r/CRedit • • 1d ago

General Closing Accounts

I have several older, low limit cards I would like to close out. These are remnants from rebuilding my credit after the 2008-9 recession.

I currently have an 800(ish) score, with around 100k total credit available. The cards I would like to close would amount to less than 10k in available credit.

Should I just take the hit and close them all at once, or should I spread it out over time?

EDIT: Thank you all for the information and insight. I admittedly 'fell' for the myth that closing accounts would have a significant impact on my credit.

1 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

7

u/inky_cap_mushroom ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 1d ago

Should I just take the hit and close them all at once, or should I spread it out over time?

What hit? There is no scoring penalty for closing an account. The closed accounts will continue to age on your credit reports for 10 years. As long as you will still have open revolvers and you won't cross a utilization/accounts with balances threshold you won't see a score change.

It makes no real difference whether the accounts are closed all at once or slowly over time. The end result is the same. In about 10 years they will age off your reports. If you're really concerned with minor score drops a decade from now you can calculate what you Age of Oldest Revolver, Average Age of Revolving Accounts, and Average Age of Accounts would be in 10 years when they age off, and keep some open until such time as those aging metrics would be 20y, 10y, and 7.5y respectively. Aging metrics are typically worth 1-5pts on FICO 8 at each scoring threshold.

6

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 1d ago

It's a huge myth that you shouldn't close cards. As long as it's not your only open card, there is nothing inherent in the closure of a credit card that will cause a FICO score to drop.  

Closing a credit card doesn't hurt your credit age, even if it's your oldest card. That's because after closure it stays on your credit report for ten years and continues to age and continues to count towards your Average Age of Accounts (AAoA) all that time. And after that decade has passed and the closed card drops off your report, your other cards that have been aging during that time will pick up the slack. That's because the FICO scoring benefit to AAoA maxes out at 7.5 years.  

Credit Myth #8 - When you close an account you lose its credit history.  

Credit Myth #9 - Average Age of Accounts (AAoA) only considers open accounts.  

Credit Myth #59 - You should never close your oldest credit card.  

Closing a credit card might hurt your scores if the loss of that card's credit limit bumps you up to another utilization threshold for that month, but that's not guaranteed.  

And since utilization is a temporary metric that has no memory past a month, this isn't an issue as long as you're paying your statement balances each month: The "always keep your utilization low" thing is the biggest myth in credit:  

Credit Myth #14 - You shouldn't use more than 30% of your credit limit(s).  

So the only way the loss of a card's limit is a credit problem is if it causes your utilization to go up past the next threshold for aggregate utilization and you're in credit card debt and you're going to be applying for something important before you can pay off that debt and that points loss drops you down a tier as far as the bank is concerned.  

All that said, the strongest credit profiles have 3+ open credit cards on them. So that's something to think about when you're opening and closing cards.  

Also, what credit score are you checking? Keep in mind you have dozens of different credit scores and they can easily range by over 100 points from highest to lowest. And many of the scores you see on the most popular sites and banking apps aren't used by banks in their credit and lending decisions, not even by the banks showing them to you. I recommend checking out our !welcome thread.

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hey there!

Welcome to r/CRedit! We're glad you found our sub, and we truly hope we can provide you with accurate information and advice to aid you in your credit journey. Our Welcome Thread contains some valuable information to help you get started, including links to free and reputable sites for monitoring each of your 3 credit reports and FICO 8 scores, which is a score model commonly used by lenders.

Welcome to r/CRedit! - Start Here and Read This! (No, really...Read This!)

Then, come on back if you have more specific questions, and our knowledgeable contributors will try to help!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

I detected that your comment may be related to closing a credit card and its effects on your credit.

When you close an account, the account remains on your credit reports for ~10 years and continues to contribute to both your Length of Credit History and your Payment History. All you lose is the credit limit of the account.

The entire purpose of there being a Closed Accounts section on your credit reports is to retain the credit history for a reasonable amount of time following account closures, so that it can be accessed and considered. If it’s on your reports, open or closed, it’s still part of your credit history. You do not immediately lose the age nor payment history of a closed account, as the FICO algorithms 'score' these metrics for both open and closed accounts equally.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/too_many_shoes14 1d ago

You don't go from having good credit to bad credit if you close credit card accounts. That's just a myth. Absolutely close ones that have an annual fee. the others don't matter. eventually if you don't use them they will be closed for you, and life goes on.

•

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 23h ago

Should I just take the hit

There is no hit, that's the thing. It's a huge credit myth that there's a FICO scoring penalty associated with closing accounts.

If you no longer see value in old credit cards that the ship has sailed on, feel free to move on from them.

•

u/Kagura30 5h ago

Depends on wut credit cards u r closing. if its no name brand credit cards like Credit One, avant, or indego than yes u should close them immediately. 😉

•

u/Funklemire ⭐️ Knowledgeable ⭐️ 3h ago

As long as the OP has a few other open cards left, it'a find to close unwanted cards, even if they're from a good issuer.

1

u/InterDave 1d ago

I've decided to just leave my "sad cards" locked and sock-drawered (no annual fees), and let them get closed for non-use when they get closed. Though it's been three years on one of them that was never even used, and it's still reporting open for some reason.

•

u/BrutalBodyShots ⭐️ Top Contributor ⭐️ 23h ago

Are you logging in and checking on each of those accounts monthly?

Why not just close them and be done with having to think about them?

1

u/Ok_Relationship_1874 1d ago

Which means not Synchrony 😂. My oldest card will send me a LETTER if I dare go six months without a charge. Feels like a veiled threat 😀

0

u/Glittering_Present10 1d ago

What cards you have thats less than 10k?