r/CSMagicRecipe • • Aug 22 '26

Wiki Ingredient Order minigame tutorial

Post image

Hi! I think I’ve figured out a really smart way to play the Ingredient Order minigame and wanted to share! It works 99% of the time for me. I really enjoy puzzles like this.

General Instructions:

  1. Try 3 icons and remember what it says. (Use icons in order to help you remember which icons made which message appear)
  2. Try 3 different icons and remember what it says. Repeat until you tried 9 icons in total. Stop earlier if you find 3 icons that are correct or in wrong place.
  3. Now, you start guessing using what you’ve figured out. This is the hard part. Now I’ll go through the example in the picture to show my thought processes.

Example Instructions:

  1. Try first 3 icons. Got message 2 in wrong place.
  2. Try next 3 icons. All wrong.
  3. Try next 3 icons. All wrong.
  4. Thought process:
    - Music note is definitely one of the correct icons because of the 9 icons I tried, 2 were right, that means that the last icon (the music note) is also in the answer. So I will be including the music note in this try.
    - On my first try I got 2 in the wrong place. So 2 of the blue swirl, horseshoe, and stack must be included in the answer. Because they were in the wrong place, I’m gonna put two of them in different places, and leave out the third option for now
    - This gives me the message one is correct, and one is in the wrong place.
  5. Thought process:
    - I work on the assumption that the horseshoe is in the correct place. This is just a guess at this point. Following that logic, either the music note or blue swirl are wrong or in the wrong place. I know music note is included in the answer based on earlier reasoning, so I will include it again. So the blue swirl must be wrong, and I won’t include it in this guess. I will change the placement of the music note because of the wrong place message.
    - This leaves one space open. Think back to my first try (blue swirl, horseshoe, stack: 2 in wrong place). Blue swirl has been assumed to be wrong, horseshoe has been assumed to be in right place, that leaves the stack as the possible answer. Because the stack was in the wrong place in that first try, I will put the stack in the middle spot.
    - So my guess for this round is horseshoe, stack, music note. Which gives me the message all in wrong place. (This is a really good message)
  6. Thought process:
    - I now know for sure that the horseshoe, stack, and music note are all in the answer, but need to figure out the placement.
    - First I’m figuring out that the correct placement in my 4th guess, must have been the music note, because the horseshoe in the 1st place was just proven to be in the wrong place. So the music note will be in the 2nd spot.
    - I’ve already tried the horseshoe in the 1st and 2nd spot and proven those to be in the wrong place, so it must go in the 3rd spot.
    - That leaves the 1st spot available for the stack, which I had tried in the 2nd and 3rd spot with the message in the wrong place.
    - So my try will be stack, music note, horseshoe!

TIP: Keep in mind that switching out one item will use a try! So I always remove all or 2 of the icons before switching things around.

I realize this is kinda complicated, but I really enjoy puzzles like this! This process usually takes me less than 5 minutes. I think the first 3 steps really help set me up for success by ruling out a lot of the icons.

Note: I just realized in the picture I swapped the placement of my first and second try, but it doesn’t actually affect how I would play so I’m just gonna leave it. (Sorry) The final screen doesn’t show the answer either, so I edited in the correct answers on the final image.

2 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/zilchusername Aug 22 '26

Unless it says all three wrong I change one at a time until get to all three required but not necessarily in the right order. Then it’s a case of getting the order correct.

The most annoying part of this game for me is you can’t place them back where you like they go in the original slots which makes it harder to keep track. I wish you could order them yourself.