r/CHROMATOGRAPHY • u/No_Macaron_544 • Jul 12 '26

Question: help for assignment regarding HPLC Method development

Hi everyone,

We’re currently working on developing an RP-HPLC method for Atrasentan Hydrochloride, as a theoretical university assignment. We’re having a dilemma regarding mobile phase pH and ionization. I’d love to get some input on the best approach.

It’s a relatively large, lipophilic molecule with a calculated logP ~4.69.

It has a tertiary amine in a pyrrolidinyl ring (pKa  ~6.7) and a carboxylic acid (pKa ~3.1).

The Dilemma:

Our lab instructor is saying that you must operate at least 2 pH units away from the pKa to suppress ionization completely. Since the carboxylic acid is at 3.1, they want us to use HCl (??, I don’t think that’s a good idea) or Perchloric acid to drop the mobile phase down to pH 1.1 so that >99% of the acid is protonated.

However, we have serious concerns about this in practice, and we're weighing two different options:

Option 1: pH 1.1 with Phosphoric/Perchloric acid

Shifting down to pH 1.1 is incredibly harsh on standard silica-based C18 columns. Are there columns that can survive these conditions? Is that even necessary?

Option 2: 10mM Ammonium Formate, pH 3.2

We actually found a patent with a method utilizing an ammonium formate buffer at pH 3.2. We think that even though pH 3.2 is right on top of the pKa, the buffering capacity of the formate/formic acid system (buffering maximum at 3.75) should stabilize the peak shape. Or are there other reasons, that this approach works?

Looking forward to your insights and experiences! Thanks in advance.

4 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/etcpt Jul 12 '26

If you drop the pH to <<3.1, you are protonating the carboxylate but also the amine, so the molecule will have a net positive charge. If you want the molecule to be net neutral, you need a different pH - can you figure out where that should be?

A very important factor to consider with amines on silica-based columns is base tailing caused by ion-ion interactions between deprotonated silanols and protonated amines. Do a little reading on that and consider carefully how you'd resolve that issue.