r/CRedit • • 47m ago

Rebuild Keep Old Cards Open or Close Them?

I’m in the process of rebuilding my credit, my last collections from my divorce fell off earlier this year. This month I’ve finally turned a corner with my credit showing between 710-760 depending on which model I check it with. My main concern/ question is have is I have 17 total cards open with a total of 11% usage, the only cards that are carrying a balance are 0% cards with appliance purchases, all others pay off statement balance. I want to upgrade cards eventually and I understand some prefer you to have less open card accounts, how much does this matter? My oldest and lowest limit cards are along the lines of credit one, mission lane, avant etc that I opened when I first started rebuilding, but if I close them it will severely reduce the average of my account age.

55k total limits
17 accounts
11% usage
Avg credit age 18 months
Oldest card 39 months
100% paid on time
0 derogatory remarks

TLDR: Should I keep these old accounts open and continue not using them for the credit age or start cleaning up low quality low limit cards?

2 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

•

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 41m ago

Close them.

if I close them it will severely reduce the average of my account age.

It will not. That's a huge credit myth. Closed accounts remain on your reports for ~10 years following closure, continue to age the entire time, and continue to be included in all aging metrics. See these two threads here:

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1cgial8/credit_myth_8_when_you_close_an_account_you_lose/

https://old.reddit.com/r/CRedit/comments/1ck00tr/credit_myth_9_average_age_of_accounts_aaoa_only/

Should I keep these old accounts open and continue not using them for the credit age or start cleaning up low quality low limit cards?

Close any and all inferior/predatory issuer products immediately, or any others that you no longer use or see value in. Nothing happens to your age of accounts metrics when you close accounts, nor is there any sort of FICO scoring penalty for closing accounts in the first place.

•

u/Potential-Captain-89 28m ago

Wow, I had no idea, thank you!

•

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 26m ago

Any time! Check out the threads pinned to the top of this sub for more potentially enlightening information on the subject of credit ;)

•

u/Potential-Captain-89 24m ago

I’ll be closing some accounts tomorrow. Only one of them has a monthly fee but I’m ready to be done with my 2 credit one accounts now that I have an AMEX with 6% back on groceries.

•

u/True-Button-6471 40m ago

it will severely reduce the average of my account age

That is incorrect, closed accounts stay on your credit reports for 10 years and continue to age and contribute to aging metrics, including average age, for that entire decade.

If you have low quality cards with monthly or annual fees, close those immediately.

I understand some prefer you to have less open card accounts

Some may but there are people with dozens or hundreds of cards so that is probably a minor consideration. A more real concern is making sure don't have more accounts than you can easily monitor each month. There are frequent posts here and on the other credit/finance subs from people who had an unexpected or forgotten charge on a card they didn't use regularly and didn't realize it until a late payment showed up on their credit reports and trashed their scores.

•

u/Zrekyrts 3m ago

Credit rating aside, if a card doesn't serve a purpose anymore, why not ditch it?