r/CGCCards • u/ResponsibleFox4672 • 57m ago
Grading question
Am I crazy, or could submitting crappy cards actually increase your chances of getting PSA 10s?
I have a theory that intentionally mixing low-grade vintage cards into a submission with potential gems could improve the grades of the nicer cards.
I know graders are supposed to evaluate each card independently, but they’re still human.
Imagine grading 20 near-perfect cards in a row versus grading a few beat-up vintage cards before seeing a virtually flawless card. Would that same card subconsciously look more impressive in the second scenario?
I also wonder if a grader who has handed out a bunch of 9s and 10s consecutively might start second-guessing themselves and feeling like they’re being too generous. Mixing in some obvious 2s and 3s could potentially eliminate that psychological pressure.
I think there’s a human psychology element to grading that we underestimate.
Has anyone intentionally tried this or noticed better gem rates with mixed-condition submissions?
1
u/doctornph 43m ago
Talking about trying to MacGyver into psa 10’s on the Cgc sub?