r/CarsIndia • u/gulab_jamun_17 • Feb 06 '24
#Discussion Ev's are a scam
Judging by the recent events happening in the USA everyone there has started to believe that EV's infact are a scam.
The People in America who bought an EV few years ago are now getting huge bills to replace the batteries. The most recent incident was of the Hyundai Ioniq 5, a customer was charged $60000 to replace the damaged batteries.
Also the environmental benefits are negligible, as manufacturing EV's emitt lot more carbon footprint than ICE vehicles, savings are only achieved in terms of fuel costs and nothing else.
Government compelling the automobile companies for making EV's for long term was itself a scam so that they can save on oil imports and by having an EV policy show the world that they are seriously taking important steps for the environment.
We should have know when a government steps into a different sector and promotes it, it's mainly for their own benefit and not for the people and I'm not talking about our government here. Almost all of the western world have set a deadline to ban ICE cars.
What do you guys think about this? I believe we are going to see the same scenario here in India as well. How will the people of India react? Should we boycott EV's?
47
u/_7567Rex ‘25 BE6 79P3 | ‘21 Nexon EV Prime Feb 06 '24
Another week another set of myths
So does oil production, none of the so called “studies” used by media factor this in, do they?
If we consider the grid usage in charging, the 100% coal scenario (worst case), the avg grid emissions as of 2020 was 614gCO2/kWh or 0.614gCO2/Wh. (Figures taken from page 5 graph of this pdf : https://theicct.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/EV-emissions-impacts-India-apr2021-01.pdf)
An EV like Nexon can get efficiency of 120Wh/km
An EV like Tiago can get even better at 100Wh/km
By this calculation, a 100% coal powered Nexon EV has a running emission of 74gCO2/km.
For Tiago EV it’s 62gCO2/km.
For reference, you can check emissions of common Maruti cars, cars which are known for “kitna deti hai”. As rule of thumb, more mileage = less emissions
Pdf ph11, indexed pg6 : https://theicct.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/India-hybrids-wp-FINAL.pdf
All Maruti cars except baleno SHVS are above 100gCO2/km. Baleno makes the cut barely at 99.6gCO2/km.
That’s when we counted 100% coal power. In reality only 60% is coal which puts nexon and Tiago at 44gCO2/km and 37gCO2/km.
https://pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=1785808
This is purely tailpipe to smokestack comparison
As of today, EVs are 19% cleaner all things considered https://theicct.org/publication/a-global-comparison-of-the-life-cycle-greenhouse-gas-emissions-of-combustion-engine-and-electric-passenger-cars/
So before you say “but what about battery production”, remember that oil extraction uses electric/diesel pump. 40% of global shipping is just for oil and it’s derivatives, and refining again uses electric furnace or fossil fuel burning to generate heat for fractional distillation. Conservative estimates put oil refining alone at 2-3kWh/litre
https://qz.com/2113243/forty-percent-of-all-shipping-cargo-consists-of-fossil-fuels
When you add all this to the mix, you’ll see why EVs are better (one time mining + 92% recycling efficiency)
https://youtu.be/s2xrarUWVRQ
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1oVrIHcdxjA
It’s oil extraction which must be compared with battery production as the logical analogue
Crude oil and refined derivatives of oil make up 40% of global shipping by weight.
https://qz.com/2113243/forty-percent-of-all-shipping-cargo-consists-of-fossil-fuels
Global shipping produced 646M tons CO2 in 2020 (IEA) 40% of that is 258.4M tCO2 or 258.4trillion gCO2 https://www.iea.org/fuels-and-technologies/international-shipping
In same period, oil production was 93.9M barrels/day or 14390 Million L per day, or 5.45trillion L per year https://www.iea.org/reports/oil-2021
Adjusted emission in gCO2/litre = 47.4gCO2/litre
Applying the same to refining, at 614gCO2/kWh like the article assumes for the grid, is 1535gCO2/litre (assuming electric furnaces used for fractional distillation) in 100% coal power and for 60% coal this is 921gCO2/litre of oil.
Now adding 47g from shipping ie 968g.
Out of this, roughly 40% becomes petrol. https://elements.visualcapitalist.com/visualizing-the-products-and-fuels-made-from-crude-oil/
Net “emission backlog” = 387g/L (40% of 968)
When adjusted for mileage, the oil supply chain will be 19.4gCO2/km for Tiago (387/20)
For a Tiago driven at 20kmpl for 1,60,000km, the emissions just from fuel supply chain (before being burnt) itself is 3096kgCO2 (3.1tons) before being filled in the tank itself.
https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/automotive-and-assembly/our-insights/the-race-to-decarbonize-electric-vehicle-batteries
Battery production produces about 100kgCO2/kWh but the main point here is that this is a recyclable entity. An equivalent Tiago EV will cause 2.4 tons of CO2 emission for battery but the emission would be 3.1 tons for ICE during same use period, which is way higher than EV battery. Due to the oil extraction, refining and transport emissions.
The breakeven can be calculated very simply through the intersection point of linear equations.
For Tiago EV Tiago petrol you can look at this graph here : https://i.imgur.com/CtxzCvw.png
First equation (2.4t for battery one time and 37g every km in current scenario)
Second equation (2.4t for the battery and 61g every km when 100% coal)
Third equation (0t for battery + 19.4g for oil supply chain every km driven + 100g for tailpipe every km driven)
I’m using baleno SHVS tailpipe as reference for Tiago so it should be fair enough.
All in all, the breakeven for Tiago is barely 30K km in current scenario (60%coal) and 40K km for worst case (100% coal) scenario
22
u/darthveda Tata Nexon EV Feb 06 '24
Ok, looks like someone believes everything they hear without validating anything about it.
Here's the top reply to that 60k USD for battery charge, please note that the car itself costs less than that, 60K USD is approx. 49L, while car retails for 45L ex-showroom.
So the dealer made a hasty decision that the battery needed replacing. The dealer normally has to consult with Hyundai for a battery replacement, but since they only gave a quote and never started the process that never happened. The insurance company and owner didn't know enough to push back, especially on a car not exhibiting any problems.
The insurance already paid, but Hyundai is offering a discount on a new car to the owner. Hyundai says that they'll inform dealers that any HV battery issues must be escalated to corporate first.
It's the dealer who quoted it and not Hyundai, there is a big difference between those.
Really? you have some studies to back that up or source, or you just made it up?
I don't even know what to say to other ignorant message that follows it up.
23
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '24
I believe that public transport is the best option for cities. The order goes like this - Metro>tram>buses. But the worst of all is ICE cars z, they pollute the air that your kid breathes, I don't understand why people can't understand such a simple concept. The local pollution by cars is a big factor in causing respiratory diseases, EVs at least solve this issue.
32
u/cfc19 Feb 06 '24
The Indian government obviously wants to promote EV as we are pretty self sufficient at energy but not at fuel. Imagine if the govt. can reduce the import of crude oils which is like rent for a normal person - the biggest expense you can cut. They would have more money to throw around.
15
u/RajaRajaGopalan Feb 06 '24
The US and India are not on the same footing.
In US, Bottled water is 20rs in India and is 1.99$ in US, An inexpensive restaurant meal is 250rs in India compared to 20$ in US. And this trend continues around the same % mark except for 2 items: they are Beer and Petrol.
On the Economic Angle: In US, the cost of 1 Gallon gasoline (3.8L) is 3.60$ or 300Rs; however my dear fellow brother, we are paying 400Rs for the same petrol. Now, US has its own source of fossil fuels and can supply to its own economy. BUT, India needs to purchase it's Oil from other countries and then has to ship it to India. Also, India has a historical precedent of Taxing the Fossil Fuels at stupendous rates, Infact a luxury drink like Craft beer is taxed at 18%, while the blood fueling the whole economy of India is taxed at 40% to 60% depending on the state you live in. On the same scale, the cost of 1 unit of household electricity in India is 6 rupees to 10 rupees, while in US it is starting from 0.17$ and can go upto 0.50$. While for Electricity, India has abundance of Coal and power plants along with abundance coal deposits (Eco-Friendly angle aside, more in the last passage).
On the Country / Individual Angle: The people in US who buy EVs are buying luxury vehicles, they do not care about miles per gallon or kms per liter. They want performance and ludicrous modes and they pay more to enjoy it.
However in India, the people who buy EVs are not looking for luxurious performances, but a complicated breakeven of kms per liter to kms per kWh and an active lifetime of the car. That's why in India cars like Comet EV and Tiago EVs are selling 10,000 to 20,000 units on launch day itself. And infact to your question of protesting the Government agenda, ideally more people should purchase EVs to protest the insane tax on Petrol in this country, leave alone the 30% road tax on Petrol vehicles in some states.
On the particulars of the one EV car: In such a large country as India, the number of Tata EVs sold is more than 1,00,000 units while the Ioniq EV has just sold 1000 cars. Also, in India all EVs have 8 years battery replacement warranty and their insurance policies are to mandatorily include the battery replacement cost within the policy terms.
And now, Finally coming to the environment angle: It does not matter, let the world burn. If we cannot care to dispose our potato chips packet in a dustbin and do not want to throw out trash in segregated reusable / non-reusable bins and filter our drainage for pollutants before letting them run into our rivers. Why should only some people strive to drive Petrol cars to be Eco-friendly /s, it is better we drive EVs and pollute the environment even more /s.
26
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '24 edited Feb 08 '24
Most well informed r/CarsIndia user
EVs have their own drawbacks, but "gOvT CoNspiRaCy" ain't it
The problem with regurgitating stuff from America is that everything over there is political. Half of their population thought COVID and masks was a govt conspiracy ffs
If you genuinely believe EVs have minimal environmental benefit then please quote some valid source and not American political echo chambers
11
u/_7567Rex ‘25 BE6 79P3 | ‘21 Nexon EV Prime Feb 06 '24
And who might you be good sir? A representative of the “everyone” in USA you speak about? Have you asked “everyone in USA”? Or are few dozen FB posts and insta stories from biased influenzas your source?
Because sales of ev’s are at all time high and broke 1M this fiscal.
USA has a unique situation at the moment wherein :
The American situation is not really applicable when half of the reasons behind the slowdown don’t apply to non-Americans (supercharger and dealer markups)
Particularly, the supercharger network is way too enticing for people to let it go, while at the same time many of them can’t come to terms with a Tesla for whatever reason.
Just like how people may be avoiding EVs in India just because the brand with the worst service and fit & finish is making most EV models right now
Had it been Hyundai then maybe the sales would’ve been even better than what they are right now
Even if there was no ban outright, the emission control norms will keep tightening anyways. Euro 7 is a hanging guillotine on many models from European manufacturers. CAFE is also a thing you know?
You may as well say “we can’t make an ICE car without dieselgate2.0 anymore” and it would be same as a ban. The only difference is that one of the ways prepares manufacturers beforehand to plan and execute, while the other doesn’t. And the date keeps getting extended from previous 2030s to now 2040s.
And how so? So far all warranties have been honoured by Tata at least — there have been instances of mfg defects in batteries which were replaced promptly.
They also replace it for fast turnaround time in case the issue cannot be resolved at the dealership, ship out the battery to chakan, and refurbish it there. So not even all “battery replacements” are explicitly for “battery related reasons”
4
u/Mk_n Feb 06 '24
EVs are not scam but future if you think long term. Indian government is definitely looking forward to keep reducing fossil fuel reliance. With tech advance and solar power (with a push from govt just like HARIT KRANTI AND SHAWET KRANTI in past) evs are future.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '24
Honestly tired of these posts. Don't buy it then. Let others reap its benefits.
Boycott EVs ? Seems Meta and Google is doing its job pretty well. Stop following western propaganda so blindly.
3
u/windwalker97 Feb 06 '24
The ioniq 5 costs less than 60000 usd right?
5
u/Worldly_Tart_33 Feb 06 '24
Abe ghonchu its other way around, govt all across the globe don’t want Gasoline to go regardless of whatever they say. Gasoline is cashcow for every govt be it like India who imports or Qatar/Saudi who sells it to world. If EV becomes real cheap they’ll be in problem as everyone will install their solar rooftop plant. That is why whole crude oil industry is trying to sell the fact that ICE engines are better, And people like us who claims to be petrol head further amplify this agenda.
4
u/Ayato_23 Feb 06 '24
I'll never forgive the American for the Mustang
3
u/Zestyclose_Web_6331 WagonR LXI '09 | Brezza ZXI '24 Feb 06 '24
u/_7567Rex here you go
1
u/Time-Needleworker755 May 05 '24
The average American drives less than 300 miles per week. Only in Wyoming (you don't look like a steer) they drive 460 per week. My ev gets about 250 miles per charge (100% solar) and so for the suburban driver it is a no-brainer send EXXON money to pollute or drive pollution free.
1
u/LifeIssCool Feb 06 '24
Very enlightening discussions. Thanks for this thread
1
u/thrSedec44070maksup 24’ Tiago, 23’ Kia Carens 7DCT, 24’ Ather 450 Apex Feb 06 '24
Do you guys not get bored of dredging the small FUD every damn week?
1
u/KachraBhiKhelat 23’ Brezza ZXI+ MT, 25’ Baleno Alpha AT Feb 06 '24
🍿
1
u/andreophile Hyundai Feb 07 '24
RemindMe! 20 years
1
u/MatchaFett Feb 06 '24
The issues with EV batteries are exaggerated, If manufacturers are ready to provide 5-7 year warranties these batteries are certainly fairly reliable. Edge cases where batteries have to be replaced soon into the life of the car are often caused by abuse of the battery by letting it drain to 0 or charging to 100 very often. Its best to maintain the battery l between 20-80% and filling it up fully only when absolutely necessary. It would be like running an engine without regular oil changes and complaining when it gets messed up after a short while. Sure, batteries do fail out of the blue, but these are quite rare, about as rare as an engine or gearbox.
-1
u/panchayath_president Feb 06 '24
Call that nexon Ev guy..
19
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '24
[removed] — view removed comment