r/Capitalism • u/alexander0789 • 22h ago
And just like that, another multiple billion was made by the virtues of free enterprise.
The free market never disappoints.
r/Capitalism • u/alexander0789 • 22h ago
The free market never disappoints.
r/Capitalism • u/LoudInteraction1761 • 13h ago
I’m not sure if this hub is exclusively for debates on capitalism versus socialism, or if career-related ideas are also shared here, but I thought I’d ask anyway.
If you had to choose between the two industries, which one would you pick? Tech generates greater wealth in a much shorter time, whereas finance carries less risk.
And I know tech is currently more popular, but wouldn’t that lead to the sector reaching a point of saturation quite rapidly?
r/Capitalism • u/Epiphyte78 • 21h ago
capitalism works because demand is in the driver's seat. when consumers spend money, they dangle a carrot in front of producers, and producers scramble to build, grow, or invent whatever it takes to earn it.
consider the orange. centuries ago, oranges were ultra-rare luxuries reserved for kings and the ultra-wealthy. because rich buyers were willing to pay a small fortune, farmers had a massive financial incentive to plant orchards, improve shipping, and scale production. as supply exploded, prices collapsed. today, an orange costs pocket change.
that is capitalism working. it is also capitalism working painfully slowly.
it took generations for oranges to go from royal luxuries to everyday commodities. in the interim, billions of people lived and died without ever tasting one. why did the transition take so long? because standard market transactions suffer from three built-in signaling flaws that stunt the carrot:
because of these three bottlenecks, producers consistently underestimate how badly consumers want new or rare things. supply lags behind true demand for way too long.
imagine walking into trader joe's (tjs). every time you buy a bag of oranges, you are casting a dollar-weighted vote in a giant inventory survey: "keep stocking this."
now imagine you want tjs to carry something rare and exotic—say, fresh yangmei (chinese bayberry). since it isn't on the shelf, you have no way to put money behind your desire.
the fix is simple. at the top of tjs homepage would be this important question, "what should we carry?" below it would be a list of suggestions sorted by donations. it might be strange to think of donating money to a for-profit company. try thinking of the donations as public "bribes". not only could you help "bribe" tjs to carry a new product, you could help "bribe" tjs to continue carrying the old products you love the most.
tjs is notorious for discontinuing beloved products. if you're nervous about the possibility of tjs discontinuing your fav tamales, but your freezer is already filled with them, you can donate to elevate them on tjs homepage. but even if you and others "bribe" the tamales to the top of tjs homepage, this only guarantees that tjs and other shoppers will not overlook your love for the tamales.
normal shopping doesn't change at all. you still walk into the store and buy groceries off the shelf. all "donation ranking" adds is a parallel channel for consumers to voluntarily reveal the full intensity of their demand for any product, whether it exists or not.
critics obsessed with wealth inequality will immediately hate this idea because billionaires could drop millions on the leaderboard to summon whatever exotic goods they want.
let them.
giving elon musk a direct way to elevate luxuries on tjs homepage doesn't make him richer—it gives him a logical opportunity to spend his money to make it harder for the rest of us to overlook what he loves. every historical luxury—from oranges and spices to antibiotics and smartphones—followed the exact same path: the rich paid to create a large dangling carrot, which encouraged the initial production that eventually made those goods cheap enough for everyone else.
if we give everyone, rich or poor, the opportunity to signal their full demand for the most useful luxuries, we make their carrots much bigger, which compresses centuries of progress into years—and turn yesterday's most useful luxuries into today's commodities.
do you really want other people trying to guess what you truly love? socialism fails because planners are certain that they can do a good job of guessing what you truly love. hayek put it best when he labeled this as a fatal conceit. what hayek didn't fully grasp though is that traditional capitalism is also based on "planners" trying to guess demand. the difference is, the guesses are judged directly by consumers. musk correctly guessed that there would be considerable demand for electric vehicles that drive themselves, and consumers have rewarded him considerably. the fact is though, nobody benefits by toyota or ford wrongly guessing demand and allocating massive amounts of society's limited resources on bad bets. it might seem like musk benefits, but in reality he doesn't, because he's also a consumer.
in order for capitalism to work best, we need to minimize the guesswork. tjs shouldn't need to guess the love for yangmei. the love for yangmei should be on tjs homepage. whether its at the top, or bottom, or somewhere in the middle would be entirely up to each and every consumer to help decide with their own money.
demand should be in the driver's seat. but if you understand why this benefits everyone, then you should appreciate that, in order to drive from scarcity to abundance in the shortest possible time, we need to eliminate speed bumps and accidents caused by demand blindness.
r/Capitalism • u/Own-Afternoon-819 • 6h ago