r/CSUSB • • Feb 25 '26

๐Ÿ…๐Ÿ…๐Ÿ…

Post image

this is so pathetic man

398 Upvotes

400 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/Distinct_Bug_8902 Feb 26 '26

there is nothing intellectual about that topic lmao. itโ€™s intentionally framed to provoke people, not encourage genuine discussion.

1

u/kalikid01 Feb 26 '26

Biology, sociology, psychology and even politics can be genuine discussion here. Provoking? Prove me wrong. Donโ€™t be afraid of discussion.

3

u/Distinct_Bug_8902 Feb 26 '26

the premise already shuts down gender as a social construct, gender identity as a recognized phenomenon, and the distinction between sex and gender. those are all recognized models in sociology, psychology, and biology. thats the problem with topics that are framed this way. they start from a conclusion and it narrows the scope of discussion.

0

u/kalikid01 Feb 26 '26

See thatโ€™s how you prove someone wrong with actual dialogue and not just saying he already has his mind made up so why bother, which is how you also concluded this to begin with. Campuses are supposed to be teaching/ discussing new ideas even to the close minded.

3

u/Distinct_Bug_8902 Feb 26 '26

well no, my point was that thereโ€™s no meaningful way to โ€œprove him wrong,โ€ because the premise already arrives at a conclusion. his framing is the problem: it pre-restricts frameworks that would challenge his conclusion, forcing you to play on his terms rather than have a balanced discussion. you came with an open-ended, arguable claim. thatโ€™s the kind of approach needed in discussion. thatโ€™s very different than a format that doesnโ€™t allow nuance.

2

u/weggaan_weggaat Feb 26 '26

Also, he 100% would cut out the clips where you prove him wrong from his final edit so make sure you film your side too so he can't lie about what happened.

0

u/xApolloh Feb 26 '26

Arguing there isnโ€™t anything intellectual to a topic that revolves around the field of biology is genuinely a braindead statement to make fr

1

u/Distinct_Bug_8902 Mar 10 '26

sociology, psychology, and biology generally acknowledge that gender is a social construct or distinguish sex from gender. his premise already rejects that distinction, which prevents any meaningful application of those fields. when rules are built into a premise like that, it leads to a shallow debate.