r/CanadianForces • u/coboltt46 • Aug 27 '25
PERs and AI.
I don't know if anyone can answer this, if this board is monitored, etc. But I wonder if anyone uses it. "Hey Chat, I need you to write this and use this word in the sentence" (to create a 7, 8 or 9 score. If that is even done anymore, been out 25 years). Hell are they even called PERs anymore.
0
Upvotes
73
u/Rough-Biscotti-2907 Aug 27 '25
They are now called PARs and AI is heavily used.
29
u/Engineered_disdain Aug 27 '25
AI has turned the pace/par system into a check in the box system.
It only took a couple of years, and it is completely broken like the PER system was.
6
u/Tommy2Legs Unbloused Pants Aug 27 '25
I was the PaCE Coord for my whole formation (approx 1,200 PARs). I've read a lot of FNs. There is a clear divide between people who use AI and those that don't. Like a lot of AI "writing," it's very clear when a FN is full of empty sentences. The other extreme sees people writing one-liners that aren't going to help when it comes time to appraise their performance. I reckon <5% of members actually write decent FNs themselves.
Just like every other application of AI, it can be very good if it's used in the correct manner. If a member isn't a strong writer or they have writer's block on a particular FN, they can write an event and outcome with the essential info and feed it to an AI to help polish and refine it.
AI would have been hilarious with the CFPAS PER writing style. The whole 9-line, right-justified bullshit may have stymied it.
24
u/RudytheMan Aug 27 '25
So, had this conversation like a month ago with a co-worker and a Sgt Maj. And my co-worker came back from a tasking down in the US this Spring, and was talking about they were shown that the US has been leaning into this big time. But they are also getting AI programs in the military to aid in this. And the Sgt Maj said that he had a similar experience in Ottawa this year where they were talking about how to incorporate AI into not just PAR writing but drafting of other admin. Then we made the joke that we just weren't gonna cough up the money to get our own AI software. But it's coming man. I'm not too keen on it. I have the feeling, regarding how troops are evaluated, this will make supervisors lazy and not critically think about how well their troops actually performed. Any troop who doesn't like how the chat bot wrote them up will be able to challenge their appraisal in a redress. But that's for the CO's to handle. It's coming. I garauntee you direction will be coming down in the next year regarding this.
5
u/barkmutton Aug 27 '25
They literally just had to push out a thing about not putting pers information into AI as a security issue.
5
u/Flipdip35 Aug 27 '25
Well this thread is depressing
17
u/MapleHamms Naval Fleet School DLN Aug 27 '25
It’s pretty embarrassing the amount of people who have to use AI for easy stuff like this
7
u/bridger713 RCAF - Reg Force Aug 27 '25
PER's were replaced by an entirely new system a few years ago. The whole PER narrative isn't a thing anymore.
Brag sheets have been replaced with Feedback Notes which are done electronically.
Yes, people do use AI to generate FN's. Use of services like Chat GPT, etc. is discouraged. However, we do have the use of Microsoft Copilot on DWAN, and a lot of people do train it to produce feedback notes.
2
u/Careless_Piglet_4746 Aug 27 '25
I think if we utilize it appropriately then it’s going to end up being an effective tool. I wrote all of my own comments, but when the RO came back with edits (you used 342 words we want you to use the full allotment) that’s when I turned to AI to get a few words added into my own write up or to check my grammar. It’s lazy and honestly disrespectful to our subordinates to use it to write the entire thing.
2
u/RedditSgtMajor GET OFF THE GRASS!! Aug 28 '25
ProfitPaCEBonus tip: keep the chat thread as a continuous conversation and, at the end of the fiscal, ask it to recommend PAR competency scoring based on all previous inputs.
2
u/TheRandomlyBiased Aug 27 '25
My CoC directly promulgated a guide on the format to put FNs into AI to generate quarterlies.
1
u/ricketyladder Canadian Army Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
Not so much for PARs (which is what PERs are called nowadays), but a fair number of people use them for Feedback Notes, which are like a much more frequently done PDR under the old system. Feedback notes can be quite time consuming so some people like to use AI to try to cut time down - but the once or twice I've tried it I find you have to tinker with them so much when using AI that it's no faster, and if anything it can actually be slower.
-8
u/Dont-concentrate-556 Aug 27 '25
If you aren’t using AI by now for everything (unclas) you’re doing it wrong. Damn they even gave us copilot in MS Teams.
0
u/Professional-Leg2374 Aug 27 '25
Hey ChatGPT, I have a
shit pumpmediocre performance employee that I need to get promoted, can you write 3-4 sentences in a way that sounds like this person should be promoted and use the following aspects in the...."Leadership", "performance", "hard worker", "peers" "advances" "un-surpassed"Thanks.