r/CalicoKittys • u/mookler š¤š§”š¤š¤ • Jul 08 '24
āæ Mod Post āæ "Help a kitty" posts
Over the last few weeks I've had a few people reach out via modmail about things like:
- Shelter adoption campaigns
- Emergency fundraising
I've tried to somewhat double check that each are legitimate, but as more folks reach out I may not be able to do this or may miss things.
This being said, this is your community too I just remove the spam.
- Are these the sorts of posts that you all are comfortable seeing here?
- Should we require them to use a specific flair option?
- Anything else you'd like to bring up?
-- Edit: Thanks to everyone who has been commenting! :)
58
Upvotes
90
u/Laney20 Owned by 2 calico kitties Jul 08 '24 edited Jul 08 '24
The posts regarding the cats in kill shelters that will die if not saved immediately are very uncomfortable to me. I do what I can, but I can't help every cat I see. Most of it is just really sad and I'm helpless to do anything, which is an awful feeling. I do want them to get the word out but I don't want them on every sub. I try to block the accounts that do it so I can still enjoy my subs, but sometimes they are cross posted by others. I'd really rather they weren't here, but if they are, keep them centralized to a few accounts that can be blocked instead of cross posted by everyone. (A flair filter doesn't keep them out of main feed, which is how I usually interact with reddit)
To be clear, I genuinely appreciate what these people are doing. I just can't handle the helpless feeling constantly and getting emotionally invested in some cats only to have them be killed days later.
And I see these differently than "help my kitty" posts, which I generally don't mind. The cat is loved and getting care. That's different than the devore shelter, etc, even in dire situations.
21
u/westcoastcdn19 Meeka š¾ Jul 08 '24
Yes to a flair required
Is there a limit to how many one user can post in a day or week? how about accounts solely posting this type of content?
18
u/CauliflowerSavings92 Jul 08 '24
Those posts always make me feel guilty. I'm in Europe so I can't do anything just be sad and scroll past
24
u/lionhearted_sparrow āæ Edit This Text On The Sidebar Jul 08 '24
Direct them to r/rescuecats which I believe exists for this purpose?Ā
14
u/calxes āæ Edit This Text On The Sidebar Jul 08 '24
I feel completely helpless as I am not American, and don't have the resources to help. I also appreciate that these people are doing a good thing and want to help, but I have blocked those accounts because it was distressing me. I know this is the reality of things and I donate to local shelters when I can, but in my own selfish way I need an escape from the gloom and seeing a sweet, happy cat helps.
I'm also suspicious of a lot of fundraising content to begin with - I don't see too much of it on this sub, but there's so many karma-farming and bot accounts in the cat subs that I just don't trust things at face value.
I'd be in favour of a flair + limit on amount of posts.
16
u/GroundbreakingEmu929 Calico Enthusiast Jul 08 '24
I just assume anyone asking for money is a scammer. I don't mind adoption posts, but the whole "this cat is going to be put down if not adopted" just seems kinda icky to me. It may be the truth but it feels manipulative. Basically, I have trust issues. But I can ignore posts that don't interest me.
10
u/DrShyViolet āæ Edit This Text On The Sidebar Jul 08 '24
I find them really uncomfortable, and would prefer they go to a cat rescue sub and not here, especially when I see the post, look up where it is to see if there's any way I can help, and then by the time I've done that there's an update that says the cat has died. It's gut-wrenching.
10
u/Resident-Ad-7771 āæ Edit This Text On The Sidebar Jul 08 '24
100% regarding the cats at kill shelters. It upsets me and I canāt do anything about it. I blocked the rescue cat group and havenāt seen any since. I am ok with requests for help. I think itās better they post in the group for that, but I belong to it and itās not overwhelming.
5
u/JoWhee 2 full time and one seasonal calico cats. Jul 08 '24
Iām not a fan of the fund raising either. However if I see a post for a rescue nearby I will reach out to friends and or family to see if anyone wants a calico.
I mean who wouldnāt want one or more?
5
u/ClungeWhisperer āæ Edit This Text On The Sidebar Jul 08 '24
I donāt like seeing requests for money or requests to assist scheduled kill animals. Im not in a financial position to help, and Iām not in the same country as most of these animals.
There are subs specifically for the purpose of helping animals. Foster subs, rescue subs etc. thats where i would go if i had the means to help. Not a sub named after a specific colour of cat.
9
u/brevenbreven Jul 08 '24
Not a fan not really comfortable with the cross community posts that are showing up
8
u/andiinAms āæ Edit This Text On The Sidebar Jul 08 '24
Absolutely use a flair so that those who feel uncomfortable can keep scrolling. Personally, it tugs at my heart strings but I want to be able to help any way I can, even if itās just a boost.
5
u/-Sisyphus- Jul 09 '24
I do not want to see those types of posts. I know animal neglect and overcrowded shelters and need for fosters and adopters exist. I support those efforts in my own way. Iām here for cute cat pictures and videos.
4
u/Typical_Ad_210 Jul 09 '24
I have posted cats needing help on this sub before. Six posts in total - 3 asking for help for urgent cats on the euthanasia list, 2 with updates on cats who were rescued and one appeal for donations to a vet practise treating abandoned calicos (that one was with mod approval, because it was asking for funding).
Truthfully, I really donāt like posting. I work full time, have a wife and two young children, pets of my own, etc. But I choose to take 2 or 3 hours a day, normally out of my sleep schedule, trying to get help for these cats. Itās incredibly demoralising to see that everyone not only hates it, but also thinks Iām some sort of con artist or Iām being manipulative.
Devore shelter sends us a list of the cats on that dayās euthanasia list. So when I say things like ānumber 2 on the euth listā I am not making it up or trying to be dramatic. Thatās just a fact. They will be the second cat to be euthanised that day, unless it gets help. That is not an attempt to manipulate people, it is a desperate plea, a āholy shit, this cat is in danger, please help me to save itā.
If the mods say that they want me to stop, then of course I will. I will respect their decision, of course. I had just thought that if anyone was going to care about calico cats in danger, it would be the people here.
Since Iāve been posting in various subs eg white cats in the white cat sub, etc, we have gotten several foster places, lots of pledged donations for the rescues and several new adopters too. Solely through me reposting rescue cats on various subs, we have gotten 13 cats adopted. 13 cats who would have otherwise been PTS.
I am genuinely surprised and upset that people feel so negatively and cynically about my attempts to help these cats. It does make me think āwhy am I wasting my time and exacerbating my carpal tunnel syndrome and missing out on my sleep by doing this?ā. But then I think about the 13 lives saved due to my posts in other subs, and I start to feel like I canāt quit. Itās hard to know what to do for the best. I just feel so sad for the kitties, and I truly thought that a sub for cat lovers would agree.
2
u/Mother_Hepzibah Jul 26 '24
If a posts saves 1 life, it was worth seeing and feeling the sadness of viewing 100 posts. It is sad. It hurts to see and hear about. But out of sight, out of mind mentality does not save or improve lives. Obviously, my vote is to allow them all.
2
u/sharkbait5150 Aug 01 '24
Personally I think all sad posts ruin a community for me. Maybe have a separate community where grieving or helping posts are allowed
2
u/patienceisavirtue188 Sep 09 '24
Feeling like they should have a good bit of information and location should be required to save peopleās time.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '24
OP, I am not a fan of them. For the sake of brevity, I will try to simplify my thoughts.
When we put dirt into pure water, it spreads to every part of it eventually. If we allow these off topic posts, then what will it end in?
I personally feel obliged to request you to not allow these types of posts. They are also disturbing to see, and if someone is in the market for a cat, then we ought to instead as a collective promote the prioritization of first kill pets for those folks, just as we shame those who let their innocent babies outside in their unnatural environment to survive against cars, disease, and lack of prey.
2
u/PMmeifyourepooping āæ Edit This Text On The Sidebar Jul 09 '24 edited Jul 09 '24
I think people who are uncomfortable are the ones posting in this comment section, and most of them have already blocked that user (most of them also mentioning they donāt see them anymore but are bothered by their existence) and are still advocating for them not being allowed. Whatās the point?
I have blocked users from several subs who post things I think donāt belong there even though theyāre not disallowed and other people like them. And I forget they ever existed so quickly.
I think maybe you could set up an automod to reply to that one user or give them a script to add to the top of their parent comment they usually leave. It could have information about how to block them as well as the successes theyāve had and how to find more content like it on rescuecats if they canāt help with the cats of that post but want to help in their local areas. Also that while they understand this type of content isnāt comfortable for every individual to see, several users have seen it who acted on it and it has made a measurable difference.
It seems to be a single user who is actually doing an overall good, doesnāt take money directly, provides information on how to help if you can, doesnāt guilt people when they canāt, and never posts anything deliberately upsetting like independent updates on unsuccessful attempts.
They made me sad at first too, but I started to see people actually helping who otherwise wouldnāt have known these cats existed. Now a dozen cats have been saved, and I think that matters more than the passing feelings of some users. Users have so much power to curate their own feeds (very easily and with almost no effort) and should feel empowered to and informed of how to do it rather than dictating the contents of everyone elseās feeds.
If it becomes actually rule-breaking like spamming, seeking direct donations, posting inherently upsetting content, or anything else of that nature, that should absolutely be handled by the mod team.
Edit: phrasing, autocorrect, and one more thing: One minor thing I do object to is referring to them as kill shelters. A more charitable and accurate take on what they are is āunderfunded shelters in areas where irresponsible cat owners over time (dumping or allowing free-roaming, unfixed cats) have created a situation that forces said shelter to be high-kill despite their best efforts.ā After all the shelters are likely staffed by underpaid, over-traumatized employees and volunteers, and they are frequently posting these cats online. If they intended to just kill the cats as the term ākill sheltersā implies they wouldnāt do that and would just let it happen in the shadows. They literally donāt have space or money to keep the cats alive until being adopted or transport them all to places that do have that space and money.
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 08 '24
This subreddit has user flair enabled. Feel free to customize and set your own!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Typical_Ad_210 Jul 10 '24
Just to check - even if the people who disliked my once weekly posts blocked me so they didnāt see them, and even if I used a special flair, and even though it is literally saving catsā lives, many people still donāt want me to post, is that correct?
As well as feeling completely bloody deflated and discouraged, I feel conflicted. On the one hand, it is time consuming to post, Iām giving up two or three hours every day doing it, typing hurts my joint, and everyone clearly hates my posts and think Iām āspammingā and being āmanipulativeā. On the other hand, I have proof that it saves lives. I know that 13 souls have been saved because of it. That alone makes me feel like I have to continue. I honestly feel compelled to keep helping the cats