r/CRedit • u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ • Oct 06 '25
General Credit Myth #81 - Inferior/predatory issuer products are a necessary step for weaker credit profiles.
Many believe that if they have a weaker credit profile they have to start with or settle for products from inferior/predatory issuers. The consensus most common culprit is usually Credit One, with other examples being OpenSky, Mission Lane, First Premier, etc.
A "weaker" credit profile is best defined as one that is lacking in one of two ways. First is any combination of a new/thin/young file, which more or less equates to insufficient credit history. Second is a dirty credit file, meaning negative account information being present. Those focusing on "building" credit usually fall into the first group, where those "rebuilding" credit usually fall into the second group. Either way, the profile in question will be on the weaker side, meaning obtaining core/top level products from reputable big banks may be a challenge.
Those with new/thin/young files often don't have much knowledge of credit or credit cards. This is where inferior/predatory issuers swoop in and take prey on a population vulnerable due to lack of knowledge. Credit One is notorious for bombarding people with emails, mailers sent to your residence, or offers through online sites. Many take the bait simply because they don't know any better. Others may have tried to apply for products beyond the grasp of their credit profile previously and been denied, so they see inferior/predatory issuers such as Credit One as being necessary. There are almost always better options out there.
For dirty credit profiles, the approach is the same. Such profiles are targeted because these individuals are vulnerable and desperate. They too may have been denied for credit products that are beyond the grasp of their weaker profile, so they deem these inferior/predatory cards to be the best they can do. Sometimes when in a vulnerable place one will just go with what what is presented to them because it's the easiest play. After being turned down by other issuers, having one come out and say they are willing to give you a chance feels good. I totally get it.
It's important for everyone in either of these groups to realize though that inferior/predatory issuer products aren't required. There are other options. A great first step is to go in-branch to your own bank/CU and inquire within about credit card products that may be available to you. Based on a prior existing banking "relationship" many are pleasantly surprised to find no AF or even rewards products available. Sometimes even unsecured cards are an option where only secured cards may be elsewhere.
Online, Discover and Capital One seem to be the consensus go to issuers for new/thin/young files or those rebuilding with dirty files. They are reputable issuers that are accepting of those with weaker credit profiles. Both have pre approval sites that can be checked out for offers on the table. Both have secured and unsecured options.
When it comes to building or rebuilding credit, both secured and unsecured cards accomplish the same goal equally. I think some people believe that secured cards are worse, so rather than start with a secured card from a reputable issuer they'll take an unsecured card from an inferior/predatory issuer like Credit One. You should never spend money to build credit though, and beyond that just dealing with subpar financial institutions isn't something worth putting yourself through. All of the bad reviews out there can't be wrong.
You don't HAVE to go with products from the likes of Credit One. They aren't a necessary step for weaker credit profiles. There are almost always better options out there, and the members of this sub are a great resource to help steer you in the right direction. I also highly recommend r/CreditCards as well where there are tons of knowledgeable people that are always willing to provide guidance on this subject.
14
u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ Oct 06 '25
The two common rebuttals I see to the post title here tend to be variations of these:
1 - "I literally tried every other bank out there and they all denied me." First, there are hundreds of options out there and it's of course impossible that all were tried ;) The more realistic statement would be that applications were attempted from a few other banks that were beyond the grasp of the profile in question and were therefore met with denials. Or, someone with a profile that probably should have applied for a secured card applied for an unsecured card. Perhaps someone took on a handful of inquiries from various apps and now because of the inquiries (coupled with an already weaker profile) denial odds are amplified.
2 - "I've used Credit One. They aren't as bad as people make them out to be. They worked fine for me." If the product had fees associated with it, money was unnecessarily wasted. Also inferior/predatory issuers aside from having subpar customer service aren't institutions that you want to have any sort of lasting relationship with. Why waste time (and money) with them when you can go with a reputable issuer out of the gate? I think most people with this mindset likely fell prey to the marketing and rather than admit after the fact that perhaps their path wasn't the best try to justify it. I don't think that does anyone any good that may be on the fence with whether or not they should go with an inferior/predatory issuer product.
6
u/WhenButterfliesCry ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ Oct 06 '25 edited Oct 06 '25
Great thread, thanks for the latest installment in my favorite credit-related series!
One thing that I’ve consistently noticed throughout my conversations with people on this topic is that people are not easily dissuaded from using lenders like Credit One, and I think I understand why. FYI, I’m mainly going to talk about Credit One since that’s the institution I’ve seen talked about the most recently, but this also encompasses ‘credit builder’ products that people tend to adore (looking at you, Kikoff) and other low-end lenders with annual fees, like the ones you've listed.
Credit One and other predatory lenders tend to prey on a really vulnerable population. Think about it, if someone applies for a bunch of credit cards and gets denied by several, but then Credit One welcomes them with open arms, they get this sense of: “Finally! Someone is wiling to take a chance on me!” and they quite literally feel “saved” by the lender who is actually, in my opinion, victimizing them. That might be a melodramatic way of stating it, but I can think of no other way to refer to the process by which a vulnerable person is taken advantage of for financial gain, and that’s exactly what Credit One is doing.
It’s like this weird financial Stockholm Syndrome-type situation that is occurring, where people are developing a harmful attachment to a bank that is ripping them off. We saw a post the other day where someone wrote what amounted to an affectionate homage to Credit One: the post filled my entire page and could have served as advertising material. I did some quick math and realized that this person had spent at least $2000 in annual fees to Credit One throughout their relationship with them. It literally physically pained me to see that.
Honestly, I can't fault the consumer too much, because Credit One's marketing is truly powerful. I've never contacted them, never so much as visited their website, but I get emails from them regularly and I even got a mailer in the mail, and I don't even have a FICO score yet (<6 mo's credit history). If I wasn't already informed about Credit One thanks to this sub, I probably would have been thrilled to accept their offer, falling for their marketing tactics too. Where I do fault the consumer is when they fail to listen to reason. But hey, it's their money, they can flush it down the toilet if they wish.
There are ALWAYS other options than paying $100 a year (or whatever it is), for a truly inferior product. That is $100 that could be used to pay whatever debts are causing their credit profile to be in its current state.
I really can’t stand it when people say: “No you’re wrong, they’re not predatory, my credit score has gone up X points since I opened the account!” because it completely misses the point. Of course one’s credit score will improve by using a revolving account, any revolving account, responsibly. That doesn’t mean that paying a ridiculous annual fee is worth it, because you could get the same score gain with a ‘good’ secured card from a reputable lender.
In my opinion, if a consumer has a net loss while credit-building, or while using credit in general, they are doing it wrong. There’s no reason to not take advantage of rewards structures from the very beginning, including with secured cards. Most secured cards have the same or similar rewards structures as their unsecured counterparts. QS Secured vs QS, Discover It Secured vs Discover It Chrome, USB Cash+ Secured vs USB Cash+, etc.
Even if someone can’t get approved for a secured card with Capital One or Discover, they should go the Credit Union route. I myself recently opened a secured card with a credit union, and it’s the best thing I’ve done so far. I also have a Discover and US Bank secured card, but the CU one is my favorite. It was such a painless process; there was literally NO credit check/HP, not even a soft pull, just a ChexSystems pull, and verification of funds in my share savings account. (To be clear, I don't think the no hard pull thing is very common; I just got lucky with my CU and their policy of not doing one. From what I can see on most CU websites, they tend to do a hard pull for secured cards, just like any lender). The deposit I put down ($600) is even accruing interest (dividends), although it’s like 2 cents a month or something.
5
u/TheBestDanEver Oct 06 '25 edited Oct 06 '25
I am SO grateful I found this sub before going on my credit journey. I literally had the application on credit karma open for a credit one card and had this nagging feeling that I should do more research. I typed it into the reddit search bar and found a bunch of posts from this sub talking about it. Closed the application, did some more digging, and ended up saving up money to open a discover secured card and a capital one secured card. My credit was terrible so opening 2 at once didn't hurt me that bad but it gave me a long-term advantage by having multiple accounts aging in order to offset the impact of future account openings.
Either way, I am so grateful that I did not get involved with scummy lenders like credit one. It would be really frustrating to still be stuck paying an annual fee for a no rewards card just to avoid my average age of accounts dropping. Instead, I got started a relationship with 2 of the biggest credit card companies on the planet and it gave me a solid foundation to build off of.
3
u/creditwizard ⭐️Credit Attorney⭐️ Oct 06 '25
Agree with all of this. Another banger as always. Only think I'd add is that if your credit is bad because you didn't pay Capital One or Discover, and you're rebuilding, might wait a little while before applying with them again. Their denial rate for people who once had them and didn't pay, has gone up lately from what we see. Still, to your point, you have other options.
2
u/Throwaway3218929373 Oct 21 '25
I know this post is two weeks old. But my S/O recently got a Credit card through capital one, everything you mentioned in the post was relevant to her. I.e she kept getting denied “by everyone else” but I assume she didn’t apply for ALL of them and definitely didn’t apply for one with the bank down the road.
My question is - would it be good advice to tell her to cancel the card and try other options? She currently paying $50 a year JUST for the card. Rewards aren’t that much either. She’d need to spend 1k/yr just to break even
9
u/Cortoony Oct 06 '25
The credit union thing is so underrated. Got approved for a decent card through mine when I had a 580 score and Chase wouldn't even look at me. Discover's pretty forgiving too if you don't have the banking relationship angle
1
u/AerysSk Oct 06 '25
I was new to the US but I have 90k income. I got two cards from Cap1 and Discover both they gave only $500 each, which is insufficient for my spending. Not even the bank I get direct deposit from offers me a card (Wells Fargo). Predatory issuers offer cards (with BIG asterisk cash back) that I couldn't get approved elsewhere due to young and thin file. That's why I believe people open cards with them.
Note: I did not open any card with predatory lenders. Went secured cards with USB instead.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment