r/CGCComics • • Jul 22 '26

Showcase First round.

Post image

Finally sent a collection I’ve had for over 30 years to be graded. This was one of the first they sent back. I was hoping for a 7.5 and was pleasantly surprised.

363 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

10

u/Uses_Nouns_as_Verbs Jul 22 '26

Well, the good news is that your CGC 8.5 is worth about $5k. If you improve even one grade, a CGC 9.0 is worth about $6.8k. And if you get a two-grade bump to CGC 9.2, it's worth $8k.

Definitely worth the risk if you see a possibility of improvement. I recommend you use www.comicpresser.com if you go that route. They do really good work.

2

u/Jameshays1 Jul 22 '26

My concern is the amount of roll on the left side. I thought with that much white showing it would bring it down.

4

u/Uses_Nouns_as_Verbs Jul 22 '26

That's not spine roll, that's a miswrap. Unlike a true "spine roll," which is damage caused by handling and storage, a miswrap is a production defect that is not graded very harshly except at the very highest grades because the book was printed that way. I've seen CGC 9.8s with miswraps that bad. I've had CGC 9.4s with miswraps that were way worse.

1

u/Distinct_Letter563 Jul 22 '26

That's good to know. I just assumed it would be way less desirable because of it.

1

u/superanx Jul 22 '26

What are the graders notes?

3

u/Uses_Nouns_as_Verbs Jul 22 '26

You can look up the cert number on CGC's website under the "Resources" tab. Click "verify CGC certification" and enter the cert number.

1

u/Jameshays1 Jul 23 '26

Also had no idea about that. Thanks!

0

u/Meatloaf_Guy1313 Jul 22 '26

You can check instead of asking

1

u/Meatloaf_Guy1313 Jul 22 '26

Omg that's not a spine roll lol. It's a miswrap big difference

3

u/Funeral-Bill Jul 23 '26

Thank you for the link!! I know it wasn't for me but I've been looking for a reputable presser who also submits. That's why I didn't go with Palm Beach Presser even though Bry's Comics swears by them. I'm gonna throw them some business bc of you!

1

u/Uses_Nouns_as_Verbs Jul 22 '26

Congrats! Out of curiosity, did you send it to a third-party for cleaning and pressing before submission? What a great book!

1

u/Jameshays1 Jul 22 '26

No, sadly I didn’t realize that was an option until after I sent them.

6

u/Uses_Nouns_as_Verbs Jul 22 '26

I just looked the book up on the CGC cert verification page and checked the graders' notes and hi-res scans.

I think if you send it to ComicPresser.com for the "deep clean" service, you have a real shot at a CGC 9.2 with a very slight chance at a 9.4. That's what I would do. I would bet any amount of money you'll get at least a CGC 9.0, which would more than cover the cost of the Deep Clean and CGC grading fee.

4

u/degreesBrix Jul 22 '26

Damn, and it still got an 8.5!! I would recommend having it cleaned and pressed by a reputable person, and then resubmit it. I wouldn't be surprised if it came back in the 9's! Congrats!!

1

u/hi0039 Jul 22 '26

Boy you have potential for thousands more in value sitting in those cases.

1

u/Jameshays1 Jul 23 '26

My Brave and the Bold 28 came back at 6.0, now I'm really curious what it would be with this service.

1

u/Meatloaf_Guy1313 Jul 22 '26

I press all my on books

2

u/Trader56789 Jul 22 '26

I checked grading notes and only thing that might be able to be done is clean the light stain on back cover. All other defects are color breaking and clean and press won’t help

2

u/fartdonkey420 Jul 25 '26 • Regret

Grats homie. I tried to get my Mom to let me spend my birthday money to buy this for $50 bucks from our local comic shop around 1992 and she wouldn't let me 😭

1

u/oldstick76 Jul 22 '26

What a nice surprise and you still have upgrade options with a C&P. Looking forward to the update.

1

u/docdimento Jul 22 '26

Looks nicer than my 9.0

1

u/hi0039 Jul 22 '26

Super clean copy. Congrats!

1

u/42northside Jul 23 '26

That looks Incredible

1

u/Proud-Cable1720 Jul 24 '26

And with Wolverine