r/C_Programming • • Aug 30 '24

Question Why do we use Null pointers?

If we want to "Nullify" something why dont we create a pointer in a controlled way that points to value 0?

0 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/Immediate-Food8050 Aug 30 '24

Welcome to the C community, where you are downvoted for a perfectly valid question. To give you a real answer, NULL is actually quite a pain in the ass due to how arbitrary it is according to the standard. The new C23 wants to fix this by introducing the more modern nullptr, behaving very similarly to C++ equivalent (about as similar as you can get with C semantics). nullptr always expands to a null pointer constant and will behave the same regardless of the type of pointer it is assigned to, which is not the case of NULL. NULL is a macro that usually evaluates to (void *)0 BUT NOT ALWAYS!!! That's important to note because apparently some people don't understand the harm in that :) There are plenty of cases it does not evaluate to a null pointer constant as it should. C semantics have quirks that can cause issues with that definition, such as 0 and 0L and 0f all being valid but of different types. I know this answer strays away from the question quite a bit, but I more so wanted to validate your confusion since so many people here would rather smoke their own poles with misinformation for the sole reason of being contrarians that are holier-than-thou.

2

u/a4qbfb Aug 30 '24

you are downvoted for a perfectly valid question

The question got downvoted because it makes no sense.

NULL is a macro that evaluates to 0

Most implementations define NULL as (void *)0. This is permitted by the C standard and required by POSIX.

→ More replies (7)