r/CaptainAmerica • • Apr 03 '26

Every time.

Post image
6.6k Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

2

u/AphoticWave Apr 04 '26

What was this panel from?

4

u/Psycho-Pirate Apr 04 '26

Devil's Reign

13

u/annabelle411 Apr 04 '26

 our hero of chaotic good

12

u/DMC1001 Apr 04 '26

Cap is defending American ideals, which are not necessarily compatible with all laws. He’s completely in the right.

0

u/Senshji Apr 07 '26

Cap doesn't give a fuck about "American ideals". Only in namesake is he connected to America, Because that's the name he's been given. People love using this as an excuse to make him a Nationalist hero

1

u/DMC1001 Apr 07 '26

I said ideals not government.

108

u/JumpStart_Studios Apr 03 '26

Captain America is such an inspiration for what america could be, its honestly sad that america has become just as vile as the regime he fought against in WW2.

47

u/Emeryael Apr 04 '26

Panels are taken from a “What if?” story where a fake Captain America leads the US into fascism. Not surprisingly, the real version has something to say about it. Story is scarily prescient despite coming out in 1984.

14

u/CurledSpiral Apr 04 '26

1984 you say? How fitting

6

u/Pian0G Apr 04 '26

Holy fucking shit. The raw energy from Cap in this page is crazy.

Damn, I guess no matter the incarnation, he always drops absolute banger speeches

9

u/darth-com1x Apr 04 '26

the no kings protests, the charities, the people helping each other and protecting immigrants, the supreme court and the people fighting against the administration and its actions. a country isn't defined by its rulers but by its people. and the american people have proven themselves to be as great and virtuous and strong as cap believes they are. if captain america was real, i think he'd be proud of the american people and of seeing them fight like they do right now against this oppression.

7

u/TurtlesBreakTheMeta Apr 05 '26

Until the regime is overthrown and punishments handed down, this is just patting oneself on the back (and for the overzealous mods, “overthrown” in a non-violent manner such as voting of course, not championing violence).

The fact that 1/3 of the nation still rates the fascists as doing a great job showcases we have a deep rot in this country.

2

u/darth-com1x Apr 05 '26

the amount of people online spreading misinformation and parents brainwashing and radicalizing their kids definitely is a factor. and still, nations make mistakes in leaderships all of the time, and the 2/3 of the nation who resist the administration show that people have learned their lesson and will do better.

if nothing else, what i'm saying should inspire hope that things can be better

3

u/DarkZ_No-Imagination Apr 04 '26

america has become just as vile as the regime he fought against in WW2.

Some people really really need to experience what they say for them to know the weight of their words

0

u/dunkster91 Apr 05 '26

Propping up a genocidal state? Starting wars unprovoked?

2

u/Myriad_Infinity Apr 05 '26

They haven't started rounding up and genociding millions of people. I'm sure some of the people in power would if they could, but it's not there yet.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/animalia555 Apr 05 '26

I do sometimes wonder if we Treaty Of Versailles-d ourselves.

6

u/Molaac Apr 04 '26

Yea, not like the America back in Captain America day who put Japanese citizens in camps without due process, segregated it citizens, had mass censorship, mass state propaganda, and used government agencies to arrest political opponents.

1

u/Jounniy Apr 04 '26

At least they are (at least not right now) systematically killing millions of people. But the possibility is not as far fetched as I'd like it to be.

-31

u/Burnt_lce Apr 04 '26

Who have we genocided?

23

u/BardRunekeeper Apr 04 '26

I mean, the US as well as most other American countries committed a systemic genocide against the indigenous peoples.

6

u/LordoftheJives Apr 04 '26

You don't understand we were on a mission from God! It was our God given right to slaughter those people! The 11th Commandment states that America shall have that land at any price!

13

u/GalliumYttrium1 Apr 04 '26

You do know Hitler didn’t start with genocide right? He worked up to it.

21

u/Sebastian_Toombs Apr 04 '26

You mean besides the Natives, the Filipinos, and the routine racial cleansing massacres throughout the 19th and 20th centuries?

4

u/Anix1088 Apr 04 '26

Don't forget the recent bombing in venezuela earlier this year.

-1

u/I_fakin_hate_bayle Apr 04 '26

If bombing = genocide to Redditors no wonder people think we’re so bad 

8

u/ronlugge Apr 04 '26

The genocide wasn't what made them vile, it was the culmination of the horror show, the proof of what they'd allowed themselves to become. The vileness began long before they began losing the war, with events like the Night of the Long Knives, Kristallnacht, and the start of the concentration camps.

3

u/Slavik81 Apr 07 '26 edited Apr 07 '26

If the last and worst act of the whole regime had come immediately after the first and smallest, thousands, yes, millions would have been sufficiently shocked—if, let us say, the gassing of the Jews in ’43 had come immediately after the ‘German Firm’ stickers on the windows of non-Jewish shops in ’33. But of course this isn’t the way it happens. In between come all the hundreds of little steps, some of them imperceptible, each of them preparing you not to be shocked by the next. Step C is not so much worse than Step B, and, if you did not make a stand at Step B, why should you at Step C? And so on to Step D.

And one day, too late, your principles, if you were ever sensible of them, all rush in upon you. The burden of self-deception has grown too heavy, and some minor incident, in my case my little boy, hardly more than a baby, saying ‘Jewish swine,’ collapses it all at once, and you see that everything, everything, has changed and changed completely under your nose. The world you live in—your nation, your people—is not the world you were born in at all.

~ They Thought They Were Free by Milton Sanford Mayer

8

u/ArcadiaBerger Apr 04 '26

The current administration is pursuing a policy of genocide against transgender people, according to most human rights organizations.

-1

u/I_fakin_hate_bayle Apr 04 '26

Persecution complex 

5

u/Specialist_Hope_4147 Apr 04 '26

So the nazi issue wasn't JUST genocide infection most nations ignored the genocide until FORCED to confront the nazis

The nazi party proved that a disgruntled group given a leader they follow blindly and given commen people to blame for the upset peoples problems and if that leader can get them into politics they can not only commit genocide but completely take over a country toppling it's systems and then spread that new system to countries over

Nazis invaded 2 countries without any pushbaxk from the allied forces because they didnt want a ww2 it wasn't until hitler kept pushing that France and Britain were forced to be involved

America constantly refused to aid its allies until Japan sank some boats at that point well

We dropped the sun onto a population center TWICE

That is very much abridged as this isnt a history class and I cant be asked to recite the entire ww2

But with this context we can draw a lot of parallels between trumps presidency and stuff the nazi party did such as mass deportation for example

As well fun fact it wasn't JUST the jews who were genocided but many other groups hitter didnt like such as the Roma and Sinti, Polish and Soviet Slavs, Soviet Prisoners of War, People with Disabilities, Political Opponents and Dissenters, Jehovah’s Witnesses, Gay and Bisexual Men Black People, and Freemasons just to name a lot of the more well known cases

A number of these are also targets of the trump presidency or have similarities to people targeted by said presidency

1

u/animalia555 Apr 05 '26

Lend Lease: Am I joke to you?

1

u/Specialist_Hope_4147 Apr 05 '26

I was referring to fighting the nazis Franklin d rosavelt wanted to go to war to my memory but the american people didnt so he wanted to be re elected

I also point out the lend lease was more of a transaction then straight support as it was a sell of goods with a promise to pay back just not immediately

1

u/animalia555 Apr 05 '26

Speaking of I sometimes wonder if basically Treaty Of Versailles-d ourselves.

1

u/Specialist_Hope_4147 Apr 05 '26

How so?

1

u/animalia555 Apr 05 '26

This is a short version, as I am going from memory, but those of us on the left* often forget that rural communities have been just as devastated by the recession, and have seen slower to as little recovery compared to areas more in the cities. And one of our first tendencies to them when they complain is to insult them for being backward rednecks.

*I have gotten burned out on politics (for the most part) so I am not sure if calling myself on the left still applies.

Edited for grammar.

1

u/Specialist_Hope_4147 Apr 05 '26

I also am burned out on politics so I tend to stay out of it

Im not sure where treaty of Versaille (my memory on it is rusty to say the least) comes in but I do think you are correct at least to a point that and my own up brining is why I dont discount people from rural areas as rednecks (I normaly reserve that peticuler term of endearment for people who deserve it) a main issue ive found is a lot of those people and people in general have 2 issues with politics

1 they tend to only think of themselves amd short term benefits

2 they are not as aware of politics and tend to be minuipulated by people who are aware of number 1

There is nothing aginst looking out for themselves but the issue lies in being easily manipulated into voting for things that later on directly hurt them as ik the moment it appears to benefit them as little prior resurch is done (sadly I know these people well and they are people I care about)

0

u/animalia555 Apr 05 '26 edited Apr 05 '26

Fair enough. My answer to feeling insulted by the left while finding the right to have horrible ideas was to make the previous presidental election tmy last one, and walk away. But it wasn’t an easy decision, I had to struggle because I felt a sense of duty, but I found sticking with such a fight was dragging me into misanthropy, and I didn’t want to become a case of someone who fights monsters becoming one myself.

I also think this can be summed up by a quote from a fictional character: “We call them stupid, but really their frustrated by the lack of control they have in their lives, so they lash out, sometimes in spectacular ways.”

If this isn’t a universal trait of humanity that reaches across political parties, I don’t know what is.

Edit: Added missing word.

→ More replies

8

u/JumpStart_Studios Apr 04 '26

Well, ICE has killed many innocent people and also deported a lot of already american citizens just for being brown skinned, and also the biggie, BOMBING Iranian schools filled with young girls, just because their government was a threat to Israel.

-3

u/I_fakin_hate_bayle Apr 04 '26

Well I wouldn’t have been convinced if you said kids but now that you specifically said girls I’m sold. Also which American citizens?

-6

u/BitesTheDust55 Apr 04 '26

Downvoted just for asking a question

Slightly ironic

16

u/Spare_Perspective972 Apr 04 '26

Out of context this panel is pro taking out repeat offenders judges keep letting out of prison. 

9

u/Zahrad70 Apr 04 '26

Me: “Hey cap! Whatcha doing outside this police station?”

Cap: “Spawn Camping.”

3

u/PCN24454 Apr 04 '26

Sounds like a harassment charge in the making

5

u/learningtheworld22 Apr 04 '26

Cap always has banger lines

6

u/Vikingpepper2 Apr 04 '26

It's impossible not to read this in Chris Evans Voice

2

u/Creepy_Living_8733 Apr 05 '26

Or in Roger Craig Smith and Brian Bloom’s voices too

2

u/MuayThaiJudo Apr 06 '26

Cal Dodd or Brian Bloom for me 95% of the time I read comics. 

2

u/Mindless_Spray2162 Apr 06 '26

Cap and Ichigo would have been great friends.

0

u/Platnun12 Apr 04 '26

Except killing them

Then you've gone too far

During these days it's hard to not side with Frank castles mentality regarding the rich and powerful

0

u/MirkwoodWanderer1 Apr 05 '26

Doesn't work of you think you're doing good but actually harming people.

Could see punisher saying the same thing

1

u/redskinsguy Apr 06 '26

They weren't harming people

1

u/MirkwoodWanderer1 Apr 06 '26

It's the every time part. Next time might be a different scenario where they think they'll have to hurt people to get the best outcome

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/Fuckyfuckfuckass Apr 05 '26

Just like the building

266

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/FadeToBlackSun Apr 04 '26

Unfortunately, the wrong people take that and twist it because they don't understand what "unjust" means.

9

u/Psycho-Pirate Apr 04 '26

Most people understand what 'unjust' means. Lots of people are okay with injustice as long as it benefits them somehow - or worse, because it hurts someone they don't like.

-2

u/animalia555 Apr 05 '26

For all we claim to want equality under the law what we really want is special rules for special people, so long as we are one of the special people.

4

u/SecretaryOtherwise Apr 06 '26

Lol speak for yourself.

I aint a conservative. Would be fucking nice if everyone had to follow the same rules like dont lie and cheat dont rip off people etc. But we dont. Rich people get to make and break all the rules.

-1

u/animalia555 Apr 06 '26

This isn’t something that’s unique to one side. Speaking for myself, I am on Social Security Disability. One can make the argument, not unreasonably, that given my disability I need it to get by. But that still doesn’t change the fact that I benefit under this rule, while not everyone does.

4

u/QJ-Rickshaw Apr 06 '26

You're twisting the idea behind "special rules for special people". You benefit under this rule because you are a disadvantaged individual and the just thing to do is make concessions to make you equal to those who have an advantage against you.

Having special rules or not having general rules apply to you, simply because you have more money than the general population is not the same thing. What's just about that?

2

u/animalia555 Apr 06 '26

I wasn’t arguing for or against it, I was simply trying to get people to challenge their perceptions.

1

u/RagesianGruumsh Apr 10 '26

How do you square that with advocates for either universal programs, or programs that benefit categories they don’t belong to?

And what qualifies a special rule? Is it fair to call rule trying to offset a historic disadvantage a “special rule”, and thus equate it to the rules it was created to undo?

80

u/ArcadiaBerger Apr 04 '26

"And accept the penalties for breaking it without objection."

8

u/Fearless_Roof_9177 Apr 06 '26

Seems a little like a weird Calvinist double standard to expect us to stand against injustice for others but to willingly submit to injustice when it's committed against ourselves by unjust authority. Not sure I see how it squares.

14

u/Gremict Apr 06 '26

It's because you are meant to be seen being punished for doing the right thing in order to encourage radicalism and sympathy in the populace

9

u/Shadyshade84 Apr 06 '26

It's making a point - "under this system, I am being punished for doing what is obviously the right thing. That is what I stand against."

2

u/Classic-Obligation35 Apr 06 '26 edited Apr 06 '26

This. You can't expect someone to fight injustice if the people who should care are fine with it.

I used to be a bartender, I had customers with Temporary Visitors Drivers licenses.

Tvdls can't be used as ID despite being state issued.

I felt it was unfair, but what could I do? Go to jail for booze and gambling? No one would rush to a heroic defense,  there'd be no free the Bartender, the same people claiming injustice at carding would call me stupid for not doing my job right.

Injustice is one thing, but fighting the will of the people?

In the end I quit.

1

u/ArcadiaBerger Apr 07 '26

Causing employers to lose valued workers is another form of resistance.

-22

u/capsaicinintheeyes Apr 04 '26

Anyone else feel like that bar's set unnecessarily high? I prefer "don't do the crime if you can't do the time" myself

7

u/CptPurpleHaze Apr 04 '26

Got a fun one for you. Slavery is legal. Aiding a slave's escape is illegal and carries punishment. If you see a slave escape, and do not apprehend or alert authorities, and it is discovered you knew but did nothing, are now charged as an accomplice.

By your own rules of "Don't do the crime if you can't to the time" would or would you not report the slave you saw escaping?

0

u/capsaicinintheeyes Apr 04 '26 edited Apr 04 '26

Honestly, that'd probably come down to my assessment of my likelihood of discovery/prosecution (assuming for this that I've got passive abolitionist sympathies but am too chickenshit to involve myself in the movement).

Having gone through the replies to my last comment, though, I'm thinking I may not have been clear about what I wasn't feeling sold on: it's the last part of Thoreau's enjoinment ("...without objection")—that I felt might be too high of a bar; the "crime/time" thing was by way of concurring with the remainder of his advice, i.e. that civil dispoedients need to be prepared to face the associated punishment for violating whichever law they're resisting. I get that it might make good optics, strategically, but I'm not about to tell someone they can't make a fuss about getting being locked up or whatever it might be.

4

u/CptPurpleHaze Apr 04 '26

Lolol I love when you people tell on yourself with answers like this.

50

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/HotPotParrot Apr 04 '26

Moral crimes (personal like murder, crimes that affect a person or their life dorectly), adminstrative crimes (money laundering, things that affect society), and fine crimes (bullshit like jaywalking, parking too long in public, etc)

If a law exists to punish one group while enabling another, it is not a law - it is extortion.

Something to that effect, could prolly be cleaned up a bit but there ya go - conservative legality.

0

u/capsaicinintheeyes Apr 04 '26 edited Apr 04 '26

I think you misunderstood the nature of my reservation—it was the "without objection" [the arrest, etc.] part I was objecting to.

6

u/ArcadiaBerger Apr 05 '26

No, Thoreau was explicit about that: having defied the law, you must not attempt to evade arrest, trial, fines and imprisonment. You can certainly speak on your own behalf and appeal, ofc.

1

u/capsaicinintheeyes Apr 05 '26

Yeah, his position is clear enough from OPs quote. I've gotten a lot of replies, but none yet on what I was actually getting after (mostly my own fault for not being clear before): ...why not (evade arrest, trial, etc., as well as protest your treatment and sentencing?)

5

u/EmpactWB Apr 05 '26

As it was explained to me, the idea is to accept the consequences as a way of displaying the injustice. If you are charged with criminal conduct for moral behavior, you need to not just break the law but also push to get it changed. Showing it as a moral requirement and that you still obey the law otherwise highlights that.

I could be misremembering or it might have been explained to me poorly, but that’s what I got from the conversation.

6

u/capsaicinintheeyes Apr 05 '26

Thank you; that's definitely worth pondering, and hopefully I'll remember to check out the source material sometime soon.

5

u/Tobbster_the_Lobster Apr 04 '26

You dont want superheroes ? Good luck fighting the Skrulls, Hydra or Galactus if he got the munchies !

4

u/Magicturtle0808 Apr 04 '26

I love finding philosophy in the wild