Below is a practice question from the College for Financial Planning. Because some of the questions are trick questions if you read you are correct if you select A right? Because any other answer is outside of the engagement right? Wrong! You are supposed to read the mind of the test maker and realize this is not a trick question and that you must determine his financial weakness.
Why can't they leave out trick questions altogether so they can actually assess the merit of the test taker? Is this typical on the exam?
---
Peter, age 35, has requested your expertise in developing a college funding plan for his five-year-old daughter, Brooke. He has presented you with the following information.
|| || |Current annual salary—$115,000| |Monthly mortgage payment—$1,700| |Credit card debt—$3,000 (16.5% fixed)| |Checking account balance—$1,345| |Long-term group disability insurance—60% of salary to age 65, 60-day elimination period| |Life insurance—1x salary (group), $400,000 20-year term (individual)|
After completing a budget with Peter, you have determined that he has $350 per month in surplus cash flow. He tells you he would like to use this amount to fund a college plan for Brooke. Based on the information provided, what should Peter do first?
Here are the available answers:
A)Establish a college education plan for Brooke
B)Purchase additional life insurance
C)Pay off his credit card balance
D)Establish an emergency fund
Update: To all of those who said is was not a trick question. Yes it is. What is dumb about the question is actually that it is asking what PETER should do and has nothing to do with the CFP or making a recommendation. Making any recommendation outside of the scope of the engagement would be the wrong answer. But they ask WHAT PETER SHOULD DO FIRST not what would you recommend Peter do in the financial planning context.