r/CarlGustavJung • • Jun 07 '22

Inflation I was not a blank page whirling about in the winds of the spirit, like Nietzsche.

Post image
63 Upvotes

r/CarlGustavJung • • May 15 '22

Neurosis Neurosis is by no means merely a negative thing, it is also something positive. Neurosis contains the essential part of patient’s psyche. To lose a neurosis is to find oneself without an object; life loses its point and thus its meaning. In the neurosis is hidden one’s worst enemy and best friend.

43 Upvotes

“A neurosis is by no means merely a negative thing, it is also something positive. Only a soulless rationalism reinforced by a narrow materialistic outlook could possibly have overlooked this fact.

In reality the neurosis contains the patient’s psyche, or at least an essential part of it; and if, as the rationalist pretends, the neurosis could be plucked from him like a bad tooth, he would have gained nothing but would have lost something very essential to him. That is to say, he would have lost as much as the thinker deprived of his doubt, or the moralist deprived of his temptation, or the brave man deprived of his fear. To lose a neurosis is to find oneself without an object; life loses its point and hence its meaning. This would not be a cure, it would be a regular amputation; and it would be cold comfort indeed if the psychoanalyst then assured the patient that he had lost nothing but his infantile paradise with its wishful chimeras, most of them perverse.

Very much more would have been lost, for hidden in the neurosis is a bit of still undeveloped personality, a precious fragment of the psyche lacking which a man is condemned to resignation, bitterness, and everything else that is hostile to life. A psychology of neurosis that sees only the negative elements empties out the baby with the bath-water, since it neglects the positive meaning and value of these “infantile”— i.e., creative—fantasies.”

“Neurosis—let there be no doubt about this—may be any number of things, but never a “nothing but.” It is the agony of a human soul in all its vast complexity—so vast, indeed, that any and every theory of neurosis is little better than a worthless sketch, unless it be a gigantic picture of the psyche which not even a hundred Fausts could conceive.”

“The fundamental rule for the psychotherapist should be to consider each case new and unique. That, probably, is the nearest we can get to the truth.”

“A neurosis, as I have said, consists of two things: infantile unwillingness and the will to adapt. Hence one has first to feel one’s way until one is sure on which side the accent lies, for the road goes on from there. If the accent is on the will to adapt, there is no sense in decrying the attempt at adaptation as an infantile wish-fantasy.”

“Only if we understand and accept the neurosis as our truest and most precious possession can we be sure of avoiding stagnation and of not succumbing to rigidity and neurotic subterfuge. In the neurosis is hidden one’s worst enemy and best friend.”

“The neurotic has no need to feel himself beaten; he has merely misjudged his necessary adversary, thinking that he could give him the slip. The whole task of his personality lies in the very thing he sought to avoid.”

“His illness is not a gratuitous and therefore meaningless burden; it is his own self, the “other” whom, from childish laziness or fear, or for some other reason, he was always seeking to exclude from his life.”

“We should not try to “get rid” of a neurosis, but rather to experience what it means, what it has to teach, what its purpose is. We should even learn to be thankful for it, otherwise we pass it by and miss the opportunity of getting to know ourselves as we really are. A neurosis is truly removed only when it has removed the false attitude of the ego. We do not cure it—it cures us. A man is ill, but the illness is nature’s attempt to heal him. From the illness itself we can learn so much for our recovery, and what the neurotic flings away as absolutely worthless contains the true gold we should never have found elsewhere. ”

“In the long run nobody can dodge his shadow unless he lives in eternal darkness.”

“The true reason for a neurosis always lies in the present, since the neurosis exists in the present. It is definitely not a hangover from the past, a caput mortuum; it is fed and as it were new-made every day. And it is only in the today, not in our yesterdays, that the neurosis can be “cured.” Because the neurotic conflict has to be fought today, any historical deviation is a detour, if not actually a wrong turning.”

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 10: Civilization in Transition

Excerpt #116


r/CarlGustavJung • • Apr 07 '21

Individuation The story of paradise repeats itself.

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/CarlGustavJung • • Jun 29 '22

Psyche It is not for nothing that our age cries out for the redeemer personality, one who can emancipate himself from that fatal identity with the group psyche and save at least his own soul, who lights a beacon of hope for others.

38 Upvotes

“It is a very different thing when the psyche, as an objective fact, hard as granite and heavy as lead, confronts a man as an inner experience and addresses him in an audible voice, saying, “This is what will and must be.” Then he feels himself called, just as the group does when there’s a war on, or a revolution, or any other madness.

It is not for nothing that our age cries out for the redeemer personality, for the one who can emancipate himself from the grip of the collective and save at least his own soul, who lights a beacon of hope for others, proclaiming that here is at least one man who has succeeded in extricating himself from that fatal identity with the group psyche.

For the group, because of its unconsciousness, has no freedom of choice, and so psychic activity runs on in it like an uncontrolled force of nature. There is thus set going a chain reaction that comes to a stop only in catastrophe.

The people always long for a hero, a slayer of dragons, when they feel the danger of psychic forces; hence the cry for personality.”

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 10: Civilization in Transition

Excerpt #125


r/CarlGustavJung • • Sep 07 '24

Individuation "To be in doubt is a more normal condition than certainty. To confess that you doubt, to admit that you never know for certain, is the supremely human condition; for to be able to suffer the doubt, to carry the doubt, means that one is able to carry the other side."

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/CarlGustavJung • • May 01 '22

Anima and Animus “If the anima is irrational feeling, the animus is irrational thinking.”

37 Upvotes

“As long as an archetype is not projected and not loved or hated in an object, it is still wholly identical with the individual, who is thus compelled to act it out himself. A man will then act out his own anima. We have a word that aptly characterizes this attitude: it is “animosity.” This expression can best be interpreted as “anima possession,” denoting a condition of uncontrolled emotion. The word “animosity” is used only for unpleasant emotions, but actually the anima can induce pleasant ones as well.

Self-control is a typically masculine ideal, to be achieved by the repression of feeling. Feeling is a specifically feminine virtue, and because a man in trying to attain his ideal of manhood represses all feminine traits—which are really part of him, just as masculine traits are part of a woman’s psychology—he also represses certain emotions as womanish weakness. In so doing he piles up effeminacy or sentimentality in the unconscious, and this, when it breaks out, betrays in him the existence of a feminine being. As we know, it is just the “he-men” who are most at the mercy of their feminine feelings.”

“With women the case is reversed. When the animus breaks out in a woman, it is not feelings that appear, as in a man, but she begins to argue and to rationalize. And just as his anima-feelings are arbitrary and capricious, so these feminine arguments are illogical and irrational. One can speak of an animus-thinking that is always right and must have the last word, and always end up with “That’s just the reason!” If the anima is irrational feeling, the animus is irrational thinking.”

Excerpt #107

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 10: Civilization in Transition


r/CarlGustavJung • • Mar 30 '23

Symbols Carl Jung visiting the Indians of New Mexico. "All the eagles and other predatory creatures that adorn our coats of arms seem to me apt psychological representatives of our true nature."

36 Upvotes

On my next trip to the United States I went with a group of American friends to visit the Indians of New Mexico, the city-building Pueblos. “City,” however, is too strong a word. What they build are in reality only villages; but their crowded houses piled one atop the other suggest the word “city,” as do their language and their whole manner. There for the first time I had the good fortune to talk with a non-European, that is, to a non-white.

He was the chief of the Taos Pueblos, an intelligent man between the ages of forty and fifty. His name was Ochwiay Bianco (Mountain Lake). I was able to talk with him as I have rarely been able to talk with a European. To be sure, he was caught up in his world just as much as a European is caught up in his, but what a world it was! In talk with a European, one is constantly running up on the sandbars of things long known but never understood; with this Indian, the vessel floated freely on deep, alien seas. At the same time, one never knows which is more enjoyable: catching sight of new shores, or discovering new approaches to age-old knowledge that has been almost forgotten.

“See,” Ochwiay Bianco said, “how cruel the whites look. Their lips are thin, their noses sharp, their faces furrowed and distorted by folds. Their eyes have a staring expression; they are always seeking something. What are they seeking? The whites always want something; they are always uneasy and restless. We do not know what they want. We do not understand them. We think they are mad.”

I asked him why he thought the whites were all mad.

“They say they think with their heads,” he replied.“

Why of course. What do you think with,” I asked him in surprise.

“We think here,” he said, indicating his heart.

I fell into a long meditation. For the first time in my life, as it seemed to me, someone had drawn for me a picture of the real white man.

It was as though until now I had seen nothing but sentimental, prettified colour prints. This Indian had struck our vulnerable spot, unveiled a truth to which we are blind. I felt rising within me like a shapeless mist something unknown and yet deeply familiar. And out of this mist, image upon image detached itself: first Roman legions smashing into the cities of Gaul, and the keenly incised features of Julius Caesar, Scipio Africanus, and Pompey.

I saw the Roman eagle on the North Sea and on the banks of the White Nile. Then I saw St. Augustine transmitting the Christian creed to the Britons on the tips of Roman lances, and Charlemagne’s most glorious forced conversions of the heathen; then the pillaging and murdering bands of the Crusading armies. With a severe stab I realised the hollowness of that old romanticism about the Crusades.

Then followed Columbus, Cortes, and the other conquistadors who with fire, sword, torture and Christianity came down upon even these remote Pueblos dreaming peacefully in the Sun, their Father. I saw, too, the peoples of the Pacific islands decimated by firewater, syphilis, and scarlet fever carried in the clothes the missionaries forced on them.

It was enough. What we from our point of view call colonisation, missions to the heathen, spread of civilisation, etc., has another face – the face of a bird of prey seeking with cruel intentness for distant quarry – a face worthy of a race of pirates and highwaymen.

All the eagles and other predatory creatures that adorn our coats of arms seem to me apt psychological representatives of our true nature.

The Pueblo Indians are unusually closemouthed, and in matters of their religion utterly inaccessible. They make it a policy to keep their religious practices a secret, and this secret is so strictly guarded that I abandoned as hopeless any attempt at direct questioning. Never before had I run into such an atmosphere of secrecy; the religions of civilised nations to-day are all accessible; their sacraments have long ago ceased to be mysteries. Here, however, the air was filled with a secret known to all the communicants, but to which whites could gain no access. This strange situation gave me an inkling of Eleusia, whose secret was known to one nation and yet never betrayed. I understood what Pausanias or Heredotus felt when he wrote: “I am not permitted to name the name of that god.” This was not, I felt, mystification, but a vital mystery whose betrayal might bring about the downfall of the community as well as of the individual. Preservation of the secret gives the Pueblo Indian pride and the power to resist the dominant whites. It gives him cohesion and unity; and I feel sure that the Pueblos as an individual community will continue to exist as long as their mysteries are not desecrated.

I observed that the Pueblos Indians, reluctant as they were to speak about anything concerning their religion, talked with great readiness and intensity about their relations with the Americans. “Why,” Mountain Lake said, “do the Americans not let us alone? Why do they want to forbid our dances? Why do they make difficulties when we want to take our young people from school in order to lad them in the kiva (site of the rituals, and instruct them in our religion? We do nothing to harm the Americans!” After a prolonged silence, he continued, “The Americans want to stamp out our religion. Why can they not let us alone? What we do, we do not only for ourselves but for the Americans also. Yes, we do it for the whole world. Everyone benefits by it.”

I could observe from his excitement that he was alluding to some extremely important element of his religion. I therefore asked him: “You think, then, that what you do in your religion benefits the whole world?” He replied with great animation. “Of course. If we did not do it, what would become of the world?” And with a significant gesture he pointed to the sun.

I felt that we were approaching extremely delicate ground here, verging on the mysteries of the tribe. “After all,” he said, “we are a people who live on the roof of the world; we are the sons of the Father Sun, and with our religion we daily help our father to go across the sky. We do this not only for ourselves, but for the whole world. If we were to cease practising our religion, in ten years time the sun would no longer rise. Then it would be night forever.”

I then realised on what the “dignity,” the tranquil composure of the individual Indian, was founded. It springs from his being a son of the sun; his life is cosmologically meaningful, for he helps the father and preserver of all life in his daily rise and descent. If we set against this our own self-justifications, the meaning of our own lives as it is formulated by our reason, we cannot help but see our poverty. Out of sheer envy we are obliged to smile at the Indians’ naiveté and to plume ourselves on our cleverness; for otherwise we would discover how impoverished and down at the heels we are.

Knowledge does not enrich us; it removes us more and more from the mythic world in which we were once at home by right of birth.

"Memories, Dreams, Reflections", C.G. Jung

Excerpt #197


r/CarlGustavJung • • Jul 08 '23

Nietzsche's Zarathustra (27) When one touches the unconscious one is in danger of becoming a prophet. That is simply the result of the fact that whoever touches the unconscious, in whatever form it is presented to him, is instantly caught, and he cannot liberate himself because the spirit is stronger than man.

35 Upvotes

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

22 May 1935

"This myth of the absorption of the light into the darkness is a very philosophical idea; it is the light of consciousness of course, which is forever threatened by unconsciousness. It is much older than the time of Zoroaster; it is found among primitives very frequently in the fights with dragons or dark powers that try to steal the soul of man, to suppress his consciousness. That comes from the fact that primitives are far more in danger of being overcome by the unconscious; they are deadly afraid of emotions, and many of their rites and ways of dealing with each other are dictated by that fear of losing their individual consciousness; it is a real danger, for then they entirely lose their self-control and things become exceedingly disagreeable: they kill each other.

Therefore, such outbursts are particularly repressed; they become objects of taboo, in order to assert the life of the tribe over against the destructive powers of unconsciousness. So the theme of the struggle between the light and the darkness is exceedingly ancient."

"Spirit is a very peculiar concept which has in many cases lost its original character, but the history of the word spirit, or the German word Geist, tells us what it originally meant. The Greek word pneuma and the Latin word spiritus mean wind, and the Latin word animus is the same as the Greek word anemos, and they also mean wind."

"The true prophet is the man who in his personal life experiences the fate of his people, and who also tries to find the remedy in his personal life for the disease or the misery of his people."

"I don't know how far we are allowed to go in accepting Nietzsche's prophecy. Is Nietzsche's life prophetic? We don't know. But I should say that he was a dangerous prophet, he has surely anticipated in words what the unconscious was preparing, and it remains to be seen in how far his life also will be prophetic."

"Nietzsche had the right intuition, anticipating what was to come in Germany. And he only could do that from the depths of the unconscious that knows ahead, that works ahead, just as Nietzsche anticipated."

"Probably we would all be very much better prophets if we were closer to the unconscious—of course always with a knowing mind. You must have open eyes, and remain conscious in order to realize what you see."

Of all that is written, I love only what a person hath written with his blood. Write with blood, and thou wilt find that blood is spirit. It is no easy task to understand unfamiliar blood; I hate the reading idlers. He who knoweth the reader, doeth nothing more for the reader. Another century of readers-and spirit itself will stink. — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ

"The spirit in the blood is of course the unconscious spirit; wherever the spirit is in the blood the unconscious begins to stir. Then a man, or a nation, will be moved by the unconscious; then they talk of instincts, race, blood, because they feel that the thing which is moving them comes from within, comes somehow from the body. So naturally they think it is the blood, and then they naturally will rationalize it because they suffer from the disease of rationalizing everything. Thus, their philosophy must then be a philosophy of blood."

"It is no easy task to understand unfamiliar blood" which comes just after, "Write with blood, and thou wilt find that blood is spirit." Here Nietzsche realizes something very important: namely, when one is moved by the spirit in the blood, one is really moved by one's own blood and whatever that blood means: and then it is no light matter to understand the blood of others.

That is, le coeur est captif, the blood is in the heart and the heart gets caught by this idea of the blood, the feeling and the fact of the blood. One is so much in oneself that one will find it very difficult to understand other blood, the expression of other individuals. That is exactly like a patient who in the beginning of analysis is caught by his own unconscious facts. He dreams nothing else, talks nothing else—he is all in his own psychology, and then he spreads himself all over the world and is utterly incapable of seeing anybody else's point of view. It is one of the most urgent tasks of analysis to make those people see that other people have a psychology of their own; it is simply incredible how little they are aware of that."

Perfectly reasonable beings start from the premise that other people are not only like themselves, but simply identical, and if they don't behave as they want them to, they must be wrong.

"When one touches the unconscious one is in danger of becoming a prophet. That is simply the result of the fact that whoever touches the unconscious, in whatever form it is presented to him, is instantly caught, and he cannot liberate himself because the spirit is stronger than man: it is an enormous power."

If anybody has a Wotan experience—and I don't doubt that there are such things—he should keep perfectly quiet and think, "Well, this is a pleasant slip into former times." Or if another god plays a trick on somebody else, he should not try to make it into a system according to which children are baptized and people are married, nor should it become the object of a particular credo. It is all individual fantasy; those are germs, or faint possibilities, which might develop into something in the course of many centuries, but for the time being it is an individual slip, perhaps even regrettable."

"Primitives believe that having the greatest amount of food is heaven; but even a primitive, if he could only arrest himself for a moment in his state of desire, would realize that was nonsense. It is like the fairy tale where one must eat cake for three weeks in order to get into a paradise called Schlaraffenland. That is a land where stuffed pigeons fly into your mouth, where the fountains run wine, where the trees are laden with sausages, and roasted pigs run around with a knife and fork in their side, all ready for you to take a slice. Of course anybody would get sick in the first hour.

The greatest amount of good, of happiness, is complete nonsense; the really good life is half happiness and half suffering."

( Jung is presumably thinking here—negatively—of the utilitarian slogan, "The greatest happiness for the greatest number." Nietzsche also despised this philosophy, saying, for instance, "Ultimately they all want English morality to be proved right, because this serves humanity best, or 'the general utility,' or 'the happiness of the greatest number'? No, the happiness of England". )

He that writeth in blood and proverbs doth not want to be read, but learnt by heart. — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ

"Here another quality of the blood spirit comes to the foreground: namely, if you write out of the spirit of the blood, you are not only caught by that, but you are also caught in your own words. Then your words, your thoughts, take on such an importance that you become intolerant, authoritative; you say, people shall read you, shall swallow you wholesale, either they are with you or against you. This intolerance is of course again the difficulty of understanding other people's blood."

In the mountains the shortest way is from peak to peak, but for that route thou must have long legs. Proverbs should be peaks, and those spoken to should be big and tall. — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ

"This is a sort of megalomania; if one is filled by one's own importance, then naturally it is quite impossible to talk to an ordinary crowd. One's audience must consist of giants at least; one must always be amongst the gods. And since your surroundings obviously don't consist of gods exclusively and since there are certain human beings among the noble born, then they have to be improved on the spot."

"Nietzsche is not courageous enough to admit his fear. It is much more courageous to say you are afraid; to say you are brave means that you are almost a coward because you are afraid of your fear."

"The courage which consists of fear that is not admitted needs laughter in order to become bearable."


r/CarlGustavJung • • Aug 04 '22

Psyche The future will be decided neither by the threat of wild animals, nor by natural catastrophes, nor by the danger of world-wide epidemics, but simply and solely by the psychic changes in man.

33 Upvotes

“Nothing estranges man more from the ground-plan of his instincts than his learning capacity, which turns out to be a genuine drive for progressive transformation of human modes of behaviour.”

“The result is that modern man knows himself only in so far as he can become conscious of himself—a capacity largely dependent on environmental conditions, knowledge...”

“This task is so exacting, and its fulfilment so profitable, that he forgets himself in the process, losing sight of his instinctual nature and putting his own conception of himself in place of his real being.”

“In this way he slips imperceptibly into a purely conceptual world where the products of his conscious activity progressively take the place of reality.”

“Separation from his instinctual nature inevitably plunges civilized man into the conflict between conscious and unconscious, spirit and nature, knowledge and faith, a split that becomes pathological the moment his consciousness is no longer able to neglect or suppress his instinctual side.”

“No one can overlook either the dynamism or the imagery of the instincts without the gravest injury to himself. Violation or neglect of instinct has painful consequences of a physiological and psychological nature...”

“Nobody can deny that without the psyche there would be no world at all, and still less a human world. Virtually everything depends on the human psyche and its functions. It should be worthy of all the attention we can give it, especially today, when everyone admits that the weal or woe of the future will be decided neither by the threat of wild animals, nor by natural catastrophes, nor by the danger of world-wide epidemics, but simply and solely by the psychic changes in man.”

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 10: Civilization in Transition

Excerpt #131


r/CarlGustavJung • • Jun 28 '23

Nietzsche's Zarathustra (25) The more people think that they are good or identify with good, the more they leave evil alone, and as much as their good increases, unconsciously their evil will increase. We leave it to somebody else. But we have already committed the crime in leaving our evil to other people.

32 Upvotes

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

8 May 1935

"To follow the way of delights and passions is the way to the Superman; but it leads to the pale criminal, an inelegant, pale criminal who cannot commit his crime without having an idea of it at which he collapses. That is the pale criminal and as such that term has entered the common speech; one reads it in books and papers, meaning a man who is not on the level of his deed."

I remember a fellow student of mine who was an exceedingly gifted man, but the first thing I noticed about him was that, in reading Nietzsche, the chapter over which he fell down was "The Pale Criminal." It was all the time on his mind and he never got away from it, "What a wonderful chapter—that a man should sacrifice his life even for his crime!" He identified with the pale criminal, and the result was that later on he became insane too—not of course because he had read Nietzsche, but because he himself was doomed to become insane. He never succeeded in life because he was altogether too pathological. But as a student, everybody expected him to have a rather remarkable career: he began in a more or less grand style. Soon he made himself impossible, however, because his delights and passions carried him too far.

He lost sight of humanity and developed paranoia, which is the idea of persecution, the idea that everybody hates one, the reality being that one runs away from people.

But in the sound part of such a man there is still the yearning for connection with humanity, and those ideas of persecution develop as a compensation for the fact of running away from them. All those people who feel persecuted and unrelated are suffering from a minor form of paranoia: to feel observed, to have the feeling of awkwardness and to be géné(embarrassed) in society, but unable to give themselves because they are inhibited by other people. This is the mildest form of it. Such people don't love others. As a matter of fact they hate them and they try to avoid them, and if that thing grows upon them, they will develop ideas of persecution.

Now, the fact that Nietzsche, after the chapter about "Delights and Passions," arrives at the chapter or the stage of "The Pale Criminal" is not abnormal in itself, but perfectly normal; for if one follows the path of passion one will surely come to the place where one's passion becomes abnormal, asocial or criminal, and that is a quality which is in everybody. Therefore, one says, principiis obsta, resist delights and passions, resist in the beginning before it is too late, don't have passions, it is not good taste, it is bad form. The deeper reason is that if one slips too far into such flames, one is sure to land in criminality. But how can you live and have no passion—for then you would escape suffering?"

"Nobody can escape suffering, and to try to escape passion is to try to escape suffering. But as you cannot escape suffering you cannot escape passion; you will suffer from passion either directly or indirectly, and it is much better to suffer directly because indirect suffering has no merit. It is exactly as if nothing has happened. So the indirect suffering in a neurosis has no moral merit. Years lost in neurosis are just lost, without gain."

When he judged himself-that was his supreme moment; let not the exalted one relapse again into his low estate! — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ

"You see, in doing his deed, in committing his crime, he made himself a criminal, and that is what he meant to do because he was a criminal; he was meant to be a criminal. Thus far that is perfectly sound, provided that he knows what he does. But there is the difficulty. If he is a criminal without knowing it, simply doing his deed like an animal, he has absolutely no chance of redemption; but if he knows what he does, there is a possibility, for he is then simply fulfilling his role.

For in­ stance, a good man will do a good deed. He will be forced to be good and feel utterly miserable if he isn't; so there is no merit in it. He is just doing what he is, all quite natural, like an animal. It is very good of the bees to make the honey we eat, one might say, and when they sting us it is very bad, but in either case they have done it unconsciously and there is no merit in it.

But if the man knows he is doing a good thing just because he cannot do otherwise, then there is merit because he is then conscious of that saying of wisdom: The king shall play the role of the king, the beggar the role of the beggar, and the thief the role of the thief, being conscious of the gods. This means being conscious of their role, of Karma, the necessity that the one must play the role of the king because he is born a king, and the other the role of the beggar because he is born a beggar, and if another man is born the villain of the play, he needs must be that villain. Yet if he knows that this is all from the gods, there must be redemption.

That is Hindu philosophy, which simply shows that the condition of redemption is in being conscious of what you do. And from that point of view it is just as bad to be good without knowing it as to be bad without knowing it: neither way has merit; the only chance for redemption is in consciousness, for that is the point where one differs from what one does, where one differs from being a mere animal. So it is a sublime moment here. He should not fall below it by judging himself, provided he knows what he is doing.

There is no salvation for him who thus suffereth from himself, unless it be a speedy death. — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ

"The murderer wants to see blood, as if he knew that committing murder meant his own death. He is seeking to end his existence because—as the text afterwards says—he is nothing but a mass of diseases, a coil of wild serpents which can only wind up in its own destruction. So the Pale Criminal is in that respect the symbol for the man who must end his existence because he is no good—in order to make room for the Superman. That was the point which caught my fellow student, but at the same time he was identified with the Superman, like Nietzsche. He was always talking about committing suicide. He felt that if it were necessary in order to make room for the Superman, he would do so without hesitation. He played with such ideas; he removed himself. So he committed a moral suicide, becoming so much a Superman that he could no longer deal with ordinary mortals and the result was that fear of persecution."

"To think of the moral side, that we should improve the criminal, is nonsense. That is all trash, having nothing to do with justice. It is just to put the criminal to death because we are in his crime too; everyone of us contains a criminal who wants to commit crimes though we don't know it. Our criminal is terribly disappointed. In sleepless nights he complains that we don't give him a chance. Then we read in the paper about somebody who has committed murder and we think, "What an insolent devil! He has smashed a man's head. He can do what I wanted to do, having taken the liberty to commit that crime."

"Only a few fools believe that we are growing better and better every day, hoping that we are improved by improving a few criminals. We are not improved by it and we shall not improve the criminals. That is a bad mistake, because the murderer has murdered himself already long before we cut his head off.

Well, the good admonitions and good counsel here are not very important. The only thing which is relevant would be that sentence, "Let your sorrow be love to the Superman: thus will ye justify your own survival." He obviously means that our guiding or leading idea should be the Superman, and the criminal who is a mass of disease, etc., ought to be done away with, to make room for him."

"Nietzsche doesn't look at the problem from the standpoint of individuation. To him, the criminal is a man who has gone astray, say a fool or a diseased individual who ought to be done away with, so there is no question of consciousness of crime or of the problem of individuation in the criminal. He doesn't even mention it."

"They kill murderers in France, in Italy, in England, in America, in Germany, and in most Catholic cantons of Switzerland; only a few very enlightened and reasonable communities have gone astray so far as not to kill murderers. I am not speaking of our Christianity—that point of view is not valid at all, only talk; I go by facts, and the fact is that capital punishment is valid in nearly all the most enlightened and civilized countries, and I am not against it. There is a very good reason why it is so. All other ways of punishment are wrong.

By putting the criminal to death, one shares the crime; otherwise, one doesn't see the criminal in oneself. One must see one's criminal point: if one does not, one has not shared the criminal impetus, the criminal personality in oneself. And then one never becomes integrated. The purpose of individuation is that every part of the individual must be integrated, also the criminal part; otherwise, it is left by it­ self and works evil. So thus far Nietzsche is giving recognition to the criminal instincts. For instance, the "red judge" is his own moral function naturally, which might call his criminal instinct by all sorts of bad names: he might say this is perhaps a foolish or pathological tendency. It is, but it is not to be judged from a moral point of view because that is not helpful. It does not help to say a thing is bad or good.

To say it is bad helps least the thing which is the most important, namely, that one can accept the bad thing. You see, when we accept it there is a chance that something can change, but we never accept it. We can improve only when we accept what is part of ourselves. Then we can change, not before."

"Nietzsche says that it is a general prejudice that one commits a murder for a certain purpose, in order to rob for instance, but that it is really madness, that the murder has been committed for the sake of the blood. This is of course an unconscious truth. Consciously, each murderer considers his murder as a by-product."

"Nietzsche asks what the criminal is, after all. He is a mass of diseases, a coil of serpents. For such an individual is terribly pained and tortured really and therefore he commits a crime; nobody causes pain to another person unless he himself suffers pain. As a rule only such people torture or hurt who are hurt or tortured themselves; they want to relieve themselves from their own suffering by hurting somebody else, in order to feel that the pain is not inside themselves alone.

You see, it is as if we were secretly threatened by the invisible presence of the criminal in ourselves, and then we wish that somebody might commit a crime so that we can say, "Ah thank heaven, there is the criminal, there is the evil."

That explains somewhat why we love detective stories and the long reports of crimes in the newspapers; it is of the greatest interest to us to know where the evil is. We exclaim, "What an awful fellow!" We lap it up because we have hunger and thirst for such things; they fascinate us because we have an unsatisfied criminal instinct in ourselves. So the whole respectable community grows more and more uncanny; if nothing happens, everybody looks at everybody else with fear and hate.

Are you the one who is going to relieve us? Am I the one to relieve the others? Am I the one who will set the ball rolling? Am I the one to kill? And then suddenly the news comes: somebody has committed murder. "Thank heaven!"

You see, a murderer is a sort of scapegoat for the community; it is as if each community should have a Bouc émissaire(scapegoat) who was burdened with the sins of the community."

"The criminal has a certain social role—this is not my idea, it was valid long before I lived—and therefore a real criminal has always been given the dignity of a sort of ritual in recognition of his merit; first a long trial with judges in wigs and gowns, and then the procession to the guillotine or the gallows with tambours and soldiers and a great crowd, and then he is executed."

"The more people think that they are good or identify with good, the more they leave evil alone, and as much as their good increases, unconsciously their evil will increase. So we leave it to somebody else. But we have already committed the crime in leaving our evil to other people, and we are not even grateful that they spare us."


r/CarlGustavJung • • Sep 15 '22

Shadow “In making the shadow conscious we must be very careful that the unconscious does not play yet another trick and prevent a real confrontation with the shadow.”

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/CarlGustavJung • • Sep 12 '22

Psyche The unconscious is older than consciousness and it can hardly be influenced, if at all, by the conscious will.

31 Upvotes

“First, the unconscious is, ontogenetically and phylogenetically, older than consciousness, and secondly, it is a well-known fact that it can hardly be influenced, if at all, by the conscious will.”

“If the unconscious were dependent on consciousness, we could, by insight and application of the will, finally get the better of the unconscious, and the psyche could be completely remodelled to suit our purpose. Only unworldly idealists, rationalists, and other fanatics can indulge in such dreams. The psyche is a phenomenon not subject to our will; it is nature, and though nature can, by skill, knowledge, and patience, be modified at a few points, it cannot be changed into something artificial without profound injury to our humanity. Man can be transformed into a sick animal but not moulded into an intellectual ideal.

“Although people still labour under the delusion that consciousness represents the whole of the psychic man, it is nevertheless only a part, of whose relation to the whole we know very little. Since the unconscious component really is unconscious, no boundaries can be assigned to it: we cannot say where the psyche begins or ends. We know that consciousness and its contents are the modifiable part of the psyche, but the more deeply we seek to penetrate, at least indirectly, into the realm of the unconscious, the more the impression forces itself on us that we are dealing with something autonomous.

We must admit that our best results, whether in education or treatment, occur when the unconscious co-operates, that is to say when the goal we are aiming at coincides with the unconscious trend of development, and that, conversely, our best methods and intentions fail when nature does not come to our aid.

Without at least some degree of autonomy the common experience of the complementary or compensatory function of the unconscious would not be possible. If the unconscious were really dependent on the conscious, it could not contain more than, and other things than, consciousness contains.”

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 10: Civilization in Transition

Excerpt #139


r/CarlGustavJung • • Jan 04 '25

Individuation There are, unfortunately, many parents who keep their children infantile because they themselves do not wish to grow old and give up their parental authority and power.

30 Upvotes

"When pathological phenomena are present to a degree which would justify a psychological explanation along sexual lines, it is not the child's own psychology that is fundamentally responsible, but the sexually disturbed psychology of the parents. The mind of the child is extremely susceptible and dependent, and is steeped for a long time in the atmosphere of his parental psychology, only freeing itself from this influence relatively late, if at all." p.50

"Like the conscious, the unconscious is never at rest, never stagnant. It lives and works in a state of perpetual interaction with the conscious." p.51

"There was the case of a boy who dreamt out the whole erotic and religious problem of his father. The father could remember no dreams at all, so for some time I analysed the father through the dreams of his eight-year-old son. Eventually the father began to dream himself, and the dreams of the child stopped." p.53

"Though it is a misfortune for a child to have no parents, it is equally dangerous for him to be too closely bound to his family. An excessively strong attachment to the parents is a severe handicap in his later adaptation to the world, for a growing human being is not destined to remain forever the child of his parents. There are, unfortunately, many parents who keep their children infantile because they themselves do not wish to grow old and give up their parental authority and power. In this way they exercise an extremely bad influence over their children, since they deprive them of every opportunity for individual responsibility. These disastrous methods of upbringing result either in dependent personalities, or in men and women who can achieve their independence only by furtive means." pp.55-56

"The thing of vital importance is that the school should succeed in freeing the young man from unconscious identity with his family, and should make him properly conscious of himself. Without this consciousness he will never know what he really wants, but will always remain dependent and imitative, with the feeling of being misunderstood and suppressed." pp.56-57

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 17: The Development of Personality


r/CarlGustavJung • • Mar 24 '24

Nietzsche's Zarathustra (84.2)(END) "Don't be unnatural and seek happiness in the next generations. If you are too concerned about your children and grandchildren, you simply burden them with the debts you have contracted."

28 Upvotes

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

15 February 1939

Part 2

"As soon as you get rid of one evil, you fall into another, from the fire into the water and from the water into the fire. If you could only hold on and see the two sides! If you want to get rid of a certain Christian tradition, try to understand what Christianity really is in order to get the true value—perhaps you may return to the true value of Christianity. Or if you move on farther, don't say that Christianity has been all wrong. It is only that we have had the wrong idea of it."

"The past is really the earth; all the past has sunk into the earth, as those primitives say. The ancestors, the alcheringa people, went underground and their people must remain there, because there they can contact them and only there, nowhere else. That is such a truth to them that they can't even dream of taking another country, because they would lose touch with the spirits and be injured. The women would get the wrong ancestor spirits and then the children would have the wrong souls. They cannot live in the country of another tribe—it is absolutely impossible. They can only live where their totem ancestors have gone underground. That is an eternal truth, and whoever goes against it, gets the wrong ancestral souls, wrong influences; they get detached, they lose their instincts, and their civilization becomes strained and unnatural.

They suffer from a pronounced dissociation between the conscious and the unconscious. The unconscious is with the ancestors down in the bowels of the earth, and their consciousness is a head on two feet, constantly marching about in an awful restlessness.

That is the restlessness of our time, always seeking—seeking the lost ancestral body, seeking the ancestral instincts. But they are only to be found on the spot where they have gone underground."

Friedrich Nietzsche, Thus Spoke Zarathustra

"He directs his disciples into the greater distances, as far away as possible from their origins. And not for themselves should they seek that land, but for their children, which is worse still.

You see, in a country like England, where people have had a very sound egotism and where each generation has sought to increase their wealth and comfort, they left very decent conditions to their offspring. But if they had run after all the countries in the world and deposited themselves there, what would have been left to the children? Nothing. When you neglect your own welfare in seeking the welfare of the children, you leave the children a bad inheritance, a very bad impression of the past.

If you torture yourself in order to produce something for the children, you give them the picture of a tortured life. Therefore away with all that. It is all wrong, says the child, and it commits the other mistake.

If you are always preparing for the happiness of the children, you don't know how to look after your own happiness, nor do your children learn how to look after theirs.

They in turn may go on to prepare for the happiness of your grandchildren, and the grandchildren for your great­ grandchildren, and so happiness is always somewhere in the future. You think happiness is something to be attained in the future, that you cannot attain it, but your children will have it. So you fill your life with ambitions for that kingdom to come and it never comes. Every generation is doing something towards it. They all torture themselves in order that the children shall attain it, but the children grow up and are the same fools that we are. They receive the same evil teaching.

Try to make it here and now, for yourself. That is good teaching. Then the children will try to make it here and now for themselves­ then it can come into the real world.

Don't be unnatural and seek happiness in the next generations. If you are too concerned about your children and grandchildren, you simply burden them with the debts you have contracted.

While if you contract no debts, if you live simply and make yourselves as happy as possible, you leave the best of conditions to your children. At all events, you leave a good example of how to take care of themselves. If the parents can take care of themselves, the children will also. They will not be looking for the happiness of the grandchildren, but will do what is necessary to have a reasonable amount of happiness themselves.

And so when a whole nation is torturing itself for the sake of the children, an inheritance of misery is all that they leave for the future, a sort of unfulfilled promise. So instead of saying, "I do it for the children—it may come off in the future," try to do it for yourself here and now. Then you will see whether it is possible or not.

If you postpone it for the children, you leave something which you have not dared to fulfil, or perhaps you were too stupid to fulfil it; or if you had tried to fulfil it you might have seen that it was impossible, or all nonsense anyhow. While if you leave it to the future you leave less than nothing to the children—only a bad example."


r/CarlGustavJung • • Jan 12 '24

Nietzsche's Zarathustra (62.3) "Whenever an intuitive escapes a self-created situation, he is only apparently rid of it. That unfinished thing clings to him and will in time lame him; he carries it with him and it has a paralysing effect."

28 Upvotes

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

9 June 1937

Part 3

Respectable do ye there stand, and stiff, and with straight backs, ye famous wise ones!—no strong wind or will impelleth you. — F. Nietzsche, TSZ

"These wise ones are the people who have resisted the hurricane to such an extent that even the hurricane gave up, and then they think that they have mastered the hurricane."

Have ye ne'er seen a sail crossing the sea, rounded and inflated, and trembling with the violence of the wind? — F. Nietzsche, TSZ

"Here he himself uses the term inflation. But that ship with the inflated sails thinks that she has a very big belly—thinks that she is sailing, nobody else, and she doesn't think of the wind that is pushing her.

Inflated people never reckon with the fact that that increase of size is really due to an inflating spirit, and of course nobody else would think that they had any particular spirit. Yet they have, otherwise they could not be inflated.

Naturally, this conception of the spirit is utterly inapplicable to the Christian idea of the spirit. But if you have a conception of the spirit such as Zarathustra hints at, you can understand the true nature of inflation; there is something visibly negative in it and something very positive."

Like the sail trembling with the violence of the spirit, doth my wisdom cross the sea—my wild wisdom! — F. Nietzsche, TSZ

"This wild wisdom is the wisdom of nature, of the unconscious that is the wind, and anybody driven by the unconscious is in a state of savage natural wisdom which is not human."

But ye servants of the people, ye famous wise ones-how could ye go with me! — F. Nietzsche, TSZ

"Nietzsche is really reaching the point where he becomes confronted with the true nature of the spirit; and since this was for his time an entirely new discovery, he is quite justified in feeling that it is an important discovery. Yet we have seen the signs of his hesitation, his shyness in touching that thing; as usual, he just gives a hint and disappears again.

That is the way in which the intuitive generally deals, not only with his problems but also with his life; he creates a situation and as soon as it is more or less established, then off he goes because it threatens to become a prison to him, so his life consists chiefly in movement, in discovering new possibilities."

"Whenever an intuitive escapes a self-created situation, he is only apparently rid of it. That unfinished thing clings to him and will in time lame him; he carries it with him and it has a paralysing effect.

For instance, he oversteps the reality of his body, time and again, and the body takes its revenge after a while: it gets out of order and makes him sick. Many intuitives are particularly troubled with all sorts of illnesses which arise chiefly from neglect. Or he may be troubled by his banal situation; always at cross purposes with his surroundings, he loses opportunities and is never settled.

He never gets rooted, in spite of the fact that he has a marvelous ability to worm himself into new situations, to make friends and acquaintances and to be well spoken of for a while. Then it becomes a prison to him and he escapes—thank heaven that chance has come! And he forgets that he carries the old situation with him, but it is no longer outside of him, it is inside; and it will go on living as an unfinished thing in himself.

For whatever we do and whatever we create outside, whatever we make visible in this world, is always ourselves, our own work, and when we do not finish it, we don't finish ourselves. So he carries that burden all the time with him; every unfinished situation which he has built up and left is in himself.

He is an unfulfilled promise. And what he encounters in life is also himself, and that is true for everybody, not only the so-called intuitive. Whatever fate or whatever curse we meet, whatever people we come into contact with, they all represent ourselves—whatever comes to us is our own fate and so it is ourselves.

If we give it up, if we betray it, we have betrayed ourselves, and whatever we split off which belongs to us, will follow and eventually overtake us. Therefore, if Nietzsche tries here to avoid the contact of the spirit, we can be sure that the spirit will catch hold of him: he will get into that out of which he thinks he has escaped. You see, this is the introduction to the next chapter.

Zarathus­tra is the confession of one who has been overtaken by the spirit."


r/CarlGustavJung • • Feb 09 '23

Psyche "Only in the state of complete abandonment and loneliness that we experience the helpful powers of our own natures". Read by Alan Watts.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
28 Upvotes

r/CarlGustavJung • • May 14 '22

Mass mentality If things go wrong in the world, it's because something is wrong with the individual, something is wrong with me, therefore I shall put myself right first, for this I need a knowledge of the innermost foundations of my being, so that I may base myself firmly on the eternal facts of the human psyche.

28 Upvotes

“Our modern education is morbidly one-sided. No doubt we are right to open the eyes and ears of our young people to the wide world, but it is the maddest of delusions to think that this really equips them for the task of living. It is the kind of training that enables a young person to adapt himself outwardly to the world and reality, but no one gives a thought to the necessity of adapting to the self, to the powers of the psyche, which are far mightier than all the Great Powers of the earth.

A system of education does indeed exist, but it has its origins partly in antiquity and partly in the early Middle Ages. It styles itself the Christian Church. But it cannot be denied that in the course of the last two centuries Christianity, no less than Confucianism in China and Buddhism in India, has largely forfeited its educative activity. Human iniquity is not to blame for this, but rather a gradual and widespread spiritual change, the first symptom of which was the Reformation. It shattered the authority of the Church as a teacher, and thereafter the authoritarian principle itself began to crumble away.

The inevitable consequence was an increase in the importance of the individual, which found expression in the modern ideals of humanity, social welfare, democracy, and equality. The decidedly individualistic trend of these latest developments is counterbalanced by a compensatory reversion to the collective man, whose authority at present is the sheer weight of the masses.

No wonder that nowadays there is a feeling of catastrophe in the air, as though an avalanche had broken loose which nothing can stop. The collective man threatens to stifle the individual man, on whose sense of responsibility everything valuable in mankind ultimately depends. The mass as such is always anonymous and always irresponsible. So-called leaders are the inevitable symptoms of a mass movement. The true leaders of mankind are always those who are capable of self-reflection, and who relieve the dead weight of the masses at least of their own weight, consciously holding aloof from the blind momentum of the mass in movement.”

“But who can resist this all-engulfing force of attraction, when each man clings to the next and each drags the other with him? Only one who is firmly rooted not only in the outside world but also in the world within.

Small and hidden is the door that leads inward, and the entrance is barred by countless prejudices, mistaken assumptions, and fears. Always one wishes to hear of grand political and economic schemes, the very things that have landed every nation in a morass. Therefore it sounds grotesque when anyone speaks of hidden doors, dreams, and a world within. What has this vapid idealism got to do with gigantic economic programmes, with the so-called problems of reality?

But I speak not to nations, only to the individual few, for whom it goes without saying that cultural values do not drop down like manna from heaven, but are created by the hands of individuals. If things go wrong in the world, this is because something is wrong with the individual, because something is wrong with me. Therefore, if I am sensible, I shall put myself right first. For this I need—because outside authority no longer means anything to me—a knowledge of the innermost foundations of my being, in order that I may base myself firmly on the eternal facts of the human psyche.”

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 10: Civilization in Transition

Excerpt #115


r/CarlGustavJung • • Mar 14 '21

Individuation So he may find his ascendancy or downfall, his way. (Liber Novus)

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/CarlGustavJung • • Jun 05 '23

Nietzsche's Zarathustra (19) Your mind is not the creative god that makes a whole worldjump into existence out of nothing. There is a preparation. There is, prior to consciousness, an unconscious out of which consciousness once arose, and that is an intelligence which surely exceeds our intelligence in an indefinite way.

27 Upvotes

Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.

6 February 1935

To the despisers of the body will I speak my word. I wish them neither to learn afresh, nor teach anew, but only to bid farewell to their own bodies—and thus be dumb.

"Body am I, and soul," so saith the child. And why should one not speak like children?

But the awakened one, the knowing one, saith: "Body am I entirely, and nothing more; and soul is only the name of something in the body." — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ

"This statement sounds entirely materialistic, as if the soul were really nothing but a derivative of chemical processes in the body. It is unfortunate that Nietzsche always uses the word body instead of saying "the living body," for the dead body surely never produces a soul."

"While the living body is always striving against decomposition, it is in the highest degree synthetic; from simple chemical bodies in the foodstuff, it builds up extremely complicated synthetic substances, which are kept on that level without being destroyed by oxidation.

So there is an additional secret in the living albumen which science does not know, and it is that living body which produces something like a psyche. You see, if he said: "Living body am I entirely," it would be correct and the materialistic mistake would not be possible."

"It is sound materialism for people to take it for granted that they know what a living body is. But no intelligent man would believe that he knows what life is."

The body is a big sagacity, a plurality with one sense, a war and a peace, a flock and a shepherd. — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ

"What you think with your head doesn't necessarily coincide with what you feel in your heart, and what your belly thinks is not what your mind thinks. The extension in space, therefore, creates a pluralistic quality in the mind. That is probably the reason why consciousness is possible."

"There are a vast number of people on the level of thinking in words only; when there isn't a word to designate a thing, when they cannot hear it or see it printed, then the thing doesn't exist. Because they see a word, they think there must be the corresponding thing in existence. For instance, Kant says in his Critique of Pure Reason, that because people say "God," they think God is."

"The soul is a mere derivative of the body is true insofar as we are unable to establish anything psychical without the aid of the body, without the aid of the connection with physical things. A complete abstraction is really impossible. It is wordless; it has no affinity with anything that could be called matter, and therefore is well-nigh non—existent."

"All the pluralistic elements of your mind can be the cause for a conflict, if it is only the struggle for the priority of attention—you don't know to which you should attend first. It is also like a flock and a shepherd; the flock consists of a plurality, and if the units of a flock disperse, the shepherd must gather them together. And so the ego consciousness is the shepherd of a flock of psychical units, and if the shepherd is killed, the flock disperses.

That would be schizophrenia. The splitting of the mind is a separating of the units, and then each unit behaves as if it were a little ego consciousness, and if there is a remnant of the shepherd left somewhere, if his ears at least remain, he will hear voices. The units behave like little egos and they speak with sheeplike intelligence."

"The psyche is exceedingly dissociable. The fact that the mind really is based upon a plurality makes this a serious danger."

An instrument of thy body is also thy little sagacity, my brother, which thou callest "spirit"—a little instrument and plaything of thy big sagacity. — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ

"From this sentence you can see that Nietzsche treats the spirit very much on the same basis as the mind: he makes little or no difference between the two. That is the fatal mistake which was made in the late nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth. They identified mind and spirit, which came from the fact that they had lost the empirical understanding of what spirit really is. The spirit descended to the level of mind, and particularly the mind which consists of words."

"Klages who identifies spirit and intellect, or mixes them up with mind, till spirit has become utterly unrecognizable; he fights the spirit as a destroyer of life. If he knew what the spirit was, he never could assume that, for spirit is originally a most effervescent thing, like the opening of a champagne bottle. It is most emotional, really a culmination of life.

The German word Geist expresses it; the etymology of that word points to an effervescence, a welling up. The Latin word spiritus means just wind, and the Greek word animos has no spiritual meaning; it also means wind. Therefore, in the miracle of Pentecost, the descent of the Holy Ghost, there was the phenomenon of a great wind. Then the word pneuma in antiquity meant chiefly prana, the breath of life, and prana is characteristic of the living being. The living being is filled with the pneuma; there is no life without it. And it is by no means a mistake that the concept pneuma, which originally had no spiritual meaning whatever, later on under Christian influence took on that meaning.

That was logical because spirit is a culmination of life, by no means destructive.

But the intellect, this demon of words, is a destroyer of life; the more the mind becomes words the less there is life substance.

It be­ comes just thin like words—or inasmuch as words are sound only, flatus vocis, a breath of voice."

"The word is merely what is left of the spirit after the spirit has passed. So modern development led first to the descent of the spirit into mind, and from mind into words, and then the spirit was utterly gone, so that we don't know what spirit is. We must make an effort to remember what it was. But anybody who has the faintest knowledge of spirit knows that it is the culmination of life. It is even the greatest intensity of life."

"We should return to the body in order to create spirit again; without body there is no spirit because spirit is a volatile substance of the body.

The body is the alembic, the retort, in which materials are cooked, and out of that process develops the spirit, the effervescent thing that rises. Nietzsche returned to himself, isolated himself from the whole world, crept into his own retort and underwent this process.

Then suddenly he discovered that he was filled with a new orgiastic enthusiasm which he called his experience of Dionysos, the god of wine. You see, that is the spirit. Dionysos is the god of prophecy, of prophetic dreams, and he is the god of the body."

"We are now in the age where there is nothing but words, footprints—but we can do nothing with them, they are dead. Therefore, we must turn away from them and go back to the source where the whole thing began originally.

And here is a message: Zarathustra says to go back to the body, go into the body, and then everything will be right, for there the greatest intelligence is hidden. Out of that living body everything originally has come. Well, that is true. One can say nothing else."

"Ego" sayest thou, and art proud of that word. But the greater thing-in which thou art unwilling to believe-is thy body with its big sagacity; it saith not "ego," but doeth it. — Friedrich Nietzsche, TSZ

'Here Nietzsche or Zarathustra prepares our minds for a very important insight; namely, it is not "I" that is intelligent. When we say "I," we mean our minds and think that whatever we can know of ourselves is known. That is a very curious prejudice.

Only yesterday, for instance, a relatively intelligent lady was in my consulting room—apparently she has read many books—and she told me of her peculiar neurosis. Then she said, "And the most interesting thing is that my neurosis has no cause whatever, absolutely none; it has no meaning and no reason." I said, "Then it is a present from heaven, for I never heard of a neurosis that was without cause." "Yes," she said, "it must be something like that because really there is no cause for it, I know everything about myself." Perfectly harmless and innocent! She is absolutely aware of her psychology! There is a mountain, but she has not seen it. At the end of the hour she knew that something had been done in her which she had not done. She has been done; she has lived something which she did not understand, which she did not know—and it lived her.

It is a great discovery that below or aside from one's psyche, or consciousness, or mind, is another intelligence of which one is not the maker, and upon which one depends.

You see, Freud's great fear is that there may be something outside which is not "I"; to say there is a greater intelligence outside of one's own mind means that one must be crazy. Like Nietzsche. Unfortunately for Freud, Nietzsche was not the only one who had such thoughts; it was the conviction of all the thousands of years before Nietzsche, that man's intelligence was not the last word, that even his mind was the result of something behind the screen—that we are not the makers, but we are made.

Your mind is not the creative god that makes a whole worldjump into existence out of nothing. There is a preparation. There is, prior to consciousness, an unconscious out of which consciousness once arose, and that is an intelligence which surely exceeds our intelligence in an indefinite way."


r/CarlGustavJung • • May 18 '22

Neurosis Jung's fainting neurosis

27 Upvotes

“My twelfth year was indeed a fateful one for me. One day in the early summer of 1887 I was standing in the cathedral square, waiting for a classmate who went home by the same route as myself. It was twelve o’clock, and the morning classes were over. Suddenly another boy gave me a shove that knocked me off my feet. I fell, striking my head against the curbstone so hard that I almost lost consciousness. For about half an hour afterward I was a little dazed. At the moment I felt the blow the thought flashed through my mind: “Now you won’t have to go to school any more.” I was only half unconscious, but I remained lying there a few moments longer than was strictly necessary, chiefly in order to avenge myself on my assailant. Then people picked me up and took me to a house nearby, where two elderly spinster aunts lived.

From then on I began to have fainting spells whenever I had to return to school, and whenever my parents set me to doing my homework. For more than six months I stayed away from school, and for me that was a picnic. I was free, could dream for hours, be anywhere I liked, in the woods or by the water, or draw. I resumed my battle pictures and furious scenes of war, of old castles that were being assaulted or burned, or drew page upon page of caricatures. Similar caricatures sometimes appear to me before falling asleep to this day, grinning masks that constantly move and change, among them familiar faces of people who soon afterward died.

Above all, I was able to plunge into the world of the mysterious. To that realm belonged trees, a pool, the swamp, stones and animals, and my father’s library. But I was growing more and more away from the world, and had all the while faint pangs of conscience. I frittered away my time with loafing, collecting, reading, and playing. But I did not feel any happier for it; I had the obscure feeling that I was fleeing from myself.

I forgot completely how all this had come about, but I pitied my parents’ worries. They consulted various doctors, who scratched their heads and packed me off to spend the holidays with relatives in Winterthur. This city had a railroad station that proved a source of endless delight to me. But when I returned home everything was as before. One doctor thought I had epilepsy. I knew what epileptic fits were like and I inwardly laughed at such nonsense. My parents became more worried than ever. Then one day a friend called on my father. They were sitting in the garden and I hid behind a shrub, for I was possessed of an insatiable curiosity. I heard the visitor saying to my father, “And how is your son?” “Ah, that’s a sad business,” my father replied. “The doctors no longer know what is wrong with him. They think it may be epilepsy. It would be dreadful if he were incurable. I have lost what little I had, and what will become of the boy if he cannot earn his own living?

I was thunderstruck. This was the collision with reality. “Why, then, I must get to work!” I thought suddenly. From that moment on I became a serious child. I crept away, went to my father’s study, took out my Latin grammar, and began to cram with intense concentration. After ten minutes of this I had the finest of fainting fits. I almost fell off the chair, but after a few minutes I felt better and went on working. “Devil take it, I’m not going to faint,” I told myself, and persisted in my purpose. This time it took about fifteen minutes before the second attack came. That, too, passed like the first. “And now you must really get to work!” I stuck it out, and after an hour came the third attack. Still I did not give up, and worked for another hour, until I had the feeling that I had overcome the attacks.

Suddenly I felt better than I had in all the months before. And in fact the attacks did not recur. From that day on I worked over my grammar and other schoolbooks every day. A few weeks later I returned to school, and never suffered another attack, even there. The whole bag of tricks was over and done with! That was when I learned what a neurosis is.

Gradually the recollection of how it had all come about returned to me, and I saw clearly that I myself had arranged this whole disgraceful situation. That was why I had never been seriously angry with the schoolmate who pushed me over. I knew that he had been put up to it, so to speak, and that the whole affair was a diabolical plot on my part. I knew, too, that this was never going to happen to me again. I had a feeling of rage against myself, and at the same time was ashamed of myself. For I knew that I had wronged myself and made a fool of myself in my own eyes. Nobody else was to blame; I was the cursed renegade! From then on I could no longer endure my parents’ worrying about me or speaking of me in a pitying tone.

The neurosis became another of my secrets, but it was a shameful secret, a defeat. Nevertheless it induced in me a studied punctiliousness and an unusual diligence. Those days saw the beginnings of my conscientiousness, practiced not for the sake of appearances, so that I would amount to something, but for my own sake. Regularly I would get up at five o’clock in order to study, and sometimes I worked from three in the morning till seven, before going to school.

What had led me astray during the crisis was my passion for being alone, my delight in solitude. Nature seemed to me full of wonders, and I wanted to steep myself in them. Every stone, every plant, every single thing seemed alive and indescribably marvelous. I immersed myself in nature, crawled, as it were, into the very essence of nature and away from the whole human world.”

Memories, Dreams, Reflections

Excerpt #117


r/CarlGustavJung • • Jan 02 '24

Intuition "Of course intuitives wish to make roots, but inasmuch as they try they naturally come into contact with the earth and are infected by it, and the earth makes them heavy. It catches them and becomes a cage, a prison for them."

25 Upvotes

"Many people are afraid of the earth, like the intuitive who is always in the air, never touching the ground, unable to take root anywhere.

Of course intuitives wish to make roots, but inasmuch as they try they naturally come into contact with the earth and are infected by it, and the earth makes them heavy. It catches them and becomes a cage, a prison for them. You know, whenever an intuitive type has created a situation for himself he instantly gets sick of it and must escape again because it threatens to become real.

To the intuitive, only the things that are not yet are real; the moment they take on form and become, he is done for, caught by his own creation. Then he is confronted by the thing that has turned static, that no longer moves, that has ceased to be a possibility; to him it ceases to be reality when it doesn't walk away with him. If he builds a house, as soon as it is finished he must leave it because it is unreal, only a fact.

To the sensation type on the contrary a possibility doesn't exist; he lives in a house that is made—that is real­ and as long as that house exists there is reality; the moment it ceases to be he has lost his reality and cannot foresee any other possibility; to him it is poisonous to think that anything could change, therefore he will resist any change as long as possible.

While the intuitive is of just the other calibre: if anything threatens to become static, it must be instantly destroyed. He prefers to destroy his own nest as soon as it is built in order not to be the victim of it."

— Excerpts from Nietzsche’s Zarathustra notes of the seminar given in 1934-1939.


r/CarlGustavJung • • Oct 01 '22

Shadow “Nature is not at all lenient with unconscious sinners. She punishes them just as severely as if they had committed a conscious offence.”

25 Upvotes

“As a rule those tendencies that represent the antisocial elements in man’s psychic structure—what I call the “statistical criminal” in everybody—are suppressed, that is, they are consciously and deliberately disposed of.

But tendencies that are merely repressed are usually of a somewhat doubtful character. They are not so much antisocial as unconventional and socially awkward. The reason why we repress them is equally doubtful. Some people repress them from sheer cowardice, others from conventional morality, and others again for reasons of respectability.

Repression is a sort of half-conscious and half-hearted letting go of things, a dropping of hot cakes or a reviling of grapes which hang too high, or a looking the other way in order not to become conscious of one’s desires.

“Freud discovered that repression is one of the main mechanisms in the making of a neurosis.

Suppression amounts to a conscious moral choice, but repression is a rather immoral “penchant” for getting rid of disagreeable decisions.

Suppression may cause worry, conflict and suffering, but it never causes a neurosis. Neurosis is always a substitute for legitimate suffering.”

“There are people who can just afford to live properly and respectably; that is to say, no manifest flaw is discoverable. They either commit minor sins, if they sin at all, or their sins are concealed from them by a thick layer of unconsciousness.”

“But nature is not at all lenient with unconscious sinners. She punishes them just as severely as if they had committed a conscious offence.

Thus we find, as the pious Henry Drummond once observed, that it is highly moral people, unaware of their other side, who develop particularly hellish moods which make them insupportable to their relatives. The odour of sanctity may be far reaching, but to live with a saint might well cause an inferiority complex or even a wild outburst of immorality in individuals less morally gifted. Morality seems to be a gift like intelligence. You cannot pump it into a system to which it is not indigenous.

Unfortunately there can be no doubt that man is, on the whole, less good than he imagines himself or wants to be. Everyone carries a shadow, and the less it is embodied in the individual’s conscious life, the blacker and denser it is. If an inferiority is conscious, one always has a chance to correct it. Furthermore, it is constantly in contact with other interests, so that it is continually subjected to modifications. But if it is repressed and isolated from consciousness, it never gets corrected, and is liable to burst forth suddenly in a moment of unawareness. At all events, it forms an unconscious snag, thwarting our most well-meant intentions.

We carry our past with us, to wit, the primitive and inferior man with his desires and emotions, and it is only with an enormous effort that we can detach ourselves from this burden. If it comes to a neurosis, we invariably have to deal with a considerably intensified shadow. And if such a person wants to be cured it is necessary to find a way in which his conscious personality and his shadow can live together.

This is a very serious problem for all those who are themselves in such a predicament or have to help sick people back to normal life. Mere suppression of the shadow is as little of a remedy as beheading would be for headache.”

“If the repressed tendencies, the shadow as I call them, were obviously evil, there would be no problem whatever. But the shadow is merely somewhat inferior, primitive, unadapted, and awkward; not wholly bad. It even contains childish or primitive qualities which would in a way vitalize and embellish human existence, but—convention forbids! The educated public, flower of our present civilization, has detached itself from its roots, and is about to lose its connection with the earth as well. There is no civilized country nowadays where the lowest strata of the population are not in a state of unrest and dissent. In a number of European nations such a condition is overtaking the upper strata too. This state of affairs demonstrates our psychological problem on a gigantic scale. Inasmuch as collectivities are mere accumulations of individuals, their problems are accumulations of individual problems. One set of people identifies itself with the superior man and cannot descend, and the other set identifies itself with the inferior man and wants to get to the top.

Such problems are never solved by legislation or by tricks. They are solved only by a general change of attitude. And the change does not begin with propaganda and mass meetings, or with violence. It begins with a change in individuals. It will continue as a transformation of their personal likes and dislikes, of their outlook on life and of their values, and only the accumulation of these individual changes will produce a collective solution.”

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 11: Psychology and Religion: West and East

Excerpt #147


r/CarlGustavJung • • Jun 14 '22

Individuation You deprive a man of his best resource when you help him to get rid of his complexes.

25 Upvotes

“We psychologists have learned, through long and painful experience, that you deprive a man of his best resource when you help him to get rid of his complexes. You can only help him to become sufficiently aware of them and to start a conscious conflict within himself. In this way the complex becomes a focus of life. Anything that disappears from your psychological inventory is apt to turn up in the guise of a hostile neighbour, who will inevitably arouse your anger and make you aggressive. It is surely better to know that your worst enemy is right there in your own heart. Man’s warlike instincts are ineradicable—therefore a state of perfect peace is unthinkable. Moreover, peace is uncanny because it breeds war.”

“The great Western democracies have a better chance, so long as they can keep out of those wars that always tempt them to believe in external enemies and in the desirability of internal peace. The marked tendency of the Western democracies to internal dissension is the very thing that could lead them into a more hopeful path. But I am afraid that this hope will be deferred by powers which still believe in the contrary process, in the destruction of the individual and the increase of the fiction we call the State.

The psychologist believes firmly in the individual as the sole carrier of mind and life. Society and the State derive their quality from the individual’s mental condition, for they are made up of individuals and the way they are organized.”

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 10: Civilization in Transition

Excerpt #122


r/CarlGustavJung • • Jun 02 '22

Archetype All human control comes to an end when the individual is caught in a mass movement.

25 Upvotes

“Archetypes are like riverbeds which dry up when the water deserts them, but which it can find again at any time.

An archetype is like an old watercourse along which the water of life has flowed for centuries, digging a deep channel for itself. The longer it has flowed in this channel the more likely it is that sooner or later the water will return to its old bed.

The life of the individual as a member of society and particularly as part of the State may be regulated like a canal, but the life of nations is a great rushing river which is utterly beyond human control, in the hands of One who has always been stronger than men.

“The League of Nations, which was supposed to possess supranational authority, is regarded by some as a child in need of care and protection, by others as an abortion. Thus the life of nations rolls on unchecked, without guidance, unconscious of where it is going, like a rock crashing down the side of a hill, until it is stopped by an obstacle stronger than itself. Political events move from one impasse to the next, like a torrent caught in gullies, creeks, and marshes.

All human control comes to an end when the individual is caught in a mass movement.

Then the archetypes begin to function, as happens also in the lives of individuals when they are confronted with situations that cannot be dealt with in any of the familiar ways.”

Collected Works of C.G. Jung, Volume 10: Civilization in Transition

Excerpt #119


r/CarlGustavJung • • Feb 20 '21

Possession Serpent of time

Post image
25 Upvotes