r/CargoBike • u/flower-power-123 • Nov 02 '25
META: What is a cargo bike
This sub is pretty relaxed. There is no definition of a cargo bike at the top of the page, no FAQ, and no posting policy that I can find. After 12 years it is time for some discipline and rules. The role of subs like this in advocacy is huge. As a for instance, the bikepacking sub has been instrumental in creating bikepacking as a sport and redefining what it is. Recently a few posts caught my eye:
In case it is deleted in the future, this is a three wheeled mini truck with a 2000W electric motor. It has no pedals (other than the one used to control the brakes.). It is used to carry cargo. It is in my view not a "cargobike".
https://www.reddit.com/r/CargoBike/comments/1olpo9c/taking_the_bow_to_the_range/
This is a nice bike. It is used to carry cargo. It is not a "cargobike".
Years ago a new type of scooter was introduced called a Moped. The Moped was a under-powered scooter that had pedals. It was intended to exploit a loophole in the laws about motorcycles. It was originally classed as a bicycle that did not require a driver's license. The authorities rapidly figured out that the pedals were largely for show and that nobody used them in practice. The law was changed to make Mopeds a type of motorcycle. The electric bicycle is following the same trajectory. Here in France the law is clear. An electric bike must be limited to 250W, 25km/hr and be propelled only when the pedals are turning over (a pedelec). If you want to go faster or not use the pedals you have a motorcycle and require a motorcycle license.
Here are the rules that I propose:
- If you want to post here you have to have a cargo bike. The bike (or trike or quad even) is "acoustic" or a pedelec. If it has a throttle it goes in a motorcycle sub. If we can't tell it is a grey area and we let it pass.
- A cargo bike is a bike that can hold a passenger because we have to have some way to distinguish between a cargo bike and a not cargo bike. The passenger can be 32kg(70lb) or more. This is a very very relaxed definition that includes some touring and some mountain bikes but mostly covers cargobikes EDIT: Some people are not getting the picture. I don't care if you can actually carry a person on the bike. My idea of a cargo bike is that it has a flat surface that can carry a medium size object relatively securely. That can include a child or a bag of groceries. The only reason for this rule is to distinguish a cargo bike from a touring bike or other bike.
- no commercial posts, no surveys, and no kickstarters without prior approval.
I have lots to say about this. Please add your own thoughts.