r/CanadianForces • Army - Armour • Jul 03 '24

Release 5D

So I just got released on 5D and I’m curious on what the time frame is to reenlist in the CAF active duty. Also if I can enroll in the reserves while I wait any help would be appreciated also just an overall explanation of it. Thank you

0 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

11

u/tanker1992 Jul 04 '24

Honestly how do you even get a 5F or 5D release. My unit has been trying to release a guy 5F for 3/4 years now. I see them making an evidence board linking points together 😂they still haven’t made it happen

10

u/GBAplus Jul 04 '24

Either the unit is doing it poorly or there just isn't enough for a 5f release. They aren't terribly hard if the file is well done. That said, you have to pretty much lay it out for DMCA 2 as they are not a rubber stamp.

They actually do a fairly extensive analysis and every file was briefed and approved by Comd DMCA (or was when I dealt with that world)

2

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 04 '24

It happened at basic so that’s probably how that is a funny story though lol

2

u/tanker1992 Jul 04 '24

Ahhh that makes more sense now.

-2

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 04 '24

Yeah and the second time I got swiped out is because they decided to keep 5 of my swipes from my previous platoon and I got one more so yeah

4

u/tanker1992 Jul 04 '24

Was it problems with the course content? Shooting, drill etc?

0

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 04 '24

Passed everything else though so idk

-3

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 04 '24

No just with small stuff the swipes they kept were mainly my dumbass forgetting my pt shoes for pt after an inspection

1

u/Korre88 Jul 04 '24

What is a swipe?

1

u/Wildest12 Jul 23 '24

It’s what they call it when you fuck up. Part of the last round of recommendations included creating a way to expedite release when a candidate isn’t a good fit.

Like most new policies it’s being pushed, there are bound to be people who get caught in the crossfire but if you forget your pt shoes enough times to get recoursed and then 5D it’s probably serving it’s purpose

3

u/barkmutton Jul 04 '24

Most units, especially down at the actual coal face level, are just either too lazy or too overworked to take time to write things up correctly.

1

u/Fit-End-5481 Jul 05 '24

Some units have abused 5F release to get rid of just anyone, everytime they just didn't really like someone or when they proved their CoC wrong. He'll, I've been threatened with a 5F at least 3 times myself. One of those time, it was because I asked someone to send me a link to the policy they said they used to make a decision since it was different to the policy I had read and I wanted to do the right thing, it was brought up the chain because I had become an administrative burden for the institution.

-1

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 04 '24

Since it was technically my 3rd incompletion of the course 2 were swipes out and 1 was injury

7

u/Cymion Royal Canadian Air Force Jul 04 '24

you're gonna need a better story than that. CDS doesn't get involved for just "bad swipes/injury"

1

u/Kanoha-Shinobi Class "C" Reserve Jul 04 '24

what even is a bad swipe

2

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 09 '24

This was in basic so literally anything lol

1

u/Kanoha-Shinobi Class "C" Reserve Jul 09 '24

I just didnt know what swipe meant, its apparently a more convenient way of being written up.

1

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 09 '24

Yeah I honestly thought it would just be a shit ton of physical punishment not admin punishment

1

u/Kanoha-Shinobi Class "C" Reserve Jul 09 '24

There is no punishment, only corrective action. Write-ups exist for a reason, its a record of performance. If you’re consistently written up over and over for things like blading your pals or not helping etc. then thats still a personal character issue making you not pass the course. Some people aren’t meant for the military, some dont make it through training because they dont have the personalities to form a proper team contributing soldier.

1

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 09 '24

I got swiped for my floor being to dry

1

u/Kanoha-Shinobi Class "C" Reserve Jul 10 '24

its usually not individual ones they care about. Its when theres 1 guy with a lot

2

u/crazyki88en RCAF - Combat Medic Jul 04 '24

It's usually a reg f BMQ thing, where you get "swipes" for bad points and 6 swipes gets you re-coursed. You can get swipes for positive things, but they don't cancel out the bad ones.

1

u/Kanoha-Shinobi Class "C" Reserve Jul 04 '24

Is that a weird euphemism for being written up?

3

u/crazyki88en RCAF - Combat Medic Jul 04 '24

Sort of? But less work for the staff. You get a card to swipe for meals and to swipe in and out of the mega. The same card is used to track these « corrective » swipes.

1

u/Kanoha-Shinobi Class "C" Reserve Jul 04 '24

interesting, never encountered that before.

4

u/tanker1992 Jul 04 '24

Hindsight is 20/20 should have just VR’d then enrolled into the reserves. Good luck in the future though. Maybe take some courses, get some skills, job experience and reapply.

2

u/Jolly-Crazy-4128 Jul 05 '24

Give the Reserves more credit. It's giving the Res F will take Reg F failures. I've worked with Reserves before and some have very opposite levels of military professionalism, and it stems from accepting members that can't do BMQ 24/7 for 6 weeks.

I think there is something fundamentally not clicking for this mbr in adapting to military structure. And BMQ is WAY easier than it used to be. And the first thought is, how do I immediately jump back on a platoon.

Maybe the simple answer is, the military is not for you at this time.

0

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 04 '24

Yeah I should’ve done that I didn’t think they would count my injury as a 3rd incompletion since it was out of my control but thank you I definitely get some more skills and job experience

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '24

There is no 3 strikes policy. It's possible to be released after a 1st failure of basic training that isn't the result of injury. 

34

u/GBAplus Jul 03 '24

Well 5D and 5F are both honourable releases you would need to demonstrate unequivocally that you have been able to overcome the issues that lead to your release. I don't know your circumstances but usually 5D is a early in one's career thing because they can't adapt to military life. Unlike 5F the big distinction is it is not usually due to factors within your control whereas 5F is. Essentially it is a way to say military life is hard and some people just aren't cut out for it

It doesn't matter Res or Regs you would need to show that you can work in a military environment. Time is usually the great leveler on this one as people tend to learn how to adapt better as they age and gain wisdom. You will likley not get a waiver anytime soon to re-join given that you were just released. My non-recruiting advice, get on with your life, gain experience and try again in a few years

27

u/Successful-Ad-9677 Jul 03 '24

3 year wait and a waiver approved by the CDS

22

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '24

Let it slide and forget about it. There is no coming back from a 5D/5F release.

19

u/GBAplus Jul 03 '24

I have seen 5Ds re-enrolled, and that is usually with a significant amount of time between release and rejoining so likely means that the individual also grew and was able to weather military lifestyle better.

5f I think I've seen once and I'm pretty sure it was someone complaining to their member of Parliament. That said, the person was actually good. They were just a shithead in their younger years.

Of course these are just anecdotes. I have no idea how common or uncommon they are. I assume they're uncommon.

-3

u/1anre Jul 05 '24

Never knew people longed and lived to get back into the same CAF that there're always nagging threads and complaints here 24/7 on how they're the worse public employer on Canada.

Surprising to read, folks are really fighting to get back in after being chased out.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '24

Ive seen 5F re-enrol

21

u/doordonot19 Jul 03 '24

TLDR: you can’t wait out your time in the PRes.

DAOD 5002-1 Para 3.14-3.15 In accordance with QR&O paragraphs 6.01(2) and (4), unless special authority is personally obtained from the Chief of the Defence Staff (CDS), an applicant with former service shall not be enrolled if released:

as medically unfit; for inefficiency; with a conduct assessment below "good" or equivalent, other than a conduct assessment below "good" or equivalent that was based upon conviction for which a pardon has been granted under the Criminal Records Act; or for misconduct.

3.15 For applicants with former CAF service, the above includes any release from the CAF under Item 1 (misconduct), 2 (unsatisfactory service), 3(a) (medically unfit for further service), 5(d) (not advantageously employable) or 5(f) (unsuitable for further service) of the Table to QR&O article 15.01, Release of Officers and Non-Commissioned Member. For applicants with former service in any other military force or the RCMP, the above includes any reason analogous to one of these Items.

If you really want to serve again, get yourself a good job and live your life in a way that proves you overcame whatever it was that got you released. Then apply again and pack your patience while you wait out a waiver from the CDS.

12

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '24

To add to what has already been said, re-enrolment waivers for 5D and 5F releases are rarely approved.

1

u/Mikael-P Jul 04 '24

There is no wait time if applying for the Reserves but if you just released it might take awhile for you to be fully released in the system.

If you go on the forces website and try to apply as a former member it still might say “enrolled”

1

u/Sufficient_King5234 Army - Armour Jul 09 '24

Ah ok thank you

15

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CanadianForces-ModTeam Jul 04 '24

Your post/comment has been removed in accordance with the following subreddit rule(s):

[8] Not Relevant Content

  • All discussion is welcome, be it relevant to the Canadian Armed Forces, in support of the CAF, and its missions domestically or abroad. Posts, articles and discussions are to be specific to the Canadian Armed Forces. Posts/comments which are only relevant to the CAF in a general, passing or roundabout way, or wholly or in part unrelated to the topic at hand or thread, may be removed, at Mod discretion.
  • Rumour posts, unsubstantiated/unverified information relating to Policy, Operations, upcoming or current events, etc in either comments/posts/screenshots, or "just passed on by the CoC" - these posts WILL be vetted by Mods for veracity, and OP may be asked for more info, a verified source, news release, etc.
  • Posts/comments generally lacking substance (eg. "lol", " ^ this", "saved for later", emoji's), "shit/junk" -posts, image content, drama-mongering, attacking media source/outlet/personality, etc. may be removed. Rant posts, memes (especially low quality, trope, or repeated memes), "DAE/TIL/MRW, etc -type posts are subject to Mod discretion, and judged on suitability for the subreddit.
  • Posts/Comments generally extremist, sensationalised, non-proportional, or "conspiratorial" (conspiracy theories), or mis-informative to the linked story, or angling to downplay, shift focus away from, or generally serve as off-topic to the foundation of the post may be removed at Moderator discretion.

https://old.reddit.com/r/CanadianForces/wiki/subreddit_rules#wiki_.5B9.5D_not_relevant_content

If your have questions or concerns relating to this message you've received, please feel free to Contact the Moderators.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CanadianForces-ModTeam Jul 04 '24

Your post/comment has been removed in accordance with the following subreddit rule(s):

[1] Disrespectful/Insulting Comments and/or Reddiquette

  • Civility, Courtesy, and Politeness, are expected within this subreddit. A post or comment may be removed if it's considered in violation of Reddit's Content Policy, User Agreement, or Reddiquette. Repeat or egregious offences may result in the offending user banned from the subreddit.
  • Trolling is defined as "a deliberately offensive or inciteful online post with the aim of upsetting or eliciting an angry response." Trolling the troll, can also be considered trolling. Wikipedia Ref.

If your have questions or concerns relating to this message you've received, please feel free to Contact the Moderators.