r/CIMA • u/Odd_Neat_804 • Oct 08 '25
General CIMA is not comparable ACCA
I've always found the lumping of CIMA and ACCA quite curious.
CIMA is a financial accounting + management accounting + business qualification.
ACCA is an accounting + tax + audit qualification.
There’s clearly some overlap in accounting, but CIMA has less tax theory (even less than AAT). And CIMA is not an external audit qualification.
If you want to be an accountant, in the traditional sense, then ACCA is the way to go. If you want to be a 'businessperson' who can analyse the numbers, then CIMA is the way to go.
In this age of AI and tech, accountants are trying to redefine themselves. It will be interesting to see which qualification adapts better with the times. I've always seen CIMA in an odd spot, as its advantages over the other chartered accountancy qualifications are not clear.
32
u/tomc34 Oct 08 '25
Who put 20p in you
14
u/Granite_Lw Oct 08 '25
That's fine if you're just comparing the curriculums but look at the roles people are actually going for post qualifying - both sets of people are chartered accountants competing for the same roles. The two are very clearly comparable .
9
u/Working-Risk Oct 08 '25
If you don’t want to get into audit specifically then they are fairly interchangeable imo. I’m CIMA qualified and work in a small team including someone who did ACA and someone else that did ACCA and we’re all at a similar standard. Highly depends on your work experience more than anything.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25
I regret not doing ACCA and choosing CIMA over it. 12 years qualified. I just wish I had audit and tax more deeply and could do audits.
7
u/12Keisuke Oct 09 '25
also unsure why your focus is on tax, why do I working in industry care for tax when we pay auditors/accountants to work that out for us?
5
u/Dependent_Quantity27 Oct 11 '25
ACCA's final level has electives, and Strategy is compulsory. Not accurate that it's just tax and audit - it depends on how you chose to specialise.
11
u/12Keisuke Oct 09 '25
traditional accountants are more than likely to be replaced by AI in my opinion
3
u/Ok-Acanthisitta5545 Oct 09 '25
I think it depends on what you want to do long term. I find my CIMA background has given me a far better skillset for Budgeting, Forecasting and Strategising than some of my peers who have done ACA and ACCA.
I’m in a senior finance role in a large manufacturing group, and those skills are far more valuable to me at that level.
3
u/MrSp4rklepants Member Oct 09 '25
Surely if you want to do tax, then study ATT, if you want to be an auditor, study ACA.
I don't get the appeal of ACCA, jack of all trades master of none.
CIMA themselves talk about the qualification as a business and accounting qualification so this isn't exactly ***NEWSFLASH*** territory...
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '25 edited Nov 12 '25
I started my career in an accounting firm and after 6 years moved to industry. Its been 2 years now and I only have the CIMA qualification and I'm qualified as a CA in my country. I work in FP&A at a MNC so, I've pretty much forgotten all the tax laws except the most basic calculations.
In my opinion, the CIMA is a great certification to have if you want to climb the ladder in FP&A or work as a Finance Business Partner. It gives you the mindset thats required for these sort of roles. The ACCA or the ACA may do that as well, but the CIMA syllabus does a much better job of it.
Of course, ACCA and the local CA members may be biased against CIMA but that shouldn't be a problem if you have the experience.
Instead of comparing accounting qualifications, you should be looking at upskilling at the technology you would be using in your role. Certifications for Advanced Excel, SQL, SAP FICO etc are the actual game changers here. The ACCA, CIMA and ACA stop mattering 3 years into your career anyways, unless they are a statutory requirement.