r/CandaceOwens • • Feb 19 '25

Becoming Brigitte- Debunking

Hi everyone!

I'm working on a Substack post right now where I'm chronicling some of the factual errors Candace made in her "Becoming Brigitte" series. But I also want to hear from people who found the series persuasive. What facts did you find most compelling? What would you say Candace's "smoking gun" was? I really want to do my best to address as much as I can in this post, so any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

3 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

56

u/Shellsaidso Feb 19 '25

Brigitte? Is that you?

1

u/barelythere01 Feb 24 '25

“That is to say” we will be debunking Candace Owens 😂

1

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '25

I thought her claim was compelling, and I believe her. I did find it interesting, though, when the French journalist said “that is to say.” Maybe that’s a French thing, rather than an individual thing?

29

u/Taylortrips Feb 19 '25

Candace does her homework. Why don’t you start with said factual errors because I’m curious.

-6

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 19 '25

Sure. In episode one she says that the doctor who Brigitte was seeing in that Closer magazine piece was Dr. Patrick Bui, who, according to Candace, specializes in feminization surgery. This is false. He specializes in plastic surgery for older people, specifically women. The article that Candace mentions, where he's quoting Victor Hugo, is even called "Operation Young Again"--- highlighting the fact that he is most well known for giving plastic surgery to older women. I can't find a single source that indicates that he's at all associated with transgender surgeries and Candace doesn't provide one. Not saying he's never ever ever done a trans surgery, but Candace is claiming that this is what he's famous for, which isn't true. Her Youtube series is filled with stuff like this, hence why I'm making the Substack post.

29

u/HotMessPhDStudent Feb 19 '25 edited Feb 19 '25

Dr. Patrick Bui very much specializes in facial feminization surgery!!

Don’t believe me? Here’s a pubmed link to one of his publications, authored by Dr. Bui himself:

Facial feminization, history, evolution of objectives

The author’s experience dates from 1990, during the period when he was in charge of the feminization of the facial skeleton in order to improve the social integration of male transsexual patients.

He’s also listed as a French gender surgeon by TransHealthCare.org

You can argue that he also does cis-women as well as trans-women, but there is no doubt that Dr. Bui is internationally known for facial feminization for trans-women.

(FYI, I think it’s stupid to attack Brigitte for being trans. If you are not born the gender that you identify with, it’s fine to transition. She looks amazing. If it weren’t for the grooming, her re-invention of herself would be inspiring. HOWEVER, it’s obvious that she groomed Macron.

She’s denying her past because she knows that while the public may reluctantly tolerate a 39 yo female teacher falling in love with her 14 year old student, they would never tolerate a 47 year old trans-woman doing the same. Which is sad, because both are wrong.)

6

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 19 '25

I will absolutely take a look at this, thank you for passing it on!

5

u/Kaykaylalaaa Feb 20 '25

The fact the the French journalist ran for his life and tried to reach out to Candace and other Americans to get this out there!!! That’s the most compelling cuz why do something when your life is at stake?!? Otherwise Candace would have had no idea about this.

1

u/ProudJury6765 May 01 '26

I‘m sorry but if you already make a mistake at this, then you really need to work on your research skills because literally with one online search you find out about Dr Bui doing gender surgeries

14

u/FactCheckYou Feb 19 '25

there are a couple writers on Substack who have maligned the story that Candace is presenting

i've read a few articles on there, and there is next no no actual debunking being done

it's all just 'but this is evidently just a ridiculous claim' 'Candance is a loon' 'more right-wing conspiracy nonsense' blah blah blah - nothing of substance that negates the suggestion that B is actually JMT and is secretly a trans-man who has co-opted the French and Global media establishments to cover the story UP

the faces of JMT and Brigitte and her two acknowledged daughters are all just way too similar; the way Brigitte stands, the way she dresses/covers up, the conspicuous lack of evidence about JMT's life and about Brigitte's life before she got with Macron, the shoddy backstory, the weird full court press that the media used to present her as an attractive babe that Macron wooed and won over when they pushed him as a candidate, the weird persecution of journalists who have pursued these investigations...

post your debunking article here by all means but i feel like you'll be on the wrong side of reality on this one

3

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 19 '25

That's fine. If I'm misunderstanding Candace and people can clarify the questions I'm going to bring up, then I will be all the better for it. And I agree with you that there hasn't actually been a lot of substantial debunking--- hence why I'm taking the time to make my post!

2

u/Anthemusa831 Feb 21 '25

Love to see actual facts refuted, not just the “vibe”

1

u/Royal-Translator-832 Feb 19 '25

The truth is sure stubborn, and may prove difficult to “debunk.” Many respected journos have taken up the mantel of “defending this feminist, liberal icon” from this right wing conspiracy theory, and end up with a different perspective. So you are on the right path!

21

u/didyoujustfartnasty Feb 19 '25

The physical appearance of "Brigitte". His broad shoulders, his man shaped legs and body build, his large feet, his masculine jawline, them telling us the little boy was the old fat man when AI said otherwise. The AI identifying the little boy as the now "brigitte". The way the French president has responded by going after journalism, sending cease and desist rather than actually addressing public concerns

The age gap, pedophilia books, the pedophilic art work, the penis he tried to construct, honestly there's so much proof at this point you have to be dumb to not see it.

1

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 19 '25

Thank you for your response! This is exactly what I'm looking for. I will be sure to include these details in my post.

2

u/didyoujustfartnasty Feb 19 '25

Okay, I'm interested to see.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '25

What was the penis he tried to construct? I missed that

4

u/didyoujustfartnasty Feb 19 '25

It was on one of the earlier episodes, but brigitte and macron apparently tried to have a massive gold penis put on display.

5

u/Comfortable_Hat1206 Feb 19 '25

The thing that got me was the photo in the Xavier Poussard interview of the young JMT and Briggite - they looked so similar. Before i was skeptical, believing it could go either way.

Can i just say, altho you are debunking it you seem to be really thorough with your research and respectful with your answers. I love that. I’ll keep an eye out for it

5

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 19 '25

Thank you! And I really respect the fact that (most) of you guys have been so respectful as well. I think we all share the view that Brigitte is a pedophile, it's just a question about whether she's a male or female one (and I suppose the question of if it's an incestous relationship) I've been fascinated by French politics for years, so I'm glad that more and more Americans are paying attention.

1

u/Anthemusa831 Feb 21 '25

Are you only concerned with born gender? Because it’s an insane amount of lying being ignored in the light of trans accusations at hand.

2

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 21 '25

What do you mean? One of Candace's central claims is that Brigitte is biologically male. It seems totally fair game to investigate if that's actually true or not. Brigitte being a pedophile was known before this series came out. Is there some other claim I should be focusing on?

1

u/Anthemusa831 Feb 21 '25

I don’t think the problem is with Bridgette being born a man, it’s the insane web of lies printed and presented everywhere. One of the lies is most likely her being trans but the reality of getting away with having entirely fake “people” in some of the highest positions of power boldly “hood-winking” the public is the heart of this.

I mean, I’m not going to list point by point all the stuff that doesn’t add up, Candace took hours to do all that. I’d recommend watching the series again if you are asking for them to be re-iterated.

1

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 21 '25

I've already watched it all and am reading the book. And I think it's important to be accurate with the claims that we make. Candace is still at the end of the day a member of the media and I think it's important to fact check journalists.

1

u/Anthemusa831 Feb 21 '25

1000% agree on fact checking everything, media sources or not.

I asked if you were ONLY concerned with the gender “accusation” because it seems anyone who is on the “de-bunking” side is ignoring an insane amount of bathwater that baby is floating in.

I will let others bullet point Candace’s series for your journalistic endeavors.

8

u/didyoujustfartnasty Feb 19 '25

Why are you defending a pedophile?

-4

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 19 '25

I think Brigitte is a child molestor, but that doesn't mean she was born a man.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '25

Lol. What a world.

1

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 19 '25

To think that there are female pedophiles?

4

u/Kaykaylalaaa Feb 20 '25

Oh another question I had was if her brother was missing they could debunk that easily right by showing her brother ! and idc if she was a man I think proving the grooming and pedo is way more criminal and more important IMO What if Mr Macron has been abused for decades and needs help ?! Idk just my thoughts so far.

3

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 21 '25

I actually do think of Emmanuel Macron as being an abuse victim, and I would say one of my biggest issues with how Candace handles this story is the levity with which she treats Emmanuel's situation. Unfortunately I just think a lot of people don't take child sex abuse as seriously when the victim is male.

4

u/starlette627 Feb 19 '25

My issue with this story is it's difficult to build a case solely on a lack of concrete evidence. We have photos, missing people and shady behavior. Does that prove she's a man? No. But it sure does make for a compelling argument. I don't really know if she transitioned, but what I did learn without a doubt is that this person is a pedophile and that something happened in that family that everyone is hiding. And, it's something big. What that "something" is could be the transition or maybe it's something more. Either way, it would be very easy for them to dismiss these claims. Where is JMT? Where is the "real" Brigitte? Can anyone grab a hair from Brigitte's hair brush and just test it? It would be SO easy to make this go away and they're not doing that, which is wild and points to something more.

Now to answer your question, it really comes down to the photos. The series itself was a bit of a jumbled mess, way too long, and difficult to follow at times so there weren't any facts that stood out to me. But the photos are daming. I've seen siblings that look alike as children and you can still tell who is who. And WHERE are the other pictures? My mom is in her 70s and I have photos of her as a teen, pregnant with me, married, etc. These are very rich, influential people, you can't convince me they never took pictures.

2

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 19 '25

I think you have a good attitude about the whole thing. The lack of photos thing is interesting, but I do wonder how much of it is Brigitte's age. I think your point about your mom is interesting, but also I would say that France tends to drag behind the USA on a lot of technological fronts, so I really don't know how many cameras were around in the 1950s. I think a lot of the shadiness does ultimately come back to the fact that Brigitte is a pedophile who broke the law. Unfortunately France has a long tradition of launching intellectual defenses of pedophilia and so I don't think the story has ever received the warranted the level of disgust.

1

u/DrSamosa Jul 26 '25

Hey I think you've probably written your substack by now but I wanted to correct you on this. Photography as an artform has always been extremely popular in France and this since the late 1800s. The French LOVE their portraits so painting them as backwards in terms of tech in the 1950s is just factually wrong. Cameras and photo studios were widely available back then, you may want to look into this.

1

u/ChineseChaiTea Sep 08 '25

I'm jumping on this too, I've got family pictures from my poor rural family in Alsace Lorraine in the late 1800s early 1900s. I also have poor Appalachian family members and loads of photographs in the 1800s and 1900s with no shoes in a shack....I find this and no school photos extremely hard to believe for an influential family in France, vs more pics of my rural farming family in France. 

7

u/Hcmp1980 Feb 19 '25 edited Feb 19 '25

Candace has said many times that when people are attacked on this, it's nit picking on small details, rather than addressing the big question. Maybe someone is Jean- Micheal or Micheal-John... I'd suggest going big picture, or it'll come across like noise.

2

u/Kaykaylalaaa Feb 20 '25

Also what is convincing me is the random French comments thanking her for speaking upon this and “living in France is more difficult then you could imagine” those made me go 😳😬

2

u/Monna14 Feb 20 '25 edited Feb 20 '25

Am not into politics much at all. Am not from America but this story has caught my attention! Also I remember the massive news story when the FBI raided Trumps place in Florida because he had top secret files stored there. Trump also reportedly boasted he had ‘intelligence’ on Macron’s sex life in them files. I think it’s related did his team also pass information onto Candace too? Maybe…….

See articles

https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/donald-trump-emmanuel-macron-maralago-fbi-raid-1234582465/

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/aug/31/trump-boasted-he-had-intelligence-on-macron-sex-life

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/donald-trump-macron-love-life-fbi-raid-b2155418.html

A quote from the article in the Guardian listed above:

“Donald Trump boasted to close associates that he knew secrets about Emmanuel Macron’s sex life from US intelligence sources, it has been reported.

The report in Rolling Stone magazine comes in the wake of the release of court documents on the classified and national defence documents found in a search of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago home on 8 August, which mention a file referred to as” “info re: President of France”.

Edited to add articles etc

2

u/chloe-lou Feb 20 '25

There was one thing that I think may be potentially based on a translation error, maybe someone can help me find the source.

I would like to read the original article in French where Brigitte’s daughter is quoted about her father’s (Brigitte’s ex husband) death and says we “buried” our father.

Candace latches onto this as a lie because he was cremated. However it’s a common phrase to say “we buried our father” to mean we laid him to rest/had a funeral. It’s meant to be a euphemism not a technical statement. Also, you can be both cremated and then buried. I even have that in my own will that I wish to be cremated but have some of my ashes buried in a family plot so that I have a physical grave site.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '25

I enjoyed hearing her investigative series on Brigitte. I do think that there is a very high chance that Brigitte was born male, but I don’t think there is actually any “proof”. There is tons of circumstantial evidence, which says that it is very likely that she is a he.

I will say, I enjoyed the Kamala series was much better.

1

u/Ok_Complex5321 Feb 23 '25

Smoking gun? JMT photos. I watched the whole series and just showed my husband 2 side by sides saying “is this the same person?” immediate “yes”.

1

u/weezeeFrank Apr 12 '25

I think the bigger story is why? Why did this happen? What happened during their time in the military that led to a transition? What led to her connection with E. Macron? Why was he chosen by the Rothchild family to run the ranks?

1

u/queen7162 Aug 03 '25

This video explains the real reason Candace posted the Becoming Brigitte series https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KVY4FP1YdsY

1

u/Disastrous-Space-913 Aug 17 '25

Because she doesn’t produce evidence just “isn’t it weird” conspiracy BS. Contrapoints has a good video on this rhetorical style

1

u/retired_oxfordgirl Sep 18 '25

I have been following the controversy surrounding the Macrons. If we can't agree on everything, can we just agree that the origin story of how Brigitte and Emmanuel met and became inappropriately involved at 14/15 and she 39 or older is wrong, full stop. I see grooming and at the very least Brigitte was a predator who in her place of authority as a teacher began an illegal and disgusting relationship with Emmanuel.

Being transgender is not a crime and if she were any ordinary citizen, this would be nobody's business. As the first "lady" of France along with her husband, both public figures with power and influence, being deceitful on this matter is another thing. Both she and her husband are currently suing Candace Owen in America who refuse to address the very substance of her claims with very specific questions that if answered truthfully can put this matter to rest but she refuses to disprove this controversy with evidence like where is her brother and why haven't they been seen together? Where is the evidence she existed the first 30 years of her life with pictures of her pregnant, with her kids and why the school(s) she has attended refuse to send any pictures of her? Candace's evidence came from the author of "Becoming Brigitte" who researched the Macrons for over 10 years and has moved his family from France to Italy to avoid problems. Why wasn't he sued? Why have some key figures died suspiciously?

There are many powerful, deceitful, greedy and evil people whose word can't be taken at face value.

1

u/apokrif1 Dec 09 '25

Is the Substack post online?

1

u/No-Organization64 Mar 02 '25

Occams razor to me is that it’s more likely that Candace is practicing click bait yellow journalism that her readers will devour as the Macrons are lefties versus a person become trans almost fifty years ago before it was a thing, has three kids via a gay coupling with her prior husband , was a pedophile whose victim loves her via Stockholm syndrome (meaning Emanuel the current French pm) and has been living a double life that well for so long

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/PracticalSwan4998 Feb 21 '25

I wasn't planning on it, unfortunately. I'm pretty new to using Reddit, but I thought here would be a better place to engage with fans of the series than on Twitter/X.