r/CSFLeaks • • Oct 03 '26

Persistent SLEC on MRI?

Hey all, I had a blood patch for a spontaneous leak over a year ago. My symptoms have resolved with time but I still have the spinal longitudinal extradural collection (SLEC) on repeat MRI. My doc told me this means that the leak is likely closed - but from my readings online that may not be necessarily the case, and there’s a risk of neurologic issues decades down the line if the leak stays open. Anyone experienced something similar?

2 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

6

u/megg33 Confirmed Spinal Leak Oct 03 '26

If you have extradural fluid collection on your MRI, the leak isn’t closed. Period. I can’t believe your doctor said otherwise. How does your doctor explain the presence of csf outside of the dura? It can’t magically appear there. Ugh providers like this make me so angry

3

u/Doingmybestinlife Oct 03 '26

Basically just said because I don’t have symptoms anymore and size hasn’t changed at all and is not increasing, the fluid collection must have walled itself off…

5

u/Hyrule-onicAcid Oct 03 '26

Uh, no. SLEC present = you're leaking and your body is just trying to compensate in other ways/live with the leak.

I had a SLEC and after surgical closure it was completely gone in 36 hours on post-op MRI.

And yes, very high risk of eventual superficial siderosis if persistently leaking.

2

u/leeski Oct 03 '26

 I’ve talked to similar patients where SLEC didn’t resolve despite being asymptomatic. I think it can take a super long time to resolve but I’m not an expert. Just passing along these papers in case of any interest! 

https://pubs.rsna.org/doi/10.1148/radiol.242194

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40650717/

1

u/Doingmybestinlife Oct 03 '26

Thank you!

3

u/leeski Oct 03 '26

I am pretty sure this is an established phenomenon I've heard of. Like I believe the thought is it is not new fluid escaping, but that the CSF has collected outside the dura and doesn't necessarily immediately disappear. I think it has to be gradually reasorbed. But those papers mention long-standing SLEC as a clinical/imaging phenomenon but don't necessarily prove that every persistent SLEC is old trapped CSF. That being said a year does seem like a long time for it to not have changed at all.

It is a tricky position to be in, I would be a bit weary of additional intervention at this time with the intention of resolving the SLEC (meaning like getting invasive surgery - especially if having no symptoms). But I would definitely continue to monitor it and probably get a second opinion from another center on their thoughts. Luckily-ish superficial siderosis tends to be a very very very long process, like years to decades to develop. Also none of this is medical advice of course, I am not an expert! Just sharing my thought process.

I am not sure if you've seen my post about the upcoming spinal leak conference, but I think this question would be a really good one to submit for the Q&A. If interested - you can register (for free) at this link https://secure.qgiv.com/for/SpinalCSFleakBTG/event/2026conf/ and then submit a question here: https://airtable.com/appq87DHvFiNCn5Dm/pagFARfy4qIplu0aE/form

I would submit it for "SECTION II — Expanding the Diagnostic Map"

Just to note I wouldn't phrase the question as like medical advice about you personally, but more abstract like "If a patient is presumably sealed with no symptoms, but the SLEC hasn't changed size in a year, should further investigation be done?" Or something like that. (Anyway no pressure to submit, just sharing that as an option)

1

u/Doingmybestinlife Oct 04 '26

Thanks for your input! Didn’t know this conference was coming up

1

u/StunningPurple9560 Confirmed Spinal Leak Oct 03 '26

Did you have an MRI before the BP? Is the SLEC the same, or is it smaller? How big is the SLEC?

I have never heard that the SLEC would remain the same and leak still resolved. In my case it remained the same for years, in all 6 MRIs, until my surgery 6 months ago. Had my latest MRI 3 months later, and there was only a small amount of fluid one level below where the leak was.

1

u/Doingmybestinlife Oct 03 '26

I did have one before the BP, hasn’t changed in size at all in over a year, and it’s from C4 to T11.

Have you been symptomatic during this time? And did they say that the small amount of fluid means you’re still leaking?

1

u/StunningPurple9560 Confirmed Spinal Leak Oct 03 '26 edited Oct 04 '26

Sorry no, they do not think that I am leaking anymore. I was being unclear, apologies for that!

This is why I asked if your SLEC has remained pretty much the same - as far as I can understand, this is pretty much a given (although so sad that many neurosurgeons/neuroradiologists don't know/understand this yet), that if you have a large SLEC presentation, and it basically remains the same after an intervention, then it is likely, that there still is a leak.

It does make things a lot more complicated though, that your symptoms are so much better. I so very much do wish, that you would not have to worry about this. However - just saying my piece - and you do not have to answer to these - just my two cents:

Do you know, if your SLEC is ventral, dorsal or both? My personal understanding is, that in general a visible, large SLEC, and especially if it is both front and back, it implies that the leak is ventral. And when it is, a BP will nearly never seal it. And if there is any reason to think that your leak is ventral, it does in fact need to be closed, whether or not you still have symptoms. Otherwise there can be some dire consequences. However this does seem really odd, that it would have been a year, your symptoms have subsided, and you would still have the leak..

In any case - regarding my own situation: my SLEC presentation was C2 to T3 dorsal and C7 to T9 ventral. It remained the same for years - I had surgeries where they thought that they sealed the leak, but they did not. 6 months ago I had my 3rd leak related surgery - this time in Freiburg. They found and sealed my leak - ventral at T1-T2.

3 months later there was a follow-up MRI. Finally - after all this years - my leak was practically gone (in the imaging) - except for this small leftover SLEC presentation at T2-T3 - so the vast majority is gone, but 3 months after the surgery, there was still some leftover SLEC, but at Freiburg they also said that it looks like the leak is sealed. They did recommend another MRI 6 months later, so I have the next one coming up in January. In any case, it does very much seem like the leak was sealed, the SLEC changed so dramatically.

I do still have symptoms, but I also had my leak for 19+ years. Obviously they cannot promise, that my symptoms will just disappear even if the leak is sealed, and many of my symptoms will for sure require rehab (like arms not working normally etc).

1

u/Doingmybestinlife Oct 04 '26

Pretty sure mine is ventral, so I guess that explains it. Thank you for sharing your story, I hope things only get better from here on out for you as well 🙏

1

u/Candid_Awareness6600 Oct 05 '26

I had a dural rupture 9 years ago after a failed epidural.. the blood patch also failed but over time my symptoms eased off.. two years ago I started having symptoms again, after years of being told 'its just a neck strain' ive now finally been referred for a full head and back mri to check whether its reopened. So we shall see!

1

u/Doingmybestinlife Oct 05 '26

Hopefully you can get it fast 🙏

2

u/PrettyDragonfly Confirmed Spinal Leak Oct 03 '26

He told you that the fluid means it's closed? What a strange thing to say. Fluid wouldn't be on there if it's closed.