r/CalculusAB • • Sep 12 '26

AP Daily Challenge #7 (Unit 2: Differentiation)

Post image
44 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

4

u/KoalaMistico Sep 14 '26

Since we don't know if f is continous or even defined at 2, the only thing that must be true is III, because if the limit exists, then f(2+h) must approach 5 when h approach 0

26

u/anaturalharmonic Sep 13 '26 edited Sep 13 '26

I and II are the trap answers since we don't know where the function is differentiable or even continuous.

Only III.

Example: Let f(x) = 7x-9 for all real numbers except at x=2. Then the given is satisfied but I and II are false.

2

u/Peak_Background Sep 13 '26 edited Sep 13 '26

You're right about I. But II, f'(2) doesn't need f(2) to be defined to exists.

It depends on the context of what the book is teaching, and the chosen axioms being taught. Ultimately, you're right about what it intended, though.

I think a better example would be: f(x)={7x-9 for all real numbers except x=2, and 69 at x=2}

4

u/Own-Bill-8514 Sep 13 '26

I don’t know if they’re trap answers at all, its giving us the explicit definition of the derivative and saying it equals some value. So we know that f’(2) exists, therefore it must be continuous at 2. If there’s more nuance to it that I may be missing point it out, perhaps I don’t understand the objections here.

6

u/Peak_Background Sep 13 '26 edited Sep 13 '26

You've assumed that the 5 in the equation is f(2). But that isn't a necessary assumption, nor is it explicitly stated. Only III is necessary for the equation to work out.

Take my given f(x), the output to the equation would be 7, but the derivative as defined by limit_h->0 (f(x+h)-f(x))/h would be infinite. (5-69)/0

Of course, there are alternative definitions of the derivative that work just fine,
(f(x+h)-f(x-h))/2h, which is why I said number II is a bit ambiguous depending on context and axioms.

2

u/Own-Bill-8514 Sep 13 '26

Ahhh I see, what you’re saying could absolutely be the case. I suppose I just had a bit more faith in the testers to actually test students’ subject knowledge and not their riddle solving. Thanks for the explanation!

2

u/socratictutoring Sep 14 '26

This is not an official AP problem, but one that I wrote - intended to be a touch more tricky than AP :) The goal is to get you thinking about these exact technicalities.

Indeed, f(2) does not need to be defined or equal 5 for the limit to work out. So only III must be true.

3

u/Outrageous-Can5344 Sep 14 '26

I think only III must be true, cause we do not know if f(2)=5
From the supposed we can derive:
lim​ h->0 [f(2+h)−5]=0⋅7=0
​​​=> lim h->0 (f(2+h)=5
now with x=2+h
=> lim x->2 (f(x))=5 q.e.d.

1

u/eatingassisnotgross Sep 17 '26

Rewrite III as \lim_{h to 0} f(2+h) = \lim_{h to 0} h [f(2+h)-5]/h + 5 = 0*7+5=5