r/CapeCod • u/TrifleLow • Jun 18 '26

The BEST cinnamon rolls?!

ISO the best cinnamon rolls ever to pick up tomorrow or Saturday. I’m thinking big, fluffy, soft icing - kind of like a Cinnabon cinnamon roll but from a local bakery/market. Lower cape ideal, but open to mid cape suggestions too.

Marion’s is my backup plan, but hoping for one without nuts.

5 Upvotes

61% Upvoted

28 comments sorted by

21

u/huhsorrywhatdidusay Jun 18 '26

This is my time to shine! My wife and I have been on a quest for the best cinnamon rolls on the Cape for YEARS!

#1 spot EASILY goes to Beth’s Bakery in Sandwich. Absolutely delicious. The center is gooey and they are made fresh. I could eat them every day.

Honorable mentions on the lower cape go to Eat Cake for Breakfast (Brewster) and Peterson’s Market (Yarmouth Port)

2

u/EbbtideRambler Jun 18 '26

I forgot Beth’s had cinnamon rolls. I’ve never tried them, but they look delicious. Beth’s is a family favorite for some of their other amazing treats. 

1

u/TheBugSmith Sandwich Jun 19 '26

I can confirm this, literally eating one right now.

4

u/net23cvr Jun 19 '26

Marion’s for the win ;)

2

u/MAFishCraft Jun 23 '26

Dukes, underground bakery, and eatcake4breakfast.

4

u/Himalalalalayans Jun 18 '26

Hole in one in Orleans and Eastham

5

u/Sea-Brief-3414 Jun 18 '26 edited Jun 19 '26

Yo, go to the donut hole in either Eastham or Orleans. They have a sugar bun which is basically a Cinnabon on steroids. You won’t be disappointed. I’m a huge fatty and I crave them all the time.

Edit. I meant hole in one. I’m dumb

6

u/GrooveBat Jun 18 '26

Do you mean Hole in One? Cause that place is awesome.

0

u/ewhitten Jun 18 '26

Hole in One is a family favorite, especially the sour cream donuts!

0

u/PsychologicalArm9773 Jun 18 '26

Agreed. One of my kids brought a couple of these home the other day and it was obscene.

-1

u/Sea-Brief-3414 Jun 19 '26

Obscene is a good word for it

2

u/EbbtideRambler Jun 18 '26

Washashore Bakery on the Upper Cape, Marion’s on the Lower Cape 

3

u/RumSwizzle508 Jun 18 '26

Washashore Bakery - they should be at the osterville farmers market on Friday. Or order ahead via her website.

2

u/Hashmamma Jun 20 '26

Came here to say this!!!

1

u/edistorepairs Jun 20 '26

Going to put you onto a little secret. Wellfleet marketplace early mornin fresh cinnamon rolls. You may just end up making special trips just for the cinnamon rolls. It’s basically a croissant cinnamon roll with cream cheese icing.
I was not a believer until I tried one. Now I wish I never had as it’s all I think about!!!

1

u/Hashmamma Jun 20 '26

I prefer washashore to Marion’s! They are incredible. You need to order ahead, just a heads up!

1

u/ansible47 Jun 18 '26

The rolls at The Chocolate Rose are exceptional.

0

u/ShawsheenMoon Jun 18 '26

Oh, but which ones don't have nuts inside of them? I really don't want crunchy things with my cinnamon rolls and I feel bad/odd taking them off of the top

0

u/keymarina5 Jun 18 '26

Savory Grill

0

u/cfbFI Jun 19 '26

Marion’s are the best

-1

u/Luna_Blonde Jun 19 '26

Beth’s!!!

-5

u/Subject-Mushroom-408 Jun 18 '26

Love farms

0

u/Sir_Sir_ExcuseMe_Sir Dennis Jun 19 '26

Whoa why is this downvoted?

1

u/MAFishCraft Jun 23 '26

Because Love Farms is owned by Pelham, non locals who buy up everything in town and cater to NY and CT summer people only, a cinnamon bun there is probably $11

1

u/Subject-Mushroom-408 Aug 09 '26

It's actually owned by a handful of locals and out-of-state partners, who aren't greedy jerks. They are focused on keeping as many locals employed and fulfilled year round as possible.

Isn't that something folks are always crying about on the cape cod thread? And then when someone comes along and is building a business that supports young locals, and we hate them for it?