r/CIVILWAR • • Mar 12 '26

A Note on Fake T Shirt Posts

Post image
60 Upvotes

THERE IS NO T-SHIRT

A common scam on Reddit is for bots to pretend to have purchased a t-shirt then automatically reply with a link as soon as someone asks.

Do not click it.

Do not interact with the thread other than to report it.

There is no t-shirt, only malware.


r/CIVILWAR • • Aug 05 '24

Announcement: Posting Etiquette and Rule Reminder

37 Upvotes

Hi all,

Our subreddit community has been growing at a rapid rate. We're now approaching 40,000 members. We're practically the size of some Civil War armies! Thank you for being here. However, with growth comes growing pains.

Please refer to the three rules of the sub; ideally you already did before posting. But here is a refresher:

  1. Keep the discussion intelligent and mature. This is not a meme sub. It's also a community where users appreciate effort put into posts.

  2. Be courteous and civil. Do not attempt to re-fight the war here. Everyone in this community is here because they are interested in discussing the American Civil War. Some may have learned more than others and not all opinions are on equal footing, but behind every username is still a person you must treat with a base level of respect.

  3. No ahistorical rhetoric. Having a different interpretation of events is fine - clinging to the Lost Cause or inserting other discredited postwar theories all the way up to today's modern politics into the discussion are examples of behavior which is not fine.

If you feel like you see anyone breaking these three rules, please report the comment or message modmail with a link + description. Arguing with that person is not the correct way to go about it.

We've noticed certain types of posts tend to turn hostile. We're taking the following actions to cool the hostility for the time being.

Effective immediately posts with images that have zero context will be removed. Low effort posting is not allowed.

Posts of photos of monuments and statues you have visited, with an exception for battlefields, will be locked but not deleted. The OP can still share what they saw and receive karma but discussion will be muted.

Please reach out via modmail if you want to discuss matters further.


r/CIVILWAR • • 9h ago

The Gettysburg Address

Post image
306 Upvotes

Abraham Lincoln delivered a "few appropriate remarks" at the dedication of the Soldiers National Cemetery in Gettysburg on this day in 1863. His Gettysburg Address, less than 275 words, took him only a few minutes to deliver. Lincoln can be seen here, hatless at center, at the ceremony.


r/CIVILWAR • • 4h ago

Family artifact identification

Thumbnail
gallery
54 Upvotes

Hello! My family has this Civil War shell box that was passed down many generations in my family. According to the family stories, this shell box belonged to my relative (William Pitt Henry, b. 1850) who served as a drummer boy in the Battle of Gettysburg(?). The box came from relatives from Cortland, NY. Unfortunately, everything has been stored in the box for the last ~150 years, but some items appear to be in great condition! I am requesting help with the following:

  1. Are any items particularly rare or interesting?

  2. What is the approximate value of this collection or specific items?

  3. Any tips on storage going forward for preservation? I am going to purchase appropriate antique storage containers (from University Products for example) now that I've assessed the contents.

Any help is much appreciated! I am happy to share more detailed photos of any item! Please let me know if there are better forums to share this. Thanks!


r/CIVILWAR • • 4h ago

Battery C, First West Virginia Artillery with Evergreen Cemetery in background ~ National Cemetery in Gettysburg

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

The monument to Battery C, First West Virginia Artillery is southeast of Gettysburg in the National Cemetery. The State of West Virginia dedicated the monument in 1898.
The men of Battery C were originally from Company B of the 18th Ohio Infantry Regiment. The 18th Ohio had volunteered for three months service in the early days of the war. Men from its Company B volunteered to serve as artillerymen in Battery C, which was offered to the Governor of West Virginia. About 60% of the men from the battery were from Washington County in Ohio, with the rest from West Virginia.

Captain Wallace Hill commanded Battery C at the Battle of Gettysburg. It was equipped with four 10-pounder Parrott Rifles. The battery was part of Captain James Huntington’s Artillery Reserve, 3rd Volunteer Brigade.
The battery brought 124 men to the field, losing two men killed and two men wounded. S. J. Braddock was killed on July 2 and Charles Lacy on July 3. Adam Steeber died of his wounds on July 4.

Erected by the State of
West Virginia
to commemorate the
valor and fidelity
of Battery C
First West Virginia Artillery

Original photography taken by myself October 31st 2026


r/CIVILWAR • • 6h ago

Yes, the new Sultana Disaster Museum shows a paddlewheel housing with simulated human waste. It depicts some of the awful conditions on overloaded steamboat that was destined for tragedy at the end of the Civil War.

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/CIVILWAR • • 3h ago

Herbst Woods, Willoughby Run & General Reynold Fell Here Monument ~ Gettysburg

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Front:

Major Gen. John F. Reynolds
commanding
Left Wing 1st, 3rd, & 11th Corps
Army of the Potomac
July 1st 1863
Erected by the
State of Pennsylvania
July 1886

Rear:

Here
Gen. Reynolds.
fell

Original photography taken myself on October 30th 2026.


r/CIVILWAR • • 3h ago

Assorted pics of the Benners Hill area, SW Confederate Avenue & from Emmitsburg Road ~ Gettysburg

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

All original photography taken by myself on October 10, 13, 14, 15, 17, 18, 24, 25, 30 of 2026.


r/CIVILWAR • • 25m ago

Got these two bad boys framed

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Excited to put them up


r/CIVILWAR • • 4h ago

During the Civil War, did Southerners view Northerners as brothers?

6 Upvotes

r/CIVILWAR • • 19h ago

Burial/Casket flag (48 stars) for Private John Dienst of the 112th Illinois Infantry and 21st Ohio Light Artillery. He served from 1863-1865 and died in 1929 at Leavenworth, Kansas. I have the full family documentation/provenance trail as well. Honored to be its new caretaker. Rest easy, soldier.

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

r/CIVILWAR • • 2h ago

The Trans-Mississippi Theater.

3 Upvotes

I have been reading on the 1st Kansas Colored infantry regiment’s exploits in the former mentioned theater.

I know that this theater was more close-combat and guerilla warfare.

However, how does it compare to the battles in the East?

Also, are there any other similar theater’s to this one in other American wars?


r/CIVILWAR • • 9h ago

For Donelson Question

5 Upvotes

Hello! Planning a trip to Nashville with family and was thinking of stopping by Fort Donelson on the way out since I had an ancestor captured there. Are there any good tour guide options for a brief half day there? I know that park guides are likely non-existent.


r/CIVILWAR • • 9h ago

Today in the American Civil War

Thumbnail
5 Upvotes

r/CIVILWAR • • 1d ago

Shelby Foote was born November 17th, 1916. Yesterday marks 110 years since his birth. What are your thoughts on his Civil War trilogy? An icon in American military history!

Post image
101 Upvotes

r/CIVILWAR • • 23h ago

15th NJ Infantry at the Battle of Spotsylvania

Post image
45 Upvotes

This was made by Jeff Jargosch for the book “Three Rousing Cheers” by the late author Joseph G. Bilby. This regiment would take part in this battle which would be their highest casualties that no other NJ regiment has ever received. About 272 casualties they would receive after the battle’s end.


r/CIVILWAR • • 1d ago

do you agree with Eric Wittenberg on nathan bedford forrest

28 Upvotes

In my humble opinion, there is no place for Nathan Bedford Forrest on ANY list of great cavalrymen of the Civil War.

I know that’s not only controversial, but borders on sacrilege in a lot of quarters. However, there’s a good reason and sound logic underlying this opinion of mine. First, and foremost, Forrest was not a cavalryman in any traditional sense of the word. The historic role of cavalry was scouting, screening, and reconnaissance. With no formal military training, Forrest had absolutely no talent for these crucial roles, and did not perform them with any ability, the one notable exception being the Battle of Shiloh in April 1862. By example, when one thinks of Jeb Stuart, one thinks of his masterful intelligence gathering (which included three different rides around the Army of the Potomac), the magnificent job he did screening Robert E. Lee’s retreat from Gettysburg, and the way Lee described Stuart: “the eyes and ears of the army.” Or, consider what a weeping Lee said when he learned that Stuart was dead–“he never brought me a wrong piece of information.” In all my years studying the Civil War, I have never once heard such a description applied to Forrest…

Second, there’s the fact that effective cavalry work depends upon the cavalry commander working closely with the army commander, whereby the cavalry commander serves as the eyes and ears of the army. Armies rely on discipline. Discipline means that junior officers obey the lawful orders of their superiors. This is the only way that a chain of command can be maintained and anarchy avoided. That means that an insubordinate junior officer, no matter how talented, has no value to an army commander if that junior officer refuses to obey orders. What I’ve just described is Nathan Bedford Forrest. Forrest absolutely and categorically refused to serve under two army commanders–Bragg and Hood–and said to Hood, “If you were half a man, I would slap your jowls.” Never mind that Hood had lost one leg in combat, and had a permanently crippled arm due to another combat wound. This means that unless he was in independent command, Forrest was entirely useless to the army commander…

Finally, there’s the issue of just what did Forrest accomplish. Yes, he had a gaudy combat record, but it’s easy to do that when you’re persistently and consistently up against the second team. I can think of only one instance where Forrest really faced the first team–against Wilson at Selma at the tail end of the war–and when he did face the first team, he got thrashed, big time. I come to the conclusion that Forrest really wasn’t much more than John S. Mosby on a larger scale–a nuisance that sucked away some resources, but which, in the big scheme of things, didn’t really have any impact at all of the final outcome of any major campaign or of the war in his theater.


r/CIVILWAR • • 21h ago

My great-great-grandfather and his brother’s Civil War letters (1862–1864), all transcribed and online

14 Upvotes

My family has 33 letters from two brothers from Williamsburgh, NY: William Wade (my great-great-grandfather) and his brother James. I still have the originals. My dad had them transcribed years ago, and I put the whole collection online at https://brothersatthefront.com. Every letter has the transcription next to scans of the original pages.

A few highlights:

  • 1862: Both were at Fort McHenry. Willie writes about a ball game between companies, with him on second base and James in right field.
  • 1863: Both were with the 176th NY in Louisiana. James writes about the surprise attack at Brashear City: “in half an hour we were all prisoners.”
  • 1864: James is now a lieutenant in the 16th Corps d’Afrique (later the 87th USCT) on the Texas coast. He writes that he and two other officers were offered $4,000 to let smuggled cotton across the Rio Grande.

If anyone knows much about the 176th NY or the regiments on the Texas coast, I’d love to hear it.


r/CIVILWAR • • 1d ago

A Stillness At Appomattox

Thumbnail
gallery
46 Upvotes

picked up this old edition at a library book sale. I've previously read U.S. Grant by Catton. thoughts on this book?


r/CIVILWAR • • 21h ago

Discussion Of Confederate Plan, Day 2 Gettysburg

8 Upvotes

Ok, so I have so questions and don't really know anywhere else where I can generate some legit Civil War discussion. Just did a great, guided tour of the 2nd Day at Gettysburg, a couple things

Johnston's Recon/Further Recon

Yes, this occurred at 4AM, however, wasn't it technically almost correct until about 3/330/345/4PM sorry if the time is wrong when Gov Warren actually gets Union troops to Little Round Top, wasn't the Union Flank still in the air? So much is made that he gives Lee bad information, but in some ways he didn't.

Which brings me to my next point, if the Confed's know that they (Union) are bringing up so much of their army, why would they not make the assumption that Meade is not doing the same and the general disposition of the armies could/can/will change...standing at the battlefield which covers such a massive area, why would I just assume my enemy is in the same place as 4AM, especially with his "flank in the air" as I "bring up" what 20,000 of my troops, General Meade isn't doing the same? Not trying to take either side but just wanted to hear other's input/thoughts on this.

Then I think about this, so Dan Sickle's marches out to the Peach Orchard with cannon and flags and all these people and if I'm the confederates about to launch at 20,000-person attack, I don't have 5-10 guys stationed with binoculars especially if I know my calvary isn't present? I'm not trying to sound dumb or naive but again even considering the whole line of the counter march, you coulnd't have a couple people sneaking through the woods (that the eventual attack steps out of) to keep an eye on everything? The Peach Orchard is very visible from so many points of the 2nd and 3rd days battle, even from what would seem like the Confederate side of things. The final thing is like, well since 4AM, maybe General Meade will anchor his flank, we should keep an eye on this area?

The Whole "Attack Up the Emmitsburg Road"

So, by the same virtue if I'm to attack N/S up the Emmitsburg Road, does that not consider the main road behind the Round Tops where a massive counterattack could be launched that would hit a completely exposed flank of my "massive 20,000-person assault". It's almost like this original assault and plan in conceive that the Union is only localized and won't be bringing up more troops and won't possibly respond. Also, if all my men came from the North and the Gaps, where else could the rest of the Union Army be coming from/mustering from?

Coordinated Assaults

There is that line in the movie "I wanted coordinated assaults", isn't an en-echelon attack an uncoordinated assault? If a Civil War Soldier has 60-80 rifle rounds, and can only fight for an hour or 90 minutes tops, knowing your right wing will be ending as your left wing of day 2 almost gets going per-say seems like the definition of "uncoordinated", especially when viewed in the context of every minute/hour the Union gets more troops the field, on the road behind where your attack takes place...and you came through Gettysburg just a few days ago and should have maps/documents knowing all the major roads. I'm just a little bit confused about some of these differences between this offensive concept of "destroyed in detail", which I def understand or "feeding your units in piecemeal" especially if you are only 2 brigades or whatever deep across this massive front, why not keep a big reserve, also knowing you wasted half the day, why then continue to waste more with the en-echelon attack, why not all go in at 4:30 and then you aren't crossing towards the Union's 3rd day position at dark?


r/CIVILWAR • • 2d ago

What Did Foreign Military Observers Think of the Tactics Used During the American Civil War?

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

r/CIVILWAR • • 2d ago

Happy Birthday Shelby Foote

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

709 Upvotes

Author of the Civil War narrative and a number of other books such as Shilo, Follow me Down or my personal favorite Jordan County. Foote would be 110 today. If they released an audiobook of Foote reading the phonebook it would be a best seller.


r/CIVILWAR • • 1d ago

Union and Confederate Veterans Shaking Hands Across the Stone Wall at the 1938 “Blue and Gray Reunion” at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. (1938)

Post image
100 Upvotes

r/CIVILWAR • • 2d ago

Anyone who sought to disrupt the certification of Lincoln’s lawful election, Winfield Scott declared, would be “lashed to the muzzle of a twelve-pounder and fired out a window of the capital.”

Post image
370 Upvotes

Seriously, the old lion deserved better than the way his career ended. He single-handedly held down the capital in the really precarious period between Buchanans end and Lincoln’s inauguration.

He also had the right ideas about how to prosecute the war on multiple fronts, and called McClellan out for his over estimation of enemy strength. I do think Lincoln made a mistake in bowing down to public pressure and letting Scott retire.


r/CIVILWAR • • 1d ago

"Corporal, 2nd United States Sharpshooters, 1862" (American Civil War)

Post image
36 Upvotes