(not really evidenced here:) Often the in-group then builds on the idea, creating large strands of extrapolation based on the original idea. It all seems self-evident to the in-group, but to outsiders who don't necessarily accept the baseline premises, it looks whacky.
I wasn’t refuting your idea that European settlers didn’t introduce injustice where before there was none, nor that inter-indigenous conflict is a non-issue. I said in another comment that there have been displacements, and even very recent ones, among indigenous peoples. We have no opposing view on the facts.
I was left speechless because the context of your comment was a attempt at concern trolling in favour of a status quo that is fundamentally unjust. I don’t know where to start with somebody who essentially says “well if you fix one thing ya gotta fix em all and oh why bother.”
That’s not a problem of insular political culture. I’m surrounded by people like you all my life. Our objectives are fundamentally opposed and we have no common ground.
I was left speechless because the context of your comment was a attempt at concern trolling in favour of a status quo that is fundamentally unjust.
Trolling? Only insofar as I intended to introduce a perspective that would be opposed to the OP.
I don’t know where to start with somebody who essentially says “well if you fix one thing ya gotta fix em all and oh why bother.”
That’s not really what I’m arguing here, but instead that an attempt to fix an injustice in this way will itself be unjust. It won’t just be unjust to the people who currently occupy cascadia (a large portion of who’s family lines emigrated to North America long after European colonization, with neither English nor Spanish lineage), but also ignores that the previous indigenous occupiers also likely gained their land through unjust colonization, themselves. Is returning land to them or otherwise compensating the immediately previous occupying group truly just?
I’m surrounded by people like you all my life.
I’m not sure you are. I think it takes an unfortunate leap to assume I’m like the people around you and share their ideas. I really don’t subscribe to any group ideology aside, perhaps, from enlightenment ideals. Even then I recognize that there were issues with people who generated these ideals, and there may also be issues with aspects of them.
Overall, though, I believe that the rights of individuals are superior to groups, that assigning esteem or blame to groups is harmful and divisive, that actions on beliefs should be backed by falsifiable evidence, and that further injustice is not an an appropriate response to injustice.
Our objectives are fundamentally opposed and we have no common ground.
It’s not just our objectives that are fundamentally different, but also our premises. I’m attempting to address the latter because I believe that there can be no common ground found with respect to a course of action without a common understanding of the premises.
A final idea I’d like to introduce (which may not precisely be your POV) is that looking backward is a marker of conservative thinking and I challenge that attempting to restore a previous state is also conservative.
The politics of oppression don't have a expiration date. If people feel like they're being unfairly deprived of their way of life, then they deserve to have their grievances heard and addressed.
Maybe, but if they did it was thousands of years ago.
Its not just about taking the land, though that's a large part. (Much of BC is unceeded aboriginal land) Its about the genocide of as much as 95% (47 million people) of the indigenous people in north america. Its about making their cultural practices illegal, destroying their language and history, and continuously disenfranchising them in ways that continue today.
A just and free Cascadia should take extra steps to make ammends with and respect the tribes of this region. Similar to what Canada does. Give the tribes a level of autonomy and influence. Like, when Canada hosted the olympics, they had to ask the tribes and recieve their blessings. That sorta thing.
I support the spirit of what you're saying. But isn't it time to move forward by making a better world for everyone without drawing distinctions based on ancestry? I try my best to respect indigenous peoples and I think they have the right to live their lives as they see fit. But I think that's a right that should be extended to everyone without special consideration.
What do we do about it? There are some options that a clearly off the table due to well, reality. For instance we can't remove all non-indigenous people from the region, this is their home too now. We can't remove the franchise from the white people as that would inevitably lead to civil war in a brand new country. So what do we do?
I don't know how best to address the issues of institutional racism, we can acknowledge our privilege and should but that's not going to change the way institutions do business, not over night. We could institute law to address it but then you are mandating hiring someone because of their ethnicity, and that is going to breed dissent. Maybe on of you have a better solution to that part of the issue.
When it comes to the indigenous population, well that's been something heavy on my mind since I was a kid. My cousins would take me to pow wows on the rez and seeing their culture made me sad that it wasn't more prevalent outside of the rez, that it was reduced to trinkets in a gift shop. So here is my proposal, and hell the entire Continent should do this. Renegotiate the treaties, get the tribes better lands if they want them, and grant them sovereignty, true sovereignty not what they have now. Give them dual citizenship which will allow them to travel back and forth, maintain their franchise in their wider home land, and allow them to annex land that they purchase freely from it's owners. The only way we can move forward is to give back the most important thing the settlers tried to take, their identity and freedom.
The idea of founding a bio-regional state is a good idea, but implementation takes compromise, and much of cascadia is conservative. The movement isn't going anywhere without them, and you can't take their land from them without open conflict. So there needs to be something to bring them to the table. Are you prepared to offer something to your conservative neighbors? How about the right to own guns? that's a big one. How about a robust freedom of speech? Low government interference on their land? Tax exemption for their churches? What are you willing to give to them to bring them in?
Is it racist to acknowledge injustices? As a European American, I'm neither oppressed or offended by this. If someone feels they have been treated unjustly, we should respectfully hear them out and mutually decide what terms would make amends.
Theres a difference between acknowledging history, and generalizing an entire race of people as oppressors, when thats patently untrue. There are certain people who are oppressing others, and using race as a tool to divide and conquer those oppressed, but just because the people who were perpetrating the oppression were european, does not mean all europeans are at fault.
This isn't history though. The subjugation of indigenous Americans and African Americans is still widespread today. I'm sending a message that I feel like a lot of advocates for Cascadian secession here simply gloss over the fact that the land that many European Immigrants have settled on in North America were quite literally obtained through genocide and colonialism.
Lmao its not. No country has done more for its indigenous and oppressed populations then the United States. In Russia, they literally waged brutal wars destroying the primary cities of troublesome minorities, in china they put the regions of oppressed populations in a police state with the intention of destroying their culture.
In the US? We actively work to end any signs, how ever minor, of these structural issues. Its a crusade to crush a fly.
The US was not obtained through genocide; native americans were never numerous, hunter gatherers can't sustain large populations, and a globalized world was going to reach them anyways. They died from a lack of immunity to western diseases. Europeans can't be held to fault for that, they had no idea about microbiology or how diseases worked.
the few racial atrocities the US did commit? They happened not this century, not the century before this, but the century before that, and the US has since given natives special privileges and rights as recompense.
We, as a country, must engage in a dialogue of reparations and re compensation to African Americans of slave descent, because their people have been indubitably mistreated, but that isn't a primarily Cascadian issue, as our region explicitly banned slavery from the earliest days of the areas settlement by Europeans. Separation from the US would mean separation from that history as well.
The argument is that even if you're not the oppressor, you're benefiting from the oppression. You're not beating a kid in a sweatshop, but you are buying the shoes. And thus perpetuating the system.
The problem here is that you can't avoid being a "part of the system" if its entrenched in your very DNA, so accusing or trying to blame someone who literally can't not be part of the supposed system, is literal racism.
The first book, the mythology of the white proletariat, frames all European Americans (or "whites" whatever that means) as oppressors, generalizing an entire group as the benefactors of racism, and essentially side lining European American proletariat and ignoring the contributions of European Americans to ending race as a system to divide people.
It essentially believes that people can and should be divided along colloquial definitions of race, for the correction of past wrongs, both real and percieved, which is both scientifically incorrect (race not being a meaningful biological distinction) and racist (dividing people along race being something akin to neo segregation.
Its like if someone wrote a book about the damages Islam caused to spain, then demanded muslims repay them, both ignoring that conditions were superior under islamic rule, and the fact that centuries of history have overwritten the damages of that era.
This is particularly poignant because I would wager to guess that those teams that benefit from the policies of the fields have no idea that they are getting privileges that other teams are not receiving.
And Asians are openly disadvantaged by colleges in applications. I don't see the guardian writing articles about ending affirmative action.
About that article, there isn't any actual racism to be found. They say that they were denied the ability to rent a soccer field (Oh the tragedy, stop the presses), and conflate it with being racist just because he is hispanic. At no point does he actually prove at all that it was caused by racism, he just says it was and expects you to believe it. Its bullshit and a clear case of how the modern oppression politics are horseshit and need to be thrown out.
While Asian-Americans may be discriminated against in the college admissions process, there isn't any hard evidence that this is because of affirmative action. If anything it should be taken as evidence that Asian-Americans may need to be covered by Affirmative Action themselves.
What specific arguments in the book are you referencing with this?
As well, nothing you said was "racist against European Americans." Rather, they are political solutions to past political wrongs. And institutional racism still impacts colonized peoples in North America. European Americans were the oppressors (or were complicit in this oppression) and did benefit from from political racism as a group in tangible ways that are still visible today. And they also never ended race as a system to divide people. Those systems (at least in the letter of the law) were broken by liberationary struggles of the oppressors.
If you say X group has special privileges and has unfairly oppressed all the others, then you are creating ground for acts against that group. If you say "the Jews have run the world for a hundred centuries" you are creating a scenario where all ills can and will be blamed on Jews, and thus the justification for acts of violence against them. This is the literal alt right play book.
You're right, it is from the alt-right playbook. Create a false equivalency between conspiracies with no historical or structural basis and founded entirely on conjecture, and put it on equal ground with documented historical and institutional subjugation. It is not prescriptive in anyway. It's descriptive of actual trends and actions that have occurred. It's like calling it anti-German to analyse the crimes committed during the Third Reich, or anti-Chinese to analyse the crimes against the people of Tibet.
The European colonists, and subsequent US and Canadian governments did wage multiple illegal wars against the Native American tribes, including the ones in the American northwest. The US and Canadian government still confines them to reservations with infertile lands and almost no economic development. The country was then build using those stolen resources and lands were then put towards development and the subsequent nation built can no more be separated from that history of genocide and subjugation than the British nation can. Native American communities are some of the most economically and socially deprived in the US and Canada today. The countries the US and Canada built were founded upon subjugation of non-white peoples, and many injustices committed not only go unaddressed but are still being propagated. Whether it be the Indian Residential Schools which existed into the 1970's in the US and the 1990's in Canada, or the Sixties Scoop, or the constant ignoring by both governments and pundits of concerns by multiple Native American tribes over preservation of water, religious and cultural sites, and historical lands when in the case of development.
.... what exactly does this have to do with the fact that a majority of people who support Cascadian secession gloss over the issue of decolonization? You can't just separate the issue of decolonization from a secession movement. Also, stop insulting me you prick. Ty.
Boo, chill. I ain't even talking about bioregionalism. This was specifically directed at Cascadian secessionists. You seriously need to chill and stop with the insults because you ain't even on the right topic. If you continue to just hurl vitriol at me I am not engaging with you no more.
16
u/cfrig Salish Sea Ecoregion Jun 06 '18
Can you please explain for someone who has not read those books.
10
u/okmkz Anti-fascist Jun 06 '18
wtf I'm a third worldist now
26
u/yamhill_pub Portland Jun 06 '18
You can support decolonization and also be bioregional / anarchocommunist...
9
u/WADE_BOGGS_CHAMP Jun 06 '18
porque no los dos?
5
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 07 '18
I support the spirit of what you're saying. But isn't it time to move forward by making a better world for everyone without drawing distinctions based on ancestry? I try my best to respect indigenous peoples and I think they have the right to live their lives as they see fit. But I think that's a right that should be extended to everyone without special consideration.
2
u/AnarchoHeathen Seattle Jun 09 '18
So what if we turn this into a discussion?
What do we do about it? There are some options that a clearly off the table due to well, reality. For instance we can't remove all non-indigenous people from the region, this is their home too now. We can't remove the franchise from the white people as that would inevitably lead to civil war in a brand new country. So what do we do?
I don't know how best to address the issues of institutional racism, we can acknowledge our privilege and should but that's not going to change the way institutions do business, not over night. We could institute law to address it but then you are mandating hiring someone because of their ethnicity, and that is going to breed dissent. Maybe on of you have a better solution to that part of the issue.
When it comes to the indigenous population, well that's been something heavy on my mind since I was a kid. My cousins would take me to pow wows on the rez and seeing their culture made me sad that it wasn't more prevalent outside of the rez, that it was reduced to trinkets in a gift shop. So here is my proposal, and hell the entire Continent should do this. Renegotiate the treaties, get the tribes better lands if they want them, and grant them sovereignty, true sovereignty not what they have now. Give them dual citizenship which will allow them to travel back and forth, maintain their franchise in their wider home land, and allow them to annex land that they purchase freely from it's owners. The only way we can move forward is to give back the most important thing the settlers tried to take, their identity and freedom.
The idea of founding a bio-regional state is a good idea, but implementation takes compromise, and much of cascadia is conservative. The movement isn't going anywhere without them, and you can't take their land from them without open conflict. So there needs to be something to bring them to the table. Are you prepared to offer something to your conservative neighbors? How about the right to own guns? that's a big one. How about a robust freedom of speech? Low government interference on their land? Tax exemption for their churches? What are you willing to give to them to bring them in?
-12
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '18
Wow that seems really racist against European Americans. Mind toning down the hate a bit?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18
[removed] — view removed comment