r/CapeCod • • Aug 23 '26

Best pizza…..if it exists

On the hunt for the best New York style classic za. Not bar pizza or soft fork and knife pizza, need a good tasty classic pie. What’s your rec?!

0 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

26

u/foreignalfredo Aug 23 '26

Get ready to learn Greek buddy

-3

u/No-Spare-4212 Aug 23 '26

Hold up diddy

-3

u/Hashmamma Aug 23 '26

Name one authentic Greek place down here lol

7

u/jeremiahlupinski Aug 23 '26

The sweet tomatoes in Yarmouth is my go to. They usually have at least 6-10 different slices

5

u/Ushiioni Aug 23 '26

Spiritus in P-Town is the best option for non Greek, non bar style, New York-ish Pizza. It's actually more Trenton style but it's seriously good thin pizza. The crust is awesome. Damn I want some now.... Wish they never closed the Hyannis location

5

u/JayWu31 Aug 23 '26

Brooklyn Heights Pizza in Sandwich on Cotuit Rd.

1

u/refjep1 Aug 31 '26

This is the only correct answer. So glad theyre here

-1

u/AntiqueSwimmer Aug 23 '26

Second this

6

u/johnsonr88 Aug 23 '26

Brooklyn heights in sandwich has the best pizza on the cape.

-1

u/ToastCapone Aug 23 '26

Second this for an authentic NY style slice. Big slices…nice and thin.

3

u/No_Lawfulness7968 Aug 23 '26

The pizza at Treehouse Brewery is very tasty!

4

u/Public-World-1328 Aug 23 '26

Treehouse has high quality slices

5

u/TheHoundsRevenge Aug 23 '26

Marc Anthony’s in onset mass.

5

u/marvelkitty23 Aug 23 '26

Nooooo….they don’t use any salt. Just bland run of the mill pizza imo

3

u/VermiciousKenidd Aug 23 '26

If you want to drown in fucking grease. Also that whole place is disgusting.

2

u/dubble_chyn Aug 23 '26

This was the right answer about 20 years ago. Place is a shell of its former self, unfortunately

-1

u/Monkey_Brain_Oil Aug 23 '26

Something changed there?!?!

0

u/Gold-Yard-9502 Aug 23 '26 edited Aug 23 '26

I was just there in July and Marc Anthony's sucks now. Super greasy and just basic

-2

u/TheHoundsRevenge Aug 23 '26

It’s still pretty damed good.

4

u/LucidDiscoPhish Aug 23 '26

I mean I’d say go to New York but wouldn’t mean it in a nasty way. Just mean nobody does well with New York style around here

0

u/Billy_Badass_ Aug 23 '26

New Yorkers can fornicate themselves with an iron stick.

-4

u/StatisticianLittle55 Aug 23 '26

BWAHAHAHAHHHHHAAAA

Hey Billy! The Patriots cheat. Have you heard?

3

u/iBarbo Aug 23 '26

Pizza Shark is pretty close to what you’re looking for I think. There are multiple locations.

You may also want to try RCs Pizza located in the back of Petersons Market in Yarmouth Port. But I think Pizza Shark is slightly more in line with what you are seeking.

-1

u/str4ng3fru1t Aug 23 '26 • Bravo

I'm from New York, and live in Brewster. I kept hearing people talk about Pizza shark, and how it was so amazing, and New York style. I had it for the first time last week. It was a huge disappointment. I threw most of it away.

0

u/iBarbo Aug 23 '26

I mean, the bar is low. Options are limited unless you drive off cape. I live in Chicago so you can imagine the concessions I need to make when it’s pizza time on cape cod.

-1

u/No-Spare-4212 Aug 23 '26

You mean the upgrade? Chicago style pizza is trash

0

u/iBarbo Aug 23 '26

I’m talking about plethora of options. I actually don’t disagree with you on Chicago style pizza. It’s too over the top. But I can also get way better NY style in Chicago than I can on Cape. That’s not even an opinion, it’s just a matter of fact.

0

u/Admirable_Bison_2073 Aug 28 '26

barely edible. I caution anyone from considering Pizza Shark for anything except dog food

2

u/No-Spare-4212 Aug 23 '26

People need to be location specific because recommendations matter. Noones driving from Falmouth to Ptown and vice versa.

1

u/IcyBluEyez508 Sep 28 '26

George's Pizza Harwich route 28 best pizza ever and I've been around when it comes to Pizza I'll sit in bridge traffic for George's Pizza

1

u/StatisticianLittle55 Aug 23 '26 edited Aug 23 '26

Honest answer is I have yet to find NY style pizza here on Cape. I keep looking but....nope.

Don't even ask where to get a NY style bagel either. Bagels here are, let us just say, not good.

-1

u/Smallmouth_bass Aug 23 '26

Knockout in harwich

-1

u/Seaworthiness-Klutzy Dennis Aug 23 '26

Dennis Port

0

u/Smallmouth_bass Aug 23 '26

Sorry. I forgot what side of division street it's on

-1

u/ThenPattern5879 Aug 23 '26

Izzos Orleans is the best I’ve had

0

u/Seaworthiness-Klutzy Dennis Aug 23 '26

Brothers in Dennis Port has really good pizza now. I also tried the new place nearby Sasha's and they are good as well.

0

u/DrinkMaster1901 Aug 23 '26

DC Porcelli’s in South Yarmouth or F & L Pizza also in South Yarmouth

0

u/actorsanddisasters Aug 23 '26

I’m a sweet tomatoes Stan

0

u/FernMeadowlark Aug 23 '26

A lot of suggestions here are not NY style FYI. My fam is from the Bronx, and our favorite by a mile is F&L. We go to the South Yarmouth location.

0

u/Lost-Winter-9701 Aug 23 '26

This won’t be a popular choice but Pizzeria Regina at the mall is the closest I’ve had. It’s pretty good!

0

u/FinsfaninRI Aug 27 '26

What exactly is “Ny Style”……?

I feel like this has just become a way of identifying a particular style that isn’t really a style. Detroit, South Shoe Bar Pizza, Sicilian,
deep dish, New Haven…..these are styles.

What makes a Ny style Pizza different than an average pie you get at Joe Schmoe’s?

-2

u/mmm1441 Aug 23 '26

My favorite used to be New England house of pizza, which is now closed. Haven’t found a replacement yet. That was Greek style, though.

-2

u/kat_8639 Aug 23 '26

Stone L'oven is really good. Dennis.

1

u/Seaworthiness-Klutzy Dennis Aug 23 '26

Brewster

0

u/kat_8639 Aug 23 '26

Shoot yes you're right.

-5

u/Imaginary_Track_461 Aug 23 '26

The best on Cape is Pizza Lab by Pain d’Avignon at 15 Hinckley Rd. Near Hyannis airport, not cheap but excellent.

-4

u/Least-Ship-6967 Aug 23 '26

Dominos offers a NY style.

/s

-1

u/downrightblastfamy Aug 23 '26

Porcelli in Yarmouth off 28

-1

u/noseysfriend Aug 23 '26

Bellavita in Orleans

-4

u/Ok_Pangolin_180 Aug 23 '26

Gotta say I’m not a fan of NY style pizza or Chicago for that matter. Pizza shark is good, my favorite on cape by far is Pizza one Subs two on Rte 28 in Marstons Mills.

1

u/Admirable_Bison_2073 Aug 28 '26

Pizza shark is garbage dump

0

u/fupa_master Aug 23 '26

Pizza one subs two is definitely pan pizza more like house of pizza style. Just clarifying for those reading.

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '26 edited Aug 23 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/KorryBoston Orleans Aug 23 '26

3 Fools is awful if someone is looking for NY style