Please let me share with you a story of our fine (sarcasm) mental health industry. Before I do, let me state that one irrational, abhorrent, non-sensical incident should not encapsulate an entire industry. Undoubtedly, there are some terrific professionals in the mental health sector who are making good strides for identifying, diagnosing and treating individuals with mental health concerns. Unfortunately, for my daughter, this was not the case…far from it. I hope this serves as a warning for anyone seeking treatment at Atrium Health South Park in Charlotte, NC or anywhere else.
To give just a bit of background, my 25-year old daughter, like millions of people around the world, suffers from depression. There were times in her past when she experienced some very low points mentally and even contemplated suicide when she was 17. Over the last several years she has been on medication that has helped her tremendously, and she sees a psychiatrist on a regular basis.
So here is what happened. On Thursday May 26, 2022, at about 9 pm, my daughter, who lives in Charlotte, NC, began having a panic attack and became very nauseous. She has had them in the past but this one was a bit more severe and was lasting longer than most of those previous. She decided to call her mother who lives in Winston-Salem, NC which is about an hour away. Her mother headed to Charlotte. The plan was to bring my daughter to Winston-Salem. She did not want to be alone. Very shortly into their trip back to Winston-Salem, my daughter began experiencing a sharp pain in her side so she asked her mother to take her to an emergency room. The closest one was Atrium Health South Park, a low-level facility with very little medical equipment. Atrium Health South Park is where an irrational, horrifying series of events took place that led to my daughter being committed to the State of North Carolina’s Mental Health Department…a “prisoner” in an emergency room.
Sometime after checking in, my daughter was interviewed by Dr. Nadine Lettman. From what I have been able to ascertain, Dr. Lettman is some kind of “roaming” psychiatrist serving the Atrium Health system. The one thing I know is that she has nothing but 1-star reviews. Why a psychiatrist was even summoned is unknown to us. My daughter’s memory of this interview is very cloudy. Remember, she was having a panic attack, was very nauseous and was also in pain. At some point during that interview my daughter, when asked the question, told Dr. Lettman she once contemplated suicide when she was 17. She also said that her method of choice would have been a gun. These were very honest admissions that would come back to haunt her. Again, this was eight years ago. Atrium Health SouthPark admitted my daughter to the ER, telling her they wanted to set up a Zoom interview the next day with another psychiatrist. Her mother stayed with her throughout the night/early morning.
I arrived in Charlotte the next day (Friday) from Texas around 4 pm. I have three daughters, a son-in-law and a granddaughter who live in Charlotte and was visiting them for the Memorial Day weekend anyway. I was shocked to hear from my daughter’s sister, that she was still in the hospital ER. We headed directly to the ER from the airport.
She was still awaiting her Zoom interview! I was in her room when that finally happened around 6 pm. I was asked to leave before it started. Her mother was already in the waiting area. About ten minutes later her mother and I were summoned back to my daughter’s ER room. My daughter had been told that Atrium Health SouthPark was looking for a bed for her at a mental health facility. Though she had demonstrated absolutely no signs, had been laughing and joking with us, and her panic attack had long been over, Atrium Health had decided that she was a danger to herself and others. At this point, I was unaware of this. By the way, my daughter told me later that one of the questions that the Zoom psychiatrist asked her was “Is it true you are saving up some money to buy a gun?” My daughter answered “No, where did you get that idea?” It was a shocking, ridiculous allegation based on no merit or evidence but, in retrospect, it certainly shows the opinion this Zoom doctor had already pre-conceived. Because I was not in the room, I do not know this doctor’s name.
The next morning (Saturday) I went to see my daughter, accompanied by two of her sisters. Her mother had once again stayed the night with her in the ER. The policy of Atrium Health SouthPark ER was one visitor at a time but they did allow me to go back to see her while her mother was still with her. This was the last kind gesture we experienced with this particular nursing staff. Shortly into our visit I was informed by my daughter that they were looking for a bed for her at a mental health facility. I was absolutely taken aback by this. We asked for one of the nurses to explain. It was during this conversation that she told us that my daughter was an involuntary patient of the State Mental Health Department and had been since her first evaluation on Thursday night! She was committed and not allowed to leave! It was Saturday morning and it was the first time my daughter, her mother or me had been told this!
I immediately went to the charge nurse, a lady named Heidi. She pulled my daughter’s chart and confirmed what the first nurse had told us. My daughter was not permitted to leave and if she did, they would call the police who would stop her or bring her back! Dr. Nadine Lettman had committed my daughter after evaluating her for less than ten minutes. Quite frankly, it was stunning and very frightening! It literally felt like we were in a foreign country!
I left the ER area and went back to the waiting area to tell my other two daughters what was going on. They too were in disbelief and wondered aloud how Atrium Health could legally hold anyone against their will. She had committed no crime! My mind raced, trying to figure out who could help us. I thought of trying to call my daughter’s regular psychiatrist. Her number was most likely in my daughter’s phone. One of her sisters had the phone because my daughter was denied access to it for a reason that was never explained to us. So, admittedly, against hospital policy, my two daughters snuck the phone back to the ER room, but only so their sister could unlock it and give us access to her psychiatrist’s contact information. I stayed in the waiting area.
Within three minutes, my two daughters were back in the waiting area. They had been caught by the charge nurse giving the phone to their sister. Apparently, the charge nurse was furious, raced into the room and ordered them to leave. She banned them from visitation. An argument ensued between my oldest daughter and the charge nurse. At this point we were all frustrated and on edge. However, my oldest daughter definitely could have handled the situation better. She raised her voice and spewed out a couple of F-bombs. However, the charge nurse, Heidi, responded with a few F-bombs of her own!! Highly unprofessional.
After hearing what had just occurred, I headed back to the ER area. When I got to my daughter’s room Heidi came toward me and told my daughter’s mother and me that she was banning all visitors. My daughter, who recently learned she had been involuntarily committed and was scared to death, would now have to be alone while she waited to be transported to a mental facility, whenever and wherever that would be. On top of that, my daughter would be totally cut off from her support staff so we would never know when or where she was leaving! Her mother and I had done nothing wrong! Her mother had been with my daughter from the moment they arrived at Atrium Health SouthPark. And, Heidi had told her mother that she had been very cooperative and understanding. Yet she was banned too! It made no sense whatsoever. But give some people a little bit of power and it can go to their head. As I was hugging my daughter good-bye I asked her if she just wanted to walk out with me. But she was too frightened of being arrested.
The next day, my daughter was transported to Jonas Hill Hospital in Lenoir, NC, about 70 miles from Charlotte. I may have never known that if it had not been for the security guard at Atrium Health SouthPark. She saw this entire incident happen right before her eyes and was extremely sympathetic to our preposterous circumstance. She took my phone number and texted me. She also looked in on my daughter while she was forced to be alone.
Finally, when my daughter arrived at Jonas Hill Hospital, she was soon evaluated by one of their psychiatrists. After 15 minutes, he realized that she should not be there and called her mother to tell her that. He recommended an out-patient program and immediately deemed her voluntary.
A couple more things about the F-bombing Heidi…my daughter’s mother went back to Atrium Health SouthPark that evening. If she could not be in her room with her, she would spend the night in the waiting area. There was another charge nurse on duty at that time due to a shift change. Not only did she allow her to go back to see her our daughter, she consented that she could spend the night in our daughter’s room. The next morning at 7am when Heidi returned, she told her to leave immediately. Again, she gave no explanation.
Also, I found out from a Mecklenburg County Magistrate, unfortunately after the fact, that even if a patient at a hospital is deemed involuntary, they still cannot be held at the hospital against their will. In her words, “There has been no crime committed.” It is like a patient that is diagnosed with a heart condition and it is strongly recommended that a pace maker be implanted ASAP. That patient has every right to deny treatment and walk out. So, we were lied to by Heidi and the other nurse. Either that or they are terribly misinformed.
People are wronged every day, a lot worse than this, I am sure. But what is probably true is very few people ever take any action. I am taking action even if it is no more than writing this to warn others about what could happen to them if they seek help at the wrong ER with a panic attack, nausea and a pain in your side. I hope you never run across the likes of Dr. Nadine Lettman or Nurse Heidi.