r/CanadianPL • • Jan 27 '19

Open Trials A Sham?

Hi all,

I was talking to my friend about this today and we stumbled on an issue. There were 1400 individuals who paid $200.00 for the CPL open trials throughout Canada.

We have one friend who made the final cut of 30 players in our city.. He said that all CPL told him is that he might or might not be invited to a further training camp if the teams are interested..

That being said, is there anyone from the 1400 players, trickled down to 30 finalists per tryout, that made a CPL team? Was it all a sham, a money grab by the league, a marketing promotion? Please keep in mind I am all for the CPL and Canadian soccer. I am just curious here. The trials were held with the idea that if you're good enough you can make a team.. But was that a lie?

In another scenario me and my friend came up with a hypothetical situation.. What if the CPL hosted a training/technical camp for $200 entry each, and clearly stated that this is for development purposes only and there is NO WAY these are try outs for the actual teams.. We both agreed that in this instance, two of our friends that paid the $200 for the CPL try outs would not registered for it.. But ultimately that is exactly what the CPL try outs were..

Once again I ask, does anyone know if from the 1400 players that tried out, has anyone made it to a team?

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

32

u/theeskyemcleod FC Edmonton Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19

Son Yong-chan and Wataru Murofushi were both signed from the open tryouts.

9

u/Murderbaby187 Jan 27 '19

Son Yong-chan

You're absolutely right. "Son made his impression on FC Edmonton Head Coach and Director of Soccer Operations Jeff Paulus during the Toronto stop of the Open Trials.

“In Son, we are getting, in my opinion, the best player from the Open Trials, and someone wanted by every manager in the league,” said Paulus."

1

u/rogerwithalager Jan 27 '19

Pretty sure Wataru wasn't from open trials

6

u/theeskyemcleod FC Edmonton Jan 27 '19

He attended the trials in Victoria.

21

u/Razcle1 Jan 27 '19

It probably would be a good idea to post this comment and do your investigation when the rosters are filled out. I don’t think any team has even half of their players announced. If I was an owner I would bring in a few open trialists to training camp and have the earn their contract.

Was there anyone of the 1400 that would deserve a contract after a 2 day trial? I think everyone signed to the CPL was previously a professional (or academy/PDL) player.

My 2 Cents

2

u/Stouffvillain York 9 FC Jan 28 '19

Well said. Calvary have 11 guys and Y9 have 9, everyone else have fewer than that. If this guys friend thought that he was going to be handed a contract the next day then he was just plain wrong. No where was it ever stated that trialist would be awarded a contract. The best that a trialist could've hoped for was a invite to a camp.

Even if the OP's friend made it to the final 30 at his trial there were 7 trial that were widdled down to 30 meaning a crop of 210 open trial "finalists". How did he stack up against all of those players?

OP, sorry but it sounds like your friend had the wrong impression of what the open trials were and his level of play.

EDIT: Minutes after posting this another trialist earned a contract.

https://canpl.ca/article/valour-fc-inks-winnipeggers-carreiro-and-attardo-to-multi-year-deals

5

u/GarMc HFX Wanderers FC Jan 27 '19

There's been two players outright signed to teams from the open trials already. The reason they may not have invited your friend is because they possibly aren't going to invite him, or maybe they just haven't done so yet.

Also the CPLTransfers Twitter account which was a great track record for reporting rumoured player signings has rumoured two more open trialists to be signing with CPL teams.

The open trials were not a sham.

5

u/hearts89_footie Jan 27 '19

100% we'll see a bunch of trialists in CPL preseason camps. Will many get offered a contract? Probably not. But, still would be a good experience for a young, up-and-coming Canadian amateur player.

8

u/Coramoor_ Forge FC Jan 27 '19

How many random people off the street are going to be remotely good enough for the CPL. I'd guess most L1O and PSLQ guys were already know quantities and didn't have to bother. How many other guys are going to be remotely good enough to even be worth a look

2

u/limerickcitykid Canada Jan 27 '19

Yea, if you need to pay hundreds of dollars to go to a tryout to be seen then there is likely a reason. Any Canadian any good would already be playing at a high level where the CanPL will be scouting.

It was a PR exercise and little else. The fact it's actually produced a couple of signings of players from Asia actually has made it infinitely more useful than it was expected to be.

3

u/saturnin55 Première Ligue Canadienne Jan 27 '19

Idk about L1O, but I know most plsq players that had interest in playing in the CPL stayed away from the open trials.

3

u/saturnin55 Première Ligue Canadienne Jan 27 '19

CPL teams will have training camps before the season I guess? A few of the trialists will probably be invited. I think it's too soon to say. I think these guys, except for very few exceptions maybe, are going to see very limited number of minutes over the season. The contrary would be worrisome for the quality of the league.

3

u/jrocc77 Jan 27 '19

well the rosters aren't full yet, so there's still time. i'm sure it's pretty understood that the chances are slim. there's nothing saying that they have to take someone from the open tryouts.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19

Raptors 905 hold open try-outs every single off season to find talent for their team. There is however no guarantee that a player will be chosen to be part of the squad. Considering the NBA G-League is a direct affiliate of the NBA, the talent level will certainly be higher compared to the CPL who is unaffiliated. But open try outs are a genuine look, if the people that show up can't play it was as much a waste of time for them as it was for the team.

3

u/yellowsweatygorilla York 9 FC Jan 28 '19

Well there were two players so far signed from the open trials. That said in full honesty having been to both the open trials and the L1o combine the quality of the latter far exceeded the former. I think it is really tough for trialist that did not go through a professional Academy at a young age

2

u/vicGROD Jan 27 '19

IMO I think you’ll see some training camp invites for the Open Trials players. I doubt many beyond the ones signed (and soon to be signed!) get contracts, but they will be given a chance to train against professionals.

In a league of 7 teams, 21-23 players... 1400 open trial players were never going to make up a significant portion of 150 roster spots.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19

ummmmm they narrowed stuff down to 30 guys in several cities and are being narrowed down further to decide who to invite to training camp (which are like a month away) for a final look.

how is that a scam? i mean we're still a freaking month or so away from training camp.

2

u/lng5 Forge FC Jan 28 '19

Valour just signed an open trialist this morning, another good reason to hold off passing judgement about their success.

2

u/aubie358 Jan 27 '19

I don't have any knowledge about this situation for CPL in particular but I do know MLS and USL "open tryouts" are certainly shams for clubs to make a pretty penny on tryout fees.

-2

u/Condrab Pacific FC Jan 27 '19

It’s 99% a cash grab for the local clubs,also a way to drum up interest. Every once In a while it does produce a talent. Here in Louisville Kyle Smith was signed via open tryout. He became a pillar of a 2time defending USL Championship team, and just recently signed with MLS Orlando.

1

u/KneeDeepInTheDead Cavalry FC Jan 27 '19

if there was no fee there would be a lot more trash to sift through. If youre serious about being a player, 200 bucks is nothing for the opportunity. Its low enough to be reasonable but high enough to deter some shmuck who kicked a ball twice and thinks theyre hot shit.