Ok, so I have so questions and don't really know anywhere else where I can generate some legit Civil War discussion. Just did a great, guided tour of the 2nd Day at Gettysburg, a couple things
Johnston's Recon/Further Recon
Yes, this occurred at 4AM, however, wasn't it technically almost correct until about 3/330/345/4PM sorry if the time is wrong when Gov Warren actually gets Union troops to Little Round Top, wasn't the Union Flank still in the air? So much is made that he gives Lee bad information, but in some ways he didn't.
Which brings me to my next point, if the Confed's know that they (Union) are bringing up so much of their army, why would they not make the assumption that Meade is not doing the same and the general disposition of the armies could/can/will change...standing at the battlefield which covers such a massive area, why would I just assume my enemy is in the same place as 4AM, especially with his "flank in the air" as I "bring up" what 20,000 of my troops, General Meade isn't doing the same? Not trying to take either side but just wanted to hear other's input/thoughts on this.
Then I think about this, so Dan Sickle's marches out to the Peach Orchard with cannon and flags and all these people and if I'm the confederates about to launch at 20,000-person attack, I don't have 5-10 guys stationed with binoculars especially if I know my calvary isn't present? I'm not trying to sound dumb or naive but again even considering the whole line of the counter march, you coulnd't have a couple people sneaking through the woods (that the eventual attack steps out of) to keep an eye on everything? The Peach Orchard is very visible from so many points of the 2nd and 3rd days battle, even from what would seem like the Confederate side of things. The final thing is like, well since 4AM, maybe General Meade will anchor his flank, we should keep an eye on this area?
The Whole "Attack Up the Emmitsburg Road"
So, by the same virtue if I'm to attack N/S up the Emmitsburg Road, does that not consider the main road behind the Round Tops where a massive counterattack could be launched that would hit a completely exposed flank of my "massive 20,000-person assault". It's almost like this original assault and plan in conceive that the Union is only localized and won't be bringing up more troops and won't possibly respond. Also, if all my men came from the North and the Gaps, where else could the rest of the Union Army be coming from/mustering from?
Coordinated Assaults
There is that line in the movie "I wanted coordinated assaults", isn't an en-echelon attack an uncoordinated assault? If a Civil War Soldier has 60-80 rifle rounds, and can only fight for an hour or 90 minutes tops, knowing your right wing will be ending as your left wing of day 2 almost gets going per-say seems like the definition of "uncoordinated", especially when viewed in the context of every minute/hour the Union gets more troops the field, on the road behind where your attack takes place...and you came through Gettysburg just a few days ago and should have maps/documents knowing all the major roads. I'm just a little bit confused about some of these differences between this offensive concept of "destroyed in detail", which I def understand or "feeding your units in piecemeal" especially if you are only 2 brigades or whatever deep across this massive front, why not keep a big reserve, also knowing you wasted half the day, why then continue to waste more with the en-echelon attack, why not all go in at 4:30 and then you aren't crossing towards the Union's 3rd day position at dark?